Antigone Bastion Of Virtue Essay

1653 words - 7 pages

Fellow Thebans, we gather today to determine the case of Antigone. She stands accused of treason for following the will of the gods by burying her own brother, Polynices. You may ask, why would the state carry a law that contradicts the demands of the gods? I tell you good people, Creon's decree, which forbade the burying of Polynices for fighting his home city will be met with stoning. The law was forged by impulse and anger. By disobeying the "laws the gods all hold in honor", Creon disintegrated his own virtue and the virtue of Thebes itself (Sophocles, Antigone). Therefore, the actions of Antigone should not be met with stoning, but with honor and praise. For she is fighting an injustice within our laws and preserving justice, "the bond of men" (Aristotle, Politics).
As Aristotle writes, the human soul is capable of understanding, free will, planning, and deliberation. Due to these rational functions, we are able to examine our life and determine our psyche (nature), and teloi (our function, purpose, end goal). With this foundational knowledge, we can use arête (virtue) to become properly developed (eudaimonia). This journey towards happiness does not only occur on the personal level. Thebes itself undergoes this quest towards harmony. It is the role of every citizen, especially the statesmen, to lead the state down the orthodox path. This task is essential because without a just society, human happiness is impossible (Aristotle, Ethics Book I).
You are all probably thinking, how can we attain happiness for ourselves and the state? The answer lies in virtue. In particular, "human good turns out to be activity of the soul in accordance with virtue," (Aristotle, Ethics Book I). While some may think wealth is the final end, it is only a means. A life in pursuit pleasure is not a human existence but a life of beasts. Finally, honor itself is not the chief good, for it cannot guarantee our happiness. Let the great Priam of Troy serve as our example to the limits of prestige.
Friends, our responsibilities as citizens of Thebes include understanding the nature of virtue. The practice of virtue creates a proper and obedient citizenry, ready to tackle injustice in all its forms. Since virtue is the "activity of the soul", the nature of the soul must be clarified. The human soul contains an irrational element, in which exists a rational principle (lodged within the rational functions) and its antagonist. While the rational principle leads men towards eudaimonia, its opposing sense drive men towards vice and unhappiness. In the temperate man, the voice of the rational principle influences his words and motivates his actions. However, in the incontinent, irrationality and intemperance drive his motives. On one hand lies the temperate man, the champion of virtue; in the other, the lord of vice (Aristotle, Ethics Book I). Virtue itself is not bestowed upon us by nature, but perfected by habit. Both intellectual (reason) and moral (ethics) virtues...

Find Another Essay On Antigone- Bastion of Virtue

Antigone Essay

1912 words - 8 pages Antigone did not receive approval from the gods as well. She states that gods ordinances are ?unwritten and secure.(499) This means that one must use their own conscience, and moral beliefs, to decide what is the will of the gods.The deities need not justify themselves to mortals, and for mortals obedience to the gods is a virtue. Creon has so much faith in his own sense of order that he can not imagine the will of the gods to be different than

Antigone Analysis Questions

3579 words - 14 pages been passed through his sons and now Antigone. This shows that power belongs to the gods, Zeus more specifically. The second choral ode shows that man is not actually powerful at all, as the disastrous fate of Oedipus and her family shows. The Chorus states on page 218, "O Zeus, what creature pits himself against thy power?" Humanity is a foil of the Gods, because although humans believe they have virtue it is actually the gods who decide the fate

The Faults of King Creon

849 words - 4 pages good intentions. The character of Creon demonstrates the quality of position when he is boasting over his wealth and power: Now here I am, holding authority/ and the throne, in virtue of kinship with the dead. (171-172) Creon’s position is also shown when the people of Thebes follow his orders not to bury the body of Polyneices. The respect of Creon’s power from the people is expressed when Ismene tells Antigone of how their terrible deaths

How Sophocle's Antigone effectively presents its theme, which is that of human law vs. divine law and the inevitable triumph of the gods

701 words - 3 pages There are many principles and themes existing in Sophocles' tragedy, Antigone. The dialogue and action of the play, along with the choral odes, effectively present the themes and principles. The principles that are at stake in the central conflict are the role of gender and the role of pride. However, the major theme of the tragedy is the conflict of interest between human law and divine law.The conflict between human law and divine law is the

Antigone Vs. Jocasta

1168 words - 5 pages would not agree with you on this. It was his brother not his slave that died. Hades makes no distinction in its rites and honors. The `crime' (who knows?) may be called a virtue there" (Roche 213). Her talk of Hades shows how she leaves the judging of a person's morality to a higher power and not to mortal man such as Creon. Antigone brings this point up once again when refusing Ismene's plea to take blame for the crime and die because she

Mythology In and Around Sophocles' Antigone

2473 words - 10 pages underlying meaning of Ismene’s simple question: “But wilt thou slay the betrothed of thine own son?” Likewise when Haemon makes his appearance before his father, Creon’s lack of personal virtue, such as the gods like to see in a man, cause the situation to deteriorate markedly. After pledging his loyalty to his father, Haemon divulges the true sentiments of the townsfolk regarding Creon’s death sentence for Antigone: “’[N]o woman,' they say, 'ever

Antigone

1117 words - 4 pages In the Greek tragedy Antigone, contempt of death, honor, and virtue enables the young heroine Antigone to conquer a powerful ruler Creon, who, proud of his ignorance, turns his back to the people of Thebes, his son, and divine law. Creon learns all too late, from the destruction of his family, that Fate in due course brings him the punishment he deserves for his fit of outrage. In Antigone, God's judgment of man plays an essential role in the

Antigone - The Tragic Flaw

2277 words - 9 pages meaning of Ismene’s simple question: “But wilt thou slay the betrothed of thine own son?” Likewise when Haemon makes his appearance before his father, Creon’s lack of personal virtue cause the situation to deteriorate markedly. After pledging his loyalty to his father, Haemon divulges the true sentiments of the townsfolk regarding Creon’s death sentence for Antigone: “’[N]o woman,' they say, 'ever merited her doom less,-none ever was to die so

The Suffering of the Proud

606 words - 2 pages The Suffering of the Proud Pride is a key to self-respect; however, when it goes to far, people forget that humility is a virtue too. In the play Antigone, pride plays a major role throughout, appearing as fatal flaws in both Antigone and Kreon, the main characters of Sophocles’s tragedy. For Antigone and Kreon, as soon as the stepped past the line of humility, they were doomed to fail. For example, Kreon became so proud of himself he

A Production of Sophocles' Antigone

1611 words - 6 pages much about relationships between humans instead of between humans and the Gods and a third actor would help dramatise these relations. Antigone, as with most of Sophocles plays, is concerned with the foolishness of arrogance and pride and the virtue of accepting ones fate, whatever that may be. Pride is a major theme in Antigone and a common trait amongst its characters. Polynices and Eteocles killed each other because they disagreed on how

God Versus Man in Sophocles' Antigone

2260 words - 9 pages philosophies have been, and is still submitting himself to only human law, and caring nothing of the laws of the gods.  The Chorus has a different view, however.  They are chastising Antigone for her crime, and indirectly supporting Kreon’s selfish views on honoring only human law.  Chorus: Reverence is a virtue, but strength             Lives in established law: that must prevail.             You have made your choice,             Your

Similar Essays

Antigone Essay

976 words - 4 pages shows the annoyance of Creon about Antigone because she knows the law and still buries her brother. It reveals the stubbornness Creon says about Antigone. Hence it indicates she is loyal to her family. In addition Creon says to Antigone" Revenge is a virtue, but strength lives in established law; that must prevail. You made your choice, your death is the doing of your conscious hand (Antistrophe 2 710-704). Antigone loyalty to her brother is going

Antigone Essay 948 Words

948 words - 4 pages social order that her uncle Creon, the king of Thebes, was trying to control with a reign of terror.Creon generously agreed to raise his nieces and nephews (Antigone, Ismene, Eteocles, and Polyneices) after their father and his brother-in-law Oedipus gauged his eyeballs out of their sockets and exiled himself from the kingdom he once ruled with patience and virtue. The city-state of Thebes never made a complete recovery from the tragic loss of their

Antigone Essay

1067 words - 5 pages than that. For example, the interpretation of state law and customary law are interpreted from the love, justice, legal perspective and humanitarian law. Antigone just confined within the scope of family ethics, did not put her up to oppose the draconian height. Tragedian has no emphasis on natural law and national law tension and confrontation; he insisted that no one is a virtue exclusive. For example, Antigone’s sister accused her practice

Antigone Essay

1757 words - 7 pages The opening events of the play Antigone, written by Sophocles, quickly establish the central conflict between Antigone and Creon. Creon has decreed that the traitor Polynices, who tried to burn down the temple of gods in Thebes, must not be given proper burial. Antigone is the only one who will speak against this decree and insists on the sacredness of family and a symbolic burial for her brother. Whereas Antigone sees no validity in a law that