Antigone: An Irrational Desire Essay

1033 words - 5 pages

Throughout time society has developed a system from which humans are able to define good and bad, Ethics. Although Ethical norms have been adapted throughout the passing of time, its most intrinsic values have prevailed, enabling individuals to agree on standards of what good and bad are built on their moral standards. Morals are what give the individual the capacity to distinguish good from bad. In the ancient Greece morals were indeed the individuals perception of good, and bad however, these perceptions were greatly abided and driven by the divine laws imposed by the gods. In Antigone, a tragedy written by Sophocles, we see the how the main character defies the kings rules and stands for ...view middle of the document...

Perhaps for Eliot’s neither of these reasons exemplifies Antigone’s honest lust, with the development of the story it’s inevitable not to realize that all of these apprehend one common goal, the stubborn desire to defy, to prove and to triumph over Creon and a desirable death which in the end clarifies that Antigone’s does what she has to, only to feed her irrational reasons. However from many perspectives Antigone’s rightful actions serve as more than enough prove and contradict Eliot’s observation.

Antigone’s decision to give her dear beloved brother a proper and honorable burial succeeds in abiding to many morally correct choices involving the conception of good. A prime obligation that justifies Antigone’s action is the laws imposed by the gods, which are meant to be followed and to never be broken. Her actions also demonstrates her devotion and loyalty to her blood bond ties, to the point that for her brother she is willing to give up her own life. Another reason that illustrates Antigone’s the drive behind the burial of her brother is the opposition to Creon’s statute, which symbolizes the female’s power of will and civic duty as a citizen of the state. As said before Antigone does the most natural human action, by burying her brother she is giving a prime importance to her family ties, consequently she is also obeying the divine law imposed by the Gods, and portraying woman not as weak and fragile as they’ve been foolish seen, but as strong minded beings, stubborn enough to oppose men and stand for their ideals. However these are not reasons for Antigone, but instead inevitable causes that describe her actions and unveil the ambiguous and irrational reasons Antigone stands for.

Through her words speak her reasons. “But now, Polynices, after burying your body, I reap rewards like these. Still, I honored you well (910) in the eyes of the wise. No, if somehow children whose mother I was or my...

Find Another Essay On Antigone: An irrational desire

The Personality Traits of Antigone Essay

1161 words - 5 pages punishment for breaking his law was public stoning, which ultimately resulted in death. In a way she becomes a martyr - she is giving up her life based on her belief that her brother Polyneices be given a proper burial as was her other brother Eteocles. There are so many consequences that will follow her actions but Antigone is only looking to demonstrate her love, honor and loyalty to her family. She makes is very clear that she has a will, an

Roles of Women in Antigone Essay

2511 words - 10 pages evoking passion and subjectiveness on their role as people in this world, but more specifically as civilians of Greece. Antigone has the mentality that she owes her duty of being an obedient family member (Johnson 370). Likewise, Ismene fears for her sister’s life and tries to persuade her that her allegiance may lay too strongly in the wrong place. Both women ultimately value family, however, they are split between whom they are most considerate to

Antigone as a Tragedy

1051 words - 4 pages condemns her to be buried alive in a cave and she decides to hang herself instead of enduring the slow death. As a consequence, Kreon loses his wife and son and is left to rule alone. Even with this plot, it is argued that Antigone is not a tragedy because it does not fit into Aristotle's mold like Oedipus the King does and therefore has not become as classic of an example of tragedy. Proving that Antigone is not a tragedy consists of

Creon's Defense to Oedipus's Accusations and Their Relevance to the Ambivalence Nature of the Kingship

1207 words - 5 pages of the assertion that the kingship changes one's character, one could point to the events of Antigone and Creon's striking change in character in the play. In Oedipus the King, Creon reveals himself to be a reasonable ruler, who makes rational decisions and is not quick to anger, as is revealed by his calmness in his responses to Oedipus's heated accusations. However, in Antigone, Creon has become prideful and irrational. His dealings with

Tragic Characters of Antigone: Examining Creon's Hubris

1240 words - 5 pages threatens to kill the Sentry just because he does not have information. Creon’s actions and views directly disagree with the saying, “don’t shoot the messenger.” The most irrational and foolish decision of the play, however, was Creon’s sentencing of Antigone to death. Sophocles writes,“ …Even brave men run when they see Death coming,” (1. 2. 165-166). Had it not been for Creon’s fatal impulsivity, Antigone, his son, and his wife would have all

