This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Asses Why The French Lost Indochina By 1954 Modern History Essay, Extended Response

906 words - 4 pages

Assess why the French lost Indochina by 1954 // The reasons for French defeat and Vietminh victory in Indochina, by 1954
France was one the world’s great powers during the late nineteenth century, and benefited from imperialism and the exploitation of its colonies. France controlled land in Africa, South America and Indochina – Laos, Cambodia and Vietnam – with Indochina becoming one of Frances most lucrative colonial possessions. However, the short-lived control from the late 1850’s was diminished by 1954. This was due to oppressive French nationalism, rise of Vietnamese nationalism and communism, and military solutions to political problems. The convergence of these factors resultantly contributed to one of the most infamous and controversial military defeats of the 20th Century.
To justify their imperialism, the French developed their own principle called ‘mission civilisatrice’ (civilizing mission), as like most colonists, they believed that the natives were inferior and in need of French contact to relieve them of their ‘backwardness’. French imperialists claimed it was their responsibility to intervene and introduce modern political ideas, social reforms, industrialization and new technology. As historian, Melvin E. page states “The French ‘mission civilisatrice’ was the transformation of subject peoples into loyal French men and women.” However, this ‘mission civilisatrice’ was a façade, as profit and economic exploitation were the main motives behind the French colonization of Indochina. French industries transformed Vietnam’s thriving subsistence economy into a capitalist system, based on land ownership, increased output, exporting resources and low wages. The needs of the French colonists outweighed the priority over the development of Indochina, resulting, with the French using most of the 25 million people as cheap labour forces in mines, factories, rice fields and mainly rubber plantations. Workers on plantations were known as ‘coolies’ – derogatory term for Asian laborers – and worked 15 hour days in debilitating conditions for pitiful wages, that were sometimes paid in rice instead of money. Resulting with anticolonial movements in Vietnam that started with the establishment of French rule.
In Vietnam, Guerrillas fought to prevent forceful takeover of their land, with the French responding with violence and attempts to suppress radical thoughts. A new national movement arose in the early 20th century. As by 1930, a new figure became a prominent leader in the national movement, Ho Chi Minh. Unlike the dispersed and disorientated Vietnamese National Party, Ho Chi Minh’s Viet Minh, relied on cadres whom were trained with pro-national and communist ideologies from the Soviet Union and China. From the beginning, the Vietminh knew that to succeed with guerilla warfare,...

Find Another Essay On Asses why the French lost Indochina by 1954 - Modern History - Essay, extended response

'NOH THEATRE' - Drama Essay (Extended Written Response)

876 words - 4 pages environment themselves, as Noh stages are very bare and simplistic.Noh performers place huge importance on the aesthetics of their plays. The costumes and masks (generally worn by the Shite* only) are crafted with elaborate precision, just as every gesture and movement is perfectly accurate and refined. The prose in Noh plays has a poetic and often rhythmic structure to it, similar to a modern 'haiku' poem. ["Encyclopedia: Noh Theatre" (Internet

The Importance of the French Revolution and Napoleonic Era to the Development of Modern World History

1878 words - 8 pages controversies that we have to deal with when studying Napoleon and the French Revolution. In this essay, I will discuss my opinion on whether or not was he a destroyer of the ideals of the French Revolution.Certain individuals approved of Napoleon's reign as the saviour of France. He finished and completed the Revolution by fulfilling the ideals the people of France demanded. A person such as one belonging to the bourgeoisie, or even a peasant would be

Why was the League of Nations a failed organization by 1937? - History - Essay

1245 words - 5 pages Why was the League of Nations a failed organization by 1937? The League of Nations was an international organization established after the end of the First World War in 1920. It simply had one main task which was to ensure that war would never break out again. After the turmoil from the Versailles Conference ending World War I, many believed that the League of Nations was the one real glimmer of hope to bring stability to the world. In order to

How was Ho Chi Mihn's leadership essential to the Viet Minh in the defeat of the French in 1954?

832 words - 3 pages trust and respect. Seen as a nationalist by many, Ho used communism as a way to achieve Vietnams independence and was the basis for exploiting the French throughout 1946- 1954 bringing them back into the country only so it would be easier to defeat them. All this brought confidence to the people and they in fated their support with Ho Chi Minh.Vo Nguyen Giap was a huge asset to the defeat of the French at Dien Bien Phu. Giap was the scourge of the

Extended Definition Essay over "Wutering Heights" by Emily Bronte's

706 words - 3 pages of going to heaven, and refuses to eat. Bronte writes "His gun burst while out on the hills by himself; a splinter cut his arm, and he lost a good deal of blood before he could reach home. The consequence was, that, perfore, he was condemned to the fire-side and tranquility, till he made it up again." (Bronte 270) One can almost see physical pain. Heathcliff however responds to an emotional distress left to him by his lost love of life, Catherine

