Argument Against Capital Punishment Essay

1467 words - 6 pages

Protected under the Constitution, “No person shall be deprived of his or her LIFE, liberty, and property under Due Process of law.” These fundamental rights, primarily LIFE, apply to capital punishment- the death penalty. For years, the Court has deliberated decisions in regards to the death penalty and countless times they have overthrown previous decisions. This in no way means laws, under the Constitution, have changed; however, the Court and our interpretation(s) of the law have changed.
In Furman V. Georgia (1972), the Court held the death penalty is a violation of the Eighth Amendment. Furman quickly gave rise to the controversial issue of capital punishment. As a result, several states adopted laws requiring juries to consider aggravating factors (justifying the imposition of capital punishment) and mitigating factors (justifying the imposition of an alternative sentence to the death penalty based on the aspect of the defendant’s character and/ or record) (O’Brien).
In Gregg V. Georgia (1976), the Court upheld Georgia’s statute specifying the aggravating and mitigating circumstances for imposing the death penalty and providing two separate trials: one for guilt and the other for punishment. Gregg reversed Furman. According to Kenneth Haas, the aftermath of Gregg led the Court to be aware: death is a different kind of punishment from any other and there should be fairness and consistency in determining the sentence. I agree. When determining a decision there should be consistency in making a decision. However, the Court must also take into account the facts and issues of the case. As stated in Lockett, every case for the individual is different.
In Lockett V. Ohio (1978), with a six to three vote, the Court held states may limit the mitigating factors juries consider in imposing the death sentence. Each case is different and there should be individual sentencing.
Chief Justice Burger gave the opinion of the Court and argued under the statue, a defendant is found guilty of aggravated murder after meeting one of seven specified aggravating circumstances: the death penalty must be imposed unless, considering the “nature and, circumstances of the offense and the history, character, and condition of the offender…” To determine their decision, they considered three statutory mitigating circumstances: 1. The victim of the offense induced or facilitated it; 2. By fact, it is unlikely that the offense would have been committed. The offender must be under strong pressure and persuasion; and 3. The offense was primarily the product of the offender’s mental incapacity, even though such condition does not establish the full defense of insanity. (O’Brien).
In Coker V. Georgia (1977), the Court held capital punishment is disproportionate for the crime of rape on an adult woman. I agree. Regardless of the legislator’s beliefs or values, dicta in Coker gave state legislators and constituent’s good reason to fear any law permitting the imposition of...

Find Another Essay On Argument Against Capital Punishment

Argument for Capital Punishment Essay

945 words - 4 pages Argument for Capital Punishment If it were up to me, every murderer in this country would be put behind bars on death row and have their life taken from them just as they took the life of another. The guidelines of " an eye for an eye" go back thousands of years. Many countries still hold true to these guidelines. Although America doesn't follow the same as these countries, I believe when it comes to murder, they should. Putting people

Speech: Against Capital Punishment

1774 words - 7 pages Speech: Against Capital Punishment MOTION: " We believe that capital punishment is not needed in a civilised community." Imagine yourself in a small, isolated cabin waiting to be led to your execution. A small, scrawny man comes to collect you. Your whole life rushes past you as you take your few, final footsteps to the execution chamber. This is the thought 7,000 people have experienced in the last 18

Speech Against Capital Punishment

2163 words - 9 pages Speech Against Capital Punishment Good Afternoon, I am honored to be here, and I thank you for having me. Today I would like to speak to you about a very controversial issue- capital punishment. What do those two words mean to you? To most people they mean a murder victims family receiving justice for their deceased. Let me see a show of hands. How many people in the audience believe in the death penalty? I conducted a weeklong

Against Capital Punishment

1900 words - 8 pages dangerous for the entire practice itself. Capital Punishment is a practice that exists in the most fragile circumstance of social policy; between anarchy and tyranny; lacking the support or reason but backed by the force of the gun; invulnerable against forceful rebellion but always fearing a single whisper that speaks the truth. The Death Penalty is a simple-minded solution to a complex problem. It seems people like to complain about problems

The Ethicality Against Capital Punishment

819 words - 4 pages have lost all humaneness. Dehumanization will be, for the sake of my argument, classified as depriving someone from his humanity, and by depriving them of humanness, which is essential to ethics; we fracture the foundation of morality and ethics because without humans there is no morality or ethicality. I will argue that Capital Punishment undermines ethical and moral foundations in particular Kant’s theories by dehumanizing the condemned

