This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Animal Instinct And Epistemology Essay

1865 words - 7 pages

Animal Intelligence and Epistemology
Epistemology is defined as the area of philosophy that deals with questions concerning knowledge and that considers various theories of knowledge. There are many paths to follow in epistemology, including skepticism, rationalism, empiricism, constructivism, and epistemological relativism, all of which offer very different views to explain how people know things. These views concern primarily human intelligence and largely ignore animal intelligence in creating their theories, but animal intelligence could play a pivotal role in the development of epistemological theories. This issue has been controversial, especially in recent years when research has revealed that animal’s thoughts very likely extend beyond instinct and conditioning as B.F. Skinner and Rene Descartes once thought. Today, the question of whether animals besides humans possess intelligence is a prevalent one and may help humans to understand better the intricate concept of epistemology.
The concept of intelligence is itself controversial. There are varying definitions of intelligence, including the Russian Artificial Intelligence Researcher’s definition that an intelligent being gives intelligent answers to intelligent questions (Animal Intelligence). Webster’s dictionary defines intelligence as simply the capacity for learning, reasoning, understanding, and similar forms of mental activity (Webster). In an article for The Nature Institute, intelligence is given the definition of “ the capacity to meet new and unforeseen situations by rapid and effective adjustment of behavior” (Holdrege). So, with a vague definition of intelligence, it is difficult to determine whether or not animals exhibit intelligence. To meet this end, scientists look for the things in animals that seem like singularly human behavior. They study language abilities, tool use, and emotion in animals to determine to what
Walker 2
extent animals exhibit intelligence.
Language abilities and symbolic complexity involve the number of symbols that a group uses in communication with each other. Humans typically have verbal symbols in the range of twenty to forty symbols and some pictographic languages can have thousands of symbols. While different species of animals have varying amounts of symbols, the most basic, least intelligent animals have as few as eight symbols that they use to communicate. Another factor in determining intelligence through symbolic complexity is the extent to which these symbols can be used in relation to each other. The aforementioned basic creatures use each of their limited symbols to give a specific message, which indicates limited intelligence on their part (Animal Intelligence). However, it is speculated that there are other animals, like the dolphin, that can use their extensive amount of symbols to interact with each other with combinatorial complexity close to that of humans. In an article for...

Find Another Essay On Animal Instinct and Epistemology

Twentieth Century Aesop’s Fables: How Ted Hughes Presents Modern Man through the Non-Human

1729 words - 7 pages Twentieth Century Aesop’s Fables: How Ted Hughes Presents Modern Man through the Non-Human. Ted Hughes’ poems mostly explore the world of nature. He uses ordinary animals like crow, pike, and skylark, but adding mythical quality to them. Animals in his world are superior to human and he seems to adore their brutality and instinct. He does not rationalize animal, which is unlike D.H Lawrence. Some criticize him for praising animals’ brutality

Philosophical Comparison Darwin & Bergson Essay

2053 words - 8 pages at impulses to keep creative evolution moving along. Bergson's concept of instinct, in tandem with intellect, is an explicit theory that follows logically with his ideas of élan vital, vegetable torpor, vegetable kingdom (immobility), and animal kingdom (mobility). He brings his reader up the stepladder of organic evolution one logical step at a time without ever having to justify himself or his theory. He just let it speak for itself

The Issues of Animal Testing?

1128 words - 5 pages one has the right to kill any other living organisms. Nevertheless, there is always an exception. For example, animals must hunt weaker animals for food. Without any food they will not be able to live long and spread their species. Just like this example, animal testing is a same concept. The reason for animal testing is to research for better medical science related to extending human life. The desire for longevity is a natural instinct that

The Animal Testing Controversy

964 words - 4 pages Animal Testing Animal testing is a controversial subject amongst many people, some of which believe it greatly benefits humanity and others who believe it is animal cruelty. Animal treatment during testing is one of the most discussed arguments between those who are for and against testing. How regulated and ethical or unethical are these procedures? Do animals deserve rights that would make them exempt from laboratory testing

What do you know? A question and overview of Philosophy. Based on the study of 'Sophie's World'by J Gaarder

2053 words - 8 pages the gap; taking the notably feasible points of each and blending them together in a remarkable way that makes them all the more feasible.Platonic epistemology seems a little bit 'out of our world', though quite intriguing.Knowledge involves many factors; these include belief, truth and justification, reason, sensory perception, common sense and instinct. Common sense is innate; it is something every human being is born with to more or lesser

