Apple Inc. V. Samsung Electronics Co.: An Exploration Of Patent Law And Ever Evolving Technology

1508 words - 6 pages

Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co.:
An Exploration of Patent Law and Ever-Evolving Technology

April 15, 2011 marks the date that kick-started the most high-profile US design patent cases of all time; a lawsuit that could possibly change the face of technology as we know it. Apple Inc. sued Samsung Electronics Co. on the grounds that Samsung’s smartphones as well as tablets infringed upon Apple’s technology and design patents (Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., 2013). Deemed by the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit to be “The Patent Trial of the Century”, the case drew an extraordinary amount of worldwide attention, grabbing the headlines and taking center stage. The jury found that Samsung had infringed Apple’s design patents on the home button, and rounded corners of the phone, as well as their utility patents covering the “bounce back effect,” and “tap to zoom” functions (L., 2013). Samsung was asked to pay Apple $1.05 billion in damages (Stern, 2012). The case is likely to be re-examined, however, as appeals have already been filed. Impacting the product design of new technologies for years to come, this lawsuit has provided an opportunity for experts to further understand the scope of design rights and determine how close is too close in regards to design patent infringement (Carani, 2012). Patent laws are impeding to the point of prohibiting new products created by emerging or existing companies from entering the market; furthermore, patent laws have made it possible for current technology-producing companies to seemingly create a monopoly on technology design.
Knowing the law is not only the key to understanding the reasoning behind the jury’s verdict but also in ensuring that infringement is minimized or eliminated altogether as the number of technological advances grow each day. The current design patent infringement test, better known as the ordinary observer test, was first exercised in the U.S. Supreme Court case of Gorham Co. v. White in 1871. According to this precedent case, infringement occurs if two products appear to be similar enough for one to have inspired the other. In 2008, another clause was added to the test that stated it should be conducted “in view of the prior art” [Egyptian Goddess v. Swisa, 543 F.3d 665 (Fed. Cir. 2008)]. Prior art is an earlier publication that shows a similar invention. The obvious standard requires the patent office to view the manner in which the invention occurred to insure the innovation was not made obvious by another idea at that period in time. When determining whether or not a product accused of infringement has truly crossed the line, investigators are asked to use everyday perceptions, discernment, and awareness (Carani, 2012).
This idea of patenting technology has been long debated. In some ways, patents help push the boundaries and expand the horizons of technology. Patent laws help protect innovators who create never-before seen...

Find Another Essay On Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co.: An Exploration of Patent Law and Ever-Evolving Technology

Samsung Electronics: Company Analysis and Overview

652 words - 3 pages accessibility to various softwares and utilities. The picture is not completely rosy for Samsung. As the consumer electronics market trends towards intense competition for global sales of smartphones and tablets, technology companies are defending their intellectual properties and seeking to derive revenue from licensing. Samsung has been embroiled in several patent litigations, most notably the $1.05B alleged patent infringement case that

Evolving Technology and Society Essay

1061 words - 5 pages technology in the past fifty years has been extremely substantial in our society. We have developed machines and methods of accessing endless amounts of information, affecting the very core of our daily lives. Evolving technology has brought society together through the use of advanced and instant methods of sharing, communicating and learning in our daily lives. The development of technology has had a profound effect on society, fundamentally

Competition of Apple and Samsung: Which Phone Is Better?

1082 words - 5 pages Arabic but the form of each letters is difficult to read in the Galaxy S3. The other reason is, I am an engineer, and I’m interested in some professional applications I didn’t find in the Galaxy S3, but I found them in the iPhone 5 such as, MATLAB and Solid work. For these reasons I prefer using the iPhone 5 to the Galaxy S3. However, that doesn’t mean the iPhone 5 better than the Galaxy S3. Also, there are a lot of people around the world who prefer using the Galaxy S3 than the iPhone 5. Since Apple and Samsung are two of the strongest communications companies, I think the competition between them will continue for a long time.

