This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Article Critique Essay

782 words - 4 pages

Introduction
In 2006, an article was published by three doctoral students, (Tricia Seifert, Jerri Drummond, and Ernest Pascarella) at the University of Iowa, highlighting a research study undergone by the three concerning the role of institutional types, with emphasis on historically black colleges (HBC’s) in African-American students’ experiences. The findings, as published in the Journal of College Student Development showed that students who attend HBC’s report greater levels of good practices than their peers at other institutions of higher education. These findings suggested a greater emphasis on the teaching of students, as defined by the mission statements of these particular institutions.
Critique
The authors highlight the main purpose of their research, which was to compare the educational experiences of African- American students in and out of the classroom with faculty and peers along the dimensions of good practices in undergraduate education by institutional type. To do so, they gathered data from a sample of students who participated in the NSSL, examining 19 dependent variables in 7 sub categories, controlling for factors such as student demographic and background, institutional characteristics, and as well as academic ability of students and institutional selectivity.
A quite extensive literature review was made, and the researchers took care to account for many independent variables, as well as the capabilities and limitations of the study. The key question guiding the study was: “To what extent, if any, does institutional type affect African-American students’ experiences of good practices in undergraduate education”, which defined good practices in seven different areas, including student-faculty contact, cooperation among students, prompt feedback and expectations of students, among others. The research credentials were impressive, as each author has multiple articles peer-reviewed in their area of research.
Although the results suggest otherwise, I found issue with the implications for practice. The article did not really present a “call to action” in terms of future research, but rather discussed and suggested that it would “behoove all of us to learn” rather than make a implicit argument to suggest further research that would advance knowledge of the results, which I take as a notable oversight, particularly when I read the limitations section. Although the article outlines the research limitations succinctly, the authors seem to take...

Find Another Essay On Article Critique

Quantitative Research Article Critique Essay

1627 words - 7 pages Quantitative Research Article Critique This paper is an academic critique of an article written by Lautrette, et al. (2007) titled: “A Communication Strategy and Brochure for Relatives of Patients Dying in the ICU” and accurately reflected the content of the article and the research study itself. The abstract explained the article in more detail, while remaining concise. The type of research study, sample size, variables, intervention

Nursing Research Article Critique Essay

993 words - 4 pages study, the researchers conclude that with increase stress, there is a higher risk of having an eating disorder (King et al.). Ideal Setting and How Writer Implements Study In reviewing this article, this writer was able critique the study and the suitability that it can possess if applied to actual practice. An important factor on whether a study can be considered valuable is if it is transferable in other situation, that is, a study's results

Quantitative Study Article Critique

1436 words - 6 pages Quantitative Study Article Critique This paper is a critique of an article written by McKinney and Jones (1993) entitled: “Effects of a Children’s Book and a Traditional Textbook on Fifth-grade Students’ Achievement and Attitudes toward Social Studies”. In their research the authors examined the effects of a children’s book and a traditional social studies textbook on knowledge acquisition and attitudes toward social studies and the textbook in

Journal Article Critique

1883 words - 8 pages later years. The sample of this study was also small. There was no evidence of future studies. Critique This article implies that children with alphabet letter instruction would help the child to learn phonetically sounding words. The study proved that in most cases the phonetic word recognition was significantly better after the instruction. Most children learn how to recognise words at their own pace with both home and school help. Some

Research Article Critique: A Critique on Bitchener

1217 words - 5 pages , group 3, and group 4, meaning that the result obtained by group 2 (Direct CF + W) was not significantly different from the control group. Critique of the method There are several points worth discussing in this article. The first and the most important one is the integration of the ‘mini lesson’ in the treatment given to group 1. As the researcher had explained, this mini lesson comprised of explaining “the rules and examples that the students

Critique of Johnson’s Quantitative Research Article

4118 words - 16 pages for a school and no company was benefiting from her research conclusions. She was not trying to promote the use of any specific tool to help sleep, like someone working for a drug company might do. Johnson publishing the article in a community nursing journal seems appropriate because many community nursing patients are older adults. The following essay will be a critique of the quality of Johnson’s research process in her study of whether music

Article Critique

1152 words - 5 pages In an article written by Antonanzas, Rive, Badenas, Gomez- Lus and Guilhaume (2006), the different style of treatment of Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) was found to have implications on research. In the United States and many other developed countries, AD patients are often institutionalized at a certain point of the disease when they are said to cause a burden on their caregivers. In Spain, AD is rarely a disease that institutionalizes a

Article Critique

838 words - 4 pages In this paper, I will conduct an analytical review of Wonsuk Chang’s article “Confucian Person in the Making”. In my analytical review I will answer the following questions: - What is his argument/thesis? Was it stated clearly? Did I have to hunt for it, for example? - How well did he go about supporting his thesis? Were appropriate methods used? Did his approach make sense? Any errors? - What evidence did he present to support his

Article Critique

739 words - 3 pages petrels but after reading their argument it seems that they are first testing whether chemical signaling occurs that there are chemical signals assisting in the process. However, this means that the findings they report on are not ecologically realistic. In my eyes, ecological realism occurs when an experiment or study is a copy of an event that happens in nature or is close to what happens in nature. This article does not seem ecologically realistic

Article Critique

1426 words - 6 pages beneficial a program may seem, there is never going to be a program that works for all students. That is why as educators we must constantly strive to find new and engaging methods to help all of our children reach their full potential. I feel like this article was one that proved to be beneficial for the authors study and the findings helped some children with learning disabilities have another option for them to be successful.

Critical Thinking Article Summary and Critique for MGT350

664 words - 3 pages also critique how the author dealt with the following elements: perception, assumption, emotion, language, argument, fallacy, logic, and issue problem resolution. All of these elements will demonstrate the need for critical thinking and questioning of material.Critical Thinking Crucial to Global SuccessThe article examines the current language teaching methods and techniques used in Indonesian schools. The author states "that many have suggested

Similar Essays

Article Critique Essay

747 words - 3 pages Fastest Growing Occupations This review will critique the article ‘Fastest Growing Occupations’ by Daniel E. Hecker in the journal Monthly Labor Review in the book Everyday Arguments by Katherine Mayberry (Mayberry, 2009). The brief analysis of the articles author, the point of view, and the evidence provided to prove a claim, is the evidence factual, and sources utilized. Finally the conclusion will be my viewpoint on the article and my

Article Critique Essay

1352 words - 6 pages ethnic differences in violence across areas and on why this research was important and past research done on this topic (Groveland). Next I discuss the theoretical framework of the article and the hypothesis that guided the research. In this section I address the general criminological theory that the researchers used to inform their analysis. (Social disorganization theory) Lastly I end the article critique with a summary of the study design

Article Critique 1 Essay

910 words - 4 pages Article Critique 1 Catherine Cangany’s article Fashioning Moccasins: Detroit, the Manufacturing Frontier, and the Empire of Consumption, 1701-1835, cover the main theme 18th century Detroit. Cangany explores how the moccasin, a fashionable and practical shoe, transformed from a shoe exclusively worn by native groups to a highly fashionable shoe that French and British colonies started to integrate into their own culture to taking the moccasin

Article Critique On Gmo Essay

694 words - 3 pages Article Critique on GMOPOL 1113Prof. Marija NaumoskiFall 2014By Sachet KhanalEverybody enjoys eating ice cream on a hot summer day, and having pan cakes for breakfast, but most of us don't bother thinking about what is in our food or how it was made. A lot of food available for sale are genetically modified, but as these foods do not have to be labeled, we will not know whether the food we buy is genetically modified or not. In an article titled