Argumentative Essay 1

920 words - 4 pages

Kant’s Formula of Universal Law is determined a priori and it an idea that for something to be moral it must pass a universal test. In Kant’s Groundwork for the Metaphysic of Morals he states to act as if the maxim of your action would become a universal law of nature. This means that an act can be considered the right thing to do if it can be applied to everyone else and it would be right for everyone else to act that way.
When looking at Dr. Tom’s actions as when considering Kant’s Formula of Universal Law, Tom’s actions do not pass the test. In the case Mary does not want her organs to be donated because she believes that she has a chance of survival. Tom knows that Mary is soon going to die so he takes Mary’s organs against her wishes and in turn saves the lives of three other patients. When testing this case with Kant’s Formula of Universal Law the maxim would be that Mary wants to live so she wants to keep her own organs. Tom knows that she will die soon and her organs can save three other people so he takes them. Putting this maxim to the test would be saying that if anyone was going to die soon, anybody could take any organs that they if those organs were to save a life even if it I against that donor’s wishes. The results from this test would conclude that Tom’s actions would not be coherent with Kant’s Formula of Universal Law.
If every doctor took organs from patients who were soon going to die in order to save others’ lives even though it was against that donor’s will, people would eventually stop going to the doctor. Also if Tom’s actions were to be universalized the idea of a person agreeing or disagreeing with being a donor would be trumped by another’s will to take whichever organs they please in order to save a life. This would be breaking the respects towards other people’s own personal rights and wishes to live.
Mill’s Greatest Happiness Principle works a bit better with regards to Tom’s actions. The main idea of Mill’s Greatest Happiness Principle is to maximize happiness. The Greatest Happiness Principle categorizes actions as a right actions if the actions promote happiness and not pain. It is the duty for everyone to seek happiness for others and to seek happiness for themselves. Mill also adds the ideal of quantity to this principle. The more happiness an individual’s act can spread through society the better. So ultimately the greater number of people who are happy as a result from a particular...

Find Another Essay On Argumentative Essay 1

reflective essay

809 words - 4 pages to my last essay, “Differences” towards the end of the semester. Throughout the entire semester I have acquired some new writing, reading, and analytical skills. Some of the important writing skills I learned are coming up with an arguable thesis. Before I did not really have argumentative thesis in my writing, which made my papers never really, have a purpose; why am I writing this? Another writing skill I learned is how to detect and fix

My Writing 121 Experience Essay

1038 words - 5 pages before was use citations, so incorporating them into my paper was a major challenge. Up until now the closest I had been to a research argumentative paper would’ve been either a persuasive essay which doesn’t compare to such a complex novel. Heart of Darkness changed this and in writing my paper I had to think critically about what Joseph Conrad meant and decide how to explain the quote after inserting it. At first I didn’t know how to do it but

Write an analysis of specific scenes in a film or films (at least one scene, no more than three) applying the concepts and terms of one chapter from Understanding Film Theory

629 words - 3 pages Essay #3: Film Analysis and Argumentative Writing12/2 Draft Due 12/8 Final Essay DueAssignment: Write an analysis of specific scenes in a film or films (at least one scene, no more than three) applying the concepts and terms of one chapter from Understanding Film Theory. The chosen scene(s) must be viewable by the professor via the internet or DVD you provide. You can relate the scene you choose to the rest of the film, but the analysis must

Importance of Science about Carl Sagan "Science and Hope"

871 words - 3 pages environment is strong and effective. [Div Thesis 1] One of the ways I can evaluate this argumentative essay is through an emotional appeal. [Div Thesis 2] The second mode that I will apply is a logical appeal, which relies on formulating claims and using supporting evidence. [Div Thesis 3] I will be evaluating Sagan's essay in terms of its ethical appeal by determining if the author is credible or not.[TS] Carl Sagan explains his feelings effectively

Reflective paper

925 words - 4 pages In the beginning of this semester, I signed up for English composition 1 with the expectation that I was going to ace it, because I had done well in my AP literature class which I took 4 months before the semester. I was always taught to have a great idea and to build upon, but the very basics of writing an essay-its unity, coherence and fluidity were thrown out of the window-was never thought. After receiving a strong scrutiny on my sentence

