Right To Decide Essay

1193 words - 5 pages

Everyday humans face ethical dilemmas; with each of these situations we must make moral choices. It is often difficult to confront ethical dilemmas and moral choices as they tend to unearth the rawest of our human emotions. This paper will discuss the ethical dilemmas brought on by the case of Jonathon, a 22-year-old male quadriplegic, diagnosed as a diabetic during childhood ("Quality of life case study - Session #1," n.d., para. 1). This case study raises many ethical issues; however this paper will focus on three. The main ethical dilemma questions both autonomy and competence: is Jonathon capable of making his own medical decisions? From there we must ask another vital question: should his family have a say in his treatment? Jonathon’s quality of life raises the third question: without medical intervention will he die? This paper will focus on two ethical perspectives that will be further discussed throughout the paper:
1) My perspective: a 30-year-old female nursing student, married, with children. My perspective on this case is based on moral decision-making.
2) Ethical egoism perspective: In which the moral choice of this case is based on self-interest (Rae, 2009, p. 67).
The personal story of an ethical case is often a driving factor behind our moral choices; causing each individual to look internally at their own values and virtues. Jonathon’s case is no different, the story behind the case is essential to understanding the choices made:
While at a fraternity party 18 months ago, Jonathon fell head first from a balcony; leaving him quadriplegic below the neck, ventilator dependent, and in need of assistance for basic functions. He sees himself as a burden and feels ashamed that his foolish behavior has created such daily struggle and expense for his parents. Whether by his personal choice or others, he has cut ties with all friends. Jonathon recently became ill, being admitted to the hospital with pneumonia. He was placed on IV antibiotics; however he is refusing to take his insulin and oral medications, requesting only treatment for pain. His father has stated, “I think Jonathan has decided that he has suffered enough. You can imagine what life must be like for someone who has no feeling below his neck but has a very sharp brain.” ("Quality of life case study - Session #1," n.d.).
Is Jonathon capable of making his own medical decisions?
Autonomy refers to a patient’s right to give informed consent for treatment (Rae, 2009, p. 112). Jonathon’s case is one of autonomy; who has the right to decide for him? According to Family Caregiver Alliance (2000), “you have the right to make your own decisions about your care” (para. 14). In this case, qualified medical staff have determined that Jonathan is mentally competent and perfectly capable of making a rational decision ("Quality of life case study - Session #1," n.d., para. 3). The fact is that he is capable of making his own medical decisions; from my perspective there is nothing...

Find Another Essay On Right to Decide

FGM, Female Genital Mutilation Essay

517 words - 2 pages Female genital mutilation has been practiced in country's around the world for thousands of years, and will continue to be practiced, until those that practice it decide to stop.Many people who live in country's that are more industrialized, like the U.S.A., tend to think that no ones believes on right and wrong is correct, except their own. That is what comes up in conversation about FGM. Personally, I am not pro-FGM when it comes to its

A Defense of Abortion Essay

998 words - 4 pages because the fetus is operationally defined as a person from the moment of conception (for the sake of this argument anyways) the fetus is guaranteed its right to life. On the other hand however, the mother has the right to decide what shall happen to her body and what happens in her body. But as Thomson says, surely the fetus' right to life outweighs the mother's right to decide what happens in her body and therefore the fetus may not be killed; an

A Crime Of Compassion

637 words - 3 pages changed my mind. A terminally ill ends a life of a person who suffered for 6 months and was resuscitated fifty two times in one month. Terminally ill should be a reason to accept whether the person wants to be alive or just die and stop suffering. Only the patient must have right to decide about his own life not even his family has the right to decide for him. Mac was a patient in the story "A crime for compassion" who wanted to die and stop the

Andrew Johnson

642 words - 3 pages Andrew Johnson After President Lincoln was killed, Andrew Johnson became president. Johnson had the task of dealing with the reconstruction of the South. This task included black suffrage. His policy concerning the franchising of blacks was to allow each state to decide. Johnson did not favor blacks being allowed to vote in order to protect the poor Southern whites, but he did want blacks to be able to gain the right with time. The

