Article Analysis: Hold The Hijab

1832 words - 7 pages

In a Los Angeles Times article entitled “Hold the Hijab,” the author argues that a company with a history of strict clothing guidelines has the authority to restrict its employees from wearing religious head coverings. This directly applies to a recent court case where Disneyland fired a Muslim woman from the Storyteller’s Café. This woman, Imane Boudlal, refused to follow Disney’s dress guidelines by wearing her hijab to work. Thus, Disney rightly fired Boudlal for a variety of reasons, the author argues. Firstly, a company like Disneyland Resort pays extreme attention to detail through its decorations, music and costumes. By allowing an employee to wear a turban or hijab at an attraction where these articles of clothing do not fit would “diminish the carefully crafted sense of leaving the real world behind” (“Hold the Hijab”). Furthermore, most restaurants require hostesses to follow loose clothing guidelines. In some restaurants, modesty is required while in others immodesty. If a restaurant’s guidelines required hostesses to dress immodestly and the hostess refused for religious reasons, the company wouldn’t allow it. Thus, Disney’s reasoning to adhere to their dress policy is congruent with other restaurants’ policies. In addition, Disney’s strict dress policy is a business tactic that applies to all employees, not just Muslims. When employees sign their contract, they agree to “refrain from wearing religious items” and adhere to the dress code (“Hold the Hijab”). However, Disney does reasonably accommodate religious practices as long as they fit with the attraction theme. In the case of Boudlal, Disney provided her with an alternate costume with a higher neckline and headgear to cover her hair and neck. Since Boudlal rejected these accommodations, the author argues that Disney had reason to fire Boudlal.
Although this author poses some reasonable arguments, there are several flaws fallaciously and tonally. For example, the author claims that a company like Disney with a “long history of dress policies” has the right to prohibit hijabs. This follows the format of an Appeal to Tradition fallacy; Disney has the right to fire employees for wearing religious clothing because it’s been in the dress code for many years. Just because a company has followed the same guidelines for many years doesn’t mean that they’re moral and correct. Furthermore, the author justifies Disney’s dress code as nondiscriminatory toward Muslims because most restaurants enforce a dress code and most people agree that it is an employer’s right. Because this premise focuses on gaining support because most people and employers support it, it is an ad populum argument. However, the reader shouldn’t be blindly persuaded to jump on the bandwagon. Rather, they should be able to form their own opinion based on reliable situations and facts. Moreover, the author’s opening statement that “Minnie Mouse doesn’t wear a hijab” is a faulty analogy. Of course a...

Find Another Essay On Article Analysis: Hold the Hijab

Analysis of Unplugged: The Myth of Computers in the Classroom, Article by David Gelernter

849 words - 3 pages field of technology, suggests to limit the use of technology in the classroom in his article “Unplugged: The Myth of Computers in the Classroom” which was published in the New Republic magazine in 1994. In this article he offers well illustrated analysis which makes the readers to regulate the use of technology in the classroom. He thinks that the technology comes in a way of building strong foundation of basic skills. He insists that computers

‘Ten Principles to Aid the Quest for Peace in the Middle East’ - Article Analysis

1180 words - 5 pages Introduction The article, ‘Ten Principles to Aid the Quest for Peace in the Middle East’ was given by Jonathan Rietman in which he concentrated on key areas and issue that should be addressed to resolve the conflicts between Israel and Palestine. This article gives some assumptions and ten principles of negotiations that can be led a comprehensive settlement between these countries. By considering the issues of 11th September 2001, the

Sarbanes-Oxley Act and the Insurance Industry. Article Analysis about the Sarbanes-Oxley Act

859 words - 3 pages Sarbanes-Oxley Act and the Insurance IndustryJames M SmithUniversity of PhoenixSarbanes-Oxley Act and the Insurance IndustryThe Sarbanes-Oxley Act was signed into legislation in 2002 and made major changes in the regulation of financial practice and corporate governance. This paper will analyze a specific article while explaining how the Sarbanes-Oxley Act impacts the internal control of the insurance industry. This paper will also discuss

Analysis of Billing's Article, Are Women in Management Victims of the Phantom of the Male Norm?

3539 words - 14 pages . Unfortunately, the author does not mention the actual question asked, nor provides a transcript of any of the interviews, therefore leaving a blank on their quality assessment and interpretation. Comments on Interviews - Sampling As already stated, although the article presents primary data analysis, it seems unclear whether the findings can be generalized to an entire population because the sample size is limited. (Brett-Davies 2007

Analysis of the Article, Censorship: a Personal View by Judy Blume

955 words - 4 pages ” was used to debate and inform the hot button issue back then of censorship in young teens literature. She comprised personal experience when handling censorship in childhood and adult life. Her personal experience alone could not hold the article together but by listing others that have lost their jobs or been suspended adds extra credibility to let the readers know how censors and censorship can effect an author’s everyday right of freedom of speech.

Article Analysis: How to Find the Best Locations for Tourism Enterprises’ in Greece

630 words - 3 pages , namely can tourism clusters be organized or structured to operate in particular locations in Greece through programmes offered by the government and also can tourism clusters develop on their own as a result of the requirements from societal influences such as demand from consumers? This article relates to chapter nine of the text because it uses the ordinal regression model to analysis the connection between the location decisions of tourism

Obesity a Silent Murderer An analysis of the article Growing Pains

1033 words - 4 pages Obesity a Silent Murderer An analysis of the article Growing Pains Every year millions of magazines publish articles that are mainly target fashion, gossip, sports, health, cars and technology. The concept of fashion and those topics have been used to spread the idea that by being the best in sports , having the best car ,having top technology, best income or being the best dressed is one’s ultimate goal in life. Although, this is not true

Hypothesis Identification Article Analysis: What the World Bank Knows, And What It Only Thinks It Knows

632 words - 3 pages PAGE 3 PAGE 3 Hypothesis Identification Article Analysis Running Head: HYPOTHESIS IDENTIFICATION ARTICLE ANALYSISHypothesis Identification Article Analysis: What the World Bank Knows… And What It Only Thinks It KnowsThe term hypothesis refers to "the suggested explanation of a phenomenon or reasoned proposal suggesting a possible correlation between multiple phenomena" (Wikipedia Online Encyclopedia, 2007). It is generally based on

Article Analysis: The Effect that Public Perception Had on French Royal Society

953 words - 4 pages markets, when compared to farms which operated entirely out of the realm of slavery. This article clearly supports my claim that the true reasons behind the further conservation and spread of slavery were often suppressed in favor of others which do not hold up in truth. MacMullen, Ramsay. “Late Roman Slavery.” Historia: Zeitschrift Für Alte Geschichte 36, no. 3 (1987): 359 – 382, (accessed April 8th

Argument analysis of Yvonne Bynoe's article entitled "The White Boy Shuffle"

1371 words - 5 pages I could see how the author might alienate a white audience.PATHOSThe author uses concrete language throughout the article to help drive his point home. An example of this is when he refers to journalist Billy Wamsatt's and other "White Negro's'" fascination with hip-hop culture as being based on stereotypes and other pre-conceived that white youth might hold in the passage "The major interest of these white teenagers is living on the edge. For

ECO/360 Article Analysis: The Supply and Demand of Hybrid Vehicles

712 words - 3 pages Article Analysis: The Supply andDemand of Hybrid VehiclesThe purpose of this paper is to summarize the article, "Hybrid vehicles hot in state, but supply is limited" and explain why changes occurred in supply, demand, and price. After reading this paper, the audience should be able to understand why the hybrid is in high demand, why car manufacturers are receiving the asking price, and how supply and demand may affect the prices of hybrids in

Similar Essays

Analysis Of The Article Dot.Com? Don’t Bother!

1191 words - 5 pages Analysis of the Article " Don’t bother!" Posted recently by T.J. Straith on a British website titled a kind of online financial resource that offers information and services to individuals in the modern workplace –the article " Don’t bother!" provides a somewhat comical yet focused, criticism-based look into the pitfalls associated with investing in today’s tech-related startup companies- the kind

Analysis On The Article, Talking About Terrorism

825 words - 3 pages The article within the Psychology Reader titled, Talking about Terrorism, took a rather interesting approach in evaluating terrorism and the world’s constant efforts in counterterrorism. What piqued my interest is the systematic approach the authors took in describing the why and how westerners view terrorism. Furthermore, the pros and cons are weighed on law-enforcement and military, in regards to how terrorism is and should be dealt with

This Is An Article Analysis Of Jack In The Box

721 words - 3 pages The article I have chosen to summarize highlights the accounting practices of a San Diego--based company, Jack in the Box, Inc. (NYSE: JBX). In addition to summarizing the article, I will discuss how the concepts of the article relate to my organization The Platinum Company Inc., including, making recommendations for improvement for my organization based on the article. Lastly, explain the importance of ethics in accounting and financial

Journal Article Analysis: The Gestapo And German Society

847 words - 4 pages The Gestapo was an information gathering and law enforcing body of the Nazi regime, which began its operation in 1933. The organization has been examined though many lenses, some more popular than others. The article, “ The Gestapo and German Society” by Robert Gellately argues how ultimately it was society that fueled the Gestapo’s power beyond the limits of what they could have achieved without society’s help. Other perspectives into the