Conducting Medical Research On Animals Essay

1448 words - 6 pages

“The notion that human life is sacred just because it is human life is medieval”, this was written by Peter Singer in his book Animal Liberation. Animals are all over, whether it is at home as companions, at the circus as entertainment, or in our closets as clothing. Citizens of the United States are aware that the medicines we are to take have to be approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), but many of us have been ignorant to how exactly the majority of these medicines are approved and who are the testing dummies that are used to come up with these medication. Conducting medical research with animals has caused break out of legal, scientific, and ethical dilemmas concerning that topic. In this paper I will try to give an unbiased understanding of the research experiments animals have to undergo and the ethical issue that arise supported by Peter Singer.
It has been recorded that physician-scientist such as Aristotle and Erasistratus has performed experiments on living animals. In 1937, a pharmaceutical company here in the United States, came up with a drug called Elixir Sulfanilamide. This drug consisted of a solvent that was highly poisonous which lead to the death of hundreds of people. It wasn’t until then that the Federal Food Drug and Cosmetic Act required testing of drugs on animals before they could be marketed to humans. In 1959, W.M.S. Russell and R.L. Burch introduced the three R’s for the use of humane treatment of animals. The first R is for the replacement of animals with non-living models, the second R is for the reduction in the use of animals, and the third R is for the refinement of animal use practices.
The Animal Welfare Act signed in 1966, is the only federal law that regulates the treatment of animals in research and transport, meaning that it seeks to protect animals used for scientific and medical research by limiting the procedures that can be performed. This Act overall is not very efficient because it only covers warm-blooded animals and excludes mice, rats, birds, and fishes which makes up 95 percent of the animals used in research. There are other acts such as the Humane Methods of Livestock Slaughter Act which regulates how animals that are raised for consumption are killed, the Endangered Species Act which list species that are threatened by extinction as “endangered” and then regulates and limits human activities in areas where those animals are mostly known to exist.
There is currently no world wide treaty on animal rights but in 1978, UNESCO was presented as the Universal Declaration of Animal rights. There are some foreign laws that focuses mostly on trade in exotic animals as pets, animal cruelty legislation, and the fur industry. In Austria there is a Federal Act on the Protection of Animals that came about on January 1st, 2005; which mainly focuses on the fact that animals are not objects and in Canada there is a Criminal Code: Cruelty to Animal that is updated on a regular basis; it is part of...

Find Another Essay On Conducting Medical Research on Animals

Research on Animals and Biodiversity Essay

1459 words - 6 pages photographs of the animal. All photographs were then processed within a laboratory and expanded so researchers could study the markings on each individual dolphin closer. The results of the research included one hundred and thirty five photo-ID pictures, which were compiled over one hundred and fifty eight research hours. A survey was held no farther than five days apart. The research showed that individual dolphins within the particular group stayed

Medical Research on Human Subjects Essay

569 words - 2 pages justified, the research have to be scientific adequate; the rights of human subjects protected; clinicians obtain informed consent from patients; patients must be informed about randomization. First, Roy et al. stated that adequate preliminary experimentation must be carried out on animal models before human subjects are used in a clinical trial. Medical researches or clinical trials with human subjects must conform to the principle of scientific

What might christians think about the use of animals in medical research?

1070 words - 4 pages What Might Christians Think About The Use Of Animals In medical Research?One of the questions facing society today is whether animals should be used in scientific experimentation. In the midst of this controversy, many ideas about nature, primarily animals, are formed. Each side has different arguments, each one posing questions on the place of humans with respect to animals and the rest of the natural world.Many people argue against using

Research topic: Global warming effects on Animals

540 words - 2 pages earth. Soplease take into consideration what I have said, and try to do your part. After all, it will be our nextgeneration that will feel the effects.Thank you.Bibliography:"The Causes of Global Warming." The Causes of Global Warming. Laura Wisland, 2013. Web. 30 Sept. 2014. <>."Global Warming Effects on Animals." Global Rush. Loveleena Rajeev, n.d. Web. 01 Oct. 2014. <http