The Ever Evolving Age of Social Networking

1035 words - 4 pages Changing and ever evolving, technology has impacted everybody’s lives in an irrevocable manner . Beginning in 2003 with MySpace, social networking is one aspect that has completely revolutionized people’s everyday lives. The empire created by MySpace was then further expanded by a new generation of social networks such as Facebook and Twitter. This era was marked with innovative new features including video chat and increased commercialization

Financial Comparison of Apple Inc. and Google Inc

1692 words - 7 pages .” Recently, many companies have struggled during the economic downturn. Many investors have lost money in their investments. Usually during an economic crisis people invest in government bonds, health care, and commodities. However, the two companies being compared are in the industry of technology, which amazed many investors when both companies continued to make record-breaking growth during recent economic times. Apple Inc. is the maker of

Analysis of Apple, Inc

1445 words - 6 pages products. For example, my sister went on vacation and we wanted to video-chat with her so we simply just face-timed with her just through a click of a button. I wouldn’t have been able to do that with a blackberry or even an android phone. Their products change our perception of how a smart-phone is supposed to be used; they change the way we work, play, and even communicate and the best part is that it’s so simple to use. Apple Inc.’s brand was

Shakespear's 'Henry V'- "An exploration of how Shakespere presents Henry as a king and as a man."

1158 words - 5 pages from the nobles who had originally helped him. This ate away at his confidence and made him into quite a cunning person. Henry V, though, started out as a young man who no one respected, because he did not accept any responsibilities. He then, however, ended up becoming a better king than his father.It was made clear, at the beginning of the play, the kind of regard shown to him when he was given a 'gift'. This was a chest of tennis balls sent to

Case Study of Apple Inc and its Success

1194 words - 5 pages grow up the success ladder with its ever evolving product line which is a mixture of quality, innovation and highly detailed mechanics. Apple continues to not only survive, but excels in the electronics market which, is becoming more and more competitive by the day.   About Apple Inc Apple Inc. is a multinational born in America which, is involved into designing, development and sales of consumer electronic products, computer software and hardware

Apple Computer, Inc. Tools, Messages, and Timing of Promotion

731 words - 3 pages of the products that are produced by the Apple Computer Inc. include the Media, Website, Social Media, Print Media, Human Resources and outdoor advertisements. The Company uses televisions by having live airing of the launch of their new products and technology. Equally, they use the media to make mass campaigns that support the effectiveness of their services and products. On the other hand, they post their innovations on their websites that give

Brief History of Apple Inc

1058 words - 5 pages Apple Inc. is an American multinational enterprise headquartered in Cupertino, California, that outlines, creates, and offers purchaser hardware, machine programming and Pcs. Steven Wozniak and Steven Jobs had been companions in secondary school. They had both been intrigued by gadgets, and both had been discerned as outcasts. They stayed in contact after graduation, and both wound up dropping out of school and landing positions working for

Marketing Effectiveness of Apple Inc

4421 words - 18 pages 1.Brief Summary of Apple Inc.Apple Inc. was started by two high school friends, Steven Wozniak and Steven Jobs. The Company is now based in Cupertino California and is a Fortune 500 company. The Company began in 1976 when Wozniak designed what would become the Apple I. (Apple Computer 2007).The Company's principle activity is to design, manufacture and market personal computers and related software and networking solutions. The Company is

Similar Essays

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd Essay

1086 words - 4 pages Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Company Overview Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. is a global leader in semiconductor, telecommunication, digital media and digital convergence technologies with 2006 parent company sales of US$63.4 billion and net income of US$8.5 billion. Employing approximately 138,000 people in 124 offices in 56 countries, the company consists of five main business units: Digital Media Business, LCD Business, Semiconductor

Analysis Of Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd

1832 words - 7 pages 1. Introduction Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd is a Korean multinational company, manufactures a wide range of product; includes computers, mobile phone, digital TVs, air conditioner, OLED panel, LCD display panel, memory and LSI system etc. The company's main growth driver engine is Smartphone business and Tablet, accounts 31.4 % and 20.4% respectively, of market share in 3Q2013 as per data from IDC. The main concern of company is that it totally

The War On Technology: Apple Vs. Samsung

822 words - 4 pages an accessory to your phone. Both companies also make laptops and personal computers. With the smartphone market continuing to grow, both Apple and Samsung will continue to be world leaders in smartphone technology for the years to come. To summarize, Apple and Samsung are two companies that work in completely different ways, but do have many similar products and business ideas. Reflecting earlier to the comparison of the two children arguing, in

Equity, Cash Flow, And Notes Analysis Paper Of Samsung Electronics

1444 words - 6 pages IntroductionThe Chief Executive Officer for Samsung Electronics, Jong-Yong Yun, contacted our firm to request our service to prepare a financial overview for the record management team regarding the following segments: Statement of Changes in Owner's Equity, Statement of Cash Flows, Notes, and other Financial Information. The theme and goal for this company is to endeavor to become the best; through the spirit of excellence; however, the only