This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Are Newly Resident Migrant Groups And Non Citizens Entitled To The Minority Rights Protection Recognised By Current International Law?

1592 words - 7 pages

If you were to ask an ordinary man on the street, “Who do you think deserves to benefit from human rights?”, he would no doubt instinctively respond ‘everyone!” But give him a little time to think, and he might come back with, “Well, not everyone, maybe not murderers…maybe not child abusers or rapists…”, and he may come up with a list of classes of people that have morally offended the society. It is a common misconception however, that these individuals among others are not entitled to human rights protection. Human Rights law is founded on a critical, overarching and universal principle, that:

“All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights….”

If rapists, murderers and the like are offered a degree of protection, why then is it so difficult to extend the same courtesy in practice to newly resident migrants and non-citizens? Newly resident migrant groups and non-citizens are definitely entitled to the minority rights protection recognised by current international law, as human rights protection is non discriminatory. At an international level, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR 1966) reinforces this point further, but more specifically worded for the prevention of discrimination against minorities. The Human Rights Committee is a body of independent experts whose function is to monitor the implementation of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights by its State parties. They have stated that:

“…The rights set forth in the Covenant apply to everyone, irrespective of reciprocity, and irrespective of his or her nationality or statelessness. Thus, the general rule is that each one of the rights of the Covenant must be guaranteed without discrimination between citizens and aliens.”

The only permitted exceptions to discrimination involve political rights that only apply to citizens, and freedom of movement . Additionally, the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination 1969 defines ‘racial discrimination’ and explicitly states another narrow form of permitted discrimination. It specifies that distinctions can be made between citizens and non-citizens, but under the condition that all non-citizens are treated similarly. The Human Rights Committee in its General Recommendation XXX made clear the duty a state has towards non-citizens. This includes but is not limited to protection against hate speech and racial violence, access to citizenship, administration of justice, non-discriminatory expulsion and deportation of non-citizens, and economic, social and cultural rights. At the European level, Article 14 of The European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights
and Fundamental Freedoms provides the rights relating to discrimination, provided the claim is linked to a right set out in the Convention.

When considering the minority rights available to newly resident migrant groups and non-citizens, it is necessary to determine whether they can...

Find Another Essay On are Newly resident migrant groups and non-citizens entitled to the minority rights protection recognised by current international law?

The International Criminal Court (ICC) and the Protection of Human Rights in Africa

1589 words - 6 pages 2 Introduction This essay will discuss the successes and challenges faced by the International Criminal Court (ICC) in prosecuting human rights violations cases in Africa. The ICC has been recently put under the spotlight by the African Union when it called for non-cooperation by its member states not to comply with the warrant of arrests that had been issued by the ICC against some of the leaders in Africa. This has created difficulties when

International Human Rights and Humanitarian Law

1077 words - 5 pages each of them cover. It is essential to note that despite common principles like protection of human life and dignity of individuals, IHL applies mainly outside the sphere of humanitarian law. However, rules of IHL deal with many issues which are outside the ambit of IHRL, such as the conduct of hostility, combatant and prisoner of war status, etc. There also exist certain areas governing non wartime issues like rights governing election or striking

Current & NonCurrent Assets Paper What are current & non-current assets? What differs b/w current & non-current assets? What is the order of liquidity? How does the order of liquidity apply to the...

836 words - 3 pages Current and Non-Current Assets PapernameACC/400: Accounting for Decision MakingMay 10, 2010instructorCurrent and Non-Current Assets PaperAssets are "resources owned by a business" (Kimmel, Weygandt & Kieso, 2007, p. 10) which are expected "to increase the value of a firm or benefit the firms operations" (Investopedia, 2010, para. 3). Assets are necessary because they are used to fund operations and expenses of a business. Assets are divided

Privacy Protection Rights for Business and How They Are Effected

759 words - 4 pages , who weren't aware of the situation, are now considering morally inadequate the exploitation by g-mail of the content of their mailboxes to generate advertisements and marketing data. Those lawsuits are consequently helping in sensibilizing users to the lack of privacy of current systems. Money trail as protection While we are considering offering email services to non-paying users, we are planning to offer encryption features to paying users

Kenya: International Human Rights Law

1362 words - 6 pages On the global scale, transnational actors have the capability to enforce international human rights laws. Such capability is currently in place in the global system through the intergovernmental organization known as the International Criminal Court (ICC). The ICC hears cases on genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity from around the world. This court is different from the World Court, as it has the ability to indict individuals from

The 'typical Australian' and indeed, Australian national identity, does not cover the diversity of Australian citizens and many groups, including women, are excluded

1422 words - 6 pages happy nuclear family" (Whitlock, G; Carter, D; p135).The above examples of the 'typical Australian' are at the exclusion of many groups of Australian citizens: Aboriginal Australians, Australians of ethnic origin and women as a whole. In examining the exclusion of women, it is argued by Linzi Murrie "...that masculine is always positioned against an excluded 'feminine' or 'non-masculine' so that any masculinity is defined as much as by what it

Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement: "It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any...

