Argument In The Apology Essay

874 words - 3 pages

The main argument in The Apology by famous ancient Greek philosopher Plato is whether, notorious speaker and philosopher Socrates is corrupting the youth by preaching ungodly theories and teaching them unlawful ideas that do harm to individuals and society. In his words Socrates quoted the prosecution’s accusation against him: “Socrates is guilty of corrupting the minds of the young, and of believing in supernatural things of his own invention instead of the gods recognized by the state.” 1 Further Socrates consistently introduces tediously compiled number of examples to provide valid and sound arguments to prove that he is innocent of the charges brought up against him to the court.
The first approach that Socrates uses to prove his innocence’s is he uses a practical comparison between horses and all living and artifical things “Take the case of horses; do you believe that those who improve them make up the whole of the mankind and that there is only one person who has a bad effect on them? Or is the truth just the opposite that the ability to improve them belongs to one person or to very few persons, who are horse-trainers, whereas most people, if they have to do with horses and make use of them, do them harm.” 2
The premises in this quote are:
1.     Horse trainers do improve horses.
2.     Those who use the horses do not enhance them.
3.     There are more horse owners than the horse trainers.
4.     Therefore, the improvements come from a small group of specialist, while the corruption comes from most people.
5.     What is true for horses is true for all living and artificial things.
The conclusion that can be made about these premises is that Socrates is not the one who is corrupting the youth because he is a specialist in this field. In addition, the real corruptors of the youth are the greater population of Athens because they are not specialist on teaching wisdom. What important about this conclusion is that even though Socrates uses horses as an example he manages to apply his example to all beings and prove his case that he is innocent of the charges.
The second example that Socrates makes is that people that don’t care about the youth are the ones who are really corrupting them. “It is quite clear that by now, gentlemen, that Meletus, as I said before, has never paid the slightest attention to this subjects. However I invite you to tell us, Meletus, in what sense you make out that I corrupt the minds of the young.” 3 The premises of this quote are:
1.     Meletus has no concern for the youth.
2.     Meletus who shows no concern for the youth cannot charge another person of corrupting the youth
3.     Since...

Find Another Essay On Argument in the Apology

Socrates Argument in the Crito Essay

1118 words - 4 pages Introduction Socrates argues in the Crito that he shouldn't escape his death sentence because it isn't just. Crito is distressed by Socrates reasoning and wishes to convince him to escape since Crito and friends can provide the ransom the warden demands. If not for himself, Socrates should escape for the sake of his friends, sons, and those who benefit from his teaching. Socrates and Crito's argument proceeds from this point. As an aside, I

The Function of the Quest or Journey Motif in the Apology and the Crito

1274 words - 6 pages The quest, in the classical era to the modern notions of the word has meant a coming of age or to notions of learning where at the beginning there was nothing known. The quest in its very nature is a search to find an answer, an artifact of power and wealth or perhaps even for peace; in the platonic dialogues they play a crucial role in the Apology of Socrates and the Crito. The Apology in the trial and death of Socrates is an example of a quest

The Argument of Sex Education in School

1269 words - 5 pages The Argument of Sex Education in School Missing Works Cited Audience Analysis: I am writing to the seven chairmen of the ___ County School Board. They are a made up of a group of five men and two women. They are most likely all parents who have a common concern on the material being taught on the issue of Sex Education in schools. Fellow parents vote on them to insure that they make the correct decisions on what their kids are

The Argument for Reincarnation in Hinduism

1697 words - 7 pages The concept of reincarnation is related to karma, karma deals with a system of rewards and punishment based on the actions of the individual (Oxtopy & Segal 266). Due to bad karma by the individual, it takes many lifetimes for the karma to be worked out; reincarnation also known as samsara in Hinduism is an ongoing cycle of death and rebirth. To be released from the cycle of samsara, to achieve moksha one must reach enlightenment (Oxtopy

Barthes' argument in The Death of the Author

2177 words - 9 pages The Function of Subject as Signified Barthes’ argument in The Death of the Author, as it is clarified by the structuralist approach of Ferdinand de Saussure and the manifestations of his linguistic system adapted by Jacques Lacan and Jacques Derrida, is composed of an ultimate dismissal of the signification of a text in favor of the ratification of the function of the subject. Once this function is ascertained, Barthes shifts his impetus

