Arguments Over The Most Desirable Form Of Justice

2384 words - 10 pages

Mahatma Karamchand Gandhi, the pre-eminent political and ideological leader of the Indian independence movement, is famously asserted “an eye for an eye makes the world blind” speaking of the need for a fundamental paradigm shift in relation to the global view of justice. The global concept of justice has a vast theoretical base which was founded upon the thoughts of John Rawls, the state of nature, and the Divine Providence (also deemed the Golden Rule). However, in recent years two opposing, philosophically based groups have rallied their proverbial troops and taken part in verbal wars over the most desirable form of justice. These groups are specifically those that subscribe to the tenants of retributive justice, and restorative justice. This argument is far reaching, and is a basic conversation focused on what is and is not ethical in relation to the treatment of offenses and the offender. Before an emphatic and clarion call for action can be sounded it is imperative that the tenants of these two opposing factions be examined. Second, the explicit examine the argument it is important to employ a rhetorical analysis in order to display how the factions are getting their points across. Finally, examination must occur to justly identify which of these ideological bases is the best alternative for current societal needs.
Dorne and Gewerth, Professor of Criminal Justice at Saginaw Valley State University, assert in their 1999 research entitled “Mercy in a Climate of Retributive Justice: Interpretations from a National Survey of Executive Clemency Procedures” assert that “retributive justice is a theory of justice that considers that punishment, if proportionate, is a morally acceptable response to crime, with an eye to satisfaction and psychological benefits it can bestow to the aggrieved party, its intimates and society” (p. 130). In more practical application retribution is the basis of the system, and its roots are founded in the both the Messianic tradition and archaic Arabic ideology. The book of Exodus 21:23-21 and verse 27 assert the basis of the Hammurabi Code of “life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, and foot for foot”. The process of punishment becomes semiotic to the mitigating offense. This idea has received added emphasis because the early Framer s of American government were largely classical English thinkers and embrace the thought of philosophers like Thoreau, Locke, Hobbs, and Immanuel Kant. Kant asserts in “The Metaphysical Elements of Justice” that retribution is the basis of justice and that it is the fundamental legal principle, and because of the Framer interpretation of such statement retributive justice became the basis of securing societal norm violators (1965). Furthermore, Kant believes that “judicial punishment can never be used merely as a means to promote some other good for the criminal himself or for civil society, but instead it must in all cases be imposed on him only on the...

Find Another Essay On Arguments Over the Most Desirable Form of Justice

Discuss the tension and arguments over the justification of the Iraq war

2694 words - 11 pages claiming that a war is unjustified and that America and Britain are just taking out past frustrations (September 11th being given as a reason) these two very public figures taking their arguments to the media has just made Tony Blair and George W. Bush do the same, only this time pinning the blame firmly on Iraq. Not a news bulletin passes without one of these figures making a derogatory comment about each other or trying to justify their reasoning

Film as the Most Important Art Form of the Twentieth Century

1903 words - 8 pages Film as the Most Important Art Form of the Twentieth Century The use of film and its explorations have progressed steadily since the 1800’s and as our title suggests, it has become an important art form and a huge influence on society today. Influencing the way we live, the way we speak, the way we act and more. There isn’t an art form closer to representing ‘reality’; this is why film has such an affect on all of us

John Marshall: The Most Influential Chief Justice of the Supreme Court

682 words - 3 pages John Marshall: The Most Influential Chief Justice of the Supreme Court In the beginning years of the United States Constitution, the Supreme Court was a struggling institution due to the lack of effectiveness of the Chief Justices and was not highly regarded by the executive and legislative branches of the government. The third Chief Justice in only twelve years, John Marshall put an end to the Supreme Court’s lack of influence after his

Marriage As A Form Of Justice In Measure For Measure

1505 words - 6 pages it may not be conventional according to Shakespeare's standards, it does make sense. However, the marriage of the Duke and Isabella does not appear to satisfy any form of justice and is thus inconsistent with the others. Is this another problem in a problem comedy? Perhaps we should take a closer look at these relationships.Claudio and Julietta, who are clearly the couple whose relationship most closely resembles that of a romance, appear to have

Arguments of the death penalty

567 words - 2 pages Is death the justification of a murder or are we merely subduing ourselves by performing the same heinous act? This argument had been debated for many decades and although some feel that death is the answer to a murder, there are others that find it completely barbaric. Through a careful analysis between Edward Koch's "Death and Justice" and David Bruck's "The Death Penalty", I believe Koch had the better argument in claiming that death is the

Rapid urbanization is the direct and desirable result of rapid economic development

1427 words - 6 pages Rapid urbanization is the direct and desirable result of rapid economic development. According to the Cambridge dictionaries online, urbanization is referring to "the process by which more and more people leave the countryside to live in cities" (2006, Internet). Historically, growth in economic activities has conceived many mega cities as well as social problems due to the migration of a rural work force in search of a better livelihood. The

Present the Advantages and Disadvantages of Globalisation, Is Free Trade Desirable?

