This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Aristotle And Heidegger Allowing Personal Accountability

6940 words - 28 pages

Aristotle and Heidegger Allowing Personal Accountability

A disquieting article recently appeared in The New York Times. The article chronicles the story of Larry W. Peterman, resident of Provo, Utah, owner of a successful adult video store, and defendant in a case in which he was charged with selling obscene material. During Peterman’s trial, the following information came to the fore, "As it turned out, people in Utah County, a place that often boasts of being the most conservative area in the nation, were disproportionately large consumers of the very videos that prosecutors had labeled obscene and illegal. And far more Utah County residents were getting their adult movies from the sky or cable than they were from the stores owned by Larry Peterman."11 Mr. Spencer, a public defender who described himself as a devout Mormon said, "The fact is that an awful lot of people here in [Provo] are paying to look at porn. What that says to me is that we're normal."22

Provo’s "normal" residents buy twice as much pornography as the occupants of other comparably sized American cities.33 Ostensibly most, if not all, of Provo’s predominantly Mormon inhabitants have heard their church leaders constantly, unequivocally decry pornography.44 Yet despite constant warnings, not only are Provoans incontinent, they are statistically twice as incontinent as their other small-town counterparts. What could explain this weakness? Moreover, what is it in us that seems to make us prone, or whereby we make ourselves prone, to incontinence? Aristotle in his Nicomachean Ethics and Martin Heidegger in Being and Time both offer models of human action that account for human weakness, which Heidegger calls inauthenticity and Aristotle names akrasia. We shall examine both Heidegger’s and Aristotle’s models of action, and our aim throughout this study shall be to discover what moral weakness is for each of these thinkers, and what exactly makes this weakness possible. Heidegger’s penetrating analysis of human action yields - as we will discover - much insight into why we as humans are prone to weakness, which he defines in loosely social-constructionist terms that still allow for a large measure of personal accountability. However, in the end we shall see that Aristotle goes further than Heidegger in explaining human weakness because his model of action (1) encompasses key aspects of Heidegger’s carefully executed existential analytic and (2) allows for more personal accountability by giving a wider account of action that allows for voluntary action that is chosen by deliberation in addition to merely voluntary action.

Dasein, Modes of Being, and Being-in-the-world

John Caputo of Villanova University relates that in Being and Time, Heidegger wishes "to find a new conceptuality in which to ‘indicate,’ however ‘formally,’ the character of the pretheoretical, prephilosophical, indeed even a preconceptual life. This provocative and paradoxical task, to find...

Find Another Essay On Aristotle and Heidegger Allowing Personal Accountability

Authentic Grasp of Being Essay

1674 words - 7 pages personal, individual perspective, and it is the experience here that sets the stage for understanding being. Heidegger repeatedly emphasizes the fact that when we begin to ask about being we seem to already have some sort of vague notion about it. After all, we have to start with something that we are curious enough about to even begin examining it, and we have a notion of what we are looking at when we interrogate it. Returning to section six, we

Rhetorical Analysis of Martin Heidegger’s Memorial Address

904 words - 4 pages the devil. We depend on technical devices; they even challenge us to ever greater advances. But suddenly and unaware we find ourselves so firmly shackled to these technical devices that we fall into bondage to them. (Heidegger)” A perfect segue into discussing the epideictic rhetoric found throughout his memorial address, this quote connects his task of persuading his audience to think for themselves and his own personal opinion regarding the

History of Philosophy - By: Aram Kamali

2358 words - 9 pages was all wrong, says the world is a picture, 25 years later picture theory is wrong.Continental Philosophers - (Husserl, Heidegger, Sartre, Deride)- Husserl invented philosophy called phenomenology- Aristotle said everything has a primary quality (what it is meant to do) and a secondary quality (colour, material, shape)- If you look at something with your mind the process is called "Bracketing" which is removing its

The Question of Being

1313 words - 5 pages the true form of “average everydayness” by identifying the world of Dasein, which is the human world, or more precisely, the soul. Heidegger characterizes Being as the totality of beings. He appeals to Aristotle and Thomas Aquinas to assert the transcendental quality of Being, which requires Being to “lie beyond every possible generic determination of a being in its material content…that are necessary attributes of every ‘something’” (56). This

The Hermeneutic Conception of Culture

4328 words - 17 pages The Hermeneutic Conception of Culture Heidegger, the founder of the hermeneutic paradigm, rejected the traditional account of cultural activity as a search for universally valid foundations for human action and knowledge. His main work, Sein und Zeit (1927), develops a holistic epistemology according to which all meaning is context-dependent and permanently anticipated from a particular horizon, perspective or background of intelligibility

