This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Article Critique 1 Essay

873 words - 4 pages

Article Review 2
Dennis Carter-Edwards’ article The War of 1812 Along the Detroit Frontier: A Canadian Perspective covers the theme of local history during the 19th century in Detroit. In particular, Carter-Edwards explores the Canadian perspective of the war of 1812 in the Windsor-Detroit region. The author examines three big categories; the measures that the British took to defended the area, the factors that influenced British decisions, and the power players that played a role on the outcome of the war. The article is an in-depth account of the events and people that were key players in the war, especially in the Canadian context.
To begin, Dennis Carter –Edwards is a historian and ...view middle of the document...

This article does not have much of a thesis or an argument; rather, Carter-Edwards is telling a historical story, such as what would be included in a high school textbook.
On the other hand, Carter-Edwards does have a very detailed account of the war of 1812, and it is a great, useful Canadian source. At the beginning of the text he provides a lot of context before exploring his arguments. Unfortunately, at other parts of the article, he was lacking context. For example, when he is introducing the reader to Prevost’s enemy, Major General Sir Isaac Brock he claims, “Brock was encouraged by what he found (in Upper Canada) and saw the benefits of providing some tactical support on the perimeter.” In this statement, Carter-Edwards leaves the reader wondering what elements, what things encouraged him to stay in province. In this case, he failed at providing context, and fully developing his statement.
In my opinion, one aspect that could have been beneficial for his readers would have been to include maps. Carter-Edwards mentions many forts such as Fort Meigs and Fort Stephenson, as well as the “road between Sandwich and Fort Amherstburg,” and also mentions places such as Maumee and Sandusky. Although, being from Windsor, I recognized certain names, I did not know them all. I believe that a map that included all the locations and forts that he mentions would be a great visual to the article; because, the reader would be able to follow along better. As well, another feature that would have beneficial to the article would have...

Find Another Essay On Article Critique 1

Two Critiques Essay

977 words - 4 pages There are many examples of strong argumentative writing in the second half of the book Everyday Arguments. Topics of writing examples include today’s college student, the internet, sports, earning your living, diet, and reading popular culture. Of the writings, two stood out as notable works to be critiqued; Who is a Teacher, and Thoughts on Facebook. Critique of Who is a Teacher In the article Who is a Teacher, the author made a factual

Hemmingway: Shifting Gender Roles in The Sun Also Rises

1048 words - 5 pages against every feature of the strict Victorian gender positions for women. According to the article “Gender Role Reversal as a Critique on Sex: Ernest Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises” throughout the novel Brett Ashley, exudes characteristics that defy the Victorian notions, which make up a “Lady”. The connotation of her name, which itself is an arguable contradiction, implies that in the aspect of social class Brett Ashley is a lady, but aside from

Involuntary Treatment of Schizophrenia Patients in Denmark

972 words - 4 pages had to discuss our article and give a critical analysis of the paper. The two papers I chose were paper 1: ‘Lithium Decreases Plasma Adiponectin Levels in Bipolar Depression’ (Soeiro-de-Souza et al., 2014) and paper 2: ‘Involuntary treatment of schizophrenia patients 2004-2010 in Denmark (Andersen et al., 2013). When the assignment was first given out I wasn’t looking forward to it. Although I wasn’t looking forward to it I thought it was a

Stress Reduction is the Key to Preventing Heart Attacks - Health 120 - Essay

568 words - 3 pages Billura Guseynova Health 120 T/TH 12:30-1:45 Row 5, seat 6 Article Critique 1 4/27/16 Stress Reduction is the Key to Preventing Heart Attacks Contrary to popular belief, saturated fat and cholesterol in the diet are not the cause of heart disease. Paul J. Rosch´s article “Why stress reduction is the best way to prevent heart attacks”(Health and Stress, American Institute of Stress, v10 July 2014) states that all we have been taught about our

The manifestation of violence in Antigone

2073 words - 9 pages ). The society needs someone to follow and thus chooses to follow Creon. Antigone in application to Benjamin’s Critique on Violence There is violence present in Creon’s decree itself as “Power established by law-making violence threatens the law- breaker with law- preserving violence” (Auerbach 1:2007). Anyone who breaks the law, will be punished, the punishment is thus, the ‘law- preserving violence’ as it gives the rest of the state an example of

