This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Angela's Ashes Essay

2642 words - 11 pages

How does the sense of emotion and depth of characterisation diminish in the film version of " Angela's Ashes""The book was much better than the film" is the ultimate cliché of the pretentious cinemagoer. However, as is the case with most clichés, there is an element of truth in this statement. For, while a picture might say a thousand words, there are some words that pictures can never express. When the words of great literature are translated into scripted lines and stage directions, some of the depth and beauty is lost. Cinema simply cannot convey internal thoughts and emotions with the same subtlety and clarity as the novel. This was certainly the case when one of the most acclaimed works of contemporary autobiographical writing was recently adapted for the screen. Frank McCourt's Pulitzer Prize winning memoir, Angela's Ashes, is a bittersweet narrative of growing up in poverty in 1940s Ireland. Seen through the eyes of a child, the events are intricately linked to a childlike innocence and wonderment. In the film version, this very personal outlook is lost because the film genre requires a more omniscient perspective. The loss of personal perspective and its accompanying insight into the protagonist's thoughts and emotions results in both a diminished depth of characterisation and a reduced emotional impact in the film version of Angela's Ashes.When I look back on my childhood I wonder how I managed to survive at all. It was, of course, a miserable childhood: the happy childhood is hardly worth your while. Worse than the ordinary miserable childhood is the miserable Irish childhood, and worse yet is the miserable Irish Catholic childhood. (McCourt, 1996, p. 11)So begins the luminous memoir of Frank McCourt, born in the Great Depression in Brooklyn to recently arrived Irish immigrants and raised in the slums of Limerick, Ireland. Frank's mother, Angela, has no money to feed the children as Frank's father, Malachy, rarely works and, when he does, he drinks his wage. Malachy is exasperating and irresponsible but strangely beguiling. Frank lives for his father's tales of Cuchulain who saved Ireland and of the Angel on the Seventh Step who brings his mother's babies. Wearing rags for diapers, begging a pig's head for Christmas dinner and gathering coal from the roadside to light a fire, Frank endures poverty, near-starvation and the casual cruelty of relatives and neighbours.Frank McCourt writes his narrative in the present tense and the first person from the perspective of a young boy. Throughout the book there is often a distance between Frank, the young boy who reports on events without forming opinions, and McCourt the writer, who explains to the reader the adult perspective of those events. In comparison, the film portrayed Frank as the central character who did not report on events, but instead only had an adult Frank narrating and forming opinions, which only gave an adult perspective. The book portrayed Frank McCourt's memoir...

Find Another Essay On Angela's ashes

Angela's Ashes author Frank McCourt Essay

583 words - 2 pages It is a common view that times for the Irish majority in the1930's and 40's were very hard. Especially for the IrishCatholic families with the stereotypical drunken father,emotionally wrecked mother, kids running round her with hersore back from the next child ready too be born. In Angela's Ashes,McCourt examines his childhood experiences, the tragedies, hardships,learning, all involved with growing up. One of the most interestingaspects of the

Frank McCourt in Angela's Ashes Essay

917 words - 4 pages Frank McCourt in Angela's Ashes This book is about a boy, Frank McCourt, growing up in a very difficult lifestyle. He and his family were very poor and moved away from America to Limerick to try and live an easier life. Frank's father is constantly out of a job and hasn't got enough money to support his family. Frank and his father have a very interesting relationship. Throughout the book, there are constant

Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt

727 words - 3 pages Angela's Ashes is a story written about the life of the author. Frank McCourt's family was poor. They lived in America (New York). Frank had a brother named Malachy. He also had two twin brothers, Oliver and Eugene. His mother (Angela) gave birth to a daughter named Margaret who died in infancy. His father would drink away his paycheck leaving the family with no money to get food. When Margaret was born, he stopped drinking. As soon as she died

Responce on Frank McCourt's "Angela's Ashes

763 words - 3 pages Frank McCourt's Angela's Ashes is a powerful, stunning and emotional memoir of his life starting from childhood to adulthood. This book has a unique way on the narrator technique which is using young Frank's 'innocent eye' to tell the story. This allows the reader to experience his own life in a transparent way and able to witness how Frank grow from a innocent child to a complex adult. His writing can be easily identified between the age of

Analysis of Angela's Ashes Narrated by Frank McCourt

4622 words - 18 pages Analysis of Angela's Ashes Narrated by Frank McCourt Angela's Ashes: A Memoir is Frank McCourt's acclaimed memoir. It charts the author's childhood from his infant years in Brooklyn, through his impoverished adolescence in Limerick, Ireland, to his return to America at the age of nineteen. First published in 1996, McCourt's memoir won the 1997 Pulitzer Prize in the category of best Biography/Autobiography, and has gone on to become a

