Article Review Paper: "The Recognition Of Brazilian Independence"

1329 words - 5 pages

When researching the subject of Brazilian independence from Portugal and the contexts surrounding its peaceful path to independence, one will find two historians standing in the foreground of the study; Kenneth Maxwell and Alan K. Manchester. Kenneth Maxwell is an expert in Portuguese and Brazilian history and currently writes a weekly column for Brazil’s Folha newspaper. Alan Manchester (1897-1983) was an expert on Latin American and South American history and was an authority on economic and political relations between Brazil and Great Britain. In February of 1951, Manchester’s article, “The Recognition of Brazilian Independence”, was published in The Hispanic American Historical Review. Nearly half a century later in April of 2000, Kenneth Maxwell presented a lecture at Harvard University entitled, “Why Was Brazil Different? The Contexts of Independence”. In both articles, the authors highlight the contexts within which Brazil became an independent nation. Though these historians have the same frame of reference, it is evident that over the past fifty years, historian's approach on the topic of Brazilian independence has changed significantly. The grounds for comparison of Manchester and Maxwell’s articles are the differences in their arguments for the major contributors and decisive factors involved in the struggle for Brazilian independence. In addition, the evidence these historians use to support their arguments has also changed. Time has also altered the questions historians ask about the contexts surrounding the independence of Brazil from Portugal.
Alan K. Manchester’s article, “The Recognition of Brazilian Independence”, contains a strong argument in favor of a British preeminence in Brazil’s struggle for independence. He examines the conflict within the context of its three major actors: Brazil, Portugal, and Great Britain. Manchester likens the relationship between these countries to that of a family, “Brazil, the impatient adolescent demanding recognition of its majority; Portugal, the reluctant mother country, seeking to perpetuate the maternal bonds; and Great Britain, the traditional guardian of Portuguese affairs, striving to settle the family row...”. Manchester's article proves that the issue between Portugal and Brazil was not independence, it was the recognition of independence.
Kenneth Maxwell's article highlights multiple contexts in demonstrating why Brazil was different. Rather than debating Manchester’s argument for a strong British influence on Brazilian independence, Maxwell’s article extends historians’ approach by offering new perspectives with a more complex transitions to independence that examines mutually supporting strands of diplomatic, military, and commercial pressure from Great Britain.
The author of “The Recognition of Brazilian Independence”, incorporates extensive research from primary documents, treaties, and diplomatic correspondence as evidence of Great Britain’s role as a mediator between...

Find Another Essay On Article Review Paper: "The Recognition of Brazilian Independence"

Article Review: The Teen Brain

1178 words - 5 pages The article under review in this paper is 'Neurodevelopment: How does the teen brain work?' by Kendall Powell (2006). this article appears to be credible based on the following: although the author is a freelance science writer, his work lead one to believe he knows what he is talking about. In addition, he provides several supportive resources to back up his topics. He has several other articles and writings available on the internet. However

sociolgy of sport article review - spmg 3661 - article review

666 words - 3 pages common for the most kids to play sports. Whether that be organized at a community park or just for fun in the backyard. Sports are fun. Sporting teams are believed to be a building block to a children’s life. Molding and shaping the youth in team work, discipline and leadership. They discuss all of this is more in Child Athletes and Athletic Objectification. This Article Review is talking about everyday people and the effects of being a child

Black Death, Bridbury article. Simply a review of A.R. Bridbury's article "The Black Death" in the Economic History Review

730 words - 3 pages Bridbury ArticleIn A.R. Bridbury's article The Black Death in the Economic History Review, he shows the main problems that are created and solved by the Black Death on the English economy and population. He has authored several historical economic works before such as The English Economy from Bede to the Reformation (1992). He also taught at the London School of Economics where he was in charge of the medieval section of Economic History. In

The Declaration of Independence

1206 words - 5 pages The Declaration of Independence is the most important document in the history of the United States of America. The Declaration of Independence is a statement that was adopted by the Continental Congress on July 4, 1776 which announced that the 13 colonies are declaring their freedom from the British Empire and the authority of King George III. The Declaration of Independence outlines the motivation of the colonies for fighting for their

