Argumentative Critique Of The Essay "A Case For Torture" By Michael Levin.

757 words - 3 pages

"The Case for Torture" by Michael Levin, presents excellent justification for the use of torture in situations of extreme desperation. Levin gives great arguments for the use of torture through clever wording and great exemplification. In supplement to the already great argument, he provides potential counter-arguments and proves why they are invalid. It is made very clear that he believes that torture is morally mandatory and makes great effort to sway the opinion of readers, provided they keep an open mind. Levin presents a great argument and presents the ideas in an organized fashion, but as with many essays, it is not without flaw and could use some minor changes to make this great essay into a incredible essay.The format of the introduction of Levin's essay is somewhat unusual. It begins with a few powerful statements, but the very first statement violates a rule of literature, inclusion of an unsupported fact. Levin says," It is generally assumed that torture is impermissible, a throwback to a more brutal age." Not only is the statement a generalization, he is saying that something is generally assumed, but he does not say whom it is assumed by. So who generally assumes it? It seems it is more of a mistake of wording because he is the one who is assuming that generally people think torture is wrong, therefore the essay should read that way because the last thing one should do is start off on the wrong foot.The essay truly lacks any real lead-in or background. The essay just jumps right into the real issues without introducing them or explaining why it was even written in the first place. The reason for the essay is not the real issue though. The issue is that it lacks background because it doesn't appear that Levin is actually arguing against another point of view. Last I knew, an argument required two points of view to start with, but as I read the introduction it doesn't seem he has an opponent to win favor over. Without question it is obvious that the paper is about torture, but the introduction does not introduce the main ideas as clearly as it should introduce them.Upon reading the body of the essay, it also comes off as unfinished. The...

Find Another Essay On Argumentative Critique of the Essay "A Case for Torture" by Michael Levin.

A Critique of "For Gay Marriage," by Andrew Sullivan

523 words - 2 pages , the fact is that he could overcome much of the ambiguity of his presentation by citing more concrete studies, including long-term studies, which support his key points. For example, when he makes the assertion that "in some ways the marriage issue is exactly parallel to the military" (283), it is unclear exactly what he means. Is he referring to prejudice against gay soldiers? On the other hand, is he referring to a common requirement of self

A Critical Analysis Of "the Parting" By Michael Drayton

801 words - 3 pages A Critical Analysis of "The Parting" by Michael Drayton By looking at a poem which has a specific form, for example the sonnet, consider to what extent its particular techniques enhance its meaning.      The parting by Michael Drayton is a sonnet. It is a poem about the break up of the relationship between the author and his partner. I feel that the meaning of the poem is greatly enhanced by its form, and

In the Skin of a Lion by Michael Ondaatje

1024 words - 4 pages “In the Skin of a Lion,” by Michael Ondaatje In the novel, “In the Skin of a Lion,” by Michael Ondaatje, the main character, Patrick Lewis, searches for identity and light. Without these elements, he lacks love and cannot survive the world. A passage in chapter three describes him as a lonely man that is isolated from the world around him. “Clara and Ambrose and Alice and Temelcoff and Cato- this cluster made up a drama without him. And he

The Search For Cleopatra by Michael Foss

1212 words - 5 pages Search For Cleopatra, Michael Foss tells the story of Cleopatra VII. He tells us about her remarkable legacy from hundreds of years before she was born all the way to her death, as well as, the historical circumstances surrounding her life. Foss begins the book with a historical explanation of the hard work and uncertainty that naturally comes with finding more about the past. In the following chapters he splits the book into four important and

The Morality of Torture

1710 words - 7 pages "accountability and transparency" which seems to be somewhat unclear to me. If torture were by law illegal, then wouldn’t the action of torment be executed outside the law? For instance, American soldiers may use the form of torture on Taliban enemies to get answers on their current or future plans of attacks on the United States of other enemy sought countries. These actions may not be seen as illegal as mentioned before in the being of the essay

