This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Article Review: Citizenship, Accountability And Community: The Limits Of The Csr Agenda

1400 words - 6 pages

Aim of the article

Understands the restrictions and capacity of the mainstream CSR agenda.

Newell was attempting to increase the awareness that the mainstream CSR agenda is not ideal for all people, all companies and all government in the developing world. The ultimate solution would require the goodwill and participation of all these three parties. ‘In particular, the role of a strong state (though often not acknowledged), an active and well-mobilized civil society and a private sector willing and able to respond to CSR priorities emerge as prerequisites for the success of CSR initiatives.’ (Newell 2005:556)

Issues raised by Newell

Neglected rights of poor communities

The poorest people in the developing states are not able to represent their own interest when faced with companies entering their communities. The governments usually fail to recognize them as the relevant parties in negotiations. Sometimes, they are represented by groups that have different interests. These communities often are affected the most because they are located in the resource-rich country-side. The incentive that prompts these big companies to develop in these states is that they usually have loose regulations and the states desperately need investments from foreign companies. The corporations recognize this situation and unfortunately the poorest people of these states are exploited. (Newell 2005:543)

Poor citizenship of the companies

Companies perform cosmetic public relationship to mislead the world that they are benefiting local communities. These tactics usually do not contribute positively to the communities in the affected areas. Issues that are not immediately seen necessary are usually overlooked by the companies and the state governments. However, they usually make a huge environmental impact on the food supply and the habitats of the poorest people. ‘Anything else they do has to be justified as a cost saving, raising the question: What about issues for which there is not an obvious business case?’ (ibid.:545)

Insufficient involvement of the governments

Because of their obvious financial interests, the governments fail to established tougher regulations, actively monitor the environmental impact of the developments and help their people in need. Some government officials are even involved in corruption. (ibid.554)

Newell’s main argument

Power and economic benefits, these are the leading causes that Newell thinks why there is a struggle between the states, the foreign investing companies, and poorest communities in the developing world. Although all three parties should participate to maximize the effect of a positive outcome, the governments need to take the leading role. Without proper legislations, the weakest people, namely the poorest in the country-side, would get hurt dearly. The companies alone just would not do enough since they are only interested in financial benefits and corporate image. ‘First, many actions that...

Find Another Essay On Article Review: Citizenship, accountability and community: the limits of the CSR agenda

Above and Beyond the Limits Essay

2322 words - 10 pages The revolution of the human society has come far through the works of modern science and technology. Science is an important factor in our lives when it is used properly for the benefits of all. However, science has not always been used for the sole purpose of creating a better society for the human race. We must understand that the human intellect has its limits and that we can’t use science to eradicate those limits. We are not to abuse or

Citizenship and the European Union Essay

5550 words - 22 pages , 1995, pp.487-518.20 O´Leary, Siofra, "The Relationship between Community Citizenship and theFundamental Rights in Community Law", in: Common Market Law Review, no.32, 1995, pp.519-544.21 See also Harmsen, Robert, Integration as Adaption: National Courts and the Politics ofCommunity Law, Paper presented at the Annual Conference of Political StudiesAssociation of Ireland 1994.22 Curtin, Deirdre; Meijers, Herman, "The Principle of Open

Limits of the Prime Minister

1237 words - 5 pages always appear on the Cabinet agenda as a formality (for example, a report on forthcoming parliamentary business and legislation) v Some items may be needed to be included due to their urgency v A group of ministers might occasionally insist on the inclusion of a particular item on the cabinets agenda. Continued refusal to permit this lead ministers to wonder what the PM is afraid of is afraid of in seeking to avoid

Testing The Limits of Fiction

560 words - 2 pages In each society, there are traditional boundaries for creating fiction. Most boundaries for fiction exist beyond society within the limits of the writer's imagination. Two very insightful writers have no limits to fiction in mind when creating their work. These two writers are Jorge Luis Borges and Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Borges and Marquez are South American authors that concentrate their writing in a meticulously realistic style of imaginary

The Limits of Software Liability

1600 words - 6 pages contract that sets some limits to anyone who violates driven to extreme results. According to the Theories of Software Liability and Survey of the Theories, we will have a quick look at theories under which a software developer can be sued to Strict Liability and Negligence. Firstly, Strict Liability according to which a product defect caused a personal injury or property damage. In this case, we look at the product's defectiveness and behaviour

