Answering The "Social Question": The Progressive Remaking Of American Liberalism.

1639 words - 7 pages

In his article "The Liberal Spirit in America", Peter Berkowitz discusses the factors that have contributed to the triumph of Liberalism in the United States. The core of his thesis is that in order for Liberalism to be successful it was necessary to reconcile the two often contradictory traditions of the theory in its application as a state ideology, specifically, the twin concerns of individual liberty and social justice. These traditions were reconciled, according to Berkowitz through the development of a sort of 'Progressive Liberalism' that in many respects, diverged from Classical Liberalism in many key tenets (Berkowitz, 2003: 27-47). In light of this apparent divergence from Classical Liberal theory, can American Liberalism today, as informed by Progressive Liberalism, really be regarded as Liberal, or has it strayed so far that its only resemblance is etymological? This essay will endeavour to answer this question by focussing on the emergence of Progressive Liberalism, and examining whether attempts to reconcile its conflicting traditions in fact morphed Liberalism in America into something largely unrecognisable as Liberalism in the Classical sense.The post Civil War era, or the 'Gilded Age' as Mark Twain famously dubbed it, was a time of unprecedented social change. Like Western Europe before them, the US was facing the dynamism of industrialisation and subsequent urbanisation, unlike the European experience of the mid to late 19th century however, the US had to quite literally reunite its nation after the disastrous schism of the Civil War. Moreover, American cities were also being filled with an influx of immigrants from a wide range of national, religious and linguistic backgrounds, fundamentally altering the composition of American society, as homogenous rural communities were replaced by heterogenous urban communities as the centres of social, economic and political power. American society was in short, confronted with an entirely new set of social and political circumstances; challenges which were utterly unique to anything pre-existing in the American historical experience (Taylor, 2004: 19). Despite the national enthusiasm for egalitarianism, there existed a deficit between the rhetoric of the nation's founding principles and the actual experiences of its citizens. The first stirrings of Progressivism can be traced back as early as 1884, with one writer commenting, "This battle between State-interference and laissez-faire is now upon us; it will be waged through all the near future" (Quoted in Fine, 1956: 373). However it was not until 1912 that the Progressives became politically dominant, exemplified by the bi-partisan subscription to Progressive Liberal philosophy in the Presidential election of that year. Perhaps the most high profile political proponents of Progressive Liberalism, 1912 Presidential candidates Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson were heavily influenced by Richard Ely, leader of a school of young...

Find Another Essay On Answering the "Social Question": The Progressive remaking of American Liberalism.

To what extent do personal attributes affect Ways of Knowing and why, if at all, does answering this question matter in the first place?

1134 words - 5 pages Einstein's belief in God made him reason differently about the new physics (quantum physics). He would not accept this new way of looking at things, and simply denied the probabilistic world view by saying "God is not malicious". Even though there are flaws in the realm of knowledge, like how can everyone with a different opinion know the same thing and if that how do we know what we know is the right way of knowing. Someone's personal

The Importance of The Gilded Age and The Progressive Era To the Development of American Society

1049 words - 4 pages displays of wealth. At the same time, this was an era of major achievements in the industry and economy, which significantly changed life of American people. The Gilded Age was followed by the Progressive Era which lasted from the 1890s to the 1920s. Progressive Era is well known for its economical, political, social reforms and technological inventions. In my opinion, The Gilded Age had a more significant impact upon the United States than the

Presidents of the Progressive Era

829 words - 4 pages The progressive era was a period of social activism and political reform in the United States. The political climate was ripe for reform and America was seeking leaders who could provide a new, more beneficial direction. Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson were two of the most renowned presidents of this era. One kindred goal of both of these presidents was to monitor and rectify large trust and monopolies in the U.S. Despite the fact that

Answering Americas Call. The role of America today

693 words - 3 pages longer do we need to send most of our country's men off to fight. Rather we can just sit some of them down on a computer and do just as much damage. With computers and the viruses that go with them, people can destroy the economies of whole countries without wasting a single American life. Countries can crumble with the push of a few simple buttons on a keyboard. But to understand all of this new technology requires a great deal of

Frederick Jackson Turner and the Question of American Exceptionalism

1784 words - 7 pages into a rapidly modernizing world. Progressive historian Frederick Jackson Turner wrote less and influenced his own generation more than any important historian. In his works, Turner spelled out his version of a New History in the modern spirit. Although his writings were few and limited, Turner promoted westward American expansion as unique and the conditions settlers faced in settling the frontier as the exception. The thing of first

