This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Any Interpretation Of Obedience To Authority, Whether Good Or Bad, Or Examination Of The Phenomenology Of Obedience To Authority Will Lead A Reader To Make Judments On Human Nature.

1566 words - 6 pages

Humans are pessimistic and often need to consult with their own conscience before making certain decisions in life. Humans can be good, bad, or maybe even both, and the characteristics they portray represent who they are. In the Milgram and Zimbardo experiments, volunteers were chosen to participate in a group project. Of the two experiments, the subjects were either tested with electric shocks or placed in a prison, and the scientists were able to observe the subjects' behaviors. Milgram and Zimbardo's experiment was psychologically disturbing and harsh. The way scientists treated their subjects and how the subjects responded to the mistreatment display positive and negative human characteristics. The environment that a person is situated in conditions their behavior, and the society can influence an individual to behave in a certain way by setting social norms. The society shapes human nature. It supplements ideas individuals use to make decisions in life and confirms with their conscience if the choices they make are morally valid. Human conscience is an inborn instinct, a "gut" feeling that drives a person to think twice about their decision. While human instincts are inborn, society influences one's decisions in life.Humans instinctively adapt to a situation without being taught. In the Zimbardo experiment, "guards were told that they must maintain law and order . . . that they were responsible for handling any trouble" (Zimbardo 367). The guards had no prior training how to be guards, and they trusted their own instincts to act strictly and harshly towards the prisoners. The guards, " moved with apparent ease into their roles" (367). Zimbardo suggests that the guards knew how to imitate the roles of guards from the media. As one guard quotes, "I was surprised at myself . . . I made them call each other names and clean the toilets out with their bare hands . . . "(368). The guard could not believe what he was harsh to his prisoner The guard was not even a real guard in reality, but his role as one seemed so real that he could not resist his power over the inmates. The guard wanted to show authority, and his conscience assured that it was a right thing to do. The society's negative perception of prison effectuates its image as acceptable place for guards to torture prisoners . Readers can make the judgement that the guards were cruel and unsympathetic toward the prisoners, but Zimbardo reassures the reader that "you cannot be a prisoner if no one will be your guard, and you cannot be a prisoner if no one takes you or your prison seriously" (367). The guards had been assured that it was alright for them to enforce strict commands and treat the prisoners harshly in order for them to obey. The media and the society encourage guards to be authoritative and attain power by controlling their prisoners. Fromm says that humans have an inborn conscience, "an internalized voice of an authority whom we are eager to please and afraid of displeasing . . ....

Find Another Essay On Any interpretation of obedience to authority, whether good or bad, or examination of the phenomenology of obedience to authority will lead a reader to make judments on human nature.

Stanley Milgram’s “Obedience to Authority” Essay

791 words - 4 pages they will prompt you with a questionnaire at the end. One of the most common questions on there will have to do with following directions and respecting authority. As children we are taught to respect anyone that is an adult regardless of your personal liking to the person or not. So it is installed in us at an early age once you determine someone is at a position of authority that you must respect them. With respect comes a level of obligation

Obedience to Authority as Showcases in A Few Good Men

2320 words - 10 pages , relatively few people had the resources needed to resist authority" (85-86). Resisting authority is often what it takes in order to stand up for one’s beliefs. In this way, one must draw the line where they will obey and where they will refuse to obey due to moral issues. Most people do not have a strong enough sense of rightness or confidence to disobey an unjust order. Obedience to authority can lead to the demise of life as we know it. In

A Brief Summary of Milgram's Seminal Research on Obedience to Authority

1537 words - 6 pages obedience of Nazis during World War II was the outcome of situational forces that could engulf anyone.” The aims and objectives of this paper is to provide a brief summary of Milgram's seminal research on obedience to authority, and describing Milgram's methodology as well as his results and his interpretation of those results. Additionally, we will be discussing what current research has found regarding conforming to authority. One of the biggest

Obedience to Authority by Stanley Milgram

2669 words - 11 pages doctors prescriptions, etc. Obedience is a fundamental part of everyday life. Milgram’s detailed examination of obedience proved “the Germans are different” hypothesis is incorrect. The implications of his work and others are wide ranging and also vitally important. Understanding the power of authority helps us better understand human nature and history. Through understanding of this power, the constraints on individual freewill must be re

Obedience to Authority vs. Personal Conscience

849 words - 3 pages electroshock and they knew the discomfort it cause at 45 voltage. It is common knowledge that human beings are responsible for making decisions. In past years the use of electroshock experiment did not cure any of the illness it caused more damage to the individual participant and it decreased their quality of life. danger to another human is a moral decision. In the case of the Stanley Milgram study the “teachers” chose to continue the experiment was of their free will. In the case of the genocide in World War II, the people lives were under directive of authority and disobedience had many consequences.

MY LAI MASSACRE AS A RESULT OF OBEDIENCE TO AUTHORITY. Relates to stanly milgrams experiments and how authority play a part in genocide killings

1215 words - 5 pages Massacre, the soldiers were not just following the thoughts of a politician or religious figure. They followed their military leader, the same person they counted on for leadership and survival. "Soldiers are trained to always follow orders, never question orders (When I say jump, u you say how high). But that belief is somewhat erroneous, the charge to the soldier is to obey any lawful order given (Schwalbe). "Absolute obedience, although not

Do They Really Go Hand In Hand? An interpretive analysis of language and obedience to authority

774 words - 3 pages , following the rules sometimes comes with a price. It is these types of cases in which one must make decisions about the things that are important to him or her. Is it better to abide by the morals that one has chosen to follow, or is it better to carry out orders at any cost? Priorities are definitely factors of obedience as well as of disobedience. Obeying no matter what is a complete sacrifice of the self - total submission. "... it implies the

The Nature and Authority of Scripture

1637 words - 7 pages , our nature and purpose, and how we enter into and grow in our relationship to God” (Wilkens & Sanford, 2009, p. 211). The three other authorities all fall under Scriptures authority. Scripture can confirm or deny the validity of an experience, reason, or tradition. For this reason, Scripture is essential to the Christian faith, no matter the denomination. It is the “first place we look and the final court of appeal in shaping a Christian worldview

Human Obedience

1097 words - 4 pages obedience and disobedience, and one should not blindly obey the orders they receive, especially when causing physical or mental harm to another human being. It is especially difficult for young adults to be disobedient to their peers, because of their desire to be socially accepted. Having to make though decisions early on in life will only make one stronger, and help deal with tough situations later in life. Works Cited Asch

Should an athlete's gender determine whether or not they will be allowed to participate in any sport they choose?

1295 words - 5 pages Should an athlete's gender determine whether or not they will be allowed to participate in any sport they choose?Whenever the topic of letting women play sports with men comes up, there are always people who have their own distinct opinions of what should happen. It is almost like bringing up the topics of religion or politics within a large group. People's ideas on the subject might agree with a main view, but each person sees minor respects of

Is Human Nature Intrinsically Good or Evil?

1461 words - 6 pages society. Then all people have the choice to make conscious decisions in life whether to be good or bad. I always picture the cartoon with the angel on one shoulder and the devil on the other when I think of someone trying to make a decision. When babies are born they are pure and innocent and only cry because they are hungry, want to be held, diaper changed, or don't feel well. This does not make them evil. These are just simple responses to needs

Similar Essays

Discuss Milgram’s Study Of Obedience To Authority

1050 words - 4 pages Introduction: This essay will outline Milgram’s experiment of obedience and outline ethical issues relating to it. Before outlining Milgram’s experiment this essay will look at Milgram himself. ‘Stanley Milgram was born in New York in 1933. A graduate of Queens College and Harvard University, he taught social psychology at Yale and Harvard Universities before become a Distinguished Professor at the Graduate Centre of the City University Of New

Obedience To Authority Essay

1568 words - 7 pages deep down inside of you that it`s questionable at the least, especially morally or ethically. It will have a detriment outcome not only on you, but possibly for any participants involved as well. Instead of taking advice handed down from the authority figures, you decide to go against the chain of commands. For example, having an authority figure demand that you go against your will and core beliefs, forcefully requiring you to inflict pain and

Obedience To Authority Essay

860 words - 3 pages causes punishment; punishment is bad, so therefore defiance is bad. This basic model follows a person through the rest of their life: in school with teachers, at work with their boss, and in life in general with the government. People are conditioned to obey the respective authority, whether or not they agree with the orders given or the rules present. In almost every instance it is true that there are basic rules that go against what a person

Obedience To Authority Essay

1132 words - 5 pages terrible destructive process.” Part of his findings reveal showed they were in one manner or another against inflicting pain on the subject- protesting while they did what they were told. He also found morality did not disappear but took “on a new nature (Milgram, pp 701-704). This experiment can be interpreted as the participants knew that they should not continue to shock the other individuals, but they were not able to translate their