This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Assess Whether The Weberian Approach Offers A More Sophisticated Framework Than The Functionalist Perspective In Understanding Social Stratification.

1422 words - 6 pages

Sociology is a social sciences’ discipline with a history of less than 200 years. It examines the nature of human behavior and of human association as well as the resultant products of both. Since it is generally agreed that one of the fundamental problems in all societies is how to distribute resources, unequal distribution of resources which leads to social inequality and the formation of different social stratum, therefore, are of the main issues in sociology. In this essay, we will first examine what is meant by social stratification and its underlying principles. Then we will go on to examine two of the major approaches of social stratification: the Weberian approach and the functionalist perspective, and which of them provides a better explanation for social stratification.Social stratification is “the hierarchical division of societies on the basis of a social characteristic. Social differences are stratified in societies when the relative possession or non-possession of a social characteristic such as wealth or status becomes the distributing principle for individuals within a system of unequal rewards.” (Lawson, T. and Garrod, J. 1996, p. 263) In other words, social stratification is a hierarchical arrangement of people into categories of different ranks in a society.There are four basic principles of social stratification. (Macionis, J.J. 1997, p.236) Firstly, social stratification not merely reflects the individual differences; it also reveals the characteristic of society. For instance, children with better family background will have a greater chance to achieve success in their works and enjoy a better livings than those of poor family, may not due to their abilities and talents.Secondly, social stratification will pass down to the next generation. People are more likely to remain rich if his family is of wealthy class and vice versa. Although some individuals may experience upward or downward social mobility, most of them move horizontally from one job to another within the same level.Thirdly, social stratification can be found in every society. It is universal, but with variation in pattern in different types of society. For instance, stratum of a traditional agrarian society may base on heredity characteristic while an industrialized country base on economic factors. But no matter which pattern it is, the top level generally will have greater access to scare resources that those are in the bottom level.Finally, social stratification is a result of inequality as well as beliefs. In other words, it not only represents the unequal distribution of resources, but also includes the judgment of fairness. There are various theories trying to explain the existence of social stratification in our human societies. Among them, there are the Weberian approach and the functionalist approach.Max Weber, one of the founders of sociology, proposed a multi-dimensional view on stratification system. Like Karl Max, he believed that...

Find Another Essay On Assess whether the Weberian approach offers a more sophisticated framework than the functionalist perspective in understanding social stratification.

Focussing on The Fiftieth Gate, a novel by Mark Baker, explain the difference between history and memory, and explain whether one is more valid than the other. Other support material included

1403 words - 6 pages . He begins to question his own motives for investing faith in documented evidence, and as he questions; "does history remember more than memory?" the reader is able to see the first point in which Baker turns from his profession.This 'revelation' is a very human one as a thing is often accepted solely because it is in print while word-of-mouth is somehow taken as less accurate or reliable. When Baker comes to this realisation, he accepts more of

Globalization: Liberal Approach More Useful than Neo-realist

1989 words - 8 pages is the liberal view that is more useful as it does state that the east has a role to play in future globalisation, ‘the fastest growing region for Microsoft is Asia’ (Friedman: 2000:p.198) here liberals acknowledge that the East has a part to play in future globalisation, therefore making it more useful than the neo-realist approach, due to the broader and deeper view given by liberals. The usefulness of each approach has been contested

"Throughout the colonial period, economic concerns had more to do with the settling of Britich North America than did religious concerns" Assess the validity of this statement

595 words - 2 pages The statement "Throughout the colonial period, economic concerns had more to do with the settling of Britich North America than did religious concerns" is in a way true. The settling of British North America reflected and equal amount of economic and religious concerns. But the colonies that were founded mainly based on religious concerns were also founded with thoughts of making money.The colonies of New England, Maryland, Pennsylvania, Rhode

"Economic concerns had more to do with the settling of British North America than did religious concerns"- Assess the validity of this statement

1533 words - 6 pages Despite the fact that both religion and economics played a part in the colonization of America, the statement that "economic concerns had more to do with the settling of British North America than did religious concerns" is valid. These economic concerns, as a cause for the colonization of British North America, outweighed the notable religious concerns that arose, and dominated colonial life during and up until the very end of the British

To what extent is integrated positron emission tomography/computer tomography (PET/CT) more effective than PET and CT alone in preoperative assess