The Right to Choose. On euthanasia

625 words - 3 pages incurable conditions of diseases." This "easy death" is often criticized by people whose ideas are shaped by religion, the media, and misinformation. It should be a basic human right for individuals to decide whether they want to continue their life or end it.It is important to gain a better understanding of what actually constitutes the act of euthanasia. There are two different types of euthanasia, active and passive. Active euthanasia gives the


395 words - 2 pages Abortion is an operation to terminate a pregnancy which kills the foetus before full term. When two people who are going to have a baby decide that they do not want to have to have the baby they go to a doctor and the woman has an abortion. Abortion is a very controversial issue. On the one hand, there are people who believe that it is a woman's right to decide if she wants to have a baby and on the other hand, there are people who

The Examined Life Socrates - Philosophy - Essay

1000 words - 4 pages don’t allow other people to decide how you’re going to live your life. People need to examine their lives and the world, to avoid making decisions without reasoning. If you examine your life you get to choose your destinations and set goals. You can decide the paths you’re going to take, decide how long those paths will take, and decide whether they’re right or wrong. We also get to decide between bad actions and good actions. You must examine

discousee board

572 words - 3 pages the company. These top managers may decide how to handle a major crisis and what product to launch or manufacture. They also identify competitors, create a corporate vision for the company, decide on mergers and acquisitions, develop budgets and set long-term goals.Middle-Level Management DecisionsMost non-critical decisions are delegated to middle level management. Top management relies heavily on middle management to make the right decisions. An

A summary and response to an article regarding pornography

1024 words - 4 pages point. Who has the power to judge what's appropriate for all? Who has the right to speak for all of humankind? There is no possible way we can hand over the power to someone to decide what's appropriate for all. No one on earth can possibly decide what's right and wrong and what we can and cannot see.What Isaacs has done in this article is explain the reasons why pornography cannot be banned. The most evident reason is that of the First

Exploring Morality in Measure for Measure

754 words - 3 pages . Through the character of Mistress Overdone, Shakespeare is able to bring a jovial side to the oldest job known to man -- prostitution. Through the character of Mariana, Shakespeare allows the audience to decide if two wrongs do, in fact, make a right. While the concepts of right and wrong are given a twist in this play, Shakespeare, in the end, allows his audience to decide for themselves what is right and what is wrong. At the beginning of

The Legalization of Assisted Suicide

1798 words - 8 pages Assisted Suicide has through out history caused controversy among our society. There are two sides to this issue, one that passionately supports it, and those who religiously disagree. I believe that assisted suicide should become legal for several reasons. Assisted suicide gives individuals the right to end their suffering when they personally feel that their time has come to die. Assisted suicide should become legal because if one can decide

Similar Essays

Nat Turner: Right Or Wrong? (We Had To Read Up On The Case Of Nat Turner's Rebellion And Decide Whether Her Was Right Or Wrong, And Argue Our Points)

1273 words - 5 pages were not only responsible for the deaths of white male planters, but also their helpless wives and, in many cases, their infant children. It is very difficult to say whether or not Turner was right to do what he did, but in order to make a judgment one way or another one must examine both the short-term repercussions of the incident as well as the long-term consequences. After having examined these things, I come to the conclusion that Nat Turner

John Corzine Letter Essay

342 words - 2 pages September 04, 2006John CorzineGovernorP.O Box 001Trenton, NJ 08625Dear Governor,Why has abortion become such a political issue? Who should have the final say?It is hard to imagine a more troublesome, emotional decision for a woman, than to end a pregnancy or to let it proceed to bear a child. It is also hard to imagine how anyone has the right to decide the fate of a pregnant woman.To qualify for an abortion in New Jersey, a woman must be over

Case Study

2340 words - 9 pages this case is the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964What issue(s) must the court decide in this case?The court must decide if Thelma Jones was withheld a promotion due to discrimination based on sex.If you were the judge, how would you rule? Did the employer discriminate unlawfully? Why or why not?If I were judge, I would rule in favor for the plaintiff. Employers have the right to enforce a dress code based on position and specific job

Is One Naturally Born A Good Citizen?

539 words - 2 pages different aspects of life that can have an effect on you being a good citizen. This time of year there is a war going on in Iraq; there are everyday robberies, shootings, and murders. You can either join this massacre of the world or follow another path, the path of a good citizen. The right choices you make decide this. Choices like whether to study for a test or fail, steal or don't steal, cheat or don't cheat, all decide if you are a good