Examine the argument in A J Ayer's passage

1591 words - 6 pages A J Ayer- God talk is evidently nonsenseExamine the argument in the passage. (30)In A J Ayer's article 'God talk is evidently nonsense' he breaks down the religious argument that God's existence can be proved and how it is improbable to dispute his existence entirely.Ayer's argument leads to the conclusion that religious experiences being evidence for God's existence is logically unsound - "the argument from religious experience is altogether

David Hume's Argument Against Belief in the Existence of Miracles

2170 words - 9 pages David Hume was a British empiricist, meaning he believed all knowledge comes through the senses. He argued against the existence of innate ideas, stating that humans have knowledge only of things which they directly experience. These claims have a major impact on his argument against the existence of miracles, and in this essay I will explain and critically evaluate this argument. In his discussion 'Of Miracles' in Section X of An Enquiry

Response to Clarence Darrow's Argument in the Henry Sweet Case

2512 words - 10 pages Response to Clarence Darrow's Argument in the Henry Sweet Case In responding to Clarence Darrow's arguments in the Henry Sweet case and in the Leopold and Loeb case, there are some considerations that would have to be addressed in the same manner in both cases. The cases however, differ in many ways that would result in very different responses to the cases. An advocate opposing Darrow would face two factors described above. First

Censorship In Music Today-Both Sides of the Argument

974 words - 4 pages Censorship in MusicCensorship in music is a topic that has brought about much controversy inthe past two decades. There have been many different arguments on the topic, however the question still remains as if it should be censored or it should not be censored. Before one can form an opinion on this, one must hear both sides of the argument. Some believe that music should be censored so all audiences can hear it without it containing any

The argument of the bourgeoisie vs. the working class in Marx's "The Communist Manifesto"

1089 words - 4 pages government, to proletariat and bourgeois.Another argument and problem that Marx observes and discusses is the distinctive class differences. He mentions how 10% of the people have virtually all the property. This is still a problem in our world today. In the United States, 20% of the population has 85% of the total wealth. Private property stands for that particular type of property that has been extracted from another's labor, but comes to be controlled

Argument against Kenneth Pollack's position in "The Threatening Storm" for war in Iraq

1796 words - 7 pages Although Kenneth Pollack makes a strong argument for war with Iraq in The Threatening Storm, his position is entirely incorrect. The evidence against war is plentiful and very well expressed by many scholars, such as Richard Betts, Mark Strauss, Stephen Walt and John Mearsheimer. There are many major factors to keep in mind regarding the situation in Iraq. For instance, the United States must remember that international support is not only

Similar Essays

Socrates In The Apology Essay

1022 words - 4 pages the body. The first argument being that everything comes from its opposite, an example of this would be something hot would come from something cold and vice versa. Socrates used the example of life and death, by using this example it's implying that when we do die we don't stay dead we come back to life at a later time. His second argument in this dialogue was believed that everything we learned was recollected. By the questioning of any subject

Women In The Apology Of Socrates

1404 words - 6 pages Women in the Apology of Socrates The most striking thing about women in the Apology of Socrates is their absence from where we might expect them. Only two specific women are mentioned: 1) the Pythia, the priestess of Apollo, who answers Chaerephon's question that no one is wiser than Socrates (21a); and 2) Thetis, the mother of Achilles (who himself is not mentioned by name but only referred to as the "son of Thetis"), who warns him

Legitimacy In The Apology And Oedipus The King

1109 words - 4 pages rule of law (rational) (Weber 1990 [1918]; 1964). Whilst legitimacy is constantly evolving due to current perceptions of society; texts such as ‘Oedipus the King’ (Sophocles) and ‘The Apology’ (Plato) that date back to fifth century BCE explore the notion of traditional, charismatic, and rational legitimation in a comparative way. Legitimacy may rest on the belief of tradition, upheld by leaders who at the time portray authority. ‘Oedipus the King

A Critique Of Socrates' Guilt In The Apology

1133 words - 5 pages that needed to be disposed of for the elites to remain the power-holders in society.List of Works CitedPlato. 'The Apology of Socrates.' West, Thomas G. and West, Grace Starry, eds. Plato and Aristophanes: Four Texts on Socrates. Itacha, NY: Cornell University Press, 1984.1Plato, 'The Apology of Socrates,' Thomas G. West and Grace Starry West, eds., Plato and Aristophanes: Four Texts on Socrates. (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1984), s.19c, p.66.2Ibid, s.29a/32d, p.80/p.85.3Ibid, s.28b, p.79.4Ibid, s.25e, p.75.5Ibid, s.26a, p.75.