Issues that Affect Educational Outcomes for Indigenous Australians

1093 words - 4 pages research on health affecting educational outcomes of Indigenous Australians. Article 2: Lyons, Z & Janca, A 2012, 'Indigenous Children in Australia: Health, Education and Optimism for the Future', Australian Journal of Education, vol. 56, no. 1, pp. 5-21. Summary This article has addressed the health and educational status of Indigenous children in Australia. The authors have indicated that high rates of infectious disease are commonly experienced by

Is Postmodernism a continuation or critique of Mod

3824 words - 15 pages answer this we must understand just what a continuation and critique are and where the differences lie. This is the dictionary definitions for the two. Contrnuation: 1.a part or thing added. 2. a renewal of an interrupted action or process.3. the act of continuing; prolongation.7 Critique: 1. a critical essay or commentary. 2. the act or art of criticising.So essentially what we need to do is look at the factor's that make up postmodernism and decide

Revisiting the Stanford Prison Experiment: a Lesson in the Power of Situation Critique

893 words - 4 pages PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 Running head: ARTICLE CRITIQUEArticle Critique Revisiting the Stanford Prison Experiment: a Lesson in the Power of Situation January 17, 2012This is a critique of an article published in Chronicle of Higher Education, (v53 n30 pB6 Mar. 30, 2007) on "Revisiting the Stanford Prison Experiment: a Lesson in the Power of Situation" by Philip G. Zimbardo. This article discusses issues related to how good people can turn

Lasting Racism in the GDR - Colby College - Final Essay

2440 words - 10 pages consensus lead the unrolling of social well fare and public spending programs after World War II. Governments in Europe largely created programs that were designed to help with reconstruction due to the damages of World War II. Such extensive government action was unheard of pre World War II. Liberalism transformed since World War II, where the government took an active role in helping an individuals lives. Part III. 1. In terms of the critique of

Influence of Media in the Public

2460 words - 10 pages differed by the different forms of media analyzed within the study. All five articles are beneficial because they include a wide variety of different demographics and forms of media, which accurately represent the population. Article 1, Images of the Body from Popular Culture: Engaging Adolescent Girls in Critical Inquiry is unique in the sense that it critically addresses adolescent females with self-esteem issues and body dissatisfaction


1183 words - 5 pages Social Analysis, Resaldo comes to grips with his misinterpretation of the “Grief and a Headhunter’s rage (Resaldo: p.1).” Whist studying the Ilongots of the Philippines, Resaldo examined the use of headhunting as an outlet for rage. However, his true understanding did not come until he had experienced the grief [and subsequent rage] of losing his wife. His use of his wife’s death to understand the Ilongot’s bereavement was imperative to his

Similar Essays

Article Critique 1 Essay

910 words - 4 pages Article Critique 1 Catherine Cangany’s article Fashioning Moccasins: Detroit, the Manufacturing Frontier, and the Empire of Consumption, 1701-1835, cover the main theme 18th century Detroit. Cangany explores how the moccasin, a fashionable and practical shoe, transformed from a shoe exclusively worn by native groups to a highly fashionable shoe that French and British colonies started to integrate into their own culture to taking the moccasin

Morality Via Kant And Hegel Essay

1505 words - 6 pages philosophy for the last two centu-ries (Finlayson, Article 2005, 1). A communitarian critique that largely mirrors Hegel’s critique of Kant, for example, confronts Rawlsian liberalism qua its neo-Kantian foundation. With his Discourse Ethics, Jürgen Habermas has made one of the most thorough attempts at dissolving this disjunction by occupying a position between Kant and Hegel. While recognizable as a fundamentally Kantian moral theory, Discourse

Essay Instructions On Decriptive Essay On Gloabalization Govt 425 Essay

686 words - 3 pages rationally defensible about a peer-reviewed journal article on US foreign policy. · For the remainder of your response, offer a critique of the article. What are the limits, problems, or gaps in the author’s argument? There are limits, problems, or gaps in every argument. You do not have to have answers to the problems you identify, but you must be able to at least develop questions about the claims made by the author. Submit each assignment by 11:59 p.m. (ET) on Monday of the assigned module/week. Page 1 of 2

Dance Criticism Essay

842 words - 3 pages " which incorporated ... "video-and audiotapes of real people with cancer and AIDS" in to his performance that were neither dancers nor dancing within the piece (Berger 1). Consequently, Croce's article is not a review/critique of the dance piece in particular but about the genre this type of sympathetic art falls into and the effect the piece has on the audience. Because of its content, Croce felt that she could not responsibly review someone that