Assessment Of Eisenhