Article Evaluation Essay

2155 words - 9 pages

This assignment is aimed at evaluating the article from existing basis of theories, research methods to researchers’ findings. It is structured as followed. The assignment will briefly describe the paper which is going to be evaluated at first, and then state the main theoretical framework of the article combining with its theoretical underpinning. Followed by that, the whole research design and the use of methods which were relative to this research will be put into evaluation, also it will expound some limitations of these methods. And then it will come up with the analysis of the reliability of the researchers’ findings and conclusions. Finally, the implications which based on the previous sections will be presented, and some personal experience and interpretations will be put at the end.
Article description
This article raised an argument to the existing dimensional approach at first, and presented the culture is not consistent but rather changing constantly, then put forward the view of emphasizing to incorporate the specific context and power dynamic rather than take the traditional and universal approach.
The research is mainly focus on the power dynamics which was based on the cross-cultural perception between Dutch and Curaçaoans. The investigation was done between two typical organizations: the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and the police from the national and organizational context. The research collected the data mainly through combining the ways of interviews, observation and literature study. Besides, the selection of the interviewees and interviewers was according to the particular methods in order to improve the veracity of the data. It was aimed to illustrate the influence of power dynamics between the two ethnic groups, Dutch and Curaçaoans.
From the aspect of organization, in the IRS, the situation seemed positive by both sides, the Dutch thought there were still some cultural differences between them but they considered it manageable. For the Curaçaoans, Dutch qualities were seen positive, especially higher in the organization. On the contrary, the situation in the police was much worse than in the IRS. In the police, the Curaçaoans were seen outside the white group and also faced problem of discrimination.
Furthermore, the cultural perception was influenced prominently by the power dynamics. From the aspect of different contexts, in Curacao, the postcolonial context and the power imbalance affected the perception. In the Netherlands, the perception was mainly impacted by the organizational context and the hierarchical position. The intra-organizational and extra-organizational factors play a significant role in actual interaction.
At the end, the article reaffirmed the research of cross-cultural perception should take the power dynamics into consideration combining with the relative factors of context instead of using a universal value-based method.
Theory construction and evaluation

Find Another Essay On Article Evaluation

Special Education Information Essay

1190 words - 5 pages great deal of additional information as well. There are definitions of words that may be confusing for parents such as, IEP, evaluation, the bell curve, standard score, standard deviation, norm-reference, and criterion reference. It is great how the article also provides routes to additional resources, suggestions as to how many times to read the article and actual practice questions to deal with. Pacer Center (2007) also writes an article

A Probation Officer's View of Effectiveness

749 words - 3 pages order to be successful throughout the community. By displaying the information in the article, the newspaper had to of known the negative affects on the probation office and in hopes there would be some sort of improvement throughout the department.The newspaper articles lead to the evaluations within the probation department. In the proposed evaluation, the probation department will have different theories of effectiveness throughout the

Education Assignment Review

678 words - 3 pages Librarian JOURNAL ARTICLE REVIEW 1 "Codes of Ethics" Topic: Teacher's Code of Ethics. Instructions: You are to locate a scholarly journal article on the topic "Teacher's Code of Ethics" and write a 500-word summary of the article. Two sites that gives a listing of journals of interest to educators are: Educational Journals on the Internet Scholarly Journals in Print in the JSCC Library Evaluation: The following

Justification of Choices of Polemic Arguments

1087 words - 4 pages evaluation of merit of argument. It was justified that the Medscape article had more merit and comparable strength then the USA today article and would prove a valuable resource to the arguments page. A possible replacement of the current text supporting argument 6 for pro, should gay marriage is even plausible as the Medscape article would be more use friendly and accessible to patrons using the site despite providing just as much applicable

asylum seekers

633 words - 3 pages detail about the actual study itself. This drags down the reliability, as it lacks references, similar studies and evidence to back up the claims of the study, which is an evaluation of the government dispersal policy. However, the article does quote the book (Spreading the 'burden'? : a review of policies to disperse asylum-seekers and refugees Robinson, Vaughan; Andersson, Roger; Musterd, Sako 2003) in which the study mentioned is described

Rate My Teacher

924 words - 4 pages overlooked, there are two parts in the equation when considering the educational prosperity of students, the student and the teacher. In a nation of opportunities and equality, how can it be fair that teachers grade students with the possibility of failure without an evaluation of the teacher’s performance? Many places around the country have begun to factor in these teachers and schools in the success of their students. In Indiana, an educational

A Literature Review on Post Occupancy Evaluation

2061 words - 9 pages need developed or re-deigned. Not only this but it gives the owners a sense of is there building preforming. There could be different areas in where the clients are loosing money or wasting resources where they could be used elsewhere. The Seventh and final article that I have looked at talks about the history of post occupancy evaluation. Saying that it was first implicated “some 40 years ago” (British Council for Offices, 2012). But it wasn’t


2432 words - 10 pages to take a supplemental evaluation. However, when the evaluation constitutes a project (the whole process or part of it outside of the classroom), the student may request a revision of his/her final grade as stipulated by Article 5.19 of the Institutional Policy on Evaluating Learning (IPEL). Institutional Requirements Student's commitment By registering for this course, you commit to: - obtaining the necessary course materials at the start of the

Education Software Review

1077 words - 4 pages Step 1: Online Article In their article, Predicting Quality in Educational Software, Squires and Preece cite Nielsen’s (1994) version of ten usability heuristics. At the end of their article, they also note an initial set of “learning with software heuristics.” I pinpointed additional key questions based on eight of these guidelines that I feel should be considered when evaluating software for classrooms. 1. Does the software have

The Signs of Suicide Program

1485 words - 6 pages Introduction This evaluation critique is focused on the article: “An Outcome Evaluation of the SOS Suicide Prevention Program,” by Robert H. Aseltine Jr, and Robert DeMartino. Based on their evaluation, the authors (2004) conclude that the SOS program was successful as “significantly lower rates of suicide attempts and greater knowledge and more adaptive attitudes about depression and suicide were observed among students in the intervention


2254 words - 9 pages Synopsis on article: This article mentions that Private Bookmark 3.0 is a soft ware that helps you to keep web sites private in an encrypted file and runs automatically as a hidden program when Windows is running. This prevents other users from pulling your sites to view and can only be accessed with a special keyboard combination. Date: 4/18/00 Class: Senior Seminar in Computer Science Useful WWW Sites: :Training

Similar Essays

Summary Of Article Outline And Evaluation Of Major Issues. Explanation Of Accounting Terms And Data. Relevance And Limitations Of Accounting.

1356 words - 5 pages By:Chan Kwan LoongU025143JFang WeiweiU025686ULow Lip HenU025695ANg Cai LingU022299YQuek Kwang TiU025095NB2420 March 2003ContentsReport Title2Main Body3Summary of Article3Outline and Evaluation of Major Issues3Explanation of Accounting Terms and Data5Relevance and Limitations of Accounting6References7Appendix8Report TitleA.Financial accounting information is frequently used in newspaper and magazine articles. Scan the articles in the Business

Critical Evaluation Of A Research Article

766 words - 3 pages Adoption is a frequent occurrence in the United States but few articles are written about the aftermath of being adopted. Whether the adoption is a familial or stranger adoption, questions arise about the best age to tell children they are adopted and what children and parents feel about the experience. The article I chose to evaluate researches these subjects. The article I chose is A Phenomenological Exploration of Adoption by Diana L

A Critique Of The Article "Psychosocial Evaluation And Prediction Of Compliance Problems And Morbidity After Heart Transplantation", Written By Shapiro Et Al.

1736 words - 7 pages In the journal article "Psychosocial evaluation and prediction of compliance problems and morbidity after heart transplantation", the authors attempt to answer the question of whether preoperative psychosocial evaluations have reliable predictive value for heart transplant outcomes (Shapiro et al., 1995). Organ transplant programs use differing selection criteria and screening procedures to establish which patients are within established risk

Summary, Discussion And Evaluation Of The Article 'capacity Of Bottle Nosed Dolphins For Generalization Based On A Relative Sign'

2400 words - 10 pages SUMMARY OF INTRODUCTION'This study investigated weather bottle-nosed dolphins could recall their own recent behaviors and reveal those recollections on the basis of an abstract (i.e. highly generalizable) rule. Two dolphins were trained to respond to a specific gesturual command by repeating the last behavior they performed. Unlike previous studies with other species, the behaviors the dolphins were asked to recall in this experiment included a