Animal Experimentation

1540 words - 6 pages ,” concerns about animals, but cannot hinder to improve medicine or other advance for the welfare of humans. On the other hand, philosopher Tom Reagan, contributing to the book, “Ill-Gotten Gains,” is against animal experimentation. He argues that conducting experimentation on animals “exacts the grave moral price of failing to show proper respect for animals’ inherit value, whatever the benefits for the research (224).” Consequently, after reading

Animal Testing is Vital to Medical Advances

3050 words - 12 pages Research said, “Every major medical advance of this century has depended on animal research” and Dr. Wise Young who is a neuroscientist from Rutgers University said, “There’s never been a medical therapy developed without animals” (Greek).Positive opinions from a researcher and neuroscientist who are very familiar with animal testing show how animal testing is greatly valued in the science world. Thanks to animal testing there are cures, vaccines

Animal Testing and People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals

1307 words - 5 pages % of medical schools across the United States have completely replaced the use of animal laborities in medical training with stimulators.” These studies for medical students are way better and lifesaving than cutting into animals. Doing research published in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, the food and drug administration noted that “92% of all drugs that are shown to be safe and effective on animals fail in human trials because they


4715 words - 19 pages research one performs tests on animals. For example, rabbits are locked in a chamber and forced to inhale grass, sprays, and vapors. In dermal toxicity studies, rabbits have their fur removed to have substances placed on their skin. In this case they are restrained so they don't scratch (2:55). Testing is conducted to assess the potency, effectiveness, or toxicity of substances that have established or potential usefulness for medical

Animal Experimentation in Scientific Research

2561 words - 10 pages horrible living conditions. This shows that they experience distress before they even enter the laboratory and being experimentation. It is estimated that more than 100 million animals are used in America “as models biological and medical research to study human disease, injury, development, psychology, and anatomy and physiology” (AAVS). Millions of animals are given these diseases and injuries to be studied for medical research in hopes of insight

Animal Testing

1017 words - 4 pages there are any unforeseen effects is to test it on a living being. (Animal Welfare) The testing of laboratory animals for medical research has played a big part in the advancement of mankind. Without animal testing the world would be a very different place. In the past century many discoveries in medicine can be attributed to animal testing. Many more are expected to be found in the future as the testing of animals continues. The regulations

Animal Experimentation

800 words - 4 pages Animal experimentation is the concept of animals being used in experiments to testify if cosmetic, medical, and household items are safe to be used by humans daily. Animals have been used throughout the world since 500 B.C. as a tool to experiment on that may involve the use of surgeons torturing animals while experimenting, causing deaths, and suffering throughout the experiments. It has been a huge debate between surgeons and the public that

Similar Essays

Medical Testing On Animals Essay

697 words - 3 pages vivisection. Vivisection is the medical term forthe practice of experimenting on animals. Charles River BreedingLaboratories, a company owned by Bausch and Lomb, provides 40-50% ofthe animals used in experiments of laboratories. The other remainigmisfortunate animals come from places a little closer to you and me.Some of them come from animal shelters, some come from the "free togood home" ads in the classified section of the newspaper, some

The Use Of Animals In Medical Research.

993 words - 4 pages health, safety, and well being of both humans and animals have been enormous. Without animal research, very few of the medical advances we expect today for ourselves and our loved ones would be possible. Vaccines for rabies were developed using dogs and rabbits. Smallpox, which killed more than two million people, can now be prevented because of research on cows. Diphtheria was dominated with research on guinea pigs and horses. Polio would have

Should Animals Be Used For Medical Research?

1441 words - 6 pages accelerated by the Medicine Act, 1968, which provided a guide to the use of animals in safety testing. This expansion reflected a growing medical field. In 1986, in UK the Animal Welfare Act was approved, ensuring higher animal care in laboratory. Scientists improved better tests, using less animals and making sure that none received intentionally a fatal dose. Thanks to animals research the 20th century made many medical discoveries, to state few

Medical Testing On Prisoners, Not Animals

2558 words - 10 pages should be used in the place of animals for the advancement of medical history. There have been multiple cases and stories where prisoners have been abused through medical research, which the reader will realize as this paper is being read. All of these incidents with the prisoners are not as nearly graphic or inhuman as animal testing. Animal testing is cruel, they have no choice, whereas prisoners would have a choice. Prisoners on death row should