This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Are Humans Animals, Or Are They Something More?

1167 words - 5 pages

Human beings should be more than animals, but are they really? In Republic, by Plato, Antigone, by Sophocles, The Aeneid of Virgil, by Virgil, and On Justice Power and Human Nature, by Thucydides, it seems as though human beings really are nothing more than animals.
     Animals are thought of as not caring about anyone but himself or herself. It is survival of the fittest, if you are not strong enough, someone else will take your place. Human should be caring for other human beings, if someone is in trouble, another human should help them. This is not the way it is in these 3 works. Humans don’t care about anyone but themselves, they kill so they can better themselves, and don’t care what happens. It seems as people are getting murdered all the time to take power, and the killer, instead of being jailed, is now the leader.
     In Plato’s Republic, he basically designs a caste system. People are chosen at birth what level they will be in society, and there is nothing they can do about this. This is almost like a food chain. In regards to reproduction, Socrates severely regulates sex. Socrates proposes a rigged lottery to ensure that the best man has sex with the best woman, and all women and children are shared between all the men. People can only have sex within their own class to guarantee the finest genetics. After the babies are born, the rulers will take them; the babies of the lesser classes will be left to die, whereas the babies of the upper class will take care of by nurses. This is totally barbaric, even animals know what happens to their offspring, whether they die due to a predator or they become healthy adults. In this situation it is humans being the predator. (Plato p.125)
     In Antigone, Creon is about as close to an animal as you can get. He refuses to bury his own nephew, Polynices. Even if Creon didn’t want him buried in Thebes, he could at least have his body sent back to his city to be buried. Then, after he finds out that Antigone buried Polynices, he sentences her, and her sister Ismene to death. He just assumes that Ismene helped Antigone, even though Ismene tried to talk Antigone out of burying Polynices. Even though Antigone seems the most human, or least animal like for trying to give her brother a proper burial, she tells Creon that she would not have done it for her husband, or child. (Antigone p.105) This brings Antigone down to the level of an animal because she would just let her husband’s or child’s body rot on the ground. Haemon is the only one in this play that does anything respectable by killing himself to show Creon that he was wrong by forbidding the burial of Polynices, and sentencing Antigone to death for burying Polynices.
     The Aeneid of Virgil gives some of the best examples of how humans are nothing more than animals. “Within, unholy Rage shall sit on his ferocious weapons, bound behind his back...

Find Another Essay On Are Humans Animals, Or Are They Something More?

Oceans: are they Untouchable or Vulnerable?

1160 words - 5 pages include global warming. Pollution of the ocean ranges from the deliberate dumping of toxins and plastics by factories, governments and the like, to runoff from over-fertilized plantations and the accidental oil disasters, such as the Exxon spill of ’89 or the more recent BP Gulf of Mexico spill in 2013. All forms are highly destructive to wildlife. The fertilizers do little to directly harm the oceans, but they catalyze and sustain algae

Are Men or Women More Fortunate?

840 words - 3 pages crying in public, right away one may assume he is gay or a wimp. Socially it is more acceptable for females to let their emotions flow freely. As well, females most of the time tell you what they are thinking and how they feel about something. This is quite helpful for the single task male. While males have similar feelings, it is not, at this time, socially acceptable for a male to talk about them. By not talking about ones feelings one could

Apps are they useful or garbage?

1012 words - 5 pages types of apps are much more suited for a computer because desktop or laptops computers are faster, they are more versatile, and the programs are fully functional. The more apps that are running on a mobile device or a tablet, the slower the device performs as well as launching and operating the applications on that device. There are a number of apps that are extremely useful, such as Dropbox (an online storage space for documents and pictures

Are Families in Decline or Are They Resilient?

675 words - 3 pages Position Paper - Towson University The meaning of family changes over time, contexts, and cultures. This is partly because of how diverse the world is in the present day. The question ìAre Families in Decline or are they Resilient? is not easy to answer because modern family arrangements are more adaptable then in the past. However, there is more statistics indicating that families are in decline. First, the traditional family, which used to

Are Humans Intrinsically Evil?