Antigone- Bastion of Virtue

1653 words - 7 pages "laws the gods all hold in honor", Creon disintegrated his own virtue and the virtue of Thebes itself (Sophocles, Antigone). Therefore, the actions of Antigone should not be met with stoning, but with honor and praise. For she is fighting an injustice within our laws and preserving justice, "the bond of men" (Aristotle, Politics). As Aristotle writes, the human soul is capable of understanding, free will, planning, and deliberation. Due to

Antigone essay

904 words - 4 pages to uphold her family’s honor. Antigone defends her actions by revealing how the law interferes with family matters. Her behavior clarifies her morals, which pertain to the idea that family is a legitimate reason to defy higher authorities, and her thoughts on family and its significance. Though Creon’s law may be seen as irrational, he believed that it was the right decision at the time. In order to maintain his reputation as king and preserve

The Tragedies of Thebes

921 words - 4 pages fate as a result of a tragic flaw. During Antigone, Creon suffers from an overwhelming sense of pride. Creon’s pride causes him to condemn Antigone, who is the fiance of Creon's son Haemon. Creon condemns Antigone to be buried alive for defying his law to never bury her brother Polyneices. While arguing with his son Haemon about the fate of Antigone, Creon says, “Better to fall from power, if fall we must, at the hands of a man - never be rated to


1757 words - 7 pages as a fool, and you so old. For what you say is surely insupportable when you say the gods took forethought for this corpse” (310-313). Even though Antigone exhibits a blamable pride and a hunger for glory, her disobedience is less serious than those of Creon. It is evident that Antigone’s actions are driven by a love for her brother, and a desire to please the gods. While Creon’s actions are founded in his quest for more power and complete


2564 words - 10 pages . Oedipus and Antigone arrive in shambles and rags at a grove in Colonus located just outside of Athens. This again shows the humility of Oedipus for he chose not to reign as king in Corinth. Subsequently, a stranger arrives informing the visitors that the grave is sacred and a dedication to the Furies and that the King of Athens is an amiable and generous ruler named Theseus. Oedipus replies to the stranger to notify Theseus asking him for

Antigone, Tragedy and Law versus Desire according to Lacant

549 words - 2 pages '. The question about Antigone is if she took her desire too far for an action that would give no great benefit except to her. Her motives can be seen as entirely personal, and unlike her sister Ismene who we're told loves her brother just as strongly, decides to go against the law to achieve those aims.He calls the play 'a tragedy, and tragedy is at the forefront of our experiences as analysts.' This corresponds with other analysts and scholars

Similar Essays

Comparing Sophocles' Antigone And Jean Anouilh's Antigone

2293 words - 9 pages procure the assassination of his father? (Anouilh 40). He admits that he indiscriminately picked the less mutilated corpse off the battlefield for his grand funeral and has no desire to learn more. Suddenly, Antigone?s mission to bury her brother seems less virtuous. In fact, Antigone?s character even seems flawed as her almost irrational stubbornness becomes more obvious and grating. Creon, on the other hand, is suddenly shown in a more favorable

Compare The Portrayal Of Creon In Oedipus The King And Antigone

628 words - 3 pages In both plays Creon is of high social status. In Antigone he is the king of Thebes. In Oedipus the King he is the brother in law to Oedipus and becomes king at the end of the play.In Antigone, Creon is portrayed as a main character as the plot revolves around him and his decisions as he is the King of Thebes.In this play Creon's character is irrational, as he does not obey the Laws of the Gods by sentencing his son's fiancée to a slow

The Importance Of Family For Ancient Greeks

966 words - 4 pages to listen and cooperate leads to the loss of all his valuables, meaning power. He becomes a miserable, broke man. Antigone felt that she just had to bury Polyneices justly because he is her brother. Even though he was a traitor, he represents the bonds to the family. Her desire to have a proper burial for her brother overlooks all other accountabilities and even the fact of ever having a family of her own. “Antigone goes so far as to say that the

Male Reactions To Female Power In Antigone

1488 words - 6 pages Western society has a long history of subjugating women to men. Some cite the idea that women are somehow weaker or inferior to men as a reason for the existence of this social dynamic. In Sophocles's Antigone and, Dürrenmatt's The Visit, however, the female leads show great strength and are even able to threaten the male leads with their power. Creon and Alfred Ill's disdainful and oppressive treatment of women stems not from the supposed