Silver’s Remaking Eden and the Silver Screen

1114 words - 4 pages Silver’s Remaking Eden and the Silver Screen In Remaking Eden, Lee M. Silver asks three central questions: Who controls life? What counts as life? And what will human life look like in the future? The question Silver does not ask is whether or not human life as we now know and define it will change. Silver sees the advance of genetic engineering as inevitable, due to consumer demand for it as a technology and the unrelenting curiosity of

Are the Values of Liberalism Universal

2595 words - 10 pages block through a square hole. I believe that the opposition to the imperialistic nature of liberalism to not be as simple as Okin makes out. I believe it travels a lot deeper than a simple dismissal of theories which attempt to reach out liberal tendrils across the globe. It calls into question not only our theoretical standpoint, but through its conflicting position to the ingrained logic, our whole mode of conceptualization. People who support a

Affects of American Progressive Movement

849 words - 3 pages essential for democracy.Though the progressive era was one that attempted to progress American society, the acceptance of moral and intellectual superiority, and exaggerated confidence in the social applications of science, and an uncritical acceptance of the use of state power to coerce individual behavior, which were the seeds of the progressive movement, could readily be interpreted as repressive and destructive. Through these beliefs, the increased strength of the government threatened democracy itself.

A review of Richard White's "The Organic Machine: The Remaking of the Columbia River"

618 words - 2 pages The Organic Machine: The Remaking of the Columbia River. By Richard White. (New York: Hill and Wang, 1995, ix, 130 pp. Paperback, $12.00, ISBN 0-8090-1583-8).In a close examination of the history and development of the Columbia River, The Organic Machine: The Remaking of the Columbia River connects the elements of natural and artificial energy in order to reveal both the beauty and the danger of the Columbia today. In his book, Richard White

The Effects of the Progressive Movement

884 words - 4 pages Progressive Movement The Progressive Movement was initiated to fix many of the United States problems surrounding its industrial growth of the nineteenth century. The ultimate goal of Progressivism was to clear up corruption in all phases of the economy and the government. Both President Theodore Roosevelt and President Woodrow Wilson wanted to give the working man a better chance to achieve success (, 2008). By the time of the

Samuel Huntington's The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order

2665 words - 11 pages Abstract Samuel Huntington's The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order defines eight major civilizations on the basis of religion. This division of global powers can be used to prove that the Western civilization will never completely dominate the global media. While Western thought tends to lead to a more representative form of government, and consequently a more libertarian or social responsibility-based media, the other

Similar Essays

This Is A Mid Term Exam Answering Question Posed By The Professor On The Sociology Of Poverty

5437 words - 22 pages these explanations wide appeal.The restricted opportunity perspective differs vastly from the flawed perspective. According to this perspective, the reason people are poor is because of the system (blame the system). Restricted opportunity has a more progressive approach which directly contradicts the flawed perspective. The basic elements include: "People are poor because of forces beyond their control (economic, social, and political factors

The Transformation Of Liberalism Essay

2879 words - 12 pages Liberalism is a force that has produced change from the birth of this nation to the politics of today. Liberal tenets have been a basis of thought and action in American politics since well before the signing of the Constitution. Certainly, liberalism has had to transform in order to remain a legitimate force throughout the years. When considering this transformation, one may ask whether or not the ideas and goals of classical liberalism have

The Effect Of Answering Machines On Society

1088 words - 4 pages leave all different kinds of messages in a variety of ways, the whole practice has been mainstreamed to such an extent that we can usually predict the contents of the message after the we hear the first few words. This is because the social norms dictating what is said on the answering machine are just as regulatory as the ones that assure that, as Americans, we have one in the first place.The fact that you don't know who is going to hear the

To What Extent Do Personal Attributes Affect Ways Of Knowing And Why, If At All, Does Answering This Question Matter In The First Place?

785 words - 3 pages of 6, at this age I moved to China, I completely failed to understand why did the Chinese ask my parents for permission to touch my hair and take and take a photo with me. Only after a few years of living here I started understanding that for them it was something so rare to see a little girl with, as they say, 'hair made of gold'.As far as I consider answering this question does matter. Once we know about the boundaries which our personal