Aristocracy Of Manufacturers Essay

1032 words - 5 pages

According to the Aristocracy of Manufacturers, which from Democracy in America, Tocqueville mainly discussed about how scientific manufactures bring people to the aristocracy. He separately discussed about potential harms of division of labor, and the differences between the new aristocracy and the old one. In his mind, division of labor expends the rank between the workers and masters, because work men only pay attrition on the specific work processes, which limit their views and thinking abilities, but masters consider extensive production view more than workers, which makes masters control more social capital. This phenomenon tends to the new aristocracy. In addition, he argued that this new aristocracy is different between the old one, because the relationship between the masters and workers are built by the benefits, which means masters only pay workers for producing goods, and masters have no responsibility to workers out of the working hours. In the old aristocracy, workers belong to the masters. Masters have responsibility to workers’ lives.
In order to show the potential harms of division of labor, Tocqueville presented an example about making pin head. He believed that a worker, who make pin heads over twenty years, wouldn’t do more but making pin heads. The reason is, In the process of division of labor, the pin heads maker only consider about doing his job, the job limits his ideas and views. In this situation, the worker is not belonging to himself but belonging to the job.
Tocqueville argues that this production mode leads to workers lose the general faculty of applying their minds to the direction of the work. He supports his argument as the example of workers who spent twenty years in making heads for pins. He says that workers only focus on how to make pin heads effectively. It tends to become a daily toil for workers. In this case, Tocqueville says, workers are no longer belonging to themselves, but to the work that they have chosen. The workers become more weak, narrow-minded, and dependent.
In addition, under the division of labor, the high quality products are made more than before, which attracted more rich people coming to engage. Then, more poor people were hired to be workers as well. As times goes by, masters became richer, because they focus on big view to earn more capitals, like hiring intelligent managers, using effective producing modes and opening more factories. Conversely, because workers’ views were limited by the single and repetitive job, they became weak and shortsighted. The gap between rich and poor were becoming obviously, and this is the reason that the new aristocracy was built.
In discussion of the differences between the new aristocracy and the old one, Tocqueville focused on the relationship between masters and workers. Because of the division of labor, the high effective production helps masters being richer, and the workers being weaker. The group of masters, who control more capitals, is the...

Find Another Essay On Aristocracy of Manufacturers

Industrialization Essay

1364 words - 5 pages disciplines, and more workers. These changes set the standard for more demands by consumers and manufacturers. Industrialization gave people more control over life and raised their overall standard of living. However, it caused environmental and social problems, such as crime and child labor, no society was prepared to handle. (Western Heritage, 565) In the eighteenth century, the factory system transformed the manufacture of British

Tocqueville - "Democracy In America" Essay

1036 words - 4 pages government do we have in America? Tocqueville says that we merely have an equality of material and circumstance. We all have the opportunity to do whatever we went, under the guidance of the majority of course, and the opportunity for material. We do not have liberty in its strictest sense, in either of these cases, because we are at the mercy of the majority. This is especially clear in his section titled: "Aristocracy of Manufacturers." Democracy is

The Creating of a Utopia

988 words - 4 pages listened carefully to their religious leaders. “Each feudal peasant knew exactly what proportion of his labor had to be handed over to the aristocracy” (Felluga, "Introduction to Karl Marx, Module on Stages of Development.") Not much time was spent on secular activities save for the one necessary for survival. If it sounds like a boring life, that’s because it was. A caste system fully developed at this stage and separates into different classes

Jonathan Swift - Political Activist

2140 words - 9 pages his writing. Swift wrote Proposal for the Universal Use of Irish Manufacturers, The Drapier’s Letters to protest the treatment of his countrymen at the hands of the British monarchy. Swift told of the suffering of his countrymen in A Modest Proposal bringing to the forefront the atrocities he witnessed. With his words Swift was attempting to persuade the aristocracy to apply pressure on the monarchy to end the harsh treatment of Ireland’s

The Gilded Age

4012 words - 16 pages from manufacturers. And both stood committed to the underlying system of private property in the means of production owned and controlled by individuals and small firms who bought and sold commodities (including the time and skills of human labor) and competed with one another for sales and, ultimately, profits….the definition of virtue as hard work and self-denial”(Dawley40). In order to attain optimal circumstances for increased capitalism

The Wealth of Nations: A Revolutionary Work on Economics

1344 words - 5 pages of power. It could be said that the proletariat and bourgeoisie overthrowing the aristocracy backfired on the proletariat due to the power it gives the bourgeoisie in the future. They did this to achieve equality, which is according to Robespierre, “the essence of the republic or of democracy.” In addition to the change in the bourgeoisie’s status, Smith probably did not anticipate the extreme competition between the bourgeoisie and the

Heinrich Himmler bio.

