Animal Ethics Essay

1809 words - 7 pages

- -Animal ethics is concerned with the status of animals, whereas environmental ethics concerns itself with the relationship to the environment. I will show the existence of animal ethics depends on the existence of environmental ethics. I will prove this by showing that such philosophers who have practiced animal ethics such as Singer, Regan, and Taylor are limited because they are individualistic. Which means they are limited to animal concerns, and nothing else. But with the environmental ethics such philosophers as Leapold, Wesra and Naess look at the environment ethics collectively. Which means they look at the big picture which includes the animals and its environment.I will first look at the views of Peter Singer, who is a utilitarian. A utilitarian is someone who believes the greatest amount of good for the greatest number. Singer wants the suffering of animals to be taken into consideration. He states "If a being suffers, there can be no moral justification for refusing to take that suffering into consideration. No matter what the nature of the being, the principle of equality requires that its suffering be counted equally with the like suffering...". What this means is that the suffering of animals is not justified. He also states how he thinks a major way to stop the suffering of animals is to stop the experimenting on animals. He states"...the widespread practice of experimenting on other species in order to see if certain substances are safe for human beings, or to test some psychological theory about the effect of severe punishment or learning...". When he is talking about the experiments and suffering of animals. He is concerned most with domestic animals, he is not too concerned with the other animals in the word. Views like these make Singer limited.Singer is limited and individualistic because he is not concerned with the environment in which animals live and since he is a utilitarian, equality is not something he is concerned with. Even other philosopher criticizes the utilitarian point of view exhibited by Singer. Regan protests "Utilitarian has no room for the equal moral rights of different individuals because it has no room for their equal inherent value or worth. What has value for the utilitarian is the satisfaction of an individuals interests, not the individual whose interests they are". If things are not given equal rights, that includes the environment there will be a tomorrow to look forward to.Singer has also been known to show a lack of compassion and sympathy. As stated by Westra "IT is probable that, at a minimum, instrumental values has always been ascribed to those animals which have contributed in some way to the human community down through ages...Still it is possible to raise doubts about sympathy, as many claim to have no such feeling, including such animals defenders as Singer". Westra goes on to describe how Singer is not only unsympathetic to that of animals with intrinsic value but to those people in...

Find Another Essay On Animal ethics

Animal Breeding Ethics Essay

2367 words - 9 pages win became directly affected by the desire to profit. And as is the unique case with animal based ventures, the breeding practices are easily influenced by humans and this ease is more often than not seen to be utilized at the advantage of the humans. The mentality of utilizing horses as “vehicles” for making money and not as equal counterparts is then perpetuated and carried on to other areas; it is not just a mentality though. The ideology

Final Essay: Animal Ethics in Animal Narratives

1875 words - 8 pages As I have progressed through this class, my already strong interest in animal ethics has grown substantially. The animal narratives that we have read for this course and their discussion have prompted me to think more deeply about mankind’s treatment of our fellow animals, including how my actions impact Earth’s countless other creatures. It is all too easy to separate one’s ethical perspective and personal philosophy from one’s actions, and

The Ethics and Limitations of Animal Research

1871 words - 7 pages ), 78-82. DeGrazia, D. (2008). Moral Status As a Matter of Degree?. Southern Journal Of Philosophy, 46(2), 181-198. Gruen, L. (2010, September 13). The Moral Status of Animals. In Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy . Retrieved November 1, 2013 Regan, T. (1997). The Rights of Humans and Other Animals. Ethics And Behavior, 7(2), 103-111. Rowan, A. N. (1997, February). The Benefits and Ethics of Animal Research. In Indiana University. Retrieved

The Ethics of Animal Use in Biomedical Research

1986 words - 8 pages Jersey: 1989. pp. 148-162. Singer, Peter. "Animal Interests." The New York Review of Books, March 28, 1985, Vol. 32, No. 5. Taylor, Angus. Magpies, monkeys, and morals: what philosophers say about animal liberation. Peterborough, Ont.: Broadview Press, 1999. Wilson , James G. S., “Rights”, Principles of Health Care Ethics, Second Edition, eds. R.E. Ashcroft, A. Dawson, H. Draper and J.R. McMillan. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 2007. pp. 239.

