This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Assertive Secularism Vs. Passive Secularism Essay

2357 words - 9 pages

Assertive Secularism vs. Passive Secularism
On 15th March 2004, France reopened the debate on the separation of the state and the religion by introducing a legislation to forbid the carrying of signs or clothes that indicate an affiliation to a religious group in the primary, secondary and high schools. (“Respect de la laïcité”) (Parvez 287) The supporters of the legislation, particularly in France saw in this law an implementation of secularism, a cornerstone of the public school system in France. Yet, there were several critics of the law. The United States Commission for International Religious Freedom criticized the French government, perceiving the law to represent an infringement on the freedom of expression. (Leane 1032) Whereas the French Constitution along the American Declaration of Independence are the founding texts of a common democracy around the world, their opinion seemed to diverge on this issue. After all Americans have “In God We Trust” printed on dollar bills. How could the French find a mere display of religious belief so offensive seems incomprehensible to many secular Americans. This differing understanding of the law on the either side of the Atlantic can be attributed to differing definition of the term “secularism” in the United States and France. This essay examines the history, legal definition and implementation of secularism in the United States and France to argue that the French secularism is a form of assertive secularism whereas the Americans have adopted a passive form of secularism. It also identifies why these countries differ in their definition of secularism by identifying the presence or the absence of an Ancien régime as the main factor.
A state can be defined as a secular state on the basis of fulfilling the criteria that its parliament and its courts are free from institutional religious control, and that it has constitutionally declared neutrality toward all religions by lacking any established religion (Kuru 596). France and United States are examples of such states. These states thus differ from religious states such as Saudi Arabia that do not fulfill the above criteria. These states have religion as an integral part of law and may abide by texts such as Quran for legal guidance. Another kind of state is the state with established churches such as England. These states have a secular legislature and judiciary. However, generally due to historical and cultural reasons these states establish a state religion that does not affect the lives of citizens in any significant manner. Lastly, there are anti-religious states such China and North Korea. These states have secular legislative bodies and judiciary and are hostile towards religion. As opposed to the religious states, these states are based on the dogma that the religion is harmful and/or opposed to human reason.(Kuru 596).

The term secular state is still quite broad and can be further divided subdivided into two types of secularism, passive...

Find Another Essay On Assertive Secularism vs. Passive Secularism

An Illustration of State-Society Relations in Turkey

2133 words - 9 pages Politics: Islam, Law and Society in the Modern World, ed. Robert W. Hefner, Indiana University Press, pp.146-178 Kinross, P., 2001, Ataturk: the Rebirth of a Nation, Pheonix Kucukcan, T., 2010, “Sacralisation of the State and Secular Nationalism: Foundations of the Civil Religion in Turkey”, The George Washington International Law Review, 41(4), pp.963-983 Kuru, A. T., 2009a, “Assertive Secularism and the Islamic Challenge (1997-2008)”, in

Article Review #2

931 words - 4 pages of against their world view. The concept that I found most interesting in this article was that Zigarelli was very passive in the way he went about presenting Christianity in the work place. I found it intriguing that Zigarelli almost made it sound like secularism was the world view that belonged in the work place and that Christianity was simply a guest in a secularist home, and to assert our own beliefs as the pragmatists or the Empiricists

Arguments For And Against Euthanasia

2001 words - 8 pages violation of God's gift of life. Those who oppose euthanasia feel that the advancement in pharmaceutical, technology and the increase in therapeutic measures can be embraced to prolong life at all costs (Patelarou et, al. 2009). Euthanasia is referred to as either passive or active. Passive euthanasia is, "letting a person die", and active euthanasia, also known as physician-assisted suicide (PAS) is giving a patient a lethal injection (medication) to

Turkey, A Poli-Historical Analysis

2175 words - 9 pages Greeks after suffering the dismantling of their country, they recovered the Dardanelles from British control and were the arm of Ataturk in establishing secular rule. 'The military has toppled governments three times in the last four decades,' and the military power and influence has not faded with time. Following the election of Erbakan the military had remained passive, regardless of its historical rule as a protector of secularism. This lasted

Antigone-Higher Law vs. Laws o

926 words - 4 pages Laws of the City-State vs. Higher Law as Seen in Sophocles' "Antigone" In Ancient Greece, after 800 bc., new ideas came to the forefront concerning the governing of society. These ideas led to a more organized leadership and a government whose decisions were primarily based on majority rule. This system took the form of city-states, large self-governing towns. These city-states were founded on principals of "freedom, optimism, secularism


