Ancient Authors: Who Was The Most Reliable In Ancient Sparta

977 words - 4 pages

‘It has been said that Sparta had two separate histories, its own and that of its image abroad...Considering how much was written about Sparta in antiquity, it is remarkable how confused, contradictory and incomplete the picture is. Partly this is because the mirage is constantly cutting across the reality, distorting it and often concealing it altogether; and partly because the Spartans themselves were so completely silent.”With respect to our knowledge of the helots in ancient Sparta, how accurate do you believe this statement to be? Support your position by discussing the primary sources available on ancient Sparta.It is accurate to say that many ancient writers recorded works associated with ancient Sparta. Very few of these works were recorded by Spartans or those who had any first hand experience of the city or contact with the people early in Spartan history when the helot class originated and when their role and treatment was being moulded. Those that did, such as Xenophon and Tyrtaeus, were written from the perspective of the most powerful class in Spartan society, the military Spartiates. For these reasons it is entirely accurate to claim that our evidence of Spartan society, and specifically the helot class, is distorted, incomplete and confused. Furthermore, it is accurate to assume that given these reasons the reality could be contradicted by the mirage or myths established by these writers.Thucydides who wrote his famous “The Peloponnesian War” late in the 5th century BC, wrote after the major events in Spartan history that led to the development of the helot class and when the attitudes towards the helots were being developed and their roles formulated. Thucydides work focused on the war and on foreign relations with society and the helot class not being central to his work. Any evidence produced by Thucydides must be read in light of the fact that he greatly admired the Spartan system of controlling and suppressing the helots.Like Thucydides, Herodotus wrote in the 5th century BC when he compiled his famous works ‘The Histories’. While his writings include information related to Sparta he too primarily deals with Spartan foreign policy and thus provides little to no evidence relevant to the helot class. Furthermore, any evidence he does provide on the helots is distorted by his strong bias against the constitution of Sparta and therefore against how the Spartiates controlled and treated the helots.The two famous Athenian philosophers, Plato and Aristotle, while having something to say on the Spartan system and therefore the position of the helot class within this system, provided works that were not only biased, but also written to support the political philosophies they were proposing at this time. Plato greatly admired the Spartan system particularly the order and stability that ensure the helot class remained submissive in Spartan society. Therefore, like the other ancient writers, Plato’s...

Find Another Essay On Ancient Authors: who was the most reliable in Ancient Sparta

Who Were The Ancient Unitas Fratrum

1252 words - 5 pages The Ancient Unity of Brethren, also known as Unitas Fratrum are among the oldest organized groups. The Moravians origins were organized in 1457 as descendants of these groups. They were spiritual descendants of Jan Hus. A Czech priest who attempted a reform and was killed for his attempts. Hus was a holy martyr whose stand on the Bible was the supreme rule of faith and practice in the Church. He persuaded people that partaking of the chalice was

Athens vs. Sparta- Compare and contrast the two cities of Ancient Greece.

685 words - 3 pages were his home for most of his life. Soldiers ate and slept in their barracks. There lives were there with their brotherhood.Athens was a city-state based on knowledge and learning. The schooling of the two city-states greatly differed. Schooling in Athens started at about the same age as in Sparta, but the curriculums were greatly different. In Athens, students were taught to be more peaceful, but to be prepared for war. The only war training that

Explain the main features of the Spartan Economy. This essay explains the features of the Spartan economy in ancient sparta that contributes to their austere lifestyle

1181 words - 5 pages , sometimes made to fight in war for Sparta) were rich enough to maintain a high level of professional training and equipment. Each Spartiate, therefore had to have a minimum income to pay for his mess dues and the state had to have income to pay for armour and equipment. This was achieved through the exploitation of Helots who produced foodstuff that : paid the mess dues, and was used to trade with Perioikoi that provided the armour and

Ancient Chinese Medicine How was medicine practised in Ancient China? What methodes did they use?

542 words - 2 pages combinations became necessary and more complex as experience showed that some herbs cancelled out the effect of other herbs. It was also discovered that the medicinal properties of many herbs required certain other herbs to be present to act as a catalyst.The healing power of the ingredients found in these natural herbal formulas has never been doubted by most Asians. The difficulty in utilising many of these ancient formulas has been determining which formulas work with the individual person. TCM describes a formula based upon the individual being treated as opposed to Western practices where treatments and preventatives are tested for their effectiveness on a group of people.

5 Most Important Events From Ancient History

592 words - 2 pages got people killed. His few followers devoted their entire lives to him. Since then, many people have fought wars over, died for, and lived their lives in misery over this cult turned religion. It is now the world's largest religion, though most people who are Christians aren't as devoted to it as they used to be, but it still has great significance and people continue to fight wars and die to preserve these religious beliefs.

