Analyzing The Philosophies Of Roderick Chisholm

964 words - 4 pages

Philosophy Paper 2 (Chisholm)
Chisholm begins the paper by addressing the importance of skepticism by stating “'The problem of the criterion' seems to me to be one of the most difficult of all the problems of philosophy” (Chisholm, 77). He attempts to split viewpoints of the criterion into three parts, methodism, particularism, and skepticism. Chisholm's arguments against skepticism and defense of particularism are faulty because of the breaches in his reasoning.
With a healthy common sense, Chisholm states that one will find issues with both extremes of skepticism, where we have an incredibly vast amount of knowledge or no insight at all. He rejects skeptics who like to say that people have no knowledge to what the world really is like and states that, “People tend to become skeptics, temporarily, after reading books on popular science...” (Chisholm, 77) which truly shows his distaste for skepticism and brings up the question of how to decide on what we know is authentic articles of knowledge. Chisholm's criteria for distinguishing knowledge (borrowed from Mercier) states that knowledge should be internal, in which we should be able to use it ourselves without relying on another's judgment. The other two criteria are that it should be objective (not merely a feeling) as well as immediate (presented as self-evident).
Chisholm continues by contrasting particularists, methodists and skeptics, with each of these having a different answer to the following pairs of questions:
A) “What do we know? What is the extent of our knowledge?
B) “How are we to decide whether we know? What are the criteria of knowledge?”
A particularist brings up what we know and derives the criteria from that (by answering part A they may find an answer to B). A methodist questions the criteria of our knowledge than applies it to what they know (by using answer B to derive the answer to A). Finally, the skeptic denies that we have any knowledge. A skeptic would say that you cannot answer question A without question B and vice versa. Therefore you cannot answer either question. Chisholm suggests that the first possibility is the most reasonable by bringing up that there are things that we know to be true, like our feelings, thoughts, and senses. For example, if one reports to you what their senses are experiencing, what they see, hear, feel, chances are that they are correct (though sometimes they are deceptive). With these experiences, one may forge criteria to find truth in our knowledge. He ends on the note that the problem with the criterion by begs the question and that in favor of the particularist scope, we do know things after all.
Chisholm's argument denies (and even goes as far as to ridicule) skepticism and those who believe that we have a ample of amount of what is attested to be knowledge but is not. Critics would argue that Chisholm's “The Problem Of the Criterion” isn't conclusive, because a mere strong presumption would turn into strict...

Find Another Essay On Analyzing the Philosophies of Roderick Chisholm

Analyzing the Description of Alison Essay

1179 words - 5 pages Analyzing the Description of Alison The story of Alison is a typical set piece of courtly romance. This classic example of courtly romance is represented in the description of her appearance and her relationships with John, Nicholas and Absalon. The male attitude to marriage in the time that Chaucer was writing 'The Miller's Tale' was very selfish. It was to produce a male heir and to improve social and economic

Analyzing the Use of Databases Essay

886 words - 4 pages Analyzing the Use of DatabasesSelecting a database platform for your organization's infrastructure can be an overwhelming project. IT professionals faced with this daunting task may have no prior database experience and are suddenly thrown into an arena full of vaguely familiar terms and a wide range of products with drastically differing price tags. My organization uses the Oracle database.We will look at the database powerhouse of the database

The Birth of Religions and Philosophies in the Ancient World

1315 words - 5 pages The Birth of Religions and Philosophies in the Ancient World From the beginning of time, people all over the world have wondered where we come from, what our divine purpose in life is, and what we can expect after death. Questions about right and wrong, society and government, and nature and the cosmos, are some of the few wonders that ultimately created some of the earliest philosophies and religions, helping people find peace and explanation

The Tale of Two Philosophies: Epicureanism and Stoicism

2139 words - 9 pages THESIS STATEMENT In Hellenistic Greece, Epicureanism and Stoicism were two influential philosophies encouraging a life of happiness; these philosophies were similar in their belief of the afterlife, but differed in their beliefs of the gods and the approach to attain happiness in life. PURPOSE STATEMENT Through research and analysis, it is shown that Epicureanism and Stoicism both portrayed the general idea of a content life, but had more

Application of the Vitalistic and Mechanistic Philosophies to Biology

826 words - 4 pages With regards to vitalism and mechanism, there lacks a distinct boundary separating these two scientific philosophies. However, their implications and biases when slanted either particular way are significant enough to observe. Natural history has been the subject of great debate, scrutiny, and passion amongst many scientists from early on in biology to present times. Currently mechanism has risen to be the dominant theory in biology, but not

