This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Art Can Be Functional Essay

2539 words - 10 pages


“We are in the presence of a work of art only when it has no preponderant instrumental use, and when its technical and rational foundations are not preeminent.”1

The words of George Kubler, a prominent twentieth century art historian, support the notion that art cannot be useful or necessary to society outside of its artistic expression. Kubler’s belief, however, is not solely a contemporary idea. The eighteenth century philosopher, Immanuel Kant, formally proposed this theory. Kant separated fine art from useful art, maintaining that an artist’s goal must be to convey aesthetic ideas through form and design. These ideas are original and creative and therefore have “purpose without a purpose.”2 In short, both Immanuel Kant and George Kubler, even though separated by more than a century, believe that art only exists for the sake of art, without any other functional value to society, and thus anything that possesses utility fails to be art.

Initially, we can easily agree with this notion since art does exist in this form. Famous works of art such as Monet’s “Waterlilies” or Van Gogh’s “Starry Night” demonstrate that art exists for art’s sake. These artists express their ideas through form and design, giving the work “purpose without a purpose.” Even though art exists for the sake of artistic expression, we can also find art that defies the philosophy of Immanuel Kant.

Bridges exist as art, and thus engineers exist as artists. Although bridges stand as feats of engineering that perform the task of connection, bridges also display great beauty. Undoubtedly, beautiful bridges evoke an array of emotions from observers, much the same as an inspired painting, and thus offer warnings that Kubler’s statement has its faults. Specifically, we can look at the works of Othmar Ammann, who used New York City as a museum for his many masterpieces of structural design, including the George Washington Bridge. Built upon rational and technical foundations, the George Washing Bridge possesses inherent utility, while also standing as a beautiful work of art.

Although all of Othmar Ammann’s bridges, which include the George Washington Bridge, the Bayonne Bridge, the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge, and several others, were built in America, Ammann was born and educated in Switzerland. Switzerland’s Federal Polytechnic Institute in Zurich has produced an amazing number of notable bridge engineers, considering Switzerland’s small size. The Federal Polytechnic Institute shaped the century’s two most influential and accomplished bridge designers in Othmar Ammann, who was a master in steel, and Robert Maillart, a genius in concrete bridge design.3 Recent graduates, such as Christian Menn and Santiago Calatrava, continue to lead the way in creative bridge design. Switzerland’s distinguished tradition in bridge design is rooted in the influences of France and Germany. Switzerland blends the detailed scientific analysis...

Find Another Essay On Art Can Be Functional

Critics have a responsibility to establish standards by which works of art can be judged

586 words - 2 pages Art critics are divided into two camps with regard to evaluation of their own work. Some insist that, since art is such an subjective form of creativity, it is hard to define any objective standards for evaluation. Those from the other camp, however, hold strong belief that, no matter how diviated the motives of art are and their representations, there must be some objective standards that can be applied to evaluate art works. If we examine

© MURAKAMI : "Art can be anything you want in a variety of styles."

721 words - 3 pages If issues of social reality are intervened in arts, they shows an interest but do not give good marks to the work at all. Also in such a case that arts and external purpose beyond them are combined as well as politics, and commerce they don’t approve arts. However, I have an opinion that the meaning of art must be changed according to the change of age because all arts which contain the spirit of its creator are real art. The art can be

The Progression of Forensic Art and How it can be Used

1329 words - 6 pages reconstruction. Having a history stretching back to the 1800s forensic art has grown and improved over the course of the following years. First giving a brief history on where forensic art started and then following with some of the benefits each skill set of forensic art provides to the law enforcement community. I will try to show the progression of forensic art and how it can be used by modern law enforcement. The precursor to modern forensic art

According to Sayer In World of Art, Art Can Be Broken Down Into Three Steps: Reception, Extraction, And Inference. When One Looks at A Piece of Art, The Eyes Stimulate The Nervous System.

