This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Are Rct Designs In Psychotherapy Research Essential And Exclusively Necessary To Advance Es Ts?

2126 words - 9 pages

Are RCT designs in psychotherapy research essential and exclusively necessary
to advance ESTs?

Within the literature westen et al. Seem to bring forth one of the more convincing papers addressing the problems with RCT designs, and advocate the use of alternative measure for psychotherapy research. Westen et al. Bring to light some serious concerns. The issues brought to light in the Westen et al, paper will be addressed as well as the response to the allegations. RCT designs in psychotherapy research are essential in psychotherapy research to advance ESTs, however, I do not believe they are exclusively necessary for their advancement. RCTs are one of the most important components in psychotherapy research but not the only component. Westen et. al., brings forth some interesting allegations regarding the use of RCTs. Some of which are widely agreed upon, others which appear to be nothing other than faulty allegations.

Westen et. al., brings forth some interesting allegations regarding the use of RCTs. Some of which are widely agreed upon, others which appear to be nothing other than faulty allegations.

Westens argument

Malleability (short term) -- explain what he says – and then explain how that is not true (give example)

Westen’s promotion of long-term therapies seem to ignore the issues of cost and patient compliance (Haaga, 2004). A heavy burden of cost and ability to keep patients in long term studies should beimportant considerations when comparing longer term and shorter therapies (Haaga, 2004).

- Discourage inclusion criteria, other than that a normal clinician would exclude in an everyday setting (Thompson-Brenner, 2004).

Co-morbidity

 Inclusion criteria – excluded patients are more challenging that the enrolled patients (Haaga, 2004).

Isolation of personality characteristics

Problem with using DSM

By thinking categorically rather than dimensionally, one may interpret the existence of both anxiety and depression as an instance of comorbidity, rather than considering the possibility that a person’s depression results from fear-induced inhibition and passivity (Goldfried & Eubanks-Carter, 2004).

-assigning patients to treatment based solely on their DSM diagnosis – could be the issue not the RCT itself

- systematic desensitization to the treatment of public speaking anxiety. Westen et al. noted that the difficulty occurs when complex clinical problems are studied and when the intervention requires a departure from manual guidelines to use clinical
judgment—a threat to internal validity.

There is nothing in the logic of RCTs, nor in the criteria for identifying ESTs, that requires defining the relevant participant group by an Axis I condition. Indeed, my own contribution to the EST Task Force work (incorporated in Chambless et al., 1998) involved identifying ESTs for a behavior (cigarette smoking), not the related disorder (nicotine dependence). Furthermore, as long as the inclusion criteria are clear,...

Find Another Essay On Are RCT designs in psychotherapy research essential and exclusively necessary to advance ESTs?

Persuasive Research Essay: Why Drones Are Necessary

1338 words - 6 pages War is a necessary evil. It is such a thing, that in today’s society it has become almost inexorable. But as with any war, there are always casualties. There will always be copious acquitted victims of combat. But that does not have to be ‘reality’ anymore due to the effective use of drones. If drones are used accurately and meritoriously, then children do not have to become orphans due to the fact that drones are Unmanned Air Vehicles (UAVs

Job Designs in Service and Manufacturing Organizations

2057 words - 8 pages with increased participation in the organization versus removing what control they feel they currently have. 5. Describe managerial skills and behaviors that would be required to manage effectively in a functional department. Are these skills and behaviors different from those required in a product department? Explain. Functional departments are the result of breaking down the overall activities necessary to achieve organizational goals

Compare how settings and societies are essential to the mood in 'The Great Gatsby' by F Scott Fitzgerald and 'The Importance of Being Earnest' by Oscar Wilde

2916 words - 12 pages Oscar Wilde's 'The Importance of Being Earnest' and F Scott Fitzgerald's 'The Great Gatsby' are set in different historical and cultural contexts. However, there are common themes and moods that both writers create within these different settings to help convey their social comments. But there are also some important differences in how mood is created and in the themes presents to the readers and audiences. This exploration of the moods created

Expert Systems Are Essential In Today's Society

880 words - 4 pages Social and Ethical 3Expert Systems Essential!An Expert system is software that can solve a narrowly defined set of problems using information and reasoning techniques normally associated with a human expert. Expert systems have the ability to perform at or near the level of a human expert in a particular field of study, hence the name 'Expert Systems'The government should spend money on expert systems, for research and production, as expert

Good Negotiation Skills are essential to a successful business in the tourism industry

1447 words - 6 pages important to make a good presentation, well gesture and clarify conversation. The second stage is to debate that is mostly about interaction between negotiators. Communication is central to the debate process. "Miscommunication can arise from mistakes in formulating a message, from errors in transmission or from misinterpretation by the receiver." The chance of communication errors increases when negotiators are in conflict or dislike each

Some people think that "soft sentiments" and "romantic words" are essential ingredients in love poetry. How do three or four poems show different approaches to writing about love?