The Issues of Citizenship Education

3037 words - 12 pages leaving school without knowledge or interest of issues within their community and political issues as a whole. The main reason for this appears to be an insufficient moral and social education, where there has been little teaching of 'political literacy'.In an educational context, as in answer to the second question, the subject of citizenship provides learning opportunities to gain knowledge, skills and understanding necessary to play an effective

The Hidden Agenda of Outsourced Payroll Providers

1207 words - 5 pages The Hidden Agenda of Outsourced Payroll Providers Not only payroll companies charge checking and account fees, within each check income tax are withheld which is then sent to the Internal Revenue Service or the IRS. They let the tax revenues of the employees in their accounts till the eleventh hour which helps them gain the interest on that amount while the money is in their account. This can turn out to be a huge amount if you consider your

Limits and Challenges of the Feminist Critical Approach

3325 words - 13 pages theorists. It shall argue that the feminist understanding of the critique of literature is required to further the feminist agenda of equalized understanding not just between the male and female sex, but between all people, both within and outside of the realm of literary criticism itself. The first theorist to discuss is Simone de Beauvoir. The author of a text which is called “The Second Sex”, de Beauvoir offers a specialized critique of the

The Hidden Agenda of New Imperialism

901 words - 4 pages 1890s was a decade which represented the peak of the imperial power and glory. The 20th century brought with him a new form of imperialism known as New Imperialism. This concretely referred to the colonial expansion that the Europe’s powers did during that period. Queen Victoria’s diamond jubilee exhibited the power and wealth that the British Empire possessed to the entire world. Such demonstrations could only be matched by the French, Dutch

The Relative Merits of Bounded and Global Citizenship

1966 words - 8 pages The concept of citizenship and its boundaries are contested, yet its plainest definition is to be a member of a political community, such as a nation-state and possess legal rights and duties. Seen from its many ideals – namely bounded and cosmopolitan – citizenship has multiple sources of meaning, be they cultural, religious, ethnic or gender related. These conceptions each have merits and downfalls, measured in this essay by the extent to

The Internal And External Accountability Of An Org

2568 words - 10 pages The Relationship between Inflation and the Unemployment Rate Inflation is when there is a constant rise in the general level of prices, within the economy. This can sometimes be seen as devaluing the worth of the currency. Although inflation is constant, it is however very irregular and does not rise to an alarming rate very often.There are numerous causes of inflation, however the highly popular reason maybe be caused by the demand-pull

Similar Essays

The Definition Of Citizenship Essay

2970 words - 12 pages . In other words, citizenship requires accountability to address a problem and actively work towards a solution whether through governmental representation or active contribution of the people. The dilemma of creating a social contract that addresses the needs of the people, while at the same time recognizing the representative legislative sovereignty of the government, is a task that many philosophers and governmental systems all throughout

How Does Human Mobility Affect The Nature Of Community, Politics And Citizenship Stafford University, Migration And Refugees Studies Assignment On How Human Movements Affect Community

502 words - 3 pages How does human mobility affect the nature of community, politics and citizenship? Human movements have long been recognized as important factors that can affect the hosting community, political nature and citizenship of a country and by extension the health and well-being. Human movement could be in the form migration which is movement of persons from one place to another in search for better life, it could also be for refuge reason which is a

Film Review Of "Witness" And The Amish Community

654 words - 3 pages This essay on community is a report on the movie "Witness". In this movie, an Amish boy witnesses a murder. The rest of the movie outlines his story. It also shows us various aspects of Amish life.The movie involves the Amish community. The Amish originated from Switzerland in the 18th century. Amish people avoid strangers and live with each other. Their main occupation is farming. They live very simple lives. All teenagers attend a Sunday

Germany Has Set The Speed And Agenda Of Eu Enlarge

1517 words - 6 pages "meso-levels". Therefore, the determination of the agenda and speed of enlargement is part of a broad and complex policy process where relevant national policy-makers, the Council and the Commission interacted. Germany, with strong interests in Eastern enlargement has only been one of those actors; but not the leader of the process. Albeit influential, it did not always lead the policymaking process, nor were its views always adopted by other