Ancient History, Analysing Sources Essay

680 words - 3 pages

Preliminary Course Ancient History Assessment Task #1:Assessing Written and Archaeological sourcesFactors which influenced an ancient writer -ThucydidesA)How did Thucydides' experiences, aims and sources help him to write as accurately as possible?Thucydides' experiences in the war gave him access to information that would help him to write accurately. Being an eyewitness to many events himself, he could draw from his own experiences when writing his history. It also meant he would be know people who had been involved in other battles and ask for their accounts of what had happened.He also travelled around Greece to gain others views of events, ad stories of what had happened across the country, giving him more dimensions to add to his own opinions and stories. He would not have been biased towards the politicians, as he disagreed with their views and seems to have had no want to please them. Being a General in the war, he would have been present at many battles and important event throughout the war, so his writing would be largely based on his own first hand account, rather than heavily relying on hearsay or previously written inaccurate documents. He crosschecked his references and, because of conflicting accounts treated his own eyewitnesses with scepticism. His efficiency in these matters allowed him to write as accurately as possible. He aimed to show future generations the mistakes of his time, so that it was not repeated. He wanted top reveal the tragedies of war, which would stop him from glorifying war, this would need him to be as accurate as possible.B)Explain how his background, political view and experiences might have created some bias in his accountHis memories of Athens being such a great power under the decisive ruling of Pericles would provide a comparison with Athens under the rule of Cleon that would come out negatively towards Cleon in Thucydides' writings. His political views would certainly have created some bias: He thought that Democracy was not a good concept, because he believed...

Find Another Essay On Ancient History, analysing sources

Ancient Authors: who was the most reliable in Ancient Sparta

977 words - 4 pages respect to our knowledge of the helots in ancient Sparta, how accurate do you believe this statement to be? Support your position by discussing the primary sources available on ancient Sparta.It is accurate to say that many ancient writers recorded works associated with ancient Sparta. Very few of these works were recorded by Spartans or those who had any first hand experience of the city or contact with the people early in Spartan history when the

The Practice of History Essay

1482 words - 6 pages Historians face a large problem when studying history. Because history cannot be completely value free and objective, examining one source to gain the truth is not possible no matter how detailed it may be. They must call upon many different sources and analyse each one carefully trying to see past any bias and attempting to look at them with as much objectivity as possible. Breaking them up and analysing them intricately is the best way of

Mini Paper #1

708 words - 3 pages The study of history has always been systematic with historians asking questions, collecting background information, evaluating sources, linking evidence, and presenting a conclusion while maintaining objectivity. The methods of explaining history has largely been a similar process. While the nineteenth century movement focused on altering the study of history through the importance of objectivity and professionalism, it did little to change it

Animals in Ancient Egypt

1201 words - 5 pages Egyptians studied animal’s diets, characteristic and held animals of prey with high respect. The assumption by many scholars and historians that ancient Egyptians honoured animals because they were fond of the animals, but this was proven not to be the case and that the link between religion and animals was proven by a number of sources. The altered evidence suggesting both sides of this argument is clearly seen with websites and books stating

The Excessive Preparation of Ancient Roman Women for Society

1003 words - 4 pages "Ancient Roman Clothing." UNRV History Roman Empire. 9 February 2005.Carcopino, Jérôme. Daily Life in Ancient Rome. New Haven and London: Yale UniversityPress, 1940.Matz, David. Daily Life of the Ancient Romans. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2002.Nardo, Don. Women of Ancient Rome. Farmington Hills, MI: Lucent books, 2003."Roman Dress." Illustrated History of the Roman Empire. 8 February 2005empire.net/society/soc-dress.html>."Roman Marriage." UNRV History Roman Empire. 9 February 2005."Women's Fashion in Ancient Rome." History and Thought of Western Man. 9 February 2005.