1483 words - 6 pages they are good, then they do good things as a response to their nature, and do evil things because they are corrupted by society, either because of dysfunctional social upbringing, upsetting circumstances, or because they truly believe that what they are doing is the right thing. It is important to ask if humans are intrinsically evil in order to understand how to best govern our society. In understanding our nature, we can understand the necessity

Homosexuals are Humans too

1008 words - 5 pages (Clinton, Hilary). It is something you are just naturally born with, no person would choose a life they knew people would torment them about. If anything the child would just accept every form of love there is, “They’re more likely to be tolerant of differences, because their parents are teaching them certain values that are positive.” (Wilson, Susanne) One problem they may have in their life is possibly get bullied at school for having two moms

"All Animals Are Equal"

987 words - 4 pages In order to understand Peter Singer's article "All Animals Are Equal", one has to look at his viewpoint and perspective. Singer is a utilitarian, which is someone who believes that best outcome is something that causes that greatest amount of pleasure (or the least amount of pain) for the greatest number of people. However, in this definition the word 'people' is used, as to mean only humans. This is the point that Singer is trying to argue. Who

All Animals are equal

934 words - 4 pages to giving moral equality and how can we apply it. Suffering is something every creature can experience at certain level. whether it can be seen or not. But this brings in the question of are we as a human treat animals differently when it comes into a lifesaving decision. For example if we were to save an injured person or to save an injured animal which one we should save first and how do we come up with that decision in term of who is suffering

Animals Are Good

749 words - 3 pages humans and mice and monkeys are different (actually, most animals used in research have greater than 90 percent genetic similarity to humans), the findings in studies that use animals are invalid. However, what they might not be aware of is the interconnectedness of all biological systems in their basic function, as well as dysfunction. It is this interconnectedness that makes scientific inquiry and the eventual solutions possible.

are humans by nature aggressive?

1568 words - 6 pages of the initiators of this approach, he claims that all creatures are naturally aggressive for the purpose of survival, humans being no exception. Therefore, aggressive behavior is rooted in the phylogenetic adaptation to environmental dangers. Thus, aggression led to the survival of those specimens equipped with the necessary features to their defeat or subdue their opponents, the powerful obtaining access to more resources and of better quality

Humans Are Causing Global Warming

2047 words - 8 pages pollutants that humans release into the environment. The once stable climate has in recent years begun to skyrocket, thus altering the delicate structure of earthly life. This proves to be hazardous to the future of the planet; some people worry that many of the resources the environment provides that are taken for granted will not be available for future generations to utilize or protect. Many scientists now agree that humans largely influence the

Similar Essays

Zombies: Are They Real Or Something Of Imagination?

1813 words - 7 pages Concepts are how we give meaning to everyday things. We make, name, communicate, and imagine concepts all day everyday; concepts are vital to understanding this world we live in. A concept is an abstract idea or a cognitive unit of meaning. Zombies, for example, are a concept, but where did this concept of the living dead arise? Is there some religious link to this concept or is it an image of imagination? A zombie is defined as a fictional

Animals Are Not Equal To Humans

1305 words - 5 pages creatures and would be wasted on them: the right to drive, the right to vote, the freedom to walk through streets without leashes, and the freedom to eat whatever they like. So of course, it would be unrealistic to say animals are equal to humans when more than half of what humans do does not matter to them. What most animal rights activists would say is animals should not be discounted for their intelligence, and it is true (“Animals are

Are Diverse Teams Really More Creative And Effective Or Do They Simply Invite More Conflict? Explain

648 words - 3 pages It is not simply to answer diverse teams which are more creative and effective or invite more conflict. Compare to homogeneous teams which is "team that includes members with common technical expertise, demographics, ethnicity, experiences or values" (McShane & Travaglione, 2003, p269) and individuals, diverse teams have advantages and disadvantages depend on different situations. Based on current workplace, Griggs and Louw (1995, p24

Are Zoos Good Or Bad For Animals?

1509 words - 6 pages are most likely visiting zoos that do not have any anticipation of actually helping the animals and putting them back into the wild where they belong. The animals kept in the programs are said to be used to recreate the population of that species. However, sometimes the program has a surplus of animals that they have to tend to. If there is a surplus, they will usually sell or trade the extra animals to others zoos, sanctuaries, circuses