The Declaration of Independence

755 words - 3 pages The Declaration of Independence      “We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal and that they are endowed by the Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness-That to secure these Rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their justice Powers from the consent of the Governed, that whenever any form of Government

The Declaration of Independence

1351 words - 6 pages The Declaration of Independence is one of the most remarkable documents of the United States of America. The elaborate document contains almost fourteen-hundred words including a basic structure divided into two parts and within the two divided parts contains four main ideas within seven components. The declaration is not just any standard written document; it is a work of art painted by colonists who are driven by rage because of King George

The Declaration of Independence

942 words - 4 pages In June of 1776, Thomas Jefferson drafted the Declaration of Independence in Philadelphia behind a veil of imposed secrecy. The country was wracked by military and political uncertainties. At a time when a king by the name of King George the III ruled with an iron fist, uncaring to a civilization he never knew. A group of men, from all over the new world, joined together to draft a declaration of independence to burst the chains latching them to

The Declaration of Independence

1249 words - 5 pages Two Hundred and thirty-seven years ago one of the most masterful documents in history was created, which is The Declaration of Independence. The Declaration of Independence expressed Thomas Jefferson’s along with the fifty-five American colonists’ vision of revolution towards independence, and a new government pronouncing rupture from Great Britain. In the document, Thomas Jefferson, the author, established that if their government fails to

The Declaration of Independence - 2571 words

2571 words - 10 pages The Events, the Time, the History Behind theDeclaration of IndependenceThe Declaration of Independence has been called the most important document in modern history. It has also been called the "birth certificate of America" (Kullen, 1996) Thomas Jefferson wrote the Declaration in a brick-layered house in Philadelphia about two hundred years ago (Fradin, 2002). This document told the British King that we wanted to form our own nation. Some

The Declaration of Independence - 787 words

787 words - 4 pages The year was 1776 and the colonists wanted independence from England. Their rebellion started back almost a decade before, in 1765. After British Legislature had passed the Stamp Act. The Stamp Act was a taxation measure created to raise revenues for a standing British army in America. Under the banner of "no taxation without representation," colonists put together the Stamp Act Congress in October 1765. The congress was to voice their [the

The Declaration of Independence - 549 words

549 words - 2 pages The Declaration of Independence was written to show a new theory of government, reasons why they were separating from England, and a formal declaration of war. It gave the 13 colonies freedom from England's laws. The man responsible for writing the Declaration was Thomas Jefferson. He wrote the Declaration between June 11, 1776 and June 28, 1776. Benjamin Franklin and John Adams looked at what Jefferson had written and made some changes to the

Similar Essays

The Brazilian Independence Movement Essay

1402 words - 6 pages The Brazilian Independence MovementDuring the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, many Latin American countries went through a time of enlightenment which lead them to independence. One of these movements was the Brazilian independence movement. The Brazilian independence movement was one of the most peacefully-accomplished revolutions in Latin America. In this essay, the underlying and the direct causes to Brazil's movement, the outcome of the

The Development Of Afro Brazilian Religions Essay

1857 words - 8 pages community to another and from one region to the other . Due to the recognition of the freedom of worship, many religions have emerged, most of which are based on the ethical background of an individual. Some religions have resulted from the interaction of different cultures. This essay will focus on the Afro-Brazilian Religions that are believed to have resulted from the interaction of people from different cultural backgrounds. The essay will analyze

Evaluation Of Deforestation In The Brazilian Amazon

2577 words - 10 pages is much high comparing with other regions. This paper will rigorously describe causes and effects of deforestation, and evaluate possible solutions of deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon. Tropical rainforests which is located between tropic of Capricorn and tropic of Cancer covered 12% of land surface few thousand years ago. However, today is it covers only 5% of planet. In spite of this small area, it is home for about 50% of overall species

The Benefits Of Federal Recognition Essay

1424 words - 6 pages the mistreatment of the Native Americans, the government has instituted controversial federal recognition program that aids the proven direct descendants. Not only is federal recognition be an essential benefit to Native American tribal communities but it can lead to the creation of jobs for the surrounding communities, money for the state, and gives Native American culture a strong presence in the nation. The meaning of federal recognition to a