Arguments For Slavery Essay

841 words - 3 pages

Just as ardently as abolitionists fought the institution of slavery, many citizens of the United States argued the advantages of owning human beings and keeping them in servitude as a piece of property. Slavery was not America’s finest hour, but the anti-abolitionists saw nothing wrong with the practice, arguing three key beliefs why slavery should be sanctioned: economic, religious and legal.
The American South became increasingly dependent on the lucrative cotton industry. The wealth and status associated with cotton prompted the expansion of plantations westward (Tindall & Shi, 2010, p.438, para. 2). Large plantations needed a huge labor force to harvest crops, and African slaves were cheaper and more readily available than indentured laborers from Europe. “They could more easily be bought from traders on the West African coast and were more immune to European diseases than indigenous Americans or imported white slaves” (Nash, A., n.d.). To free the slaves, proponents of slavery argued, would have a profound economic impact on the South, where reliance on slave labor was imperative to their success and survival. In addition, releasing four million slaves in to the general population would create competition for jobs and resources.
The religious argument defending slavery referred to biblical passages and claims that slavery was sanctioned by the Bible. Clergymen of all denominations joined in the dispute. “Had not the patriarchs of the Hebrew Bible held bondsmen? Had not Saint Paul advised servants to obey their masters and told a fugitive servant to return to his master? And had not Jesus remained silent on the subject, at least insofar as the Gospels reported his words?” (Tindall & Shi, 2010, p.436, para.4). Slaveholders viewed themselves as charitable and righteous, giving food, shelter and comfortable surroundings to those they viewed as property, not people, and they felt they were giving slaves something much more than they had or could ever attain on their own. John C. Calhoun, a prominent U.S. politician, told the Senate that slavery was not evil, but was “good – a great good” (Tindall & Shi, 2010, p. 436, para. 3) and spoke of the greatness of bringing Christianity to the heathens from across the ocean. This argument was particularly effective because it exploited the basic principles of the one area the majority of people believed in – Christianity and the Bible.
Supporters of slavery also rationalized the legality of slavery, pointing to the United...

Find Another Essay On Arguments for Slavery

Slavery and Sectional Attitudes, 1820-1860: What arguments did each side marshal in support of its case?

785 words - 3 pages slaves served as a surrogate mother for the offspring of the planter class.As it can be seen both the north and the south had good arguments. The north said that slavery was wrong and evil. The south said that it was necessary for the country's economy. However in the end history reveals that it was wrong and immoral. The nation is even forced to divide over this issue and fight one of the bloodiest wars which was called the Civil War.

Abolishment of Slavery in the West Indies

1175 words - 5 pages skills, and also how to work under authority. Although slaves were owned by their master, they were being cared for. They received shelter, food, and clothing, making their environment a better living environment. This also proves that slaves did not only have disadvantages during the slavery. According to the article “Arguments and Justifications” on the site called The Abolition Project , Michael Renwick Sergant claimed: “We ought to consider

Abolition of Slavery in the United States

1270 words - 6 pages In the United States, slavery was abolished very gradually and in most cases one state at a time. The issue of slavery has been debated for America since the very beginning of the founding of the country. At the time America became an independent country of British control, some wanted to end slavery and others who owned large plantations wanted to continue because they were making a large profit. The end of slavery started by the abolishment

Banneker Essay

624 words - 3 pages . However, his maturity and high respect towards Jefferson gave him a sense of authority. The frequent use of the word “sir” clearly revealed that Banneker could maintain his composure on the topic of slavery. Generally, arguments tend to raise to a level of high anger or resentment. However, Banneker in no way resorted to hostility to get his argument about slavery across. For this, Banneker showed his own self dignity. His repetition helped his

Antebellum Period in the South

743 words - 3 pages , they simply claimed that slavery was a political evil not a crime, and thus should not need to end. Slavery was a profitable business and it was around for a long time so southerners did not want to do away with it. Latter on during the antebellum period the bible was used to justify slavery, saying that God approved of the institution of slavery. They even used science in an attempt to justify slavery; it was said that African slaves were not


