Aristotelian Rhetoric: An Evolution Of Sophist’s Discredited Methodology

2089 words - 8 pages

Scholars of rhetoric consider the Greek philosopher, Aristotle, one of the great contributors to our present understanding of this art which, since its early origins and until present, has been a controversial field of study because of its association with persuasion and influence. However, an examination of ancient rhetoric and its development by the Sophists and then a study on Aristotle’s theory on rhetoric and how he concluded his findings direct our attention to whether this Greek philosopher only included in his theory what he described as inadequate and non-fundamental Sophistic teachings, or actually built up his theory on their techniques, long bashed and overlooked. In this essay, I consider Aristotle’s rhetoric is an evolution of the Sophists’ discredited methodology. I assert that the sophistic contribution to Aristotle’s theory is more than a partial inclusion of their teachings disdained by ancient orthodox philosophers and some modern scholars. Examined readings of his theory on the art of rhetoric demonstrate his elaborate use of many of sophistic perspectives. Thus, the Aristotelian rhetoric, at heart of the development of our modern studies in this field, can be considered an evolution of the Sophists’ rhetoric, which has lately been the center of study by many scholars who called for a re-evaluation of the Sophists’ long disdained and overlooked techniques.
In order to explain my argument, I will briefly review the main tenets of the sophistic rhetoric and why Plato condemned such rhetoric “foul” and “ugly,” but later retracted and stated that there was a “good rhetoric.” Finally, I will justify why the Aristotelian rhetoric can be perceived as a systemized evolution and progression of the sophist rhetoric.
Scholars noted that rhetoric as a systematic study was developed by the Sophists, a group of travelling teachers and orators who prospered in Athens about 467 B.C., a time that witnessed democratic reforms which required a skill in persuasive public speaking at assemblies, courts, and other gatherings. Herrick (2009) explained that such a political change offered the Sophists a distinguished role as they offered teaching of rhetoric and persuasive speaking to any Greek who could pay their high fees. According to Herrick, teaching of this important skill to middle class Greeks reshaped the political and social atmospheres in the polis where class and nobility of birth were no longer factors of power and influence.
The Sophists also claimed they could teach their students more than persuasive speaking; they offered teaching in arête, a term that refers to a wide range of themes: virtue, excellence, superiority, and the ability of managing personal affairs and holding a political power. Accordingly, the Sophists professed that arête was a skill that can be acquired and taught, not a born talent as the Greeks earlier assumed. Herrick (2009) noted that the sophistic rhetoric changed assumptions and reformed beliefs of the...

Find Another Essay On Aristotelian Rhetoric: An Evolution of Sophist’s Discredited Methodology


714 words - 3 pages Yelena Chernyak AN INTERVIEW WITH JOHN MAYNARD SMITH: MECHANISMS OF EVOLUTION John Maynard Smith is not unlike any biologist in that nature and science are his life. Although his career originated as an aircraft engineer, ironically, it lead his to be come an even better evolutionary biologist. A childhood in London, followed by a move to the country only reinforced Johns fascination with nature. Another childhood passion of Smith's was

Explain the evolution an expansion of hospitals throughout history

949 words - 4 pages . This disincentive is directly associated with rising healthcare costs and largely due to these costs, transportation issues, new technology, and the rising age of baby boomers, the trend of hospital expansion and evolution has not ceased.In 2004, according to the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, “through 2014, an estimated $200 billion will be spent on new hospital construction across the U.S.” and the U.S. Census Bureau reported, “

Evolution and Creationism debate with an analysis of Galileo

1204 words - 5 pages with one another. Scientists believe that evolution proves the creation of the earth, where as creationists believe that a supreme being created the earth. This debate has even reached the bottom as to argue whether creationism can truly be a science. Another debate is whether the earth is the center of the universe, which has been heavily discussed for more than a millennium. This is based on the findings of Aristotle, Copernicus, and Galileo

The Evolution of an Era – A New World Education

2153 words - 9 pages transportation where the horse gets replaced with the car only to be trumped by a flying machine now known as an airplane. A need for quicker transportation came about so the demand for it arose and developed into what we know now as modern day transportation. So has this change occurred with higher education? Yes, I do believe it has. There are multiple examples that are much like the methods of transportation. The very way we use to know education

An Essay Summarizing and Supporting the Concepts of Darwin's Theory of Evolution

997 words - 4 pages genetically based rather than an organism that reproduces by budding or a similar method, humans are for the most part genetically based. Therefore, it would be impossible for one to deny that some type of evolution has not occurred. Evolution is not merely a theory. It is a fact.Often, when evolution is discussed, people are confused at exactly what the specifics of the subject matter are. How long evolution has been going on, under what conditions, and

