This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Asian Philosophies Of Critical Thinking Essay

5517 words - 22 pages

Asian Philosophies of Critical Thinking

The research question of this extended essay came across at a very early stage in my life. Having been born and developed from a family with all its members being University instructors and professors, I was often involved in arguments related to the lack of critical thinking in Asian cultures. As I got older, having had the chance to emerge in different cultures, I started to develop my own viewpoints and answers. I started to wonder about the truth between the real differences of Asian and Western philosophies of critical thinking. This extended essay, intended to be a research and investigation, bearing the title ¡§Asian Philosophies of Critical Thinking: divergent or convergent to Western establishments?¡¨ is in fact however merely just a summary of my viewpoints and answers which I have developed throughout the years.

In the first section of the essay, ¡§Logical Tradition in India and China¡¨ I will attempt to give evidence of critical thinking in two Asian cultures that I have chosen; namely India and China. In India, I will argue that critical thinking is clearly visible in historical texts such as the Caraka and Nyayasutra. This is presented as the well-known five-membered argument, a system of logical deduction, similar to the Aristotelian syllogism found in the west. In China I would focus mainly on the two schools of logical thought, the Mohists and the Logicians. For the Mohists I would argue that critical thinking is a vital element in the building of what they call ¡§mental models.¡¨ For the Logicians, I would study deeply the writings of Hui Shih and Kungsun Lung, I would show that in fact both of them developed systems of logical and paradoxical thinking that could well serve as the foundations of modern science.

If critical thinking is clearly presentable in these Asian cultures then why are there still concerns for introducing it to them? This is the question I intend to answer in the latter section ¡§Needham's Grand Question and Fuller's Interpretation.¡¨ During this section, I would also show that discussions of modern science seem to enable us to see how the tradition of critical thinking arose and how they were promoted or discouraged.
I would cover how Asian historical, economic, social and cultural factors have a big influence on their development of critical thinking. Lastly I would show how the prioritization of a civilization has a devastating effect on deciding the future road they intend to walk.

In conclusion, I would argue that since the philosophy of a culture is but an abstract and theoretical expression and justification of the culture¡¦s decision to choose one set of priorities over another, Asian philosophy and critical thinking are neither necessarily divergent nor necessarily convergent to western establishments.

Contents
Introduction 4
Logical Tradition in India and China 4
Needham¡¦s Grand Question and Fuller¡¦s Interpretation 7
Asian...

Find Another Essay On Asian Philosophies of Critical Thinking

UIII Examine the Role of Critical Thinking

673 words - 3 pages UIII Examine the Role of Critical Thinking Elder and Paul (2011) posit, “There are predictable stages through which every person who develops as a critical thinker passes” (p. 1). I agree with this assertion. If we assume that the premise learning is a process holds true, then that process offers great insights of Elder and Paul’s argument. The later premise for learning as a process shows that a thinker must moves from regions of familiarity to

The Nature of Logic to Critical Thinking

1483 words - 6 pages The nature of logic and its relation to critical thinking is very profounding. It is important to understand how people think and make the unknown number of decisions everyday. "If people do not understand the workings of the brain, if they cannot enter its inner sanctum and unfold its mystery, then how can they define thinking?" (Thinking, 1999) What causes the perceptions that are created? Logic works as a guide through the critical-thinking

The role of Organizing in Critical Thinking

525 words - 2 pages The Role of Organizing in Critical ThinkingThe role of organizing in critical thinking is necessary in processing information that we receive on a daily basis. Without organization, there would be confusion within the everyday thought process. Organization takes all of the valid points produced while critically thinking and presents those thoughts in a pattern that is easily understood. In this paper I will detail the importance of the role of

Critical Thinking Styles and Forces of Influence

1418 words - 6 pages Critical Thinking Styles and Forces of InfluenceThis paper will discuss an organizational problem that occurred in my work several weeks ago. I will first describe the basic concept of critical thinking. I will then frame the work issue in two different ways. Next, I will describe the types of thinking used for each problem. Then I will examine the forces of influence that can influence the way the problem is framed. And lastly I will provide an