TV and It’s Effects on Society

998 words - 4 pages written argumentative essay there must be a clear thesis, good supporting examples, some objections along with any rebuttals, the writing should be focused with a natural flow. Firstly, the thesis of Greenfield’s essay is somewhat broad and it is not explicitly stated so the reader can understand the topic. He states in his thesis that TV has been blamed for the decline of scores on scholastic achievement tests, for the rise in crime, for the decline

Stuart Greene

746 words - 3 pages The essay by Stuart Greene certainly drives home the quote that “there is nothing new under the sun”. In fact, in trying to discover who to give credit for this particular quote Shakespeare, Bierce, and Ecclesiastes 1:4-11 was cited for saying it. The point here is that research is crucial to writing arguments on any topic. Without research, a person will possibly be reiterating what has already been said, which does not propel an argument

The Importance of Rhetoric and Discussion of Freedom of Speech

1710 words - 7 pages means of persuasion often in his essay, but when attempting to place pathos, ethos, and logos in his argumentative essay he fails when using fallacious reasoning. Rauch uses these three persuasive tactics in his essay as well, but does not follow them with added fallacies. In paragraph 12 of Lawrence’s essay he uses the mode of persuasion known as pathos, which is designed to appeal to the emotion and frame of mind of the reader. However, within

T.S. Eliot, Langston Hughes and Modern Poetry

1031 words - 5 pages virtues; he wishes to break away from the Euro-centric tradition and in hopes of creating a new blueprint for the African-American-Negro. To analyze Hughes’s poem thoroughly, by using Eliot’s argumentative essay, we must first identify the poem’s speaker and what is symbolic about the speaker? The title (“The Negro Speaks Of Rivers”) of the poem would hint off the speaker’s racial identity, as the word Negro represents the African-American race


1548 words - 6 pages Unit Two: Argumentative Task Scaffolding ActivitiesArgumentative essay topic: Would you have joined the Loyalist or Patriots during the Revolutionary War?Task 1:Throughout our unit of study students will have analyzed numerous source documents relating to the events leading up to and that took place during the revolutionary war. Students will use source documents to compare and contrast the positive and negative aspects that could be a result of


2963 words - 12 pages ; therefore, the inconvenience of cigarette butt littering should reinforce this policy to stay in effect.... [tags: smoking, argumentative, persuasive] 612 words (1.7 pages) $6.95 [preview] Dangers of Smoking - For a country in our financial position the general health of Scotland is very poor. In some areas the average life expectancy is as low as 54 years old for men. A major cause of this is smoking. With the young in particular smoking is much more

Similar Essays

"Public Enemy #1: Video Games And The Media" An Argumentative Essay About The Effects Of Media And Video Games On Today's Violent American Youth

902 words - 4 pages I turned on the TV the other day to the voice of a familiar "friend". The voice belonged to Dan Patrick, a regular anchor on ESPN's "Sportscenter". He was reporting the story of a Chicago man and his teenage son, who attacked Kansas City Royals first base coach Tim Gamboa on the field during a Cubs game earlier in the year. The two face criminal charges in the case for stabbing and fiercely beating the defenseless 63 year-old Gamboa. It's this

Self Evaluation Essay

1147 words - 5 pages defend my arguments. I thought I had to induce my audience to agree with me and that if I mentioned any alternatives, I would lose them. However, the purpose of an argumentative essay is not to make others agree with a point of view, but to convince them to acknowledge the validity of an argument and to consider it. Luckily, I realized this in time to write my argumentative essay about the value of public opinions, in which I pointed out that

Wr 121 Final Self Assessment Essay

857 words - 4 pages issue within the introductory. The introduction serves as foreshadowing of what my essay will be about and finally what I will be arguing. I introduced my enthymeme at the end of my introduction paragraph on all of my essays. In my first essay I address my question at issue by stating, “The photographer captures moments in time with hopes of these images having a positive influence on society” (Essay 1, 1) this raises a question at issue. Do

Ferdinand Marcos: Conflict And Compromise Caterson Research Paper

607 words - 3 pages Argumentative Essay Prep Performance Assessment Step 1: Analyze the Model (30 points total) · “T”-chart (20 points)- list multiple pieces of evidence and citations for each article on both sides of the argument (one example is listed, list more) · Discuss and Decide Question page 7- answer why or why not (5 points) · Terminology of Argumentative Tasks- column three on page 8- examples (5 points) Article Title Lots of Friends Few Close INFO