This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Antigone As A Tragedy Essay

1051 words - 4 pages

Aristotle created what he believed to be the definition of a tragedy. It consists of three parts: imitation, catharsis, and a tragic hero. One example of a tragedy written during the classical Greek period was the tale Antigone, by the playwright Sophocles. As the daughter of Oedipus, Antigone already has a curse upon her family when she sets out to bury her brother, Polynices, against the wishes of Kreon, her uncle and king. In response, he condemns her to be buried alive in a cave and she decides to hang herself instead of enduring the slow death. As a consequence, Kreon loses his wife and son and is left to rule alone. Even with this plot, it is argued that Antigone is not a tragedy because it does not fit into Aristotle's mold like Oedipus the King does and therefore has not become as classic of an example of tragedy. Proving that Antigone is not a tragedy consists of evidence from all three parts of Aristotle's guidelines. In the category of catharsis, Antigone does not bring about a feeling of pity to the reader; she brought the penalty upon herself because she knew what the consequences were for flouting the king. "I will bury him myself. / If I die for doing that, good: / I will stay with him, my brother; / and my crime will be my devotion. / The living are here, / but I must please those longer / who are below; for with the dead / I will stay forever" (Antigone 87-94). Antigone makes the choice even though she fully knows the consequences; she sees a greater reward for her in the afterlife. In addition, the reader does not experience a purification of their emotions because there are no intense emotions of pity. The next aspect of the play that does not fit is that Antigone is not a tragic hero. Even though she is the daughter of the former king and niece of the present king, she is not honored in the community. A hero, according to Aristotle, must be respected and renowned. Because of the frequent differences, it can easily be concluded that Antigone is not a valid tragedy. Still, Antigone is widely considered a tragedy because there is some evidence for it being one, even according to Aristotle. Antigone comes from noble birth because her father, Oedipus, was king; furthermore, she is engaged to Kreon's younger son, Haimon. It is important for the hero to be elevated above the average person. The play is also extremely eloquent, no matter who is speaking. One example is when a lowly messenger speaks to the chorus leader, Koryphaios: "For indeed, when men have forfeited their pleasures, / they are not alive, but the living dead. / To be sure, if you desire it, / gain wealth and power, / live in regal fashion. / However, should the pleasure of such a life be lost, / I, at least, would not purchase the rest, / not if the shadow of smoke were its price" (1339-1346). The...

Find Another Essay On Antigone as a Tragedy

Lear as a Tragedy Essay

1348 words - 5 pages Lear as a TragedyThe story of King Lear is a tragedy by the classical definition of the word. As stated by the definition, a tragedy is when a great figure falls a great distance through the mistakes brought on by pride. The reader is then left feeling pity and fear for the character's loss. The events in King Lear provide a great example of a tragedy, with King Lear himself as the great figure that falls a great distance.As the story begins

Antigone as a Tragic Hero Essay

509 words - 2 pages Antigone as a tragic hero The debate over who is the tragic hero in Antigone is unanswered. The belief that Antigone is the hero is a tough one. Antigone is widely thought of as the tragic hero of the play bearing her name. She would seem to fit the part in light of the fact that she dies for doing what she believes is right. She buries her brother without worrying what might happen to her. Unlike Antigone, Ismene says “And break the law, our

Sophocles’ Oedipus Cycle – Antigone, as a Feminist

1371 words - 5 pages Sophocles’ Oedipus Cycle – Antigone, as a Feminist Throughout history, women have always stood in the shadows of men. In many cultures, the role of women has always been to be seen and not heard. As one of the first feminists in world literature, the character Antigone, of Sophocles’ Oedipus Cycle, displays fine characteristics of a great female leader in order to stand up against male dominance for her religious, political, and personal

Oedipus Rex As A Great Tragedy

630 words - 3 pages Oedipus Rex as a Great Tragedy In approximately 330 B.C., Aristotle wrote the Poetics, which became a guideline for identifying the properties of a great tragedy. He believed that a good tragedy should be serious, complete, and have a degree of magnitude. He also held that a good tragedy should evoke feelings of pity and fear in the reader and have a sense of universality. The ancient tragedy Oedipus Rex, by Sophocles, is recognized as a great

'Medea' as a revenge tragedy. Speech

1298 words - 5 pages genre.However before discussing the revenge tragedy we must understand exactly what it is. Fore mostly, a tragedy is defined as a serious play in which the main character, along with many others, perishes upon completion of the play. A modern critic, Bonamy Dobree defines tragedy as ### 'the trial of a person's individual strength. The protagonist must be able to put up a fight, which is often against a flaw in their own character.'### Tragedies

traglear King Lear as a Bradley Tragedy

1330 words - 5 pages King Lear as a Bradley Tragedy      King Lear meets all the requirements of a tragedy as defined by Andrew Cecil Bradley.  Bradley states that a Shakespearean tragedy has to be the story of the hero and there is exceptional suffering and calamity slowly being worn in.  Also, the current time must be contrasted to happier times.  The play also depicts the troubled parts in the hero’s life and eventually he dies instantaneously because of