1959 words - 8 pages Regiment at the end of World War I, later obtaining a diploma in agriculture from Munich Technical High School where he studied from 1918 to 1922.After working briefly as a salesman for a firm of fertilizer manufacturers, the young Himmler joined a para-military, nationalist organization and participated in the Munich Beer-Hall putsch of November 1923 as standard-bearer at the side of Ernst Rohm, Secretary to Gregor Strasser and his deputy district


1725 words - 7 pages : transcendentalist, Self RelianceChapter SixteenSlave system/planter aristocracy: Cotton gin led to more slaves, aristocracyAbolitionism: movement to end slaveryFrederick Douglass: Abolitionist/former slave who spoke eloquentlyWilliam Lloyd Garrison: published The LiberatorSojourner Truth: freed slave fought for abolition of slavery and women's rightsGag Resolution: required all antislavery appeals to be tabled w/o debateChapter SeventeenManifest Destiny: belief

Blood and Iron - The Main Factors in the Unification of Germany

2033 words - 8 pages through economy before Bismarck came along with 'blood and iron'. The first and failed attempt to unify was in 1848. It was in the form of a revolution from the people. They were unsatisfied, as it had become very hard as a peasant to make a living. Many owed feudal dues to landowners; others were landless who worked for Junkers, landowning military aristocracy. Not only were working conditions less than favourable

Economic Boom Of 1920s And Birth Of Consumer Ameri

3579 words - 14 pages half of the nineteenth century, had feared the growth of such a class of plutocrats, such an ?aristocracy of manufacturers?(DeLong). The infantile capitalism Tocqueville observed, nourished by the creation of mass production and the invention of the automobile, matured into a colossal market, driven by the consumer. The fundamental concepts of mass production, consumption and advertisement have only intensified in the past century. Today, the

Economic Boom Of 1920s And Birth Of Consumer Ameri

3579 words - 14 pages half of the nineteenth century, had feared the growth of such a class of plutocrats, such an ?aristocracy of manufacturers?(DeLong). The infantile capitalism Tocqueville observed, nourished by the creation of mass production and the invention of the automobile, matured into a colossal market, driven by the consumer. The fundamental concepts of mass production, consumption and advertisement have only intensified in the past century. Today, the

Similar Essays

A Comparison Of A Coal Mining Company To An Autocracy

2388 words - 10 pages . (“How an Aristocracy May Be Created by Manufacturers.”) The previous quote that emphasizes the relationship between the world of the master and the world of the slave represents the incorrect communication and bad relationship of the Massey Energy company's refusal to even call the family after the incident, showing that the employers did not care about the employees. The company’s inability to care about their employees could have led to the

Hardship And Misery Prevailed In Pre Revolutionary Russia.

1165 words - 5 pages population living with less hardship and misery, overall these aspects prevailed throughout pre-revolutionary Russia. Despite living an often lavish life free from hardship and misery, the nobility and aristocracy accounted for only 2% of the population (Fiehn,1996, pg. 6), so cannot be used to accurately determine whether hardship and misery prevailed in pre-revolutionary Russian society. The peasants however, accounted for the largest portion

Historical Context, Social Background And Theme Analysis Of Importance Of Being Ernest

699 words - 3 pages Individuals in nineteenth century England were organized into social classes which were defined by occupation, family connections and access to wealth. Individuals generally remained within the class they were born into. At the top of the scale was the upper class, consisting of the aristocracy, the landed gentry and a select number of wealthy professionals and manufacturers. Then there was the middle class, represented by professionals

Federalist Vs Democrats Essay

810 words - 3 pages he thought the self-dependency of an agrarian society would be an honest, hardworking society whose goals, as a nation, were to better the country whereas manufacturers did not work in the best interest of the union because of their values and focus based on self-serving profit. Therefore, the Democratic Republican Party stated that the Americans should remain predominantly rural and agricultural, away from commercial or urban society. Also, the