Analyzing Two Opposing Perspectives On Smoking

1252 words - 5 pages

Do you smoke? Such a question has been asked to most people at one time or another. The topic of smoking certainly requires a thorough analysis, whether you smoke or not. It’s also an issue which seems to polarize people. In this reading we’ll compare contrasting viewpoints by two different individuals. As I present the arguments, I’ll dissect them to truly understand their inner-workings. Both Haviland and King touch on many subjects, yet seem to ignore others. I think a balance must be struck when it comes to smoking, both through individual rights and a social responsibility.
“I’d Rather Smoke than Kiss.” is Florence King’s very astute retort to anti-smokers. In this writing she advocates for smoking as a simple enjoyable thing to do. To emphasize this she recalls her first smoking experience, which is for the most part very normal and unexciting. However, this inconsequential account is not indicative of the rest of the story. King quickly switches gears as she goes on the attack. In the first section she labels hatred of smokers as a form of misanthropy which she goes on to say is “the most popular form of closet misanthropy in America today” (King). This perspective is further augmented by the fact that she considers second-hand smoke an invention; a means for the “Passive Americans” (King), to justify prejudice towards smokers.
As she moves into the second section, she begins to document the hostility shown to smokers. Through her own personal interactions or through examples she views in newspaper articles. King really focuses on the subject of public perception, and while some of the examples validate her perspective, others do not. We see this in her response to a Washington Post article, in which she states that “the whole article has a die-damn-you undertow” (King). This perspective is perhaps a bit over the top and only serves to polarize her views, thereby alienating some readers.
This is compounded by the next section with the peculiar title of Health Nazis. In it, she likens the public service ads against smoking to political propaganda. Nevertheless, she touches on some strong points in regards to public perception and the media’s control over it. As we move to the final section, she begins to draw interesting parallels. She compares the attack on smokers as a form of class warfare, and even goes so far as to allude to racism in the last paragraph. Indeed, she goes on to say that hatred against smokers is meant to “identify and punish the undesirables among us” (King). An attack by what she thinks of as the politically correct and self-righteous who happen to be going after black people, white working class people, 18-35 year old females, ethnic people, older people, middle aged women, or just about damn near everybody. Still, King’s essay draws up some very fundamental points which despite its radical views, must not be ignored. These are the individual right to do as you please to your body, and the media’s control over...

Find Another Essay On Analyzing Two Opposing Perspectives on Smoking

Cigarette Advertising Essay

1305 words - 5 pages changes so that they can revert to their former, unobstructed and unregulated methods of doing business. Spending at unprecedented levels, America's two largest tobacco companies are waging all-out battles to defeat ballot measures in several states that would sharply increase cigarette taxes or impose broad bans on smoking in public places. Philip Morris USA and R.J. Reynolds Tobacco have given more than $54 million to the campaign opposing

Nationwide Indoor Smoking Ban Essay

1019 words - 5 pages Smoking is a habit that has taken place for a longer time than one could think or imagine; the probability that the habit will stop any time soon is also extremely low. Most tobacco users believe cigarette smoking is way of clearing their psychological problems and relaxing their bodies. On the other hand, nonsmokers maintain that the allegations by tobacco users regarding the benefits of smoking are unreal perceptions, which are just in their

The Pros and Cons of Cigarette Smoking

1293 words - 5 pages are a number of different perspectives on the issue of smoking. In this particular research paper, there are three different points of view on cigarette smoking: There are those out there who believe that smoking reduces risk of diseases, such as Parkinson’s, there are others, who believe that smoking is therapeutic, and lastly, there are others who think that smoking is toxic to your health, and it should be banned altogether. There are a

The Harmful Effects of Cigarettes

1261 words - 6 pages , lead people to be exposed of second-hand smoke, and causes people to abuse their usage of these drugs which leads to health issues; thus, we need to ban the use of cigarettes in our country to stop the death rate and the problem of addiction. Two of the major factors that mostly influences one to smoke are friends and going to parties or clubs. Telling one to quit without an understanding of the health issues involved in smoking, is not quite a

Analyzing Media Ideology

1000 words - 4 pages be more readily apparent (Croteau, Hoynes, &, Milan, 2012). Following this guideline an infamous ad campaign was that of the Marlboro Man (, 2011). I can remember as a child seeing the Marlboro ads on the backs of magazines. To me the denotation was always very simple. I saw a cowboy, rigid, hardworking, and smoking a cigarette. In fact as a child the cigarette was always the thing I overlooked in the picture. I was mesmerized by the

