Compare And Contrast: The Bcs Vs. A Playoff System

915 words - 4 pages

Anderson PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1


James Anderson Jr.

Dr. Brooks

ENC1101-67581

March 9, 2010

The BCS vs. A Playoff

As long as the Bowl Championship Series has existed; its methods, match-ups, and motives have been shroud in controversy. The BCS has many advantages for schools; however, fans and teams are often left speculating what may have, could have, or should have been. The majority of college football fans are in favor of changing to a tournament style playoff system that would determine a true champion. College football's BSC postseason implements a biased system to determine a champion; but a proposed playoff system would create a more exciting postseason capable of crowning a champion based on performance, not popularity.

The BCS began as a way to create a true national championship game by pairing the best two teams in the FBS. The purpose of the BCS was to alleviate any possibility of a split or shared college football national champion. In 1997 The University of Nebraska battled The University of Michigan in the polls most of the season. Eventually, Nebraska entered the postseason ranked a close second to Michigan and accepted a bid to play in the Orange Bowl against the third ranked University of Tennessee Volunteers and Peyton Manning. Nebraska conquered Tennessee, easily defeating the Volunteers 42 - 17. In contrast, Michigan only just survived an upset bid from a run of the mill eighth-ranked Washington State University team. The result was Michigan being named AP National Champions, after narrowly being voted first in the AP writer's poll. However, Nebraska was named champions by the college football coaches' poll and received a share of the 1997 championship.

This scenario of the top teams playing in and winning different bowl games triggered the formation of the BCS in 1998. The BCS began with the consolidation of the four major bowls (Currently there are five BCS bowls) and the six major conferences in an effort to integrate postseason play between elite teams. At the end of each season the BCS uses a formula to determine the top 12 teams that will be eligible to play in the five BCS bowls. The first and second ranked teams are required to play in the BCS title game. The remaining four bowl games extend invitations to any of the other top 10 teams with the goal of creating lucrative matchups that are capable of attaining exceptional ratings.

A subtle problem with the BCS system is that only two teams can vie for the BCS title. Just two teams take part in a true postseason, in which all participants have some chance of proving their superiority.

EXAMPLES OF MANY UNDEFEATED TEAMS @END OF REG SEASON The BCS fails miserably in fundamental areas too. The original intent of the BCS was to avoid a split championship, however, in 2003 The University...

Find Another Essay On Compare and Contrast: The BCS vs. A Playoff System

"Left vs. Right" Compare and Contrast

816 words - 3 pages When we reach the voting age, some of us don't know which way to cast our vote, which party we like, which best supports what we believe in, or which party best outlines and stands for our way of life. Both the Conservatives and the Liberals want to improve healthcare, while taking opposite sides on gay and lesbian rights. In choosing a political party, both sides need to be taken into account. The left or the right may suite any one person,...

Rome Vs. Byzantine Empire Compare and Contrast

1753 words - 7 pages After the collapse of the Roman Empire in 476 C.E., much of the Mediterranean basin was in disorder with no leadership. Germanic tribes from the north had conquered the last emperor and claimed the land their own. But in the east, a new empire was blooming, the Byzantine Empire. The Byzantine Empire was both similar and different from the...

Compare And Contrast (Fb Vs. Bball)

794 words - 3 pages "America's Past Time" Vs. "A Man's Sport" Though we tend to clump all athletes in one large group, they are quite different. Many people think you're either an athlete or you're not an athlete. In reality, there are many different types of athletes. The games of baseball and football are both very well known in the U.S. Both are televised nationally, run on and both contain...

Machiavelli vs. Thoreau (Compare and Contrast Essay)

1040 words - 4 pages The way one should govern and the way for one to be governed will always be an ongoing struggle. How can a government maintain order and the safety of its people yet at the same time preserve its citizens' natural right to be free? The ideas from Niccolo Machiavelli, an Italian aristocrat, who published "The Prince" in 1513 for a Medici...

Buddhism vs Catholicism. Describe the roles of Lama and Priests within their religions. Compare and contrast. Compare and contrast Buddhist and Catholic nuns.