The Ethics of Animal Testing for Vaccine Development and Potential Alternatives

2451 words - 10 pages regulated, Edward Jenner had challenged a human subject to prove that immunity to smallpox had been established using his method.3 Challenge studies are no longer permissible on human subjects, so animal studies are essential to obtain such information.4 While the ethics of animal use are important, they may be outweighed by the ethics associated with the proper care of our fellow man. Some of the ideas associated with ethical treatment appear

Comparing Jane Goodall's A Question of Ethics and Heloisa Sabin's Essay "Animal Research Saves Human Lives"

1189 words - 5 pages choices human beings make. This view can be unrealistic in many situations. Jane Goodall’s A Question of Ethics was a very emotional and Rogerian style essay, but I found it lacked the supporting facts and credibility that can be found in Heloisa Sabin’s aggressive “classic” styled essay Animal research Saves Human Lives. Heloisa Sabin helped establish the Sabin Vaccine Institute in 1993 whose mission is to promote the role of vaccines which will

The Ethics of Medical Animal Testing

1896 words - 8 pages In all matters, including medicine, the well-being of the human race comes before any other consideration. This is the justification for the use of nonhuman animal testing in medicine. Of course this argument brings issues into play that are both ethical and professional and need exploring before a definitive answer can be given. The Rights of “Lesser Life Forms” Animals have rights. This is a statement that very few people will

Relationship Magnitude Paper: Write on the balance of human, animal and nature from a case study in "Watersheds 4: Ten Cases in Environmental Ethics". Case study Skunked was picked

850 words - 3 pages together to solve this issue albeit small in vision. The cost of fish will eventually rise to a competitive level like it did in Japan and this will be the price humans pay for not keeping the balance with nature.ReferencesDesJardins, J (2006). Environmental Ethics: An Introduction to EnvironmentalPhilosophy, 4e . Belmont, CA: Wadsworth, a division of Thomson Learning, Inc.Newton, L, Dillingham, C, & Choly, J (2006). Watersheds 4: Ten Cases inEnvironmental Ethics, 4e. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth, a division of Thomson Learning, Inc. Wadsworth, a division of Thomson Learning, Inc. .

Animal Abuse Cases

1319 words - 5 pages Throughout the world there are many animal abuse cases that increase every year, most cases not even being reported yet. The word animal cruelty gets thrown around a lot and can be categorized into different scenarios and laws. The point of researching animal cruelty is to get the reader to change their perspective on how they view animal cruelty and try to show them that animals need to be heard and helped, animals should have the same rights

Animal testing: Inevitability of animal testing

1161 words - 5 pages animals. Animal testing is inevitable for three reasons: provision of essential data, contribution to humanity and guarantee of animal rights. To begin with, animal testing deducts vital data that cannot be drawn from human testing.Scientific developments related to human ethics are accomplishedby animal testing.Ethics of human are so important that science has a limitation line drawn by them. For instance, cloning is banned due to human ethics

The Advantages of Animal Cloning

1295 words - 6 pages were disgusted with animal cloning when they learned animal suffering was involved ( Ethics : End Animal Cloning). Although animal cruelty was observed in the experimental stages of cloning, the current procedures used in cloning have become safer for the animals involved. This is important because when people realize the positive impact animal cloning can have it outweighs some peoples views of unethical wellbeing. One reason cloning should

Similar Essays

Animal Ethics Essay

1672 words - 7 pages Animal Ethics      Animal ethics is concerned with the status of animals, whereas environmental ethics concerns itself with the relationship to the environment. I will show the existence of animal ethics depends on the existence of environmental ethics. I will prove this by showing that such philosophers who have practiced animal ethics such as Singer, Regan, and Taylor are limited because they are individualistic

Ethics Of Animal Research Essay

747 words - 3 pages Ethics of Animal Research One of the many issues of today's conversations is still confusing on my understanding it. Is it ethical for people to engage in animal research for human excellence? And if so, just how far can animal research be taken to meet these achievements for human kind? When thinking about this, I would conclude that animals over human beings do not have any rights what so ever, but I would be the biggest hypocrite in

Animal Sentience In Ethics Essay

1351 words - 5 pages 1DoddJessica DoddPHI 2600Professor LuciusSentience of Animals: A Philosophical ApproachAnimal Rights is a controversial topic worldwide. To understand animals and the rights that they are entitled to as living beings, a person must first understand how truly sentient animals are. Numerous philosophical approaches could give an explanation as to why animal rights should be of a significantly respected level. These philosophical approaches include

Animal Testing Ethics Essay

1528 words - 6 pages ; Engineering Ethics, vol. 12 issue 1,p111-122Langley, G.R.(March 2007) Animals in Science education-ethics and alternatives. Journal of Biological Education, vol. 25 issue 4, p274Barnard, N. (2007, March). Animal testing? Vegetarian Times, issue 348, p 19-21