Sources of Data in The Golden Bough

1949 words - 8 pages "The Golden Bough: A study in Religion and Magic"By: James George FrazerArea of interest: Sources of DataTo begin with, Sir James Frazer's The Golden Bough: A Study in Religion and Magic is a famous landmark work of ethnography, anthropology and literary analysis regarding human, religious and cultural traditions.The Golden Bough was both scandalous and widely read when it was first published 1890, largely because it spoke frankly about the

Sources of Data in The Golden Bough

1949 words - 8 pages "The Golden Bough: A study in Religion and Magic"By: James George FrazerArea of interest: Sources of DataTo begin with, Sir James Frazer's The Golden Bough: A Study in Religion and Magic is a famous landmark work of ethnography, anthropology and literary analysis regarding human, religious and cultural traditions.The Golden Bough was both scandalous and widely read when it was first published 1890, largely because it spoke frankly about the

Evaluate empiricism as an ideology and methodology for writing history.

1257 words - 5 pages their time. Through the examination of historical practices over time, it has proven difficult to provide society with an accurate portrayal of the truth.Each composer of history has utilised differing techniques to illustrate an interpretation of the past. For example, ancient historians such as Herodotus interpreted history through story telling, incorporating elements of myth, which is a reflection of that societies beliefs, values, customs

Book Review of Ancient Israel: What Do We Know and How Do We Know It by Lester L. Grabbe

1224 words - 5 pages In Lester L. Grabbe’s book Ancient Israel: What Do We Know and How Do We Know It, his aim was to not just tell a history of ancient Israel, but to survey sources and investigate data in order to understand the interpretations that the available sources give and to reconstruct an acceptable history for Israel. He referred to this as the “prolegomena” of the actual history of Israel- the question of how historians can verify that the history of

The French Revolution

1529 words - 6 pages similar the emergence of democracy in Ancient Greece is to the emergence of it in the French Revolution. The French Revolution was the first modern revolution in history. It is one of the most studied times in history. Many questions are asked about how, when, and why this great revolution started. This essay will explain the reasons for it starting by comparing this time of history to Ancient Greece. First, the

The Use of Primary Sources in Teaching

1431 words - 6 pages . • American Artifacts A series of collections of artifacts throughout the history of America. • African Artifacts A dated list of artifacts from ancient Nubia. Primary sources are a comprehensive way to teach various subjects. This method of teaching appeals to students and instructors alike as it is a way to consciously make a connection with the proposed subject matter. Primary sources let students engage assorted senses all at one time. This helps to keep the focus of the subject matter. Mindful focus results in a higher level of learning and allows the student to retain the information taught.

Similar Essays

The Olympic Games, Its Origins, Sources And Images In The Art Of Ancient Greece This Is A Wonderful Essay On The History Of Art From The Ancient Greek Olympic Times.

1645 words - 7 pages The Olympic Games, its origins, sources and images in the art of ancient GreeceThe Olympic Games are a tradition which has been maintained for literally thousands of years. From its origin dating back to prehistoric, Ancient Greece, the Olympic Games have captured the attention and hearts of countless athletes, artists and fans. The importance of the games was originally to avoid military conflict within Greece, but the benefits derived from the

Forensic Essay

926 words - 4 pages when analysing the socially-inspired explanation, have neglected the emphasis which should be placed upon recognising the real legal problem, within its own context and time. For this to be adhered to we must, whilst ensuring not to study anachronistically, look primarily to the original sources – which, in actual fact, give no explanation which carries enough weight to be understood and adopted fully when accounting for all of these

The Increase Of Gender Equality In Ancient Egypt’s New Kingdom

533 words - 2 pages BIBLIOGRAPHYPrimary Sources"Isis nursing Horus." Bronze. Late Period, Dynasty 26 or later. Cincinnati Art Museum, Cincinnati. http://www.cincinnatiartmuseum.orgShows the importance of pregnancy and fertility of women in Ancient Egypt."Figure Vase: Woman holding a swaddled infant." Red burnished terracotta. New Kingdom, Mid-Dynasty. The Brooklyn Museum, Brooklyn.Shows the importance of pregnancy and fertility of women in Ancient EgyptPtah-hotep

Interaction Between Political And Social Life In Ancient Imperial Rome

2283 words - 9 pages Interaction between Political and Social Life in Ancient Imperial Rome The interaction between political and social life in Ancient Rome has been accurately portrayed in the well researched novel, "The Course of Honour", by Lindsey Davies. However as this is a fictional novel told as an interesting story instead of fact, the information given must be corroborated with several primary sources to correct any inherent biases. Lindsey