Legal Commentary On Negligence Essay

1520 words - 6 pages

Legal Commentary on Negligence

The article:
General Motors has recalled 224,000 1998/1999 Cadillac Deville Sedans. As a result of a defective side impact sensor module, the vehicle's airbag may either unintentionally deploy or not deploy at all. To date, there have been 306 reports of the sensor malfunction. Of these, 61 of the incidents have resulted in minor injuries such as cuts and bruises. Deemed as "the responsive thing to do", General Motors started notifying owners of the vehicle by mail commencing Sept. 25th, 2000. At present, the requisite replacement parts are out of stock, as they were no longer manufactured. However, General Motors has commissioned the original manufacturer of the sensor to produce a replacement part, of which will be available in the first quarter of 2001.
In this potential product liability case, the three parties involved as defendants are the Manufacturer of the Sensor, General Motors, the vendor of the vehicle. The plaintiffs of the case would be the buyer/consumer of the Cadillac Deville Sedan and/or any injured parties who incurred damages as a result of the faulty side impact sensor.
As a manufacturer of goods, General Motors has an obligation imposed by society to meet a standard of care to the ultimate consumer of its products. Within the context of product liability law, General Motors is liable to the ultimate consumer of the goods where it can be proven in a court of law that the manufacturer was negligent in the following legislative principles (Willes, 1998):
a) The manufacturing of the said goods.
b) The goods manufactured by the company have an intrinsic danger associated with them.
c) The manufacturer of the said goods failed in its responsibility to warn the consumer of the danger.

If General Motors does not meet the aforementioned standards of care to the ultimate consumer, than General Motors can be sued by the owner of the vehicle (plaintiff) under tort law for negligence and/or contract law for a breach of contract. Furthermore, General Motors may also be found liable in its failure to meet the duty to warn of a continuing nature. However, the scope of the paper limits the analysis exclusively to establishing negligence.

Negligence Law
In order to successfully establish General Motor's negligence, the product liability case must comply with the following established principles:
1) Is there a Duty of Care toward the injured party?
Indisputably, General Motors has a duty of care. The responsibility of a manufacturer was established in Donaghue v. Stevenson, (1932) A.C. 562, which established the principle that manufacturers have the duty to ensure that the ultimate consumers of their product do not sustain injuries as a result of the use of their products. Manufacturers of goods and services are subject to a high duty of care given that these businesses commercially profit from the purchase and use of their products.

2) What is the standard of care...

Find Another Essay On Legal Commentary on Negligence

The Law of Torts Essay

1308 words - 5 pages Negligence. To put it simply negligence is the breach of duty, to take reasonable care in the circumstances, resulting in damage to another person or organisation. Negligence is not the same as being careless. A person can be very careless without causing damage to someone else. In order for him to prove that you have been negligent, he must provide evidence to the judge, on the balance of probabilities. These are called the conditions for

Involuntary Manslaughter Essay

1133 words - 5 pages the death of the victim. The breach of duty can be committed by an act or an omission, which does not have to be unlawful. The leading case on gross negligence manslaughter is ADOMAKO (1994). The actus reus of gross negligence manslaughter is: - the existence of a duty of care towards the victim - a breach of that duty of care which causes death - gross negligence which the jury considers to be criminal

Tortious Liability and Negligence

1813 words - 7 pages are awarded in proportion to the scope of the harm done. The severity of the negligence is irrelevant. However some negligent acts may be recognized as so egregious as to merit financial penalty over and above actual damages.Proving Negligence:Proving negligence is a complicated process and involves following components.Duty:In tort law, a '''duty of care''' is a legal obligation imposed on an individual requiring that they exercise a reasonable

Common Law in Australia: The Tort Of Negligence

9095 words - 36 pages - Legal obligation on a person engaged in any activity to take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions that they can foresee would likely cause damage or injury to another personTo be liable in Negligence a 'duty of care' must be owed by one party to another. This rule was established in the House of Lords decision Donoghue v Stevenson (1932). In this case Lord Atkin formulated the "neighbour test" to determine whether a duty of care was owed by one