Cons of Genetic Engineering: The Case Against Perfection by Michael J. Sandal

1865 words - 7 pages the “Case Against Perfection” by Michael J. Sandal the author includes multiple statements such as “manipulating our own nature” and “to make ourselves better” to argue what any type of person may do for self-improvement. With genetic engineering becoming more involved it is implausible to avoid, but as a race, humans have the ability to see what is right and what is wrong. For example, a competitor may find the need to increase physical aspects

Anna Karenina - The Complex Character of Constantine Dmitrich Levin

927 words - 4 pages Anna Karenina - The Complex Character of Constantine Dmitrich Levin   In the novel Anna Karenina, written by Leo Tolstoy, both major and minor characters played important roles through out the story. One protagonist, Constantine Dmitrich Levin, caught my interest as being a compassionate, moral character. Constantine Dmitrich Levin is a complex character whose direct and indirect characterization emphasizes a search for balance

The Ethics of Torture

1607 words - 6 pages for the fact that humans are autonomous beings and should therefore always be treated as ends, not means. Therefore in the case of torture, it would be unethical to do so for two reasons: you would not want it done to yourself and you would be robbed of your autonomy. In the example case of the ticking time bomb, would one torture simply because of the reason behind the action? ‘It is right to torture only when it save lives’ is a possible

The Morality of Torture

1348 words - 5 pages The Morality of Torture The moral issue of torture is one that has come under scrutiny by many national and international organizations as of late. To talk about torture one must really understand what torture is. As taken from Dictionary.com “1.a. Infliction or severe physical pain as a means of punishment or coercion. b. An instrument or a method for inflicting such pain. 2. Excruciating physical or mental pain; agony. 3. Something

The Ethics of Torture

1439 words - 6 pages The institution of torture has been in existence for quite sometime; however, it was not always seen as an ethical question. In antiquity, the Romans employed something known as “the cat-of-nine-tails,” which was a flogging instrument with nine sharp ends. However, the use of torture was not confined to the West, the Chinese utilized “bamboo sticks to beat people.” During antiquity, torture was used as a punishment, but

The Benefits of Torture

2220 words - 9 pages traumatic event is by the skilled technique of information extraction known as torture, would it not be the government’s obligation to the people to ensure this method of prevention was exercised? When considering the threat from extremists, the United States government must allow for the use of unorthodox interrogation methods, such as torture, when lives are on the line and time is of the essence. A widely popular argument against torture

Similar Essays

Michael Levin's The Case For Torture

1165 words - 5 pages of good intentions, just to say that it is conveyed in a manner so improper that it cannot be heard by its own merits. Works Cited Levin, Micheal. "Michael Levin: The Case for Torture." Michael Levin: The Case for Torture. N.p., n.d. Web. 19 Feb. 2014.

This Essay Is A Critique Of The Book The Adventures Of Huckelberry Finn By Mark Twain.

845 words - 3 pages of Tom Sawyer with its literary furnishings, its conscious romantic desire for experience and the hero's part, and its ingenious schematization of life to achieve that aim." Some people who dislike the entire book altogether mostly do so because they think that it is racist and immoral. This book is neither racist nor immoral as the entire time it is full of attempts by a white boy to help free a black slave. It does have some racist ideas

A Critique Of Michael Grants’ Book Titled Gladia

905 words - 4 pages A Critique of Michael Grants' book titled Gladiators In Michael Grant's book Gladiators, he details various groups of people from different backgrounds which exchange blows as gladiators. Grant's book reveals a glimpse into roman culture by describing who the gladiators were in roman society. The section in the book titled "Who are the gladiators?" describes the emergence of the varieties of gladiators. Grant shows that regardless of the

The Theme Of Jorneying In For A Journey By Alan Brownjohn And To The Virginian Voyage By Michael Drayton

1812 words - 7 pages The Theme of Jorneying in For A Journey by Alan Brownjohn and To The Virginian Voyage by Michael Drayton "The death of fear is in doing what you fear to do." 'Journey' is an encompassing word. The connotations of the word "journey" are:- trying to get from one place to another, going somewhere different to where you usually go, an adventure, a journey can be life itself. It is said that many people are afraid and