Andrea Dworkin, A Detrement To The Feminist Movement

1410 words - 6 pages

Andrea Dworkin has been an influential write, speaker, and activist for over two decades. She claims to be a feminist, and that her ideas are beneficial to women. This paper will show that many of her most popular beliefs are not only detrimental to society, but also not in the best interests of women.In letters from a war zone, Andrea Dworkin presents a collection of speeches and short articles she has composed during her career as a writer and activist. Many of her articles deal with censorship and pornography. One claim is central to all of these, pornography is an act and not an idea, thus censorship is not relevant to it.In response to a New York Time Review of her 1981 book, Pornography: Men Possessing Women, Dworkin writes, "Pornography says the women want to be hurt, forced, and abused; pornography says women want to be raped, battered, kidnapped, maimed; pornography says women want to be humiliated, shamed, defamed, pornography says that women say no but mean yes - Yes to violence, yes to pain."(Dworkin p 203)In response to Dworkin's fiery rhetoric, Wendy Mcelroy writes that Dworkin has scientific backing and even cites evidence to the contrary. "In Japan, where pornography depicting violence is widely available, rape is much lower per capita than in the United States, where violence in porn is restricted." Mcelroy attacks the belief that pornography cause violence, stating that even if a correlation is present, is does not necessarily mean there is a causal relationship. (McElroy 102)Lynne Segal sees in inherent harm in trying to link the two together. She believes that feminists who try to do so are wasting valuable time that could be spent on other important issues. "In the end, anti-pornography campaigns, feminist or not, can only enlist today, as they have invariously enlisted before, guilt and anxiety around sex, as well as lifetimes of confusion in our personal experiences of sexual arousal and activity." "In contrast, campaigns which get to the heart of men's violence and sadism towards women must enlist the widest possible resources to empower socially." (Gibson 19)Another argument of Dworkin's is that pornography should not be protected as free speech under the first amendment. It is her contention that protecting what pornographers say, is protecting what pornography does. Pornography is more than words. They are acts against women. "Pornography happens to women." As a result, bans on such material are warranted, not only because it is harmfully and discriminatory to women, but also because there are no civil liberties that are violated in preventing an act. (Dworkin 185)Since it is uncertain whether there is even a correlation between violence against women and pornography, any attempt to ban it must be viewed as censorship. What ever it is referred to, it still has the same effect.In many of Dworkin's writings, she laments the silencing of women. She is partially responsible for this silencing. In 1992, The Canadian Supreme...

Find Another Essay On Andrea Dworkin, A Detrement to the Feminist Movement

Lysistrata and the Feminist Movement Essay

1853 words - 7 pages Lysistrata and the feminist movement In ancient Greece, society for women was constricted in a patriarchal society. Women could not participate in politics nor could they obtain an education. Women were bound to their homes and in charge of their slaves and rearing their children. Men were entitled to anything they desired including women. The decisions regarding all matters of the polis were decided by men and men were the ones responsible for

Is it Feminist to be a Power Feminist?

1295 words - 5 pages back is themselves and this false sense of fear that they have. For a movement to be considered feminist I believe it has to have intentions of improvement for women in some shape or form, whether that improvement is simply just awareness or something concrete. Women have every right to fight for equality in my opinion, however not all feminists see eye-to-eye on every topic as mentioned previously so it might not even be the men of the world

The Civil Rights Movement and To Kill a Mockingbird

1348 words - 5 pages same year that To Kill a Mockingbird was published and huge events were rupturing the south, throughout the novel readers can see the attitude of a want and need for equality in characters and some events. The civil rights movement was introduced to national headlines in the 1950s and 60s but in places like Georgia began as early as the 40s. In Georgia groups of African Americans were organized to try and vote. People like Thomas Brewer

A Call To Occupy Movement

1344 words - 5 pages The Occupy Movement has inspired a domino-like effect the world over, starting rebellions from the Americas to Asia. The universal vision of the movement is its aim to get the 99% to overthrow the rules decided and regulated by the rich, the powerful and the one percent for the greater benefit of the one percent. According to the anonymous writers of the official Occupy Movement page, “to occupy is to embody the spirit of liberation that we

Anti-Feminism - A Fowl Movement is An Essay Concerning the Novel "Wild Geese" by Martha Ostenso Taking The Anti-Feminist Theme Into Consideration

581 words - 2 pages Wild Geese, the classic Canadian novel by Martha Ostenso, is written from a very non-feminist point of view. To begin with, it can be seen throughout the novel that Caleb Gare doesn't give Lind Archer the time of day. Furthermore, it is the women on the farm who work the hardest and are treated the worst. Finally, it is Amelia who takes the blame for anything bad that occurs. The book Wild Geese shows us a narrow-minded view of the female

To His Coy Mistress - A Feminist Perspective

765 words - 3 pages A Feminist Perspective of To His Coy Mistress   Andrew Marvell, a 17-century poetry writer, focuses on a subject that still baffles the readers' minds today, sex.  Marvell shows a world where women are seduced.   Women and men have focused on the issue of sex for centuries.  The most ironic thing that reader should notice while reading this poem is that even though they are in two different time settings, the same persuasions are used as

In what sense might Virginia Woolf's novel ' To The Lighthouse' be understood as a feminist text?