The Relevance of Philosophy in Every Day Life

723 words - 3 pages to life can be seen in many aspects, from our general everyday knowledge, to the questions of right and wrong, and even stemming to the whole structure of society itself. Humans are naturally curious; for thousands of years, people ponder over reasons such as the common question, “Why are things the way they are?” Society creates possible answers by surrounding themselves with knowledge. The main purpose of epistemology is to discover a way and

Analysis of Jack London´s To Build a Fire

638 words - 3 pages apprehensive towards traveling in the vitriolic, pounding snow, and that could have served as a exhortation to save the man’s life. Therefore, it is animals, not arrogant men, who heed Nature’s warnings, yet man can understand Nature through the medium of animal-kind. This aids humans to become peaceful and actually understand Nature, rather than destroying it, as is occurring today. Natural thought and instinct are helpful in situations of organic

Animals’ Rights?

919 words - 4 pages animal species have been killed by the hundreds each year, many times for the purpose of putting money in the pocket of the killers. Some animals have been wounded and not retrieved and therefore left to die in agony. This must stop and there are some reasons why. If all of the animals were gone, then they could not reproduce and would not survive as an ongoing species. Humans could not survive without animals for food and shelter. Killing these

Animal Behavior

584 words - 2 pages males. The red belly of males is the stimulus for aggressive behavior. However as ethologist Niko Tinbergen discovered, any object with a red underside initiates the same aggressive FAP.Thus, it is evident from the description of pheromones, mimicry, and instinct behavior, that they increase individual reproductive successes. Thus, these kinds of animal behaviors or the mechanisms that contribute to behaviors are essential since they support in

Carl JUng

2212 words - 9 pages Epistemology with John Dewey, which addresses the question of how the human subject is adequate to its object (Dunlap 2012 pg.57). In other words, how do we as humans get to know the world? During his work with John Dewey, Jung uses terminology of clinical psychology to speak about unconscious. Which shows that even after his and Freud's fallout he still continued to work on the study of the unconsciousness."Jung speaks of the 'unconscious' as

Galen of Pergamum Apex of Greek Medical Tradition

965 words - 4 pages . While being an innovative observer in accomplishing the first depiction of a four-chambered human heart, his epistemology was indeed philosophically based (Boylan, 2002). His practice required detailed observation backed up by theory to decipher said observations (2002). Galen drew on previous theory of the four elements (earth, air, fire, and water) alongside the contraries (hot, cold, wet, and dry) (Boylan, 2002). This method was first

Similar Essays

My Essay,"What An Animal", Uses Rick Bass's "Antlers" To Exemplify Humanities Denial And Loss Of It's Primal Roots, And The Confusion That Results From Interaction With The Last Vestiges Of Animal...

791 words - 3 pages My essay,"What an Animal", uses Rick Bass's "Antlers" to exemplify humanities denial and loss of it's primal roots, and the confusion that results from interaction with the last vestiges of animal instinct. At some point in history humankind invented the notion that we are separate or even superior to rest of the animal kingdom. For centuries since, humankind has denied our nature in an attempt to prove this theory. It is now considered

Reason Versus Instinct In “The Most Dangerous Game By Richard Connell

654 words - 3 pages element of suspense also plays a key role in further emphasizing Connell’s theme that humans possess both reason and instinct. From the beginning of the story Connell repeatedly uses suspense starting from the second Whitney brings up the mysterious island to the very end of the hunt. During the hunt is when the theme becomes most prevalent. Although Rainsford wishes to take the life of Zaroff, he remains more man than animal by keeping his outlook

Philosophical Critic Of Henri Bergson's Creative Evolution

818 words - 3 pages compelled the animal to organize the external world to suit itself rather that adapting itself to the external world. Bergson says, "instinct and intelligence...represent two divergent solutions" and that intellect is so far shown strongest in the human animal (Bergson, 143). They are, in fact, two sides of the same coin. Each represents a kind of innate knowledge where instinct is interested in things and intellect in relations (Bergson, 148). The

Character Of Stanley Kowalski In Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar

1419 words - 6 pages calmly; he will roar and fight back, provided that the injury is not instantly fatal. Both of these reactions are instinctive; neither animal will think, “Oh, I’m hurt, I should start howling and fight back.” No! Each will mourn his injuries and try to set things right by attacking his attacker because their defensiveness -- that is, their passionate instinct -- has been sparked.   Stanley reacts in much the same way an animal would.  He