Argumentative Paper: Legalizing Euthanasia

1736 words - 7 pages - dracopogo ✓ Expert Reviewed

Most people do not like to talk or even think about death; much less the topic of ending one’s own life. However, for some, death is a desired alternative to living in agony. Euthanasia has been a topic of debate since antiquity, and both sides stand firm on their beliefs. The right to choose death is illegal in most countries. I believe in people’s freedom to do what they please with their own bodies. The basic right of liberty is what America was founded on. Euthanasia should be a legal option.
It’s important to start by understanding the different types of euthanasia. Allowing someone to die is, “Forgoing or withdrawing medical treatment that offers no hope of benefit to the total well-being of the patient, or that imposes burdens disproportionate to the potential benefits, allows the patient to die” (Manning 2). Traditionally called passive euthanasia, allowing someone to die was redefined by and is acceptable in the Catholic Church. Active euthanasia, also known as physician-assisted suicide, is when someone other than the patient ends the life of the patient upon explicit request. I view active and passive euthanasia to be one in the same with one very real difference; allowing someone to die delays the inevitable and the patient is left to twist and turn for awhile longer. Peter Chesterfield comments, “A terminally ill, mentally competent patient like me should not be forced to suffer. This is as morally unacceptable as murder” (qtd. In Friedman 8). On the other hand, “The phrase ‘mercy killing’ refers to someone’s taking a direct action to terminate a patient’s life without the patient’s permission” (Thiroux and Krasemann 184). Mercy killing is the form of euthanasia that must be properly monitored and consist of strict guidelines if ever to be made legal. If appropriate advance directives were taken, mercy killing would never occur. By knowing what one would want under the given situation, the act would be active euthanasia.
There are several reasons for the opposition of euthanasia. The first I would like to discuss is Natural Law. The argument is that killing ourselves goes against our very nature. I also think being in excruciating pain for the remainder of a short life is not very natural. What is natural is the want, rather the need to end such pain. If there is no hope of extending life without constant suffering, continuing on in such a manner is nothing but self-inflicting punishment. Natural Law has granted us free will, which brings me to the next point.
“Autonomy is the right of a person to control his or her own body and life decisions” (Manning 26). This is absolutely correct. Governments, groups, and various people can argue against autonomy forever. The simple fact is we have control over ourselves, whether people like it or not. It gives us an added responsibility to thoroughly think about what it is we do with our bodies. These are decisions for the individual. Many of us go through life trying to...

Similar Essays

Euthanasia a Controversial and of Risky Practice

1728 words - 7 pages to keep their patients alive as said by the Hippocratic Oath ("Euthanasia"). The Encyclopedia of American Law also puts euthanasia into a class of criminal homicide ("debate.org"). Some people believe that legalizing euthanasia will target poor and disabled people and create encouragement for insurance companies. These insurance companies could have the power to terminate lives in order to save their money ("Euthanasia"). Others say that the...

Forcefully Ending Ones Life Essay

1022 words - 4 pages to spend some time with the family. Legalizing euthanasia would not be effective. They are the several reasons why legalized euthanasia would not be effective. Choosing to die is not a simple decision to make. Life not a decision to finish by a piece of paper to sign, one shot, or hand move to switch off the life control machine. Of course, it is really hard to fight back the pains and endure it. However, people still want to live as long as...

Euthanasia, The Legal Aspect. Essay

1202 words - 5 pages involved in just about everything in this country, a law should be passed, legalizing euthanasia, while setting specific parameters to follow during the act of euthanasia. Acceptable parameters that this debate team proposes can be found in the paper written by Mary Carter under the section entitled, "Parameters for Euthanasia."Legalizing euthanasia will regularize practices that are going on secretly. Many doctors have done it, but none...

Euthanasia: An End to Misery Essay

1462 words - 6 pages people in order to get rid of groups that he viewed as inferior to others; however, the argument based off of this evidence stating that legalizing euthanasia will lead to eugenics is a slippery slope fallacy. The situation involving the Nazis was an extreme condition that would not resurface just because people are legally allowed to choose to end their own lives if they are suffering. In the same way that eugenics is very unlikely to reappear as a...