1425 words - 6 pages mental they may be considered enough of a problem to be awarded compensation. The damages must be allowed by law which means that the injuries sustained must have been whilst a legal act is being commenced. The injury must also have been caused by the negligence of the defendant. The injury cannot be too remote from the initial incident. This rule is slightly inconsistent due to the decision is based on jury's opinion. Defences Two defences

Salsa Dancing

2200 words - 9 pages coat has been stolen. Advise Robert and Lucy as to any contractual claim they may have. I will begin by looking at the contractual claim Lucy has in respect to the loss of her coat. Lucy’s claim could be based most suitably on the area of Contract law known as incorporation, and perhaps negligence. Dealing first with incorporation. For a clause to form part of a contract it must be effectively incorporated

Litigation in today's society, especially school.

1492 words - 6 pages a teacher will face legal action. It is therefore of great importance that teachers and school authorities as you are aware of how the tort of negligence operates and how to prevent legal action ever becoming. The school premises is a pit of potential legal hazards, the area that has been brought to attention is the school fields.The tort of negligence is "a failure to exercise the care that a reasonably prudent person would exercise in like

Torts versus Crimes

1549 words - 6 pages established to impose compensation to a victim and to prove that the defendant had a legal responsibility to act in a particular way and must also demonstrate that the defendant breached of a legal obligation by failing in their responsibility and as a result of the actions the plaintiff suffered a loss or injury (Suber n.d). Crimes are part of the legislature and a statue or written law is enforced (Suber n.d). The focus of the criminal case is on

Business Regulation Simulation

1016 words - 4 pages distress in the harmed individual" (Jennings). In allegations that the company refuses to assume or face the damages they aggravate the situation greatly on the plaintiff's part. This tort will only be known after the suit has been filed for negligence.Defamation could also be filed against the plaintiff if the negative statement being made can be proven to be untrue. A company can sue any potential defamer on a legal basis that they have no proof or

Bolton v Stone. Tort-Negligence

833 words - 3 pages respondent.What particular area of law did it concern?The Law covered in this case is tort, the body of law which provides legal remedies to those who have endured the civil wrongs of others. The Bolton v Stone case is based on the areas of negligence and nuisance. Negligence is an act or conduct that falls below the standard level of due care taken by a reasonable person to prevent an individual from a foreseeable risk of harm. From wikipedia


1015 words - 4 pages NegligenceWhat is negligence?Negligence: A breach of legal duty care which results in the damage to the claimant (Rogers W.V.H 2002 Winfield and Jolowicz on Tort 16th edn, London: Sweet & Maxwell p.103)To prove negligence, the burden falls on the plaintiff to prove all of:Claimant owed a duty of careThe damage was not too remoteThere was a breach of duty of care.Claimant suffered damage as a result of the breach (causation)What then

Similar Essays

Legal Systems: Duty Of Care And Negligence

1406 words - 6 pages . However, the process of establishing duty of care based on case law is critical to the imposition of liabilities. This legal practice allows courts to limit liability in negligence under the concept of duty of care. Liability in negligence further relies on testable principles that make it effective for courts to limit liability. Once the relationship between the defendant and the claimant is established, the next aspect of duty of care is to show

Chapter 11 In Law 12 Textbook

1550 words - 6 pages . Define contributory negligence, using an original example.Contributory negligence: negligence on the part of the victim that contributes to his or her own injury or loss; a partial defense to negligence.Example: you get into a vehicle of someone you know drives recklessly and they get into an accident.3. What is voluntary assumption of risk?Voluntary assumption of risk: the legal principle that a plaintiff may not recover for an

Tort Laws And Ethics Essay

1324 words - 5 pages receive jail time and/or malpractice claims if found guilty of such negligence as described in the tort claim. According the Congressional Budget Office (2006), “The system has twin objectives: deterring negligent behavior on the part of providers and compensating claimants for losses (including medical costs, lost wages, and pain and suffering) they incur as the result of an injury that occurs because of negligence” (

Test Essay

698 words - 3 pages The basics of solicitor negligence claims Few United Kingdom (UK) laws have the level of complexity as that of property law, which mean transactions in the field can be both confusing and daunting, especially when there are large sums of money involved. Those looking towards a property transaction will often seek out help, in the form of legal advice from a specialist solicitor or law firm. However, even when professional help is sought after