716 words - 3 pages ESSAY- COMPARING AND CONTRASTING PRIEST WITH LAMAS AND CATHOLIC NUNS AND BUDDHIST NUNS The Catholic and Buddhist religions have important people within their religion. These important people help to spread the word about their religion. In the Catholic religion a Priest is an important person who leads mass as too is the Buddhist equivalent, Lama. Nuns, in both Buddhism and Catholicism, are also very important within their religions....

Athens vs. Sparta- Compare and contrast the two cities of Ancient Greece.

685 words - 3 pages Greece a country united by its name, but divided by its ways. Although Sparta and Athens were both Greek cities, their societies were different. Sparta was focused on having a perfect military, whereas Athenian daily life revolved learning and knowledge. When Spartan boys were being trained for an army, Athenian boys were being trained for life.Sparta was a...

Compare and Contrast: "The Masque of the Red Death [by Edgar Allen Poe]" vs. "A Rose for Emily [by William Faulkner]"

542 words - 2 pages Most notably recognized for their strange and bizarre stories, both Edgar Allen Poe and William Faulkner wrote several disturbing narratives. As such, it is not surprising to find that Poe's story, "The Masque of the Red Death," and Faulkner's tale, "A Rose...

Compare And Contrast A Sep. Peace

832 words - 3 pages s John Knowles's A Separate Peace and the movie Dead Poet's Society, starring Robin Williams, go...

Compare and Contrast British Tourism Policy vs. Maltese Tourism Policy

1273 words - 5 pages Introduction The report presents an overview of the national and international tourism policies that have been drafted and implemented throughout the years. I will compare and contrast the Maltese Tourism Policy (2006 & 2012) with the British Tourism Policy (2011). Goeldner and Ritchie (2009) identify a tourism policy as a set of regulations, rules, guidelines, directives, and development/promotion objectives and strategies that provide a...

Compare and Contrast of Cable TV vs. satellite TV.

799 words - 3 pages Cable TV vs. Satellite TV.Millions of Americans are switching from cable TV to satellite TV.When you compare satellite TV to cable TV you'll discover the main reasons are cost, picture quality, program choices, and customer...

Islam vs. Christianity; compare and contrast two ancient religions

2721 words - 11 pages Outline:Thesis: Despite the fact that there are many similarities and differences between Islam and Christianity, both religions are significant in today's society, which is reflected in the grand number of followers each has amassed.I. Similarities between Islam and ChristianityA. The "messenger" angel GabrielB. Message delivered of one GodC. Creation and JudgmentD. Concept of ForgivenessE....

Similar Essays

Compare And Contrast The Central Local Relationship In The Uk System And The Us System.

994 words - 4 pages There are many differences between the central local government relationships in the US and the UK system. The first major difference has to be the scale upon which the two systems operate on. The US, with a population of over 275million people is divided up into 50 states. The UK's population is around 60 million and is also divided into counties. However in the UK the division is merely geographical where in the US the division is political...

"Love In L.A." Vs. "The Red Convertible" Compare And Contrast

556 words - 2 pages The stories "Love in L.A." and the "Red Convertible" compares and contrasts in a couple ways. In both stories the car is used to progress through problems and to start problems. The setting, plot, characters, and other factors make both stories have common features and differ. Jake in the "Love in L.A." and Henry from "Red Convertible" both compare dramatically, though they contrast also. Settings in both short stories differ from country to...

Compare And Contrast Of Ginsberg Vs. Eisenhower?

2247 words - 9 pages "America when will we end the human war? Go f*** yourself with your atom bomb." This quote sums up Allen Ginsberg's thoughts of American in about two sentences. Ginsberg is a person that is very unhappy with the current system that America is changing to and he tries to express his feelings through a poem title "America." He is representing a large amount of...

Compare And Contrast Kkk Vs. Black Panthers

831 words - 3 pages BrittanyInstructor S. LeighNovember 10Black Panther and Ku Klux KlanAfter doing research to compare/contrast the two groups, the Black Panthers and the Ku Klux Klan, it opened my eyes. I realized that the new generation is oblivious to the existence of both groups and the similarities and differences in them. I researched the two different groups to see when the groups came into existence who were the members, why...