1307 words - 5 pages the three pillars supporting the need of change, compassion, dignity or autonomy and secularism, and what all of these might say about our society's attitude toward the vulnerable and the dying. Euthanasia is legal in Belgium, Netherlands and Switzerland, although in Switzerland the only thing that is legal is assisted suicide and the patient must help with the administration of the drug. Currently, most states in the union do not allow this

Theology in the Modern World

1362 words - 6 pages see the world in black and white. The second sowed the seeds of discord among us." (p.52). The key in this quote is 'self-doubt'; the idea that modern Muslims are afraid to make misinterpretations, this again ties back to the taqlid vs. itjihad debate. During Sardar's encounter with the Naqshbandi Sufi tariqa in Britain there was a leader of a group known as the fuqar, this leader distinguished between "True Muslims" and "Modern Muslims" in the

Breakup of Yugoslavia

2490 words - 10 pages main purpose was to serve their countries and therefore voluntarily go to war. This directly increased the number of casualties and the suffering as most of the people who fought were not trained or physically prepared to be in the war. Political vs. Religious War It is often argued, in the first place by the churches, that the Yugoslav war was strictly political in nature, and that it cannot under any circumstances be characterised as a


4768 words - 19 pages grows ever stronger, while the Liberal Party attempts to suppress the Islamic religion and westernize Turkey. "Tension between the secularism" (Updike) and "rise of political Islam"(Updike) show the ever growing instability of the country's government. In his late twenties, Ka left Turkish politics and media, and exiled himself to Germany for twelve years to pursue happiness in poetry, and after many years of seclusion, Ka returns to Turkey to

Pascal's Wager

1535 words - 6 pages movement across the sky. Few religions today believe in a Sun God, as science very clearly explains that the Sun’s movement across the sky is a direct result of the Earth rotating on its axis. Although this idea sounds ridiculous now, consider the numerous other religion/science controversies troubling us today, one of the biggest being the evolution vs creationism debate. Undeniable evidence supports the scientific idea of evolution, and

Zionism's Change from a Passive Notion to an Active Ideology During the Nineteenth Century

2837 words - 11 pages Zionism's Change from a Passive Notion to an Active Ideology During the Nineteenth Century Although it has been a precondition of Jewish consciousness to believe that the emergence of a Modern political Zionist movement can be attributed to the rampant anti-Semitism suffered by the European Jews, this does not provide an adequate explanation. The entire history of the Jews can be defined by the way in which they suffered

Similar Essays

Abortion: Secularism Vs Religion Essay

774 words - 3 pages Abortion is a controversy between secularism and religion since the beginning of civilization. Today, 46 million abortions occur worldwide every year and eighty-six percent of pregnancy deaths are illegal abortions and one percent legal. Abortion can be defined as the 'expulsion' of a fetus in a womb, a definition where expulsion becomes an issue. Abortion is one of the most debatable ethnical and moral issues in current society influencing

The Concept Of Secularism: Walzer Vs. Wæver

1126 words - 5 pages For more than a century, the concept of secularism and its boundaries has been widely disputed by secularists and non-secularists alike. English dictionaries define secularism as simply the separation of church and state, or, the separation of religion and politics. Michael Walzer, a true secularist, believes that this separation is an essential democratic value and ultimately fosters toleration of a plurality of religions (Walzer, p. 620

An Illustration Of State Society Relations In Turkey

2122 words - 8 pages Islamism – which, if understood as support for Shari'a law, is very marginal in Turkey (Hakan Yavuz, 2010:149) – versus secularism, but between what Grigoriadis (2009) calls assertive secularism2 and passive secularism. The latter's advocates, including the ruling AKP, insist on Islamic morals and values being compatible with modernity and democracy, and demand religion to be allowed public visibility. In this regard, they argue for a re

An Illustration Of Sate Society Relations In Turkey

1757 words - 7 pages language of Islamism, but of liberalism and human rights (ibid:1198). However, mutual distrust between passive and assertive secularists makes a liberal consensus over the redefinition of the concepts of secularism and the public/private dichotomy unlikely in the near future. The headscarf controversy is but one illustration of such divisions. It was so securitised, that each side came to view the other as threatening (Hakan Yavuz, 2009:145). Each