This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Are Unions Still Useful? Essay

1734 words - 7 pages

Are unions in New Zealand (NZ) still useful is a debated issue. Logic suggests that they provide the necessary balance in power between employers and employees so will always be regarded as helpful. Conversely, changes over time mean they are not as valued as NZ’s representational avenues have changed to cope with new characteristics appearing in the workforce. This essay will explain the ideology behind this theory, illustrate evidence that supports it, but also state arguments against it by showing unions changing roles, unionisation levels, and reasons affecting decisions to join or not. It will show that although time has altered aspects of unions that unions in NZ today remain useful to employees in hearing and representing their voice.

NZ’s industrial relations developed by protection of the employment relationship through acts passed by government, particularly the Industrial Conciliation and Arbitration Act (IC&A). This is fundamental to NZ’s employment relations and set the right for trade unions to arrange and negotiate collectively with employers, as well as producing awards, wage rates and handling disputes (Bryson, 2011c).

Unions traditionally were “a continuous association of wage earners for the purpose of maintaining or improving the condition of their employment” (Webb & Webb, 1894, as cited in Bryson, 2011b, slide 7). Their function was to campaign for compassionate management procedures, equivalent bargaining power between employers and employees, and for fairness and democracy to be initiated into the workplace (Bryson, 2011a). Union activity at this time tended to focus on nationwide bargaining for industrial groups (Geare, 1983, as cited in Haynes, 2005), with their role seen as wage bargainers and individual grievance representation (Haynes & Fryer, 2001 as cited in Haynes, 2005).

Whereas, unions today provide a voice not only for workers but their families (New Zealand Council of Trade Unions [NZCTU], 2010), and they represent their member’s employment interests both collectively and individually (Bryson, 2011b). Their function to provide support can be found in other members when problems need addressing or to negotiate improvements concerning work conditions. They make sure employees opinions are heard and acknowledged and their rights maintained (NZCTU, 2010). For employees to get the greatest benefit from unions and what they can offer, NZ unions work together through the NZCTU to improve the overall position of workers (NZCTU, 2010). Haynes (2005) indicates today’s unions have modified their approach as support networks catering for the differing problems faced by workers, due to the expanding workforce and career opportunities.

The Employment Contracts Act (ECA) 1991 changed NZ’s industrial relations, shifting NZ from highly regulated to deregulated (Haynes, 2005) by outlawing required unionism. Due to this lack of state support, union membership in both the private and public sectors fell...

Find Another Essay On Are Unions Still Useful?

labor unions Essay

539 words - 2 pages reputation of unions still stands today as the public and employees find it hard to trust such massive corporations with dishonest pasts.      It is no secret that Labor Unions left a sour taste in society’s mouth; however building trust with the general public is key to Union’s future success. The unions of yesterday have left the public feeling fearful of what might happen in the future. Will history repeat itself

Labor Unions in the Workplace Essay

1614 words - 7 pages workers are not covered by collective bargaining contracts. Since these organizations are formed to help in collective bargaining, the lack of numerous bargaining contracts to cover many employers make them impediments to progress. In cases where collective bargaining contracts are used, they are negotiated between the company or business and the local union rather than national (Pencavel, 2014, p.143). Therefore, unions are no longer useful since

Private sector unions

1243 words - 5 pages the vanishing of these labor unions is affecting the workers and the work place. Most of them want a transformation in a lot of the major problems that are faced in the workforce today. While back in 1999 although still had major problems they had more people content. In ever single one of these categories the numbers went up from 1999. The biggest being job security and benefits. In 1999 50% said that their employers where doing well in that

The Decline in Union Membership in Australia

1705 words - 7 pages unions to be less and less useful. It would be difficult to make an opinion as to what is needed by the unions to increase membership, but a positive relationship between employees, employers and the government is the right step towards some harmony. Unions must realise that if they are to be efficient then they need to be responsive to members needs. Emphasis should be placed on improving the quality of core services and not adding new ones

The Past, Present and Future of Labor Unions

2270 words - 9 pages ABSTRACT: Labor Unions have become an important factor in our industries. For many years, labor unions have served as the main voice of the workers to their employers. The continuous effort of labor unions in helping the laborers ensure their rights in their jobs, acquire all the benefits they need and to eliminate the injustice experienced by workers in their workplace is still an ongoing process. In order to understand labor unions in