Decisions and the components of critical thinking

1066 words - 4 pages . We make decisions about everything from what to wear to work to what to make for dinner. Decision-making is a process and within this process is critical thinking. Critical thinking is an important aspect in making decisions. If we do not think critically then most of our decisions will not be well thought through. The most important decision in my life, thus far, was to have a child and making this decision required my husband and me to think

Critical Thinking Paper: Concerns of Website Forums

690 words - 3 pages Critical Thinking Paper: Concerns of Website Forums Enriching the learning experience for students with asynchronous techniques has become very popular, In the E-learning environment these techniques are crucial for the success of the students learning. The asynchronous techniques are also used in a classroom setting also, to add enrichment of the materials. Asynchronous Techniques Asynchronous model teaches communication with students who

Critical Thinking Styles and Forces of Influence: The basic concept of critical thinking

1370 words - 5 pages decisions are indeed made in this manner, the manager should feel confident that he or she has made an appropriate decision and is the best option given the information available at the time. This does not mean to say that the manager will always make the correct decision; lack of information or situational changes can lead to faulty analysis. However, if the manager uses critical thinking and proven successful decision-making strategies, he or she can

Critical Thinking and Business. Decisions Critical Thinking Styles and Forces of Influence by MGT 350

1000 words - 4 pages Critical Thinking Styles and Forces of Influence by MGT 350 Our basic concept of critical thinking is, at root, simple. We could define it as the art of taking charge of your own mind. Its value is also at root simple: "if we can take charge of our own minds, we can take charge of our lives; we can improve them, bringing them under our "self-command" and direction (McCall and Kaplan, 1990)." Of course, this requires that we learn self-discipline

Teacher, student and methodology as seen by classical traditional, liberal progressive and critical philosophies of education

1727 words - 7 pages relationship. These component elements, while present in each theory of education, are differently defined by all the philosophies and great minds that represent them. To truly understand social, historical, political and philosophical roots of issues in our educational system we need to carefully exam each theory. This paper will focus on comparing and contrasting classical traditional, liberal and critical pedagogies’ ideas and definitions of

Emergence of Critical Thinking and the Impact on Education

2188 words - 9 pages This literature review will examine the emergence of critical thinking in history and its impact on education. Early work in critical thinking and methods for teaching critical thinking will be reviewed as well as modern day use of critical thinking. Finally, this paper will examine the benefits of critical thinking in the classroom. Purpose of critical thinking Dr. Richard Paul (2006) defines critical thinking as the “disciplined art

The Importance of Critical Thinking to the Decision Making Process

960 words - 4 pages The decision-making process in business is an important part of a company’s success. Making the right decision relies on using the attributes of critical thinking. The following will show the relationship between decision making and critical thinking and how one company uses critical thinking in its decision making everyday to maintain the company’s health and customer satisfaction. Critical Thinking “Critical thinking is the disciplined art

Similar Essays

Barriers Of Critical Thinking Essay

943 words - 4 pages A learner who masters the art of critical thinking will be able to perform certain tasks” (Paul & Elder, 2001). Critical thinking is important and essential in everyday life because a critical thinker will be able to make wise judgments and good decisions. “Critical thinking is the ability for individuals to be able to think both clearly and rationally, it includes the ability to be reflective and also to be able to think independently.”(Lau

Assessment Of Critical Thinking Essay

948 words - 4 pages Assessment of learning can be a meaningful tool for teachers and students during a course to provide feedback to the student about the type and quality of work that is being completed in the course and for the instructor to find areas where the student is having difficulties and so additional materials can be provided or the course modified. The aim of this paper is to define assessment and critical thinking skills, and then review a State

The Elements Of Critical Thinking Essay

613 words - 3 pages Critical thinking is the intellectually disciplined process of actively and skilfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing and/or evaluating information gathered from or generated by, observation, experience, reflection, reasoning, or communication, as a guide to belief and action. (Foundation for Critical Thinking, 2011) Critical thinking consists of elements such as reasoning and intellectual standards that enable logical

The Importance Of Critical Thinking Essay

2438 words - 10 pages The Importance of Critical Thinking When you hear the words—science, formulas, scientific methods, experiments, procedures—where do you go? Do you turn off? As an educator in the field of science, how can I turn you on? For some people it may be second nature to notice whether or not descriptions (in newspapers, various publications, on television or in professional journals) make any sense logically or are avoiding some obviously