Androids And The Mind/Body Problem By Rebecca King

840 words - 4 pages

The Star Trek: The Next Generation episode “The Measure of a Man” makes a compelling argument on androids and the mind/body problem. The episode is about Lt. Commander Data who is an android who acts identically to human behavior. Data is put on trial to find out if he should have human rights or if he is considered property of Starfleet. The episode makes interesting points as to what qualifies a person of having a mind and soul.
William Hasker uses multiple categories to list out the different views on the mind/body problem in his book Metaphysics: Constructing a World View. Captain Picard, Data’s commanding officer and the defending attorney for Data’s case, would be classified as a ...view middle of the document...

73-75). Data being an android would not have a nervous system thus he would not have a soul making him a sentient.
The argument of whether Data is a sentient or not who is entitled to rights is concluded in the episode from the ruling of the JAG officer. She says in her final ruling that she is “neither competent nor qualified to answer” (Scheerer, 1989) the questions regarding the metaphysical questions reason during the trial. This makes it where she must only look at what evidence was presented to her. Since Data was able to pass Maddox test of what defines a sentient, the JAG officer must give him the ability to have rights. I believe her ruling is justified based off the evidence.
However, I do not think artificial intelligence will ever reach the level which is presented in Star Trek: The Next Generation with the android, Data. I do not see a possibility of creating an android which could think for itself and show emotion in turn which would act like a human. In order to reach the level of being like a human, the android would need to be programed that way. It could be argued that a sentient must be taught to walk which in a way is like programming. However, how a human being or even an animal learns is already built into the brain. If learning was not built in a human’s mind than how would a human learn...

Find Another Essay On Androids and the Mind/Body Problem by Rebecca King

Comparing Thomas Reid and David Hume on the topic of the mind-body problem

851 words - 3 pages nothing that has perfect identity; everything is constantly changing. The body and mind are different from day to day, as is everything else. There is no impression of the self that is constant, and does not change. Hume called the self "a bundle or collection of different perceptions, which succeed each other with an inconceivable rapidity and are in a perpetual flux and movement". There is nothing consistent and permanent to base the self off of

The Mind-Body Problem Continued: Functionalism Takes a Stab

1021 words - 4 pages The mind-body problem is an issue that yields various philosophical ideas. Functionalism is one such view that proposes a solution. The ideals of functionalism define mental events as brain states, and that mental states are created through a relationship with each other as well as with physical stimuli (such as the senses) teamed with a physical or behavioral result or response.Functionalism holds that the knowledge of the physical (or the

Discuss the mind-body problem, its origin in Descartes' philosophy, Descartes' solution and other relevant reactions, including you own?

524 words - 3 pages , is this really the answer?Some interesting alternative theories were offered by Malebranche and Spinoza. Malebranche's theory is also known as Occasionalism. He believes that mind and body are totally different. They don't even know each other! Mental events have nothing to do with physical events. God makes them occur together at the same time.Spinoza came up with the dual-aspect theory. He claims that mind and body are both attributes of one

The Mind and the Body

906 words - 4 pages tangibility, whereas the mind deals with philosophy and emotions. When Darnay is locked away for the final time, “he had heard his condemnation. He fully comprehended that no personal influence could possibly save him, that he was virtually sentenced by millions…” (335-336). Even in the face of death, the body remains certain of itself and Darnay makes no attempt to think of an alternative to his dark fate and instead, “he was conscious of no fear

The Distinction Between the Mind and Body

647 words - 3 pages to the mind is private. The events which reply to the body consist of the physical world, and the events of the mind consist of the mental world. It has been argued whether a person can directly observe all or a select few of situations of one's own private history. According to the official doctrine by Descartes at least some of these situations one has direct and unchallengeable cognisance. It is ordinary to declare branching of two

Descartes on the Mind and Body

834 words - 4 pages comprehend that it has happened. Thus there is a connection between the body and mind. So if matter were to change the mind would sense it. This sensing changes the knowledge within the mind since knows what has happened as it happens to the body. The result is that the mind is therefore affected by changes in matter since the mind understands the changes immediately as they happen. The other of Descartes distinctions is that he feels that

The Distinction between Mind and Body

772 words - 4 pages Descartes Meditations, he explains the fundamental differences between the mind and the physical world. The distinction is that matter is an unthinking, doubtable, and extended substance, meaning it extends in space. Whereas the soul is a thinking and unextended substance that cannot be doubted. My thoughts do not take up space, do not have a mass, and cannot be divided, unlike matter. Descartes concludes that mind and body are two distinct things, as

Anger in the Body and Mind

710 words - 3 pages Imagine a fight going on between two strangers in a public place like a restaurant They are loud and disturbing everyone around them. The female throws a plate on the floor and people start to stare and are maybe getting upset or distracted by the situation. What do they look like? Are they red in the face? Do their eyes look like they are about to pop out of their skull? How are they standing? What is their body language like? What chemicals

Marijuana Damages the Mind and Body

1313 words - 5 pages seems as though marijuana and amotivation remains as a “chicken-and-egg question.” It is unknowable whether smoking cannabis causes amotivation. Moreover, these could by symptoms of just growing up (Macintosh, sec. 9). On the contrary, this is untrue. Chronic users of cannabis sativa may develop amotivational syndrome. Constantly being unconcerned about the future and even feeling unaspiring are signs of this syndrome, experts say (Hasday 40

Mind And Body

751 words - 3 pages judgments, while the body requires the mind to make its decisions for it. Without one or the other, I feel they would not be able to exist.      The mind and the body coexist together and thrive on the other by using the others traits. Many argue that a human’s death is not death until the brain or mind has stopped. Once the brain is stopped there is no function to control the body and cannot be revived. By that same statement

Mind And Body

1196 words - 5 pages following paragraphs, I will argue that it is more reasonable to think that the penitent has mental since the second doctor’s argument is more justified. To begin with, there are two major branches regard to the mind and body problem, dualism and monism. The first one claim that mind and body are two distinct substances, but the latter argue differently. There are many sub-branches of the two major ones. Such as Cartesian interactionism

Similar Essays

The Mind/Body Problem Essay

1589 words - 6 pages solving the mind/body problem, we must come to the sad realization that we have not yet solved it; but thankfully, much progress has already been made.Over the course of all the work that has been done, two major schools of thought have been developed, which are dualism, and monism (specifically materialism). Dualism, which was founded by Rene Descartes, and outlined in his Meditations, is based on the fundamental claim that the mind is a metaphysical

Mind Body Problem Essay

6819 words - 27 pages persists and is regarded as significant. There are different aspects to the mind-body problem. These are the ontological, semantical, epistemological and methodological problems. We are mainly interested in the ontological problem, that is, the nature of the mind and what its fundamental essence is.The mind-body problem comes from opposing views of the mind. Mental states and processes are characterised typically by consciousness and/or

The Mind Body Problem In Descartes Meditations

1402 words - 6 pages thinking thing that thinks and not an extended thing. He has a distinct idea of body as an extended thing. Therefore, his mind is disassociated from his body. This is essentially the theory of Dualism, meaning the mind and body, though separate entities, coexist and interact with each other.The body is like a machine. The mind and body are distinct. This can be seen by noting that the mind is indivisible while the body is divisible. The mind is

Exploring The Different Theories Involved In The Mind And Body Problem

2580 words - 10 pages Exploring the Different Theories Involved in the Mind and Body Problem I will attempt to do this by firstly defining what the mind and body is secondly discussing what the mind and body problem is. Thirdly discussing the existing approaches to the problem and finally discussing the strengths and weaknesses of the approaches. The body is that which we perceive ourselves to be with our senses. It usually includes arms