This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Aristotle Vs. Plato Learning Is Recollection

650 words - 3 pages

What alternative does Aristotle offer to Plato’s claim that learning is recollection? Where would Aristotle locate the mistake in Plato’s argument in The Phaedo?

In his dialogues The Phaedo and Meno, Plato, through the form of Socrates, puts forth the idea that all learning is recollection. In The Phaedo, to prove that the soul is immortal, Socrates asserts the view that all learning is recollection and we simply need to be reminded of facts that our immortal souls are aware of. In Meno, Socrates attempts to show the truth of this belief by doing complex geometry with a nearby slave boy. Socrates leads the boy through a series of questions, and he answers correctly lending to Socrates’ idea about learning. His brightest pupil, Aristotle, disagreed with this view and put forth a differing view in his work The Metaphysics.
In The Metaphysics, Aristotle puts forth the view that universal information is gained through experience and not recollection as Plato had said. Man connects a series of events into a causal chain through experience. For instance, gathering the fact that a certain remedy has helped two different sick people get better is simply a matter of experience. In his view, art is even greater and closer to wisdom than experience. Experience belies art, in that art is created by the formulation of universals from many individual experiences. Extracting the universal idea that the remedy given to those two people will help all people afflicted with the same sickness is a matter of art. The main difference comes in that men of art know the causes of things, while men of experience simply know how to deal with them. For instance, a carpenter may know that when wood gets wet it becomes warped, but a man of art knows the chemistry behind such a change. Therefore, a man of art is to be seen as wiser, because not only do they know what happens, they know why...

Find Another Essay On Aristotle Vs. Plato Learning Is Recollection

The Beliefs of Plato vs Aristotle

3784 words - 15 pages , who were known as his "esoteric" students. In the afternoon a larger circle gathered around him, to whom he imparted simpler teachings. This was known as his exoteric group. In passing from Plato to Aristotle, we at once become conscious of a distinct change in philosophical concepts and methods. This is all the more noticeable because of our ignorance of Aristotle's complete system. The writings which have come down to us comprise only about a

PLato Vs Aristotle - Principles of Political Power

768 words - 3 pages Throughout history, many scholars have attempted to develop the perfect governing body. Three of these major scholars, Plato; Jefferson; and Aristotle, have had a great impact on our government. The most influential of the three on contemporary US society is Jefferson.In contemporary US society, the individual comes first. Individual rights have been promoted throughout our history. The ruling party has been used to enforce these rights

Discuss one disagreement or agreement between Plato and Aristotle. Who do you think is more consistent with Greek cultural tradition?

675 words - 3 pages fascinated in learning the natural phenomena. He did so approach this by using empirical knowledge. Empirical knowledge was the information gained through ones senses. Unlike Aristotle, Plato believed that everything we touch, see, and experienced was unreliable because it was the reflection of some untouchable idea of perfection or of a perfect form. To specify, due to this idea of “forms”, both agreed that it existed but, disagreed on the

Plato’s Theory of “Recollection”

1678 words - 7 pages In this paper, I will investigate the basic characteristics and properties of Plato’s “recollection” in Meno. In my opinion, Plato uses “recollection” to refute this argument, “whether people know or do not know, discovering is unnecessary.” He believes there is a state between “do not know” and “know”, he calls it “forget”. Therefore, when people are learning or discovering, they are just recollecting things they already forget. In general


3067 words - 12 pages world consists of remembering, in reminiscence or recollection. What the mind or soul once knew is raised to present awareness by a process of recollection aided by the technique of dialect or the Socratic method. (Stumpf 260) This is known as the theory of recollection. The theory of recollection is told through Plato in the Phaedo and the Meno. In the theory of

Distinctions and Comparisons between Aristotle and Plato

1638 words - 7 pages viewed in the physical world as an idea or an imperfect form of the object he studied. If Plato were to observe a tree in the physical realm he would add “ness” to an object to make it known that the tree he saw before him was participating in the form of a tree, and is merely an outline of an ideal tree. Aristotle disagreed with Plato’s ideology of an immaterial world and an invisible world not seen by the human eye. The system of Aristotle’s

Why Plato Says Recollection

1571 words - 7 pages are learning or discovering, this is impossible. And then again, if people already know what they are discovering or learning, there is no need for them to learn or discover. In this way, people either know or do not know what they are learning or discovering, learning and discovering are impossible or unnecessary. The essential start point that Plato proposes “recollection” in Meno is to refute this argument about learning and discovering

The Platonic and Aristotelian Conception of the Soul

2456 words - 10 pages its entirety. The second argument states that the soul must recollect everything it knows as it forgets everything at birth. According to Plato, if learning is recollection, then the soul must pre-exist its embodiment. This eternal knowledge within the soul is something that Aristotle had difficulty in accepting. According to Aristotle, the soul is responsible for the life of the body. It is vital in allowing organism to live for a body is only

Socrates, A great Philosopher

1005 words - 5 pages philosopher such as Socrates. He was greatly known for the first association of higher learning throughout the Western world. Plato was also known as being one of Socrates many students. Lastly there is Aristotle, he was the youngest of the three. He too was a Greek philosopher along with the rest. Aristotle was best known for his writings, in which including many topics. Each philosopher had a great impact on the Western Civilizations. One working off

The Doctrine of Recollection

1256 words - 5 pages certainly, Socrates” (Plato 85b). With this procedure of question asking, the experiment here is clearly faulty to prove the Doctrine of Recollection. This example is not convincing, and therefore I do not believe the doctrine that it is trying to prove. Secondly, the doctrine of recollection does not work with all types of knowledge. For example, what if a history question was asked instead of the mathematical problem? If the doctrine is true


1154 words - 5 pages Archytas of Tarentum who introduced Plato to Pythagorenism. This helped form Plato's ideas that mathematics was the truest way of expressing the universe. There are also rumors of Plato traveling to Egypt and learning of the water clock but like all rumors it is not know for sure. Plato founded The Academy in 387 BC; it was build on land that once belonged to a man named Academos hence the name The Academy. Plato founded The Academy for the purpose of

Similar Essays

Aristotle Vs. Plato Essay

1397 words - 6 pages Aristotle vs. Plato Excellence is a function which renders excellent the thing of which it is a function is Plato’s definition of virtue. What does this definition really mean though? Plato and Aristotle both had their own unique arguments devoted to the topic at hand, and their own ways of describing what virtue really is. Defining virtue may seem to be an easy taste, but to truly understand the arguments behind the definition can prove to

Plato Vs Aristotle Essay

1823 words - 7 pages their reason and good character. A person who follows their good character and reason instead of trying to avoid consequences is a virtuous person. Aristotle believed “virtue is a matter of developing the unique ability to reason.”(Pacquette 268) Being virtuous to Plato and Aristotle also meant, “doing things- no matter what these things were- in a way that reflected rational thought and involved making the best of one’s skills, talents and

Aristotle Vs Plato Essay

1089 words - 4 pages for the ends of making people happy, and keeping them in their places is one of the primary methods by which they go about doing so. Aristotle, on the other hand, is displeased by the communal approach Plato takes to politics and its relationship to truth and happiness. While Plato argues that the place of each person in society, as ordained by the state, contributes to individuals’ happiness, Aristotle looks upon this claim with some

Plato Vs. Aristotle On Art Essay

1979 words - 8 pages and I believe Aristotle gives a better understanding about imitation than Plato because he did not shy away from art just because art appeals to our emotions. Not only does Aristotle help others understand that art is good for the society, but he also points that art as imitation is like a learning experience. When we imitate others, it is not necessarily as negative as Plato explained in his philosophy. According to Aristotle, learning comes