1746 words - 7 pages that "mechanical labor has most of the economic properties of slave labor, though... it does not involve the direct demoralizing effects of human cruelty."[12]ApologiesMonument to slaves in ZanzibarOn May 21, 2001, the National Assembly of France passed the Taubira law, recognizing slavery as a crime against humanity. Apologies on behalf of African nations, for their role in trading their countrymen into slavery, remain an open issue since

Comparing Historical Essays About Slavery: comparing writings of John C. Calhoun, George Fitzhugh, Frederick Douglass, and William Craft

1256 words - 5 pages superiority over blacks. Craft made a lot of strong arguments against slavery, while still leaving out a lot of the cruelties that took place during his enslavement. He made a clear, logical argument against the pro-slavery propaganda.The well-known pro-slavery advocates, John C. Calhoun and George Fitzhugh, make important arguments for the institution of slavery. Fredrick Douglass and William Craft, who both have first-hand experience of

An Analysis of the Constitutional Support of Slavery

1622 words - 7 pages The peculiar institution of slavery dominated the southern economy of the United States and was a great source of political strife leading up to and ultimately causing the American Civil War. As anti-slavery sentiments rose, abolitionists denounced the Constitution for its role in the preservation of this evil. Such arguments as those from William Lloyd Garrison source slavery’s existence to the ambiguity of the text and the framework it

How Douglass Dispelled the Illusions of Slavery

1110 words - 5 pages allowed into the “chaos of free competition” because of their limited “capacity” for hard work and logic (The Universal Law of Slavery, Fitzhugh, P2). Douglass again refuted the arguments of pro-slavery supporters, as he explained how the whites in Gardner’s shipyard feared that the freed blacks would soon “take the trade into their own hands,” providing better work and rendering the white workers themselves useless (103). According to Douglass

This essays explains what caused the civil war

543 words - 2 pages validate the idea that all men were created equal. At the Constitutional Convention there were arguments over slavery. Representatives of the northern states claimed that if the southern slaves were mere property, then they should not be counted toward voting representation in Congress. A compromise settled an argument over whether slaves would be counted as part of a state's population (if they were counted, southern representation would

Slavery In The Colonies

1156 words - 5 pages The war against slavery in the United States brought about many conflicting moral arguments between peoples of different locations in the country. Northern opinion believed that slavery was in fact wrong, but unity between the North and South was a much deeper concern. The South stood strong in favor of slavery. Until slavery was abolished in 1865, the most important political actions in the United States were based on the topic of slavery.In

Similar Essays

Analysis Of Arguments For The Slavery Institution

495 words - 2 pages Analysis of Arguments for the Slavery Institution The foundation of this paper will highlight the following questions: How might southern apologists for slavery have used the northern “wage slave” discussed in the last chapter to justify slavery? To what extent do you agree with this argument? How did slaves use religious belief and kinship to temper their plight? Did this strategy play into the hands of slaveholders? How were non

Pro Slavery Arguments Essay

668 words - 3 pages freedom. This was another constitutional advantage that came from a Supreme Court interpretation of the constitution. The south presented a formidable argument to preserve slavery with these legal arguments; however there were also the economic and religious aspects to take into consideration as well.There were many economical aspects to the question over slavery. The south presented the necessity of slave labor for prosperity as one example

How Supporters Of Slavery Used Legal, Religious, And Economic Arguments To Defend The Institution

1657 words - 7 pages concluded that emancipation would cause a race war and were therefore against any sort of abolition of slavery . This is why the supporters of slavery used legal, religious, and economic-2-arguments to defend the institution, they were simply accustomed to the lifestyle slavery provided for them and they weren't going to let it go without a fight.The supporters of slavery knew how to defend the institution well, especially when it came to legal rights

Arguments About Slavery Essay

715 words - 3 pages different, for better or worse, if there had not been slavery. Ideals would not based on race or color of skin. We could truly call freedom part of being human. Works Cited Baym, Nina, ed. “Harriet Jacobs” Norton Anthology of American Literature, Volume B 7th ed. New York: W.W. Norton and Co. 2007 (2:1808-1829). Print. Jacobs, Harriet. Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl. Norton Anthology of American Literature, Volume B 7th ed. New York: W.W. Norton and Co. 2007 (2:1808-1829). Print.