An Analysis of the Epic Poem, Beowulf - Origin and Evolution of Beowulf

1659 words - 7 pages The Origin and Evolution of Beowulf       The origin of Beowulf remains a mystery, as both the poet and the year of composition has eluded scholars for centuries.  Although "[it] is now widely believed that Beowulf is the work of a single poet who was Christian . . ." (preface, Heaney 29), I see Beowulf as a mosaic of many poets.  In this paper, I will argue that with each new translation of this Old English epic, a new author of Beowulf

An essay describing the theory of evolution and its basic tenets

2108 words - 8 pages , bacteria, and insect are all such species.All these premises all have an affect on the major point of evolution. All the other factors stated above affect the law of natural selection. Natural Selection is commonly referred to as "survival of the fittest." Natural selection removes those individuals of a population who would have a negative affect on the rest of the population. Those individuals best equipped to survive or reproduce will pass on

An opinionated look into the facts and fallacies of evolution, from a Christian perspective. 11 pages

2906 words - 12 pages Evolution: The Facts and the FallaciesDeep within the isolated region of the dense, insect infested African jungle, a loathsome, four-legged creature, otherwise known as an ape, walks around his domain diligently seeking for food that his family might eat. Nearly two billion years later, that same creature, now a Homo habilis, occasionally alternates between the obvious four-legged fashion of walking and the two-legged mode and repeats the same

This is an essay about Nietzsche's christinity, talks about evolution of idealogies

674 words - 3 pages Throughout the course of European history, the progress of the continent has come largely from an evolution of not only people, but an evolution of ideologies. From Hegal's idea of synthesis to the Enlightenment philisophes, the ideological history of Europe has not been insignificant. One of the major periods of advancement in this field was the late 19th century. One such thinker to arise in this period is Friedrich Nietzsche. Greatly

An essay on human adaptability. it talks about evolution of the human person

1949 words - 8 pages evolutionary theory is like putting a completely disassembled Tissot wristwatch into a bag, and then one shakes the bag until the watch is reassembled.Adaptation is "the ability of an organism to adjust to a changing environment such that survival and reproduction are enhanced" (Boaz, 122). The human body simply changes its chemical or physical composition so that it is most benefited in its current situation. Adaptation is the basis for evolution

Atheism as an Evolution of Thought and its Place Among the Religious Multitude

2162 words - 9 pages conscious.” (qtd. Freud 77). This transferring of human aspects to flora, fauna, inanimate objects, and events is what we term today as animism, and is a practice prevalent in nearly all indigenous religions. In the early 20th century Sigmund Freud, who famously labeled religion as a universal obsession neurosis, expanded Hume’s observation of animistic practices to theistic religions, believing that deity worship was an evolution of those

Similar Essays

Othello: The Tragedy Of An Aristotelian Tragic Hero

1677 words - 7 pages the extensively defined Aristotelian tragedy. The play lacks the musical attributes that Aristotle says the play must include in his theory of tragedy. Aristotle states, “The Chorus too should be regarded as one of the actors; it should be an integral part of the whole, and share in the action, in the manner not of Euripides but of Sophocles.” (Aristotle) Without the musical element, “Othello, the Moor of Venice” would more appropriately be

The Effects Of Aristotelian Teleological Thought On Darwin's Mechanistic Views Of Evolution

2159 words - 9 pages The Effects of Aristotelian Teleological Thought on Darwin's Mechanistic Views of Evolution      The need to understand organisms has been a much sought goal of science since its birth as biology. History shows Aristotle and Charles Darwin as two of the most powerful biologists of all time. Aristotle's teleological method was supported widely for over 2,000 years. One scientist remarks that the Aristotelian

The Rhetoric Of An Apology: The Bill Clinton Sex Scandal

1758 words - 7 pages The Rhetoric of an Apology: The Clinton Sex Scandal "I ask that all Americans demonstrate in their personal and public lives... the high ethical standards that are essential to good character and to the continued success of our Nation." On August 17, 1998, exactly one year after making the statement above, President Bill Clinton prepared to deliver a speech concerning a scandal that had gripped the nation for months. It is needless

An Exploration Of Different Theories Of Evolution

3459 words - 14 pages An Exploration of Different Theories of Evolution Where did we come from? It is a question that has haunted the entire history of humanity. Thousands of years ago, our ancestors sought to answer the question with myths. Today, we are still struggling with the same question—only today we seek to answer this mystery with science. Given various observations, it seems plausible that all life arose from a few very simple organisms