Ancient Medicine was based on Belief in the Supernatural. Is this true? (What evidence is there to support this statement?)

846 words - 3 pages Ancient medicine covers medicine through Prehistoric, Egyptian, Greek and Roman times.Religion and belief in the supernatural were key factors in the development of ancient medicine. They influenced the way that people thought and the way in which they lived their lives. The supernatural could be used to explain aspects of medicine that people didn't understand at that time. Not everything was blamed on the supernatural, people did have some

Rome also known as the ancient city was the capital of the greatest empire of the ancient world. It was a great and prosperous city that was filled with at least one million people.

3899 words - 16 pages the coliseum. The reason the pantheon wasbuilt was so that all the gods who weren't as important as Hades and Zeusand Hera would have this place to be worshipped so they wouldn't feel leftout. This temple was made with no windows only a hole in the middle of thetop of the roof to give light for the temple it was built in 125 A.D. thecoliseum's were built for entertainment purposes only. The most famouscoliseum was built from 69-75 A.D. and was 27o

"An Inspector Calls" - Who was most responsible for the death of Eva Smith?

1153 words - 5 pages class, "As if a girl of that sort would ever refuse money." She believed Eva has moral values just because she was poor; only the rich had moral values and therefore the right to decide who is entitles to charity. She thinks the poor should have the right attitude if they are to deserve money. She believed in 'helping deserving cases.'When Eva needed help the most she turned to Mrs. Birling's charity. 'She was alone, friendless, almost penniless

Who do you think was the most interesting figure (male or female) in the British women's suffrage movement 1866-1914 and why?

1952 words - 8 pages It is a hard thing to categorically state who would be the most interesting figure in the British women's suffrage movement within this time period, as there were many who had great influence on the events of this time. The militant actions of the Pankhurst ladies make them an enduring symbol of the movement that lives on in today's memory and immediately spring to mind when the discussion of women's suffrage arises. Another is the first

The Athenian Constitution Using the book by the same name by Aristotle, this is a general paper summarizing(for the most part) the development of the constitution adopted by the ancient Greeks.

716 words - 3 pages of Athenian society, the courts could be seen as a fair and reliable source of justice with these new laws.The evolution of Athenian democracy was dependant on several trends in the history of Athens. The dispersal of the tribes allowed for a diverse collection of local concerns that were spread evenly amongst the tribes. Also, the council and archons did not hold office for long and were appointed by the tribes, creating a representative

Dreams in the Ancient World

2960 words - 12 pages ancient times people were cured through dreams. The village is Nydsens in the city of Acharaca there was a cave, by nature that is wonderful. Whenever they have people who are diseased prisests from teh village sleep in the cave on the behalf of the sick people through the dreams prescribe the cure. The people should be religious and pray to Gods. Some sick people go themselves and stay in the cave for days without food. If the people give heed

Similar Essays

Ancient Sparta Essay

1664 words - 7 pages enjoyed the full political and legal rights of being a citizen while still serving in the army and living in the barracks. Directly below them were the perioeci, or "dwellers about." These were foreign people who served as a safeguard between the Spartiates and the helots. Because these people served such a vital function, they were allotted a great deal of freedom. They performed most of the trade and commerce that was carried out in Sparta. And

Daily Life In Ancient Sparta Essay

2721 words - 11 pages Daily Life in Ancient Sparta Sparta, also called Lacedaemon, was a city in ancient Greece, and one of the most famous ancient Greek cities of the Peloponnesus. Found in the hills of Mount Taygetus many would consider was a brutal group of militaristic people. Although, this to some extent may be true most of the written information was derived from the ancient city-state of Athens, who were great enemies of the Spartan society. After the

Role Of Women In Ancient Sparta

1230 words - 5 pages most well-known and very distinct form of exercise that Spartan girls and women took part in was the bibasis. This was a highly strenuous exercise which involved jumping up and down, each time hitting their own bottom with their heels. This exercise primarily strengthened the females' thighs and hips which dramatically increased their chances of producing fit and healthy males who would become excellent warriors for Sparta.- Also took up sports

Discusses Athens And Sparta In Ancient Times. Fights And Government Plus More. How Both City States Resemble The Us.

578 words - 2 pages We are about to explore the roots of two political systems: totalitarianism and democracy. Both forms exist in the modern world, but the roots for each can be found in ancient Greece. Both were bitter rivals and despised each other.The form of culture of totalitarianism had its roots in the ancient Greek city-state of Sparta. Totalitarianism means of, relating to, being, or imposing a form of government in which the political authority exercises