Labour Relations Law

2377 words - 10 pages the state of these relations. THE ROLE OF TRADE UNIONS IN DEVELOPMENT The idea or motivation behind the late President’s speech was the hope of better and “free trade unions becoming an essential instrument of a democracy”. In his speech, there are four principles illustrated of industrial relations in Botswana mainly, wages restraint, industrial peace, political stability and national development. These principles give vital clues to the

Labor Unions’ Involvement in Politics

1989 words - 8 pages , trade legislation, existence or lack of health, safety, and illegal discrimination regulations. They may also affect public investment (or lack of) in infrastructure, worker’s right to organize unions, levels of unemployment, and existence of unemployment insurance. Internal disagreements are prevalent among labor unions, and even within the union there remains to be debate about how unions engage. Early in labor organizing, many union members

A Critical Analysis of Trade Union Act, 1926

2180 words - 9 pages professions and do not necessarily relate to trade unions through a bond of company. There are still management who owe their level to an company with the trade partnership. Many trade unions are able to use their effect, and sometimes energy, to effect on governmental choices. There are many who identify that energy relations are at the reasons for economic relations, and that trade unions are governmental organizations. Some identify the

Why has trade union membership shrunk so dramatically in the past twenty five years? Will this continue?

1986 words - 8 pages ) was funded by the Federal Government to weaken trade unions. Thru the survey conducted by the Social Research Centre at the Australian National University it was found that a minority of employees were still forced into union membership. More than 5 percent of members felt they were not free to resign from their unions (J. O'Rourke, 2004). However, it would not be a surprise that the government are anti-unions as most unions have their own

Rise and Fall of US unions

1700 words - 7 pages Rise and Fall of Labor Unions in The USThe American Labor Movement developed as a result of the citywide organizations that unhappy workers were establishing. These workers were determined to receive the rights and privileges they deserved as citizens of a free country. A union is an organization of employees formed to bargain with the employer. There are many types of unions. For instance, a craft union is one whose members do one type of work

Assembly For All

1577 words - 7 pages , school, etc. Labor unions affect the lives of people in different demographics, from blue-collar workers, to white color workers, to students, to stay at home moms, and even retirees. Do labor unions have a positive or negative effect on the economy and human rights of a person? Even though my experience with labor unions has not been so pleasant, I am still indeed in favor of them because of all the positive effects that they bring. Through my

Similar Essays

The Superiority Of The Labour Union: How Labour Unions Benefit The Workforce And Society

656 words - 3 pages turmoil. Evidently, unions are crucial in keeping economies flourishing while also maintaining their viability. Moreover, unions promote the importance of labour rights as well as their protection and preservation. The labour movement during the industrial era radically changed how several countries handle the rights of their workers. However, many countries today are still against valuing the labour rights of their citizens, often because unions

Trade Unions Essay

1916 words - 8 pages in union membership is because of "Structural change causing job declines, growth of contracting and self-employment, feminisation of the workforce, high job mobility rate and inadequacy inside the unions". There are also many other reasons why union membership is declining, and the ACTU has felt it necessary to step in and stop this downward spiral. In 1997, the ACTU spent 40 million dollars on improving managerial roles in trade unions. This means that, although the membership levels are low, the unions themselves will still be a strong figure in the inevitable conflict between employees and employers.

Private Sector Unions Essay

1096 words - 5 pages unions although they still can be used to advantages In Richard Freeman’s liberal piece of work, Do Workers Still Want Unions? He compares what the US workers said about unions both private sector and public sector. He think that if more workers are in and for unions then they can have a say in them, and have more of a voice then they can help better the workplace. He stats the people the that are in the workforce today want as much or more of a

The Development Of Trade Unions In Britain

1580 words - 6 pages The Development of Trade Unions in Britain There are many different factors as to why trade unions developed so incredibly slowly in Britain. The problems started from the 1850s when New Model Unions were introduced. The ASE (Amalgamated Society of Engineers) had been formed in 1851 and had become the inspiration for other unions in similar areas of craftsmanship to be formed. Many people liked the idea of a union