2024 words - 9 pages person’s disease was identified incorrectly. CT and PET were correct in 23 and 16 patients respectively that proves the higher accuracy of computer tomography over PET. However, both machines made a wrong conclusion about 20% of patients that declines their value compared to PET/CT. Contrary, in another type of experiment, integrated PET/CT classified 6 out of 37 patients incorrectly, which is even more than solitary PET did in this study. This

The Functionalist View of Stratification

1758 words - 7 pages of discovery of the full range of talent available in a society. That they create unfavorable, self-images that further limit the expression of people’s creative potential. Thus, the more resources a society is available to, the more likely that people living within that society will develop and nurture their talent. The functionalist view of stratification holds that social classes emerge because an unequal distribution of rewards is essential

Social Stratification in the African American Community

969 words - 4 pages society of today. In this paper I will discuss how stratification has been affected in the African American community over time by skin tone to make mulattoes more privileged than dark skin blacks. Over the years, research shows that lighter African American have had a higher level of attainment, shaping there social and economic stratification. Many blacks of lighter skin tone have had an advantage over darker blacks for the past

the importance of research in a social work framework

1065 words - 5 pages The importance of research in a social work framework Social work, often considered a relatively modern profession, has developed through advances in knowledge, social reforms, democratic ideas and increasing body of research and literature (Doel, 2012). The Social work profession is lead by theories from social sciences, indigenous and humanities knowledge, which comes with a respect for human rights and diversity and is often thought of as a

The Concept of Social Stratification

1455 words - 6 pages involves not only inequality but beliefs as well. This is true because any system of inequality gives some people more than others and defines the arrangements as fair (Macionis, page 225). One aspect of this that varies from society to society is the explanation of why people should be considered unequal (Macionis, page 225). One form of social stratification is a caste system, where the social stratification is based on ascription, or in a

Social Stratification in Brisbane and the wider Australian society

702 words - 3 pages theorists Davis and Moore. Davis and Moore see social inequality as "inevitable". Davis and Moore believe that the "most able person must be attracted to the most important position", saying that someone is in a particular position and therefore social class because they were the most able person to do that particular vocation. This can create social stratification because some occupations in society are more respected than others for example; a doctor

The Bus: More than just a bus?

1056 words - 4 pages Laws were created on the belief that the God chose and mandated that white Americans were the chosen people and that African Americans were damned by God to always be slaves. The creators of this law also use Social Darwinism to reason that what they were doing was right. These separated whites and blacks in everything they did. Separate bathrooms, water fountains, buses, and restaurants were just a few of the simple things that whites and blacks

Similar Essays

More Than Housing: A Double Ended Approach To The Foreclosure Problem In America

1609 words - 6 pages citizens. OBama could forgo taxing these up and coming companies until it becomes more economical for these companies to stay in the U.S. than to leave. The incentives corporations should be offered will vary from industry to industry, but it is possible to offer enough to keep them here. If the government would cancel taxes, such as property tax, for the first several years of a company’s expansion, the growing company could hire more employees

'every Sociological Perspective Has Its Limitations. However Some Are More Useful Than Understanding Society.' Assess This View. (40 Marks)

1133 words - 5 pages , nationalism and ethnic structures. Interactionalists focus upon the way in which individuals (or "social actors" as Interactionists like to call them) consciously act - rather than simply react to social stimulation. The way in which different social actors interpret the behaviour of others is significant as a means of understanding the way in which the world is socially constructed. This social construction of the world is focused upon the

"Blade Runner" (Ridley Scott) And "Brave New World" (Aldous Huxley) 'humanity Likes To Think Of Itself As More Sophisticated Than The Wild Yet It Cannot Really Escape Its Need For The Natural World'

1736 words - 7 pages that there is a general feeling in the 'New State' that the people, particularly those at the head of the social hierarchy, feel that humans, aided by science, are more sophisticated than the wild.While this may be so Huxley makes it clear that the members of this new world are unable to escape nature's rhythms. At various points through out the book different characters make reference to needing a "pregnancy surrogacy". This indicates to the

Write An Analysis Of Specific Scenes In A Film Or Films (At Least One Scene, No More Than Three) Applying The Concepts And Terms Of One Chapter From Understanding Film Theory

629 words - 3 pages Essay #3: Film Analysis and Argumentative Writing12/2 Draft Due 12/8 Final Essay DueAssignment: Write an analysis of specific scenes in a film or films (at least one scene, no more than three) applying the concepts and terms of one chapter from Understanding Film Theory. The chosen scene(s) must be viewable by the professor via the internet or DVD you provide. You can relate the scene you choose to the rest of the film, but the analysis must