2659 words - 11 pages In what sense might Virginia Woolf's novel ' To The Lighthouse' be understood as a feminist text?When looking at To The Lighthouse we see the conventional usage of feminism's challenged. Woolf uses many different styles and techniques, and although the term feminist is never used within the novel, it clearly is a feminist text. Woolf's work challenges representation and treatment of women; and the social relationship between men and women, this

Explain the poem, Hills Like White Elephants. A Feminist Approach to "Hills Like White Elephants"

809 words - 3 pages From a feminist point of view, Ernest Hemingway's "Hills Like White Elephants"uses a plethora of symbols to convey the idea that a young girl named Jig is a typical woman dealing with a woman's choice. Although the word abortion is never used in the story, the reader is lead to that conclusion through the use of symbolism.The story begins with Jig and her American boyfriend waiting for a train in the valley of Ebro, a symbolic use of the word

About the Feminist Movement in the 19th Century in parts of America.

2245 words - 9 pages an easy one. People who disagreed made violent attempts to bring her down, but she never dwindled. She married a man named Henry Blackwell after much deliberation and years of courtship and together they worked for the feminist movement. But after bearing a child, realizing that her life as a mother was not an easy one, she began to retreat and no longer had the alacrity to speak of her experiences and the issues many women including those who

Darwin, Booker T. Washington and the Feminist Movement: How They Have All Influenced Modern Society

1656 words - 7 pages equality such as biological differences ( a female’s brain size in comparison to a male’s) or even bringing in Biblical reasoning. (Cloud, Lecture 14) 6. Feminist Movement Contemporary Significance In two centuries, women’s live have been transformed by the feminist movement. The feminist movement is not just about angry women, but it is considered a staple of culture, family life, economy, political systems, education and future prosperity

Escape from Oppression - An essay which uses two literarty works to explore the theme of women's oppression from a feminist perspective (using feminist criticism)

1290 words - 5 pages , murdering her husband. From a feminist perspective, these two works give very different examples of how a woman is the cast as the "nonsignificant other" (Bressler 144), but discovers a way out of her continual oppression by rejecting their insignificance.Rich begins her poem by describing the tigers of Aunt Jennifer's tapestry. They are vibrant and powerful with no fear of men. One begins to feel that Aunt Jennifer, as the artist, must be a

Similar Essays

The Debate Over Pornography Being Art: Pornography, From Andrea Dworkin

1374 words - 5 pages , one must leave sexual desires outside the Temple (Live India). According the definition in Dworkin’s essay, the word pornography does not mean to depict sex, the erotic, sexual acts, or the nude body but quite exactly the depiction of women as vile whores. Dworkin also states that the definition has not changed through time, and that whores exist only within a framework of male sexual domination. This, in my opinion, is short-sighted

The Feminist Movement Essay

1421 words - 6 pages at that time. The Third Wave of Feminist Movement started in the early 1990’s, first mentioned in the United States by Rebecca Walker in her first article “Becoming the Third Wave” in 1992. This Article was the outrageous response to the case of Clarence Thomas’s Senate confirmation after he was accused by Anita Hills of a sexual harassment. Known for his conservative political views in the abortion issue after the Court decision in Parenthood v

The Feminist Movement Essay

1084 words - 4 pages lived their lives as second class citizens, never being able to contend with the struggles of being a woman born into a “man’s world”. Women have slowly but surely broken the barriers and glass ceilings setup to keep them down. The idea that women are not as strong mentally and physically was replaced with the idea that women might even be stronger in some instances. The feminist movement has been a movement of evolution, but still seems to be a

The Anti Pornography Feminist Movement Essay

4200 words - 17 pages of a woman’s dignity, a lie about who women are and what they want. Out of these theories, writers like Andrea Dworkin, Catherine MacKinnon and Dr. Diana Russell founded and encouraged many anti-porn groups around the country. Though movements against pornography had existed prior to feminist anti-pornography groups, they were previously conservative or moral majority inspired. Then came groups such as the Anti-Porn Feminists (APFEM) and