Are Women Teachers To Blame For Boys Low Test Scores?

2113 words - 8 pages

Are Women Teachers to Blame for Boys' Low Test Scores?

In "The Mind of Man" by David Thomas, the academic performances of both men and women are scrutinized. He quotes an old calypso song "Man Smart, Woman Smarter" (120). But is this true, and if it is true, why are women generally regarded as being smarter, especially in their primary and secondary education?
Dr. John Nicholson, author of "A Question of Sex", states that men and women are different in the types of mental tasks they perform (120). Times magazine states in an article published in January 1992, that "Males excel at rotating three-dimensional objects in their head. Females prove better at reading the emotions of people in photographs" (121). The author of the article is referring to the fact that maybe our brains are put together differently.

Girls and boys performances in school are much different. The girls get the high grades and the boys leave. Why? Is it just because their brains are different? David Thomas argues that there has to be other factors involved. It can't just be brain function. He suggests that the social aspect in these studies must also be looked at and considered.

He looks at how boys speak up more in class and girls remain quiet. He states society has often viewed a girl who speaks out as "hectoring and domineering" (121). He also points out that boys get punished more for their behavior. Tony Mooney wrote in the Independent on Sunday: "Women teachers find boys too noisy, too aggressive, too boisterous" (121). By this he means teachers favor girls over boys because boys are not acting like the girls. And the majority of primary school teachers are women. Mooneys own son remarked how the female teachers shouted at him more than the male teachers did. I am sure that there are many male teachers who feel the same way as these female teachers. There is a certain environment that is critical for learning to take place. If the boys are always too noisy, too aggressive or too boisterous, then, of course, they are going to have to face the consequences of their actions.

An experiment at the University of California, Los Angeles proved interesting when a machine taught both boys and girls. The boys ended up scoring higher than when a woman taught them. I am wondering if girls scored higher than the boys did when male teachers teach them? I also wonder how the girls scored when taught by a machine; maybe they scored higher, too. At the secondary school level boys do perform better on technical or scientific subjects. Now this goes back to the first assumption that our brains work differently, or is it because more male teachers may teach these subjects? According to Mooney, teacher of the similar sex may have the "instinctive understanding that an adult will enjoy with a child who is going through a process which he or she went through too" (122). In other words, they can relate better with a child of the same sex. I am a female kindergarten teacher and...

Find Another Essay On Are Women Teachers to Blame for Boys Low Test Scores?

Are Parents to Blame for Childhood Obesity?

1506 words - 6 pages diabetes. Several internal and external factors contribute to childhood obesity; however, many people believe that parents are primarily to blame for obese children and adolescents. On the other hand, medical professionals and sociologists have studied the consistent decline in physical activity and external societal influences that help to contribute to childhood obesity. Childhood obesity is comprised of several internal components. It is

Are the Poor to Blame for Being Poor

1527 words - 7 pages undecided and that polls reveal the 70-80 percent believe that anyone who is poor can overcome poverty by working hard (Schiller, 2008). The purpose of this paper will be to discuss the issues with poverty and if the poor are to blame for being poor. The conservative perspective will be utilized to show how the poor are perceived and whether this perspective continues to oppress the marginalized population or helps them. Conservative Perspective

Romeo and Juliet are to Blame for Their Own Deaths

3363 words - 13 pages Romeo and Juliet are to Blame for Their Own Deaths Shakespeare is said to be one of the greatest sonnet and playwrights of the last millennium. In this assignment I am going to explore and write about one of Shakespeare's most famous and talked about plays "Romeo and Juliet". Shakespeare didn't only write tragedies (Romeo and Juliet is a tragedy as we will see in throughout this task). He also wrote comedies, sonnets

Parents Are Mainly to Blame for Childhood Obesity

1349 words - 5 pages Research shows “the prevalence of obesity among U.S. preschoolers has doubled in recent decades” (May 629). This is not surprising because we live in a “fast food” world where convenience is king. Where the television is the babysitter, and staying indoors to play video games is preferred to playing outside. So is this the child’s fault? Sometimes, but it is my opinion that parents are mainly to blame for childhood obesity because they are the

Are Fast Food Restuarants to Blame for Obesity?

