This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Compare And Contrast Two Ethical Theories.

2167 words - 9 pages

In this essay I have chosen to compare two opposing theories, Immanuel Kant's absolutist deontological ethics and Joseph Fletchers relativist situation ethics. The deontological ethics focuses on actions made according to duty and the categorical imperative - which shows how acts are intrinsically good or bad. The situation ethics state that no act is intrinsically good or bad, and that actions should b made according to love. From this perspective it looks as thought Kant's views were less personal than Fletcher's, although in actuality both focus on the best outcome for humans.Deontological ethics is concerned with actions, not consequences. To act with good intention but have a bad outcome is still moral. Similarly if the intention is bad, then it is wrong in all circumstances and situations, even if it turns out for the best. If benefiting from the act is the motivation for the action, it negates any morality from a good deed. To be good and act morally is to do ones duty - duty being to obey moral law."Two things fill the mind with ever new and increasing admiration and awe...the starry heavens above me and the moral law within me"Kant (1788).Kant believed that humans know the moral law through reason and without reference it the consequences, and that it was part of people's duty not to be distracted by their emotions. If moral law dictates you ought to do something, it implies that it can be done, as it is not our duty to do the impossible. Therefore there is no excuse not to obey natural moral law.Kant maintained humans' work towards an ultimate end in which human virtue and happiness is brought together, and justice prevails. This is what is known as the summum bonum. As it is impossible to achieve it in this life, he said it was reasonable to assume that there would be a next life with God, where there is an opportunity for reaching the supreme good. In his opinion, morality leads to God.He also believed that morality is prescriptive. Once a person knows of a moral requirement it is their reason for doing something. The categorical imperative helps us to know which actions are obligatory and which are forbidden."All imperatives command either hypothetically or categorically...If the action would be good simply as a means to something else, then the imperative is hypothetical; but if the action is represented as good in itself...then the imperative is categorical."Kant (1797)From this he said that all moral imperatives are categorical -"I ought to do such and such." (E.g. "I ought to tell the truth" makes no reference to wants or needs). There are three main principles of the categorical imperative; the universal law, "treat humans as the ends" as opposed to means, and "act as if you live in a kingdom of ends."The universal law dictates you should "act only according to that maxim by which you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law." This means that if an action is wrong for one person, it is wrong for every...

Find Another Essay On Compare and Contrast two ethical theories.

Compare and contrast two theories of motivation explaining how the two approaches may differ and how they may be similar

1353 words - 5 pages The subject of motivation can be approached from a number of perspectives. Some theories approach motivation as coming from within a person (Drive Theory), whereas other theories approach motivation as coming from within the person (Incentive Theory). Compare and contrast two theories of motivation explaining how the two approaches may differ and how they may be similar. Does one theory seem to explain motivation better than the other? Support

Compare and contrast two works of Art

1376 words - 6 pages compare and contrast. I will also discuss how these inspirational sources have contributed to my final project outcome with regard to composition and technique.Baboon and young and The little fourteen year old dancer are free-standing sculptures depicting life through different animals. These artworks are of different sizes, The little fourteen year old dancer is 104.5 cm while The baboon and young is 21cm respectively. They are both made the same

Compare and Contrast of two Dramas

1387 words - 6 pages Untitled Jackie Magnuson Professor Adkins English 1B 11 May 2011 Compare and Contrast Fences By August Wilson and Death of a Salesman By Arthur Miller August Wilson's Fences and Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman warrant comparison. Wilson and Miller both execute dramatically different styles to articulate their independent perspectives of the struggles in maintaining respectful, trustworthy

Compare and Contrast Functionalist and Marxist Theories of Stratification

1550 words - 6 pages Compare and ContrastFunctionalist and Marxist Theories of StratificationStratification is the separation of society into layers which are distinguished by unequal rewards and life chances and many systems of stratification have been based on slavery, caste and feudalism.Slavery, being the oldest and most extreme form of stratification, involves the enslavement or ownership of others. This ownership came about as a result of conquest, trade

Compare And Contrast The Theories Of Personality D

2041 words - 9 pages Personality is an intriguing component in psychology vital for perception of human beings. Different theories of personality adopt different levels of explaining features of human beings. Two theories meet the conditions of personality and theories of development, Freud's psychoanalytic theory later followed by Erikson's psychosocial theory.Freud's theory of personality development relates to his theories of personality structure and motivation