Angela's Ashes Essay

923 words - 4 pages “You can turn painful situations around through laughter. If you can find humor in anything, even poverty, you can survive it” (“Brainy Quotes” 1). Frank McCourt’s, Angela’s Ashes, is an engaging memoir about his experience in the penury filled streets of Limerick, Ireland. Frank shares his adventure through life starting with his incredulous childhood. Frank’s scathing childhood consists of great deprivation; however, he adds humor throughout

Malachy McCourt: Negligent Father, or Troubled Soul? Analyzes the character of Malachy McCourt, Frankie's father from the novel "Angela's Ashes"

2133 words - 9 pages The novel Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt has entertained and astounded both literary analysts and book-lovers alike for a decade now, being critically acclaimed by countless respected scholars and critics of literature. Over the years, it has achieved numerous awards and honors, including the Pulitzer Prize. Among the most appealing aspects of this brilliant piece, Frank McCourt manages to weave a colorful tale mixed with both humor and sorrow

Family is Crucial in Angela's Ashes by Frank M. McCourt

684 words - 3 pages Many people believe that the importance of family is crucial. The memoir Angela’s Ashes is written by Frank McCourt. It examines the poor upbringing and the relationships within the McCourt family during the 1930’s. Through the use of descriptive language, dialogue and characterisation, it supports and opposes various values including the importance of family and the impact it has on the relationships enclosed in the memoir. Family should be of

Frank mc court´s angela´s ashes - analysis of main characters

3186 words - 13 pages encouraged byfriends and students who had appreciated McCourt's stories about him growing up in Ireland.His biography "Angela's Ashes - A Memoir", named after Frank McCourt's mother, waspublished in September 1996 and became, against all expectations, a bestseller. It madeliterary newcomer McCourt winner of the 1997 Pulitzer Prize and various other awards, wasfollowed by the sequel "´Tis" and formed the basis for a Hollywood movie released in

Angelas Ashes

602 words - 2 pages Angela's Ashes Exposition:      Characters: Francis McCourt- protagonist            Malachy McCourt (father)- antagonist            Angela McCourt (mother)- protagonist            Malachy McCourt (brother)- protagonist         &nbsp

Coping with poverty

1251 words - 5 pages COPING WITH POVERTY AND ITS CIRCUMSTANCESManawaka, Canada and Limerick, Ireland are on separate sides of the earth, however, when the Great Depression took place, both counties were equally affected. Angela's Ashes and Stone Angel are novels written in the era of The Great Depression, and involve characters reminiscing on their childhood and the desperate circumstances they encountered involving their poverty-stricken families. Angela's Ashes is

Similar Essays

Angela's Ashes Essay

1003 words - 4 pages Intertexual Essay By Anna Swartz Children expect many things from life, but as Margaret Michel once wrote "Life's under no obligation to give us what we expect". This statement is found to be true in "Angela's Ashes", by Frank McCourt and "Ten Thousand Sorrows", by Elizabeth Kim. In both novels the children's basic expectations for their parents like to be loved and cared for were not met. In the comparison of the two novels it

Angela's Ashes Essay

1345 words - 5 pages ''Angela's ashes'' are an Irish-American drama movie from 1999.1 The movie tells the story of Frank McCourt and his childhood after his family is being forced to move from America back to Ireland because of economical and family related problems. The movie tells us about Frank McCourt's life in Limerick in Ireland during his childhood in the 1930s. In the 20th century Ireland had a lot of economical problems. There was a lot of poverty

Angela's Ashes Essay

516 words - 2 pages f Angela's Ashes, Frank McCourt's Pulitzer Prize-winning memoir, was nothing more than a factual retelling of the author's "miserable Irish Catholic childhood," Alan Parker's film version would be a perfectly suitable companion piece. And though the grimy, waterlogged photo-realism of Parker's depiction of Irish poverty is not unmoving, the book's beating heart is McCourt's exquisite, lyric prose and his humorous, resiliently hopeful outlook

Compare To Angela's Ashes Essay

843 words - 3 pages Margaret and he has no smell of drink on him. Mam tells Minnie MacAdorey, He's in heaven over that child." (Page 30) I think that this passage connects to the book Gone with the Wind, because both Dad and Rhett Butler seem to change into different men when their daughters are born. Like Dad in Angela's Ashes, Rhett sings to his and Scarlett's daughter, and caters to her every immediate need. If the baby isn't happy, even for a