William Shakespeare's Hamlet as a Revenge Tragedy

1798 words - 7 pages William Shakespeare's Hamlet as a Revenge Tragedy Revenge Tragedy was a genre which lasted from 1590 until 1615. The genre appealed to the Elizabethan audience’s desire for blood and violence without emotional depth. ================================================================== Revenge tragedies originated in the writings of the Roman Seneca (4BC-AD65) whose plays heavily influenced Elizabethan dramatists

Othello, by William Shakespeare, as a tragedy

1128 words - 5 pages The play 'Othello', by William Shakespeare is a classic Shakespearian tragedy as it follows the conventions that the hero's downfall is caused by a character flaw. It is also seen as a classic Shakespearian tragedy as the hero's flaw is exposed by an external influence. Although despite having a flawed character, the hero possesses other good qualities. Shakespeare uses different dramatic techniques to contribute to tragedy.The idea that the

Oedipus the King as a Tragedy

787 words - 3 pages Many things can describe a tragedy. However, according to definition of a tragedy by Aristotle, there are only five. The play has to have a tragic hero, preferably of noble stature. Second, the tragic hero must have a tragic flaw. Because of that flaw, the hero falls from either power or death. Due to the fall, the tragic hero discovers something. Finally, there must be catharsis in the minds of the audience. Oedipus Rex qualifies as a

Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet as a Tragedy

1955 words - 8 pages Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet as a Tragedy "Romeo and Juliet" is the most famous love story in the English literary tradition. The play focuses on romantic love, specifically the intense passion that arises at first sight between Romeo and Juliet. The play covers a very short time span of three days, in which Romeo and Juliet meet, fall in love, marry and die. The "story of…woe" is inevitable from the moment the

Romeo and Juliet as a Tragedy

791 words - 3 pages ROMEO AND JULIET AS A TRAGEDYShakespeare's Romeo and Juliet is his eleventh play. It is with no doubt a tragedy.Shakespeare has included all the necessary elements for a tragedy. The play has a tragic heroof high standing who dies. The hero opposes some conflicting force. The hero has a tragicflaw and this flaw will lead to his downfall and the downfall of others. Good is alwayswasted driving out evil. Indeed, Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet is a

Similar Essays

Was Antigone A Tragedy Essay

864 words - 3 pages and secretly burying her brother. First, the law was not set up by the gods. Second, out of respect she buried him. She didn't have defected character. When viewed as circumstances foreseen, judgment correct and not defected in character, Antigone is not a tragedy. [4: Ibid, 1.][5: Ibid, 2.][6: Ibid, 3.][7: Ibid, 10.]In conclusion, Antigone is not a tragedy. The deciphering of Antigone in the first way to look at Antigone is incorrect. Although

Antigone: A Greek Tragedy Essay

851 words - 3 pages Antigone: A Greek Tragedy The play Antigone is often thought to be a Greek tragedy because each of the tragic heroes is neither extremely good or bad, their fortunes change from good to bad, their misfortunes do not result from their own wrong doings, and they arouse pity within the audience. Antigone and Creon are the two tragic heroes of this play; however, I believe Creon to be main one. In the play Antigone there can be seen a struggle

A Philosphical Reflection On Tragedy In Both Oedipus Rex, And Antigone. Mphs Ap Lit Essay

716 words - 3 pages worried about what people might think of him and he boils up a big pot of self pride, and wrong decisions and spills it everywhere. By not showing mercy, and locking Antigone up he causes the death of his son and wife. If he had been more compassionate and let go of his ego, he could have prevented many deaths from happening. Both of these writings expose errors in human judgement because of hubris. Through his use of tragedy, Sophocles causes the

Is Jean Anouilh's Antigone A Tragedy Or A Triumph? This Is An Assessment Of The Tragic And Trimphant Elements Within The Play 'antigone'

4517 words - 18 pages to Creon as 'the victor' and although the chorus also says that Creon is 'already vanquished', their overall implication is that Antigone's death was a defeat for her. The tragedy caused by Antigone's death is emphasised by group of three used when describing the dead bodies Antigone, Haemon and Eurydice, 'stiff, useless, rotting (71)', this creates a vivid image in the reader's mind of the destruction caused by the death of Antigone. The tragedy