517 words - 2 pages international power is held by intergovernmental organisations such as the UN, the ability of a single state to create international law has decreased greatly as they are now unable, on their own, to create viable and enforceable law. This thus shows how an individual state can't create international law. In terms of whether or not the statements of a single state are of concequence to international law, complexity theory suggests that the way in

Investigate the increasing importance of human rights after World War II in both international and Australian law

1153 words - 5 pages , human rights have gained mounting significance over years to protect the vulnerable such as POWs, women, children, refugees and Aborigines.The successive international documents after Declaration are testament to growing importance of human rights as member's ratify and non-members are circumscribed by international customary law which develops in accordance with accepted state practice e.g. non-discrimination and applies to all nations. The UN

An essay on the International Criminal Court, with a mark of 18.75/20. Including- Overview, History, Jurisdiction, Structure, Rights of the accused and Current Cases

1026 words - 4 pages Tribunals, the United Nations General Assembly recognised the need for a permanent international court to deal with atrocities associated with World War II. The International Law Commission drafted to statutes by the early 1950's at the request of the General Assembly but at the advent of the Cold War they were struck aside, as the idea of an international criminal court was politically unrealistic. In 1989 the idea was revived as the PM of Trinidad

Effects of the incorporation of international law into the dynamics of organized anarchy and how power relationships are altered

719 words - 3 pages organized anarchy shows somewhat the same picture of organized anarchy as described above except the political actors are on a global stage where the winners and losers, predicted or unpredicted, are entire nation states. International law dictates how nations interact whether it is through trade, aide, protection, or mutual interests. Anarchy within this organization tends to alter power relationships for example when the French vowed to veto the

Relevance of Public International Law in Human Rights

1317 words - 5 pages been relevant to the protection and development of human rights in at least three aspects. Firstly, public international law helped to create the main legal frame in human rights that is comprised by the UN charter, the UDHR and the bill of rights and seven subsequent treaties (Mitchell & Beard, 2009, p. 312; Bagaric, 2007, p. 123). In the UN charter is stated, that all member states are determined “to reaffirm faith in fundamental human

Similar Essays

What Are The Barriers To Human Rights Being Recognised As Truly Universal In Application?

968 words - 4 pages physical or mental traits people possess. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights is an international document that encourages states to promote social, economic and political rights to the citizens. (Un.org, 2014). Human rights heavily touch on fundamental principles such as dignity, fairness, equality, respect and autonomy. Human rights are both universal and egalitarian. The rights are inalienable rights for equality and each being inherited it

Are Non Human Entities Entitled To Moral Consideration?

1691 words - 7 pages with the topics of animal rights and environmentalism hinge upon the answer to these questions. The moral community is comprised of a body of people who are self-aware enough to make moral decisions and contribute to and obey moral mandates laid down by the community. According to philosopher Carl Cohen, human beings are the only known moral creatures that, "lay down moral laws; for others and for themselves. Human beings are self-legislative

Against Affirmative Action By Jumbo Moos Why Aa Hinders The Non Minority And The Minority By Putting Them In A Job They Are Less/Not Qualified For

596 words - 2 pages those that aren't of a certain minority. Colleges claim to seek 'diversity.' But what good is diversity without justice?Affirmative action acknowledges a difference between races. If there isn't a difference between blacks and whites, then why do blacks get a boost into college? To me this says that blacks aren't capable of getting themselves into college without a crutch. It says that blacks are unequal to whites, and therefor need a crutch. We

The Nature Of Disadvantage Encountered By Minority Groups, The Legal And Non Legal Means Adopted To Address That Disadvantage And The Limitations Those Measures Have In Addressing The Disadvantage

1527 words - 6 pages the definition of “a parent or legal guardian” with regards to Acts such as the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). This has been effective in alleviating some levels of discrimination faced by people of differing sexuality through the legal system. Various non-governmental groups such as The NSW Gay and Lesbian Rights Lobby have been successful in publicly promoting equality and social justice for Homosexuals. Due to ongoing public pressure from these