The Philosophies of Georg Hegel and Herbert Spencer

1255 words - 5 pages The Philosophies of Georg Hegel and Herbert Spencer The Philosophy of Georg Wilhelm Hegel (1770-1801) Metaphysics      Georg Wilhelm Hegel aspired to find a philosophy that would embody all human experiences with the integration of not only science, but also religion, history, art, politics and beyond. Hegel’s metaphysical theory of absolute idealism claimed that reality was the absolute truth of all logic, spirit, and

The Impractical Philosophies of Self-reliance and Civil Disobedience

1094 words - 4 pages The Impractical Philosophies of Self-reliance and Civil Disobedience   The philosophies of Henry David Thoreau and Ralph Waldo Emerson would work well in a society comprised only of highly intellectual, healthy individuals who were willing put forth the effort needed to thoroughly examine themselves and formulate their own opinions about every issue pertaining to them. Emerson said that all members of society should think for

Comparing the Philosophies of Brave New World and Anthem

1199 words - 5 pages The Philosophies Brave New World and Anthem     The books Brave New World by Aldus Huxley and Anthem by Ayn Rand are both valuable twentieth-century contributions to literature. Both books explore the presence of natural law in man and propose a warning for what could happen when man's sense of right and wrong is taken from him. In this essay, I hope to show how these seemingly unrelated novels both expound upon a single, very profound

Confucianism and Taoism: The Shaping Philosophies of China

2489 words - 10 pages are the basis of eastern thinking. It may not be so evident today, as technology shrinks our world, and western thought, carried on the back of commerce, invades the east, but Confucianism and Taoism are the two principle philosophies that shaped ancient and dynastic China, both culturally and politically.Confucianism was based on the writings and teachings of Confucius or K'ung-fu-tzu (551BCE-479BCE) , from whom it derives its name. Confucius

The utilitarian philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill

2070 words - 8 pages Compare and contrast the utilitarian philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. Which do you think is the more convincing moral theory, and why?In terms of Utilitarianism, this assignment shall outline the philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. It shall firstly illustrate the ideas of Bentham and then follow on to compare and contrast those of Mill. To continue, the assignment will view the failing qualities in both the

Using example to analyse the five philosophies of marketing

1865 words - 7 pages marketing, what philosophy should guide these marketing efforts? Generally, the five philosophies of production concept, product concept, selling concept, and societal marketing concepts should be paid more attention in marketing management process. In the following, the five concepts will be alternatively discussed with theories and practice.2. The brief meanings of marketing management philosophiesThe production concept is one of the oldest concepts

Similar Essays

The Philosophies Of Friedrich Nietzsche Essay

1002 words - 4 pages Philosophies of Friedrich Nietzsche Friedrich Nietzsche was a 19th-century German philosopher and held in regard amongst the greatest philosophers of the early part century. He sharpened his philosophical skills through reading the works of the earlier philosophers of the 18th century such as Immanuel Kant, John Stuart Mill, Arthur Schopenhauer and African Spir; however, their works and beliefs were opposite to his own. His primary mentor was

Response To Roderick Nash´S Essay Island Civilization: A Vision For Human Occupancy Of Earth In The Fourth Millenum

773 words - 4 pages In Roderick R. Nash’s essay “Island civilization: A vision for human occupancy of earth in the fourth millenium” he quotes “Of course a change like this one [Island civilization] involves compromises with human freedom.” Nashs plan for the future is to make self-sustaining “islands” of civilization. These civilizations would be clusters of the population, and quite similar to cities. His plan also relies on advanced technology that would not

Analyzing The Point Of View Essay

898 words - 4 pages Analyzing the Point of View One of the most important elements of a story is the point of view that the story is told in. The point of view is critical to determining whether or not the narrator is trustworthy. By analyzing the point of view in “A Rose for Emily” the reader can determine what point of view the story is being told in, how the story will change if it’s told from a different viewpoint, and if the narrator is trustworthy. In the

Analyzing The Spectrum Of Ozymandias Essay

785 words - 3 pages Analyzing the Spectrum of Ozymandias    The poem "Ozymandias" tells a story about a traveler, who reveals his or her story to the narrator of the poem. The author of the poem is Percy Bysshe Shelley. He keeps the interest of the poem by using constant sounds and images that are clear and concise, by supplying mystery with words that have more than one meaning, and by using a spectrum of words that capture the interpreters