The French Impressionists - Essay

1632 words - 7 pages forefront of a rapidly growing city. Artists like Mary Cassatt, Edgar Degas and Pierre-Auguste Renoir responded to the influx of development by communicating their interpretations through a style unrecognised by the art scene of their era due to their organic and expressive characteristics as opposed to the norms and expectations of traditional visual art. Through their hardships the works of these artists not only served as a stepping stone for new

Strategies used by the opposing sides in the Second Indochina War (1965-1973)

2806 words - 11 pages Evaluate the effectiveness of the Strategies used by the opposing sides in the Second Indochina War (1965-1973). Why was it inevitable that the South (USA and Republic of Vietnam) would be defeated?It was inevitable that the USA and the Republic of Vietnam would be defeated in the Second Indochina war of 1965-1973 because of the effective strategies used by the North, with the use of Guerrilla warfare and the Ho Chin Minh trail. The south was

Significance if The Cuban Missile Crisis - Modern History - Essay

1172 words - 5 pages stages of deployment. If the missiles had been discovered even two weeks later, when the sites would have been fully operational, a naval blockade would have been an irrelevant option. In an extract from a reliable secondary source explains why the blockade was chosen by Kennedy in response to the Soviet missiles in Cuba. "The costs and risk of other alternatives simply exceeded those of the blockade. The blockade was a golden mean between

Assess the achievements of Women’s Liberation Movement - Modern History - Essay

2348 words - 10 pages life and, at the same time, take up the ideas in the base of the Women's Liberation Movement. Women have continually faced ongoing struggles during history simply based on the stereotype within society that women are incapable of performing male roles [footnoteRef:7]as they are undoubtedly seen as the inferior gender. In 1969, Australia saw the first of the two major Equal Pay Cases being implemented by the Commonwealth Parliament, commonly known as

Assess the impact of Abraham Lincoln's presidency - Modern History - Essay

1221 words - 5 pages states and developing the agricultural foundation of the country which has been built until modern times, now known as the USDA. One of the impacts that holds a lasting effect in America carried out by Abraham Lincoln is his signing into law the United States Department of Agriculture. This is significant as it left a lasting impact, affecting all of America, even in modern times. One of the impacts of this are more effective and modernised

The Novel 1954 and The Lord of The Flies by William Golding

1855 words - 7 pages . Golding uses Jack’s behavior in these situations to challenge the behavior of modern men, specifically those who initiated World War II. (Spitz, 22) Jack’s desire for power ultimately drives his transformation to a totally different person, described well by the demonic self from Percy’s Lost in the Cosmos. Percy defines a demoniac as “the possessing of the soul by an unbenign spirit... and the secret and erotic love of violence. (177) Jack’s

Similar Essays

Why Were The Viet Minh Able To Defeat The French By 1954?

1345 words - 5 pages The Viet Minh defeated the French in 1954 due to the strong leadership of Ho Chi Minh. Vietnam's sense of nationalism and the determination to rid the foreign intruder, and the Viet Minh's political and military tactics were decisive factors which would contribute to their victory at Dien Bien Phu.When the French colonised in Indochina, they introduced their western way of living to the traditional people of Vietnam. To the French, Vietnam was

The French Revolution History Of Modern Civilisation Essay

1809 words - 8 pages Revolution of the Mind: Radical Enlightenment and the Intellectual Origins of Modern Democracy, pp. Vii – viii, Princeton, 2010.] These ideals are argued to have been passed on and influenced by John Locke and his principles in the ‘Social Contract’. Furthermore, pushed by the concepts of the French Revolution, we see a de-Christianisation in France during that period. Many Philosophers and Writers have considered Enlightenment to be the beginning

The Lost Opportunity That Was Indochina

2323 words - 9 pages to the French in the 1946-1954 War. By demonizing and likening the US to the colonial powers that had previously overrun the nation, soldiers and civilians in support of the Communism transferred their nationalistic passion over to Ho Chi Mihn, a symbol of a final liberation. On the other hand, Washington did little on the same front and the United States Information Service, the Voice of America Radio were two institutions that provided

Stage 2 Modern History: Essay Student Response

2820 words - 12 pages application of the skills of historical inquiry, including critical analysis. (Inquiry and Analysis) Reflection and Evaluation Comprehensive and insightful evaluation of why individuals and groups acted in certain ways at certain times. Page 6 of 6 Stage 2 Modern History annotated student response for use in 2011 2moh20-AT2-wsann01-A-v1.0 (revised July 2010) © SACE Board of South Australia 2010