Dr. Heidegger´s Experiment by Nathaniel Hawthorne

1167 words - 5 pages scientist, Dr. Heidegger, who brings together four of his friends, Mr. Medbourne, Colonel Killigrew, Mr. Gascoigne, and Widow Wycherly, to conduct an experiment. The experiment is simple; they must drink water from the Fountain of Youth. At first none of the guests believe what they are being told. They skeptically take a drink of the water and feel the effects of the magical elixir. The participants in their haste drink more water. Soon each

The Great Philosoper:Aristotle

1019 words - 5 pages Arimnestus, his brother. Sadly, Aristotle’s mother died shortly after. His father, Nicomachus, was the personal physician to the king of Macedonia at the time. He taught Aristotle about many special herbs and medicines as much as he could, like many other fathers did during the time period Aristotle grew up in. Nicomachus died fairly early in Aristotle’s life, and Aristotle became an orphan at the age of ten (Paragraph 3 Kenny). When Aristotle was 17 he

Relationships in a World without God

2247 words - 9 pages Milan Kundera and Jean-Paul Sartre, we witness the philosophical and psychological struggles for identity, existence, and ‘being’ of the characters in The Unbearable Lightness of Being, and Nausea. In connection with other philosophic writings of Heidegger, Kierkegaard, Tillich and Sartre the ideas of existentialism expressed in these two novels become more apparent, and the relationships of the characters in this world-without-God can be explored

Heidegger and Sport

1806 words - 8 pages objects in sports. This utilization of available objects lends itself to Heidegger’s ready-to-hand concept. Readiness-to-hand is crucial to understanding human action and the nature of athletic agency. Heidegger sees human being and then objects either in relation to human activity or in terms of worldly existence. Heidegger also believes humans act with purpose, but more to show care and concern for others and for objects. Heidegger focuses on

Educational Implications for Heidegger's Views On Poetry And Thinking

5172 words - 21 pages Heidegger calls the "country" of thinking is open in all directions to the neighborhood of poetry. Thus, today, when scientific method tends to suffocate thinking, we can return to thinking through reading and listening to poetry. To be specific, the fact that the country of thinking is open in all directions to the neighborhood of poetry, can often help a person follow those paths of thinking that concern him or her. How? Quite often if you

Aristotle's Influences on Biology

610 words - 3 pages . Aristotle’s father was a young doctor named Nicomachus, who traveled around the countryside, treating patients who needed care. His father began to spend more time in Macedonia before Aristotle was born, and discovered that it offered better working conditions there. Eventually, he attracted the attention of the king- Amyntas III who then appointed him as his own personal court doctor. They then moved to the capital city of Pella. Aristotle

Similar Essays

Human Mortality According To Heidegger Essay

4423 words - 18 pages generations of continental European cultural personalities of his time. The son of a Catholic sexton, Heidegger displayed an early interest in religion and philosophy; at school he began an intensive study of the late 19th century Catholic philosopher Franz Brentano and, as we shall see, Brentano's "descriptive" psychology, as presented in his "On the Manifold Meaning of Being According to Aristotle", played a major role in Heidegger's

The Pros And Cons Of Technology

3725 words - 15 pages practical, more probable, and would allow us to rid ourselves of many of the problems associated with technology while allowing us to retain many of its benefits. Heidegger's solution to this Question Concerning Technology is a "more primally granted revealing [than technology itself] that could bring the saving power into its first shining-forth in the midst of the danger." In other words, Heidegger suggests fine art, the "bringing-forth of

Too Often We Enjoy The Comfort Of Opinion Without The Discomfort Of Thought

996 words - 4 pages “own” genuine thoughts, rather than made from “right answers”. If person withdraws from pre-made stencils of thought and knowledge and chooses to make judgements and state opinion from his personal, genuine experience, he will be more likely to be taken into account as “real” person and taken into consideration. Heidegger describes these persons “as free”. Free-will in at this moment is way to become “authentic”. Un-authenticity and Authenticity

Heidegger's Reading Of Descartes' Dualism Essay

4301 words - 17 pages of Descartes Project, (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1986), 91. (35) Aristotle, Physics Book IV The Basic Works of Aristotle. Ed. and Intr. by Richard McKeon. (New York: Random House, 1941.), 219b. (36) Martin Heidegger, Being and Time , 376.