3082 words - 12 pages Present the Advantages and Disadvantages of Globalisation, Is Free Trade Desirable?IntroductionThe first part of this essay will be aimed towards understanding the concept of globalisation. We will analyse the various advantages and disadvantages that arise as a result of globalisation. The second part of the essay will concentrate on investigating the benefits and drawbacks that arise from the free trade.In order to devise an accurate and

With reference to at least four poems by Thomas Hardy, what do you think are the most notable features of Hardy's use of language and metrical form?

602 words - 2 pages With reference to at least four poems by Thomas Hardy, what do you think are the most notable features of Hardy's use of language and metrical form?With a poet as prolific as Thomas Hardy, ample material is provided for academics to both praise and criticise. F.R. Leavis famously described Hardy as 'making a style out of stylelessness' (quoted from Haslam & Turton, language section). His poetry is certainly striking to the reader for its

The Arguments of the Gettysburg Address

956 words - 4 pages The Gettysburg Address is one of the most famous speeches in American history. The History Place indicates that on November 19, 1863 President Abraham Lincoln went to a battle field positioned in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania where three dreadful days of battle occurred called the Battle of Gettysburg. While he was attending the battle field to dedicate it as a national cemetery, he read his speech to the public. After the main orator, Edward Everett

Aquinas' Arguments for the Existence of God

1952 words - 8 pages Aquinas' Arguments for the Existence of God In Summa Theologica, Question 2, Article 3, Aquinas attempts to prove the existence of God. He begins with two objections, which will not be addressed here, and continues on to state five arguments for the existence of God. I intend to show that Aquinas' first three arguments are unsound from a scientific standpoint, through support of the Big Bang theory of the creation of

Outline the arguments in favour of abortion

545 words - 2 pages -abortionists would argue, it's a woman's right. She can do with her body as she wants. And since a foetus is not yet human, according to most supporters of abortion, its removal is simply taking out of a woman's body a part she no longer wants."Some argue that the mother has the right to dispose of her body as she wills, and the foetus is regarded as being merely a "tenant" or even an "aggressor" in her body. The woman is entitled to expel the foetus in

Similar Essays

The Most Effective Form Of Media

2376 words - 10 pages The Most Effective Form of Media There are many different types of media. The media is things like: televisions, newspapers, magazines, radio, internet, cinema, phones and many more. Media is important because it influences people to buy products. They are very affective and appeal to many people. Adverts are things that show certain products and try to get you to buy them. The purpose of adverts is to make you buy

The Most Effective Form Of Treatment For People With Ocd

1218 words - 5 pages . Thankfully, OCD is a treatable disease and with the help of cognitive behavioral therapy, most sufferers can learn to manage their symptoms and improve their lives. People who suffer from OCD give their random thoughts more credibility and imagine that the things that they fear will come true. OCD sufferers often realize that their thoughts are not logical but they are engulfed by them. McGrath (2007). People with OCD suffer from

The Importance Of Function Over Form In The Classical Concerto

1558 words - 6 pages with other genres of the Classical Period that use sonata form. Sonata form, according to the Oxford Companion to Music, is the most important musical form of the Classical period. The form is composed of three distinct sections, the exposition, development and recapitulation. In genres such as the symphony or string quartet, sonata form did not stray from this general template. The Classical concerto, however, especially the concertos of

The Mary Celeste Mystery Arguments On One Of The Most Plausible Theories.

805 words - 3 pages The Mary Celeste was a brigantine built in 1860 which was found discarded in a pristine condition in 1872 on a voyage from New York to Genoa by the crew of “Dei Gratia”. Hence, many theories came up and some could sound a bit ridiculous. There are the “Huge Octopus theory”, “Captain-killing-everyone theory” and “Cheating-insurance theory” etc. Out of them all, the most sensible inference that appeared to