1605 words - 6 pages sees art. The same picture may have to different perceptions, neither of which is incorrect. According to Sayer in World of Art, art can be broken down into three steps: reception, extraction, and inference. When one looks at a piece of art, the eyes stimulate the nervous system. As one continues to study the work, he or she as an individual pulls a meaning out of the work, based on his or her own life experiences (13). The inferences made by

Discuss Bazin's idea that 'realism in art can only be achieved through artifice'. What are the implications for film of his approach? Make reference to films in your answers

1570 words - 6 pages ', believing that the essential aim of filmmaking is the representation of the real world, he argues that the film, in order to fulfill its destiny of remaking the real world, will inevitably have to apply certain styles and techniques. He claimed that the need to apply artifice to give the illusion of transparency generated a creative tension that was crucial to the work of art. (pp 339. The cinema book) He argued that that films can only be understood

Origions of the art of Asian Taiko drumming. including summary and how it can be related today

2192 words - 9 pages is not the only material to be found on the net which can raise questions of censorship and control: discussion of racial, political, religious and sexual topics all run the risk of offending someone, somewhere, leading to demands for control of the Internet. The question of censorship may also be raised in some unexpected places: one newsgroup is the rec.humor list, which is a collection of jokes submitted to subscribers. There are

David Hume's Of the Standard of Taste

646 words - 3 pages detrimental to the artist, or may never be publicised, which is unfortunate for the public. On the topic of aesthetic judgment, there are two main paths one could take: that of the subjectivists, who claim the importance of the role of the viewer or audience, and assert that art can only be judged by the preference and aesthetic taste of individuals, as well that anything that creates an aesthetic response can be considered art; then there is

Art Paper

593 words - 3 pages Edward Alexander Arias A lot of students have faced some problems writing academic papers on Art. Professors, teachers and instructors at School, High School, College or University frequently assign difficult papers on Arts and want them to be delivered on time. This may push young people to using online custom writing companies. Our professional custom writing company can provide you with the finest quality custom papers on Art such

What is the instiutional theory of art?

1987 words - 8 pages than just an object, a sound or a piece of writing. Broadly speaking, there are traditionally two types of definitions: functional definitions and procedural definitions. The former, which includes definitions from Plato, Bell and Croce see artworks as having a certain function. For example, Bell defined art as something designed to possess and exhibit its formal features. The procedural definition, on the other hand, proposes that art should be

The Importance of Art Education

2016 words - 8 pages artistic talent and those who do not (Salmon 103). The use of art can be dated back to the days of the Neanderthal, and until the Italian Renaissance, art was only considered culturally important and was not taught (DeHoyas). At the birth of the United States of America, male and female students were taught different forms of art, where the boys’ art was typically more functional. The teachings of art were often private until the 1870’s when art

Summary of Walter Benjamin's essay, " The of art in the age of mechanical reproduction"

816 words - 3 pages poems and movies of today.In the past works of art were seen as functional before aesthetic. It was only in retrospect that they were labeled art. In the same way, today's art, due to the great emphasis on its exhibition value, becomes an entirely new creation, with entirely new functions. The artistic is the most obvious of these functions, which in the future may be recognized as merely incidental.The masses reaction to art changed dramatically

Similar Essays

Can Art Be Immoral Essay

1354 words - 5 pages developed and formed in a way that abides by the morals that came from the bible. Thou shall not kill and thou shall not steal are examples of what the bibl says not to do and most of our laws abide by these ideas. Can a work of art be immoral if the immorality of it is something we cannot prove? I think art needs deep expression in it to be a good work. Since, moral topics such as sex, death, violence are very intriguing to people, I think

How Can Art Be Defined Essay

1304 words - 5 pages name of art come together, their social and religious differences are smoothed, in the name of art, the economic interests can fade generously. After all,  Art is one of the greatest manifestations of the ability of human beings, which seems to be old as the history of human kind itself. I could finally assume within its broader definition, if there is no art shall no be human history. Works Cited Adajian, T., The Definition of Art

Art Can Be Made Of Any Material.

742 words - 3 pages remarkably insightful. It spoke to me in a manner I have experienced with art in the past. My interpretation of it was that global warming is increasing and if we want snowmen to stay around they would have to be kept in the freezer. I like the installation Warlord Sun King beacuse it has a tanning bed, rocks, crystals, minerals, plants and a heat lamp. Conkle explores how everyday things can be artistic, it’s all in the way we frame the idea

How Crime And Deviance Can Be Seen As Functional For Society

2147 words - 9 pages Crime and deviance are acts that will elicit dissent from society. They take various forms and involve various concepts and theories. It will be the aim of this paper to explore those that are considered to be functional for society. It was Emile Durkheim who first clearly established the logic behind the functional approach to the study of crime and deviance[1] when he wrote The Rules of Sociological Method and The