Smoking in Public Places

1336 words - 5 pages The best thing to do for your body is to stop smoking and to never start (Thompson 1 of 2). Smoke stays on the walls, floors, clothing and toys smoke is everywhere (HANSSEN 1 of 2). Therefore smoking should be banned in public spaces because it causes harm to the smoker's body, as well as causing unwarranted health and economic problems for the public. People smoke in many places. Buses, hospitals, libraries, restaurants, bars, banks and even

Hazards of Smoking

1295 words - 5 pages , used for smoking or chewing as snuff. The tobacco plant is native to tropical America and is now wildly grown all over the world. You can find tobacco in cigarettes, cigars, pipes, and chewing tobacco (snuff). Nicotine is a poisonous alkaloid contained in the leaves, roots and seeds of tobacco plants. It is used as an insecticide and sometimes used in medicine.Tobacco and nicotine are very harmful substances that have many harmful effects on humans

One More Puff and We All Fall Down

1617 words - 6 pages . Web. 15 Apr. 2014. Jackson, Joe. "Smoking Bans Will Not Reduce Tobacco Addiction." Addiction. Ed. Christina Fisanick. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2009. Opposing Viewpoints. Rpt. from "The Smoking Issue—Bans on Smoking." Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 15 Apr. 2014. "Public opinion on smoking in public places, 1987-2003." Alcohol and Tobacco:America's Drugs of Choice. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Information Plus Reference Series

How to Quit Smoking

1519 words - 6 pages The subject of this paper is of my mother and her journey to quit smoking. I went through several different ways of attempting to influence my mother to quit smoking. I have been trying to influence her to quit smoking for years, however for the past two weeks, I have been trying different techniques to try to influence her to conform to the rest of the family and no longer smoke. I chose to try to influence my mom because; I care deeply about


1349 words - 5 pages two very different perspectives of this question, and found myself forming my own opinion along the way. In Florence King's article "I'd rather smoke than kiss", King really seems to want to exude the fact that she is a proud smoker. King begins the article by telling us the story of her conversion to cigarettes. King seems to be pro smoking and even states, "I believe life should be savored rather than lengthened" (7) King talks about how


1349 words - 5 pages two very different perspectives of this question, and found myself forming my own opinion along the way. In Florence King's article "I'd rather smoke than kiss", King really seems to want to exude the fact that she is a proud smoker. King begins the article by telling us the story of her conversion to cigarettes. King seems to be pro smoking and even states, "I believe life should be savored rather than lengthened" (7) King talks about how

Similar Essays

Analyzing Two Theories On The Relationship Between Stress And Depression

1007 words - 5 pages Stress is a component that everyone experiences at some point in life. Everyone expresses and handles stress differently, but when stress is accompanied by other issues, such as depression it can become very exhausting on an individual. In the article, A Longitudinal Examination of Stress Generation in Depression and Anxiety Disorders by Uliaszek et al. (2012) examines two opposing theories of the stress generation model of depression. As

The Essay On "The Journey" By Peter Kreeft. Cover 1 3 Chapters, Analyzing Two Major Themes

852 words - 3 pages known and ignorance. The garden of Epicuruc symbolizes pleasures of human life such as sex and money and the road of Socrates symbolizes something unknown and unexpected. The beautiful flowers at the garden of delights contrast with the sharp stones on the road. But not all that is beautiful and well known leads to the happy life or appear as a solution. Beautiful and careless life is not the meaning of life people search for. We usually

Smoking Cigarettes Should Be Banned As A Drug

2372 words - 10 pages ." Issues & Controversies. Facts On File News Services, 1 July 2013. Web. 8 Apr. 2014. "Tobacco". Alcohol, Tobacco, and Illicit Drugs. Sandra M. Alters. 2011 ed. Detroit: Gale, 2011. Information Plus Reference Series. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 2 Apr. 2014. “Deaths from Secondhand Smoke." MCT Photos. 2010. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 8 Apr. 2014 “How Tobacco Smoke Causes Diseases: The Biology and Behavioral Basic for Smoking

Smoking Bans Essay

1781 words - 7 pages : Greenhaven Press, 2009. Opposing Viewpoints. Gale Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 24 June 2011. "Update: Smoking Bans." Issues & Controversies On File: n. pag. Issues & Controversies. Facts On File News Services, 23 Mar. 2007. Web. 24 June 2011. Herman, Patricia, M., and Michele, E. Walsh. "Hospital admissions for acute myocardial infarction, angina, stroke, and asthma after implementation of Arizona's comprehensive statewide smoking ban." American Journal of Public Health 101.3 (2011): 491-496. CINAHL Plus with Full Text. EBSCO. Web. 24 June 2011.