Persuasive Essay Against Capital Punishment

900 words - 4 pages Persuasive Essay Against Capital Punishment “Kill. (Verb) To make someone or something die.” Does anyone really think they have the right to take another person’s life? Apparently yes. Perhaps we should give the judge a knife and tell her that if she has decided that the accused is guilty, she should stab him herself. Perhaps then she would hesitate. But if many people (hundreds or thousands who operate the

Capital Punishment, Injustice of Society. Argument supporting it

1395 words - 6 pages the victim's family.'(Grisham 120) Realistically, imposing the death penalty is expensive and time consuming. Retroactively, it has yet to be proven as a deterrent. Morally, it is a continuation of the cycle of violence and '...degrades all who are involved in its enforcement, as well as its victim.'(Stewart 1)Perhaps the most frequent argument for capital punishment is that of deterrence. The prevailing thought is that imposition of the death

Evaluate Argument In "Watch It" - Article Concerning Capital Punishment

816 words - 3 pages Cecilia Evaluate Andrew Sullivan's argument in his article "Watch It" In the article, Watch It, Andrew Sullivan argues that a society that accepts capital punishment as part of its justice system should be prepared to watch the executions it condones. Sullivan's basic message is that if people are not prepared to witness murderers being put to death, then they should question the rationale for having executions in the

The Death Penalty (essay gives reasons for and against capital punishment).

728 words - 3 pages killed white victims; in the same amount of time, only 12 executions were to white defendants who killed black victims. This shows that there is racial biasing when it comes to sentencing people to death row. Before deciding which side to take on this very important issue, one must first become familiar with reasons for either viewpoint.To argue against capital punishment is to want to send prisoners into the streets. Justice should be based on

Capital Punishment: A View Against

1029 words - 4 pages Capital punishment is defined as the obligation of the death penalty by the state. In 1972, the United States Supreme Court voided all federal and state laws calling for the death penalty on grounds that it was a violation of the 8th amendment to the U.S. Constitution, but in 1976 this ruling would change. In 1976 the Supreme Court abolished the ruling from 1972, holding that "the punishment of death does not invariably violate the Constitution

This is a presuasive essay on Capital Punishment. This essay has a pro-capital punishment stance. Argues against common statements used to challenge the death penalty.

857 words - 3 pages and as a form of permanent incapacitation, the death penalty helps to prevent future crime.The argument against capital punishment relies on myth, propaganda, and misplaced emotion. Many people against the death sentence claim that the justice system is discriminatory. This statement is blatantly false. African-Americans and other minorities are not impacted unfairly by the justice system. The fact of the matter is the majority of those executed

Similar Essays

Argument Against Capital Punishment Essay

1384 words - 6 pages , death may be just a bit too good for them. Bibliography "A Good Friday Appeal to End the Death Penalty." United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. 01 Nov. 2013. Speech. Eddlem, Thomas. "Ten Anti-Death Penalty Fallacies." The New American.com. N.p., 03 June 2002. Web. 01 Nov. 2013 Mehas, Michael. "Seven Fallacies of Capital Punishment." iSnare.com Free Articles. N.p., n.d. Web. 01 Nov. 2013. "The Case Against the Death Penalty." American

A Non Pacifist Argument Against Capital Punishment

2756 words - 11 pages A Non-Pacifist Argument Against Capital Punishment ABSTRACT: In this paper I present a moral argument against capital punishment that does not depend upon the claim that all killing is immoral. The argument is directed primarily against non-philosophers in the Judeo-Christian tradition. Oddly, the moral argument against capital punishment has not been effective in the United States despite the biblical injunction against killing. Religious

Against Capital Punishment : A Researched Argument

1691 words - 7 pages In the United States there has been many hangings during the Salem Witch trials, and years there after. As years went by, capital punishment has become more "humane" and less horrid compared to the past. Although less crude, capital punishment is and never will be the right solution to the killing of another man. The morality of this form of castigation has been debated among society for many decades. Out of the many factors that play a role in

Argument For Capital Punishment Essay

1097 words - 4 pages capital punishment, but for this essay, the focus shall just be on those two crimes. A few may bring about the argument that capital punishment is just punishing murder with murder. On the contrary, capital punishment is not murder; it works more like a self-defense for everyone else. If capital punishment is wrong, is killing in self-defense to prevent harm to you wrong also? The basic idea behind capital punishment is in fact self-defense