Compare and Contrast 7 of the Main Ethical Principles

4261 words - 17 pages . Developed and explicated by a group of thinkers, namely, Hume, Bentham, and Mill, over some 100 years, the theory of Utilitarianism was a major development in new ethical thinking. In contrast to the other philosophies approached thus far, Utilitarianism doesn't hold mankind responsible to morals that are commanded by God, beneficial to oneself, or relative to one's culture. Instead, Utilitarianism holds morals accountable for bringing about the maximum

Compare and contrast the two characters of Celie and Jeanette

1738 words - 7 pages Compare and contrast the two characters of Celie and Jeanette. Consider the influence of religion on the two main protagonists. Despite the fact that Celie and Jeanette are characters who appear to be lost in completely different worlds they do in fact have quite a lot in common. The influence of religion on the two girls is significant and can be seen throughout the two novels. Jeanette is trapped at home with an extremely strict

Compare and Contrast two poems: Welsh Landscape and East Moors

1217 words - 5 pages of people living in the valleys in the 1930s, people were born in houses instead of hospitals, then they lived in them throughout their lives. The second and third lines describe how the how the steelworks often gave off flashes of light "sudden glow" in the middle of the night, so the neighbours were "accustomed" to it. Then it says a "dark" sound, it's a contrast to the earlier mention of "glow", and it could mean, low or spooky. Throughout the

Islam vs. Christianity; compare and contrast two ancient religions

2721 words - 11 pages giving of money are two more distinct differences between the two religions. Because the Koran was first revealed to Mohammad in the month of Ramadan, the whole month was set aside as a period of fasting. During each day, from first light to darkness, all eating, drinking, and smoking are forbidden. Upon the end of the fasting period, the second major festival of the Islamic year ensues and lasts several days. In contrast, Christians have the Lenten

Compare and contrast TWO theories of gender role development. Make use of examples from the psychological research to illustrate your discussion

1362 words - 5 pages the sexes. It refers to the economic, social and cultural attributes associated with being male or female (Bee, 1995). In many societies being male or female brings many expectations such as wearing appropriate clothes, behaving or working in a manner that is either feminine or masculine. This essay will compare and contrast two theories of gender role development, psychoanalytic theory and social learning theory. The first discussed theory of

Using a range of theories from across the HR143 syllabus compare and contrast two organizations of your choice from either the public or private sectors

2644 words - 11 pages IntroductionIn this report I am going to apply different theories from across the HR143 syllabus to compare and contrast Marks and Spencer's and Nestle. I am going to compare how the two organizations exercise motivational aspects, their organizational cultures and their organizational structures.Motivation within Marks and Spencer'sMarks and Spencer's exercise a very effective motivational policy via their very successful human resources

Similar Essays

Compare And Contrast Two Developmental Theories Of

2321 words - 9 pages Compare and contrast two developmental theories of intelligence Intelligence is a complex psychological construct and promotes fierce debate amongst academics. Many experts maintain that intelligence is the most important aspect of individual differences, whereas other doubt its value as a concept. At one extreme many claim that individual differences in intelligence depend upon genetic factors, and at the other many argue that environmental

Compare And Contrast Two Theories Of Gender Role Development

1505 words - 6 pages Compare and contrast two theories of gender role development A dominant debate in current psychological research is one on gender development. Psychologists try to understand relative importance of social and cognitive factors. Various theories are brought up in this field and in this essay two of the most standard theory in this field are going to be explained. The theories covered in this essay relate to aspects of children’s thinking that

Compare And Contrast Two Approaches Essay

1404 words - 6 pages contrast these two very different approaches. Not only will I compare the methods of research used but also will note any similarities or differences they may have and indeed the strengths and weaknesses of each approach. My chosen approaches to evaluate are Behaviourist V Psychoanalytic.In 1913 John Watson published ' Psychology as the behaviourist view it', in it he outlined his new ideas. These ideas were considered 'new' because Watson disagreed

Compare And Contrast Of Motivational Theories

691 words - 3 pages for you. ("If you graduate from college, I'll give you a car!" or worse "If you don't graduate from college, you won't get a car.") But motivation that comes from within really makes the difference. Theories have been developed over the years as to what motivates us and those theories are what I intend to discuss.Compare and Contrast of Motivational TheoriesMaslow's Hierarchy of NeedsMaslow showed little interest in animal or laboratory studies of