1535 words - 7 pages nineteen classified as obese, has risen from five percent to seventeen percent. The percentage of adults classified as obese has risen from half to two-thirds the population. Although fast food restaurants may be a contributing factor to the increasing obesity rate in the United States, people are ultimately responsible for their own health. Obesity, according to Dr. Joan F.Tryzelaar, is defined as a medical condition in which excess body fat has

Are the Poor to Blame for Being Poor

1645 words - 7 pages type of environment. I understand what it is like to be poor and do not feel a person should be are being blamed for being poor. A child cannot control their environment and it is not their fault if they are poor. However, I do feel as an adult you have choices that do affect your life and that it is up to the individual to improve their own life circumstances. If you are mentally or physically disabled then you are limited and do not have

Schools Are Unfair to Boys

1506 words - 7 pages love and time instead of using chemical therapy. Schools are unfair to boys by providing less male teachers to them. In “Sedation nation the cost of taking boisterous out of boys”, Elizabeth Farrelly points out, “30 years ago, Australian primary school employed five male teachers for every four female. By 2006 there was one male teacher for every four females (par. 4). In other words, 30 years ago, male teachers are important to school. 125% of

Pageant Parents are to Blame for the Exploitation of Their Children

1723 words - 7 pages Pageant Parents are to Blame for the Exploitation of Their Children Until the death of 6-year-old beauty queen Jonbenet Ramsey, the child pageant circuit was never fully recognized on a national scale. In the past 17 years, many shows have attempted to give the country a glimpse into the the life of a child beauty queen, however, they are quite over dramatic. Although some sources of media may mislead a viewer to believe the child pageant

Armed Teachers Are Best For Our Children

1606 words - 7 pages A gun law currently being debated on the Senate floor in Missouri allows for teachers to carry guns on campus and while school is in session. This new law calls for well trained and competent teachers to protect students who have been physically vulnerable to armed intruders in the past. The main idea behind this legislation is that some teachers are willing to be the first line of defense when faced with a shooter intent on killing many

Failing School Systems: Are Students to Blame?

1276 words - 5 pages leaning potential. As the saying goes, it takes a village to raise a child. Therefore, the blame for the failing educational system should not be placed on the teachers, parents, school officials and the students separately. Everyone plays a part in this and the community must work together for the benefit of the children. They are our future, and if they are not successful they is no telling where the world would end up. Works Cited Dye, Jane

Childhood Obesity-Are the parents to blame?

1482 words - 6 pages , stroke, sleeping habits, as well as having low self-esteem, and problems with peer relationships (Childhood Obesity). All of these are symptoms that can carry over into their adult lives if left untreated. There is no single cause of obesity, but parents need to be aware of signs this growing problem in their own family.There are several theories to try to explain or to just shift the blame for the problem. Some children don't get the exercise

Similar Essays

Are Test Scores A Good Indication Of A School's Competency?

1243 words - 5 pages , teaching responsibility, following rules and how to have values for themselves can be taught. Test scores are gained by the students, many different students make up a classroom, and many different classrooms make up a school. There is no way to create a fair exam for everyone to take. As I stated in the beginning individuals learn at different paces. Another problem with having test scores being an indication of a school's competency would be the

Are Test Scores A Good Judge Of Student Competency?

1267 words - 5 pages for higher test scores. It has been reviewed by the New York Times’s 2009 report that the correlation between income and SAT scores “correlate strongly and positively with income” (Wade, Lisa. PhD). Not only are children from better homes well equipped, but the structure of the test itself may be biased as “ Tests tend to be written and evaluated by privileged individuals who may inadvertently include class-based knowledge, not just knowledge

Are Test Scores A Good Judge Of Student Competency?

1189 words - 5 pages and scoring of high stakes testing as a basis for student competency however, it has left out regards to its negative consequences such as classroom curriculum and learning encouragement. Furthermore, students should not be punished for inaccurate assessments that are given with such high stakes. Teachers just teaching the test in order to carry a school rank will not help students develop their own thoughts and opinions. In the long run, high

His Eaasy Talk About The Article "How Boys Become Men," By Jon Katz. I Agree Boys Are Forced To Hide Their Emotions And Men Will Act The Same Way As Women If We Treat Them The Same

806 words - 3 pages disconnection, most of them would not have the tools to talk about it or the people with whom to discuss it. According to my experiences, we girls are falling for the "I don't know" and "I don't care" excuses. It is not that we really do not know the answers, but we are just trying to pretend that we do not know so that we can ask for helps. This way we can always get the answers correctly. Therefore, girls always ask for helps, but boys never do