2406 words - 10 pages Plan of EssayPoems to include are The Beggar Women, Our Love Now, and To His Coy Mistress.Demure = to Coy = to Shy = To His Coy Mistress.Banal = Common place = conventional = stereotypical = clichéHow is equal to the language used by the poet.Different kinds of love include:Two poems are similar that they both in love in the cliché way or have been in love in this way the poems involved include To His Coy Mistress and Our Love

Effort and Awareness are Necessary for Liberation

1867 words - 7 pages . In the end, Rafea succeeded, and was able to support her family. Thus, the universal truth that effort and awareness are necessary for liberation presented in the documentary “Solar Mamas” through the idea that hard work is required for emancipation. Thirdly, the universal truth is also displayed in the song “Wavin’ Flag” by K’NAAN through the idea that perseverance and persistence are key factors in liberation. Without internal and external

"How would you define business ethics, and why are ethical standards necessary in professional selling"

1467 words - 6 pages , Fraedrich and Ferrell 2005, p. 6).Ethical standards are necessary in professional selling and it contributes to quite a number benefits for both the business and salesperson. Ethics in general, starts from the top line managers. Futrell (2005 p.56) stated that, "Salespeople are valuable resources: they are recruited, carefully trained, and given important responsibility. They represent a large financial investment and must be treated in a

Analysis of Why Fact and Fancy Are Both Necessary in Charles Dickens' Hard Times

1418 words - 6 pages Analysis of Why Fact and Fancy Are Both Necessary in Charles Dickens' Hard Times Fact and Fancy in Hard Times Coketown is a monotonous town of machinery and tall chimneys. There is a sense of sameness in the town: “It contained several large streets all very like one another, and many small streets still more like one another, inhabited by people equally like one another.” A town so sacred to fact should progress smoothly, yet residents

Connection Between Existential Psychotherapy and Ethnicity in Family Therapy

1901 words - 8 pages meetings to identify strategies to promote sensitivity to diversity in psychology" (McGuire, 1999). (Cardemil & Battle, 2003)The Existential Psychotherapy approach is best described as a "movement wanting to know to the best extent possible the existence of the patient in the world in which he lives, moves, and experiences" (May, R. 1983). According to May the purpose of this approach is to understand human existence, not a system of "how to" (p

How to Advance your Communication in a Professional Business Manner

1544 words - 6 pages points and help satisfy their wants (Mayer 2012). Not only in America is business communication a significant piece for the business world, but also in other countries. When examining research on New Zealanders and Chinese sales force teams who questions were asked: What persuasion strategies do the Chinese or NZ managers follow in writing their sales letters? How do their counterparts interpret and react to these long-used traditional strategies

Similar Essays

Paper # 4: Are Rct Designs In Psychotherapy Research Essential And Exclusively Necessary To Advance Es Ts?

2135 words - 9 pages Many convincing cases have been made both for and against the use of randomized control trails (RCTs) in psychotherapy research. Throughout this paper many of those cases will be explored. In light of the existing literature I believe randomized control trail (RCT) designs are essential in psychotherapy research and in the advancement of empirically supported treatments (EST). I do not, however, believe they are exclusively necessary for their

Health Research And Designs Essay

583 words - 2 pages Running Head: DESIGNS 1DESIGNS 4Health Research and DesignsKimberly MongoldHPR 460 Analysis of Health ResearchInstructor: Sarah HowellSeptember 07, 2014Health Research and DesignsThis paper is in regard to a cross-sectional study that was used to estimate the prevalence of tobacco consumption and secondhand smoke (SHS) exposure in private cars, commercial vehicles and taxis in the city of Barcelona in Spain (Curto, A., Martínez-S&aacute

How Sexuality And Faith Are Essential To A Person's Life

2266 words - 10 pages . She focuses on the theme that faith is deeply integrated within the person and having faith is essential in one’s life. Many religions imply that gays and lesbians are sinful and against religion. She talks about how the bible has been interpreted over the years and analyzes how it affects the gays community. She finds evidence from parts of the bible and interpretations that allow gays to be faithful to god. I found her conclusion very interesting

Good And Evil Are Essential To Each Other

1815 words - 8 pages In Beowulf the concept that good and evil are constantly contending is one of the most central themes to the epic. The poet makes it expressly evident that good and evil cannot exist without the other, for there would be no way of determining which was which. The religious undertone in Beowulf that God is intervening on the side of good is apparent in many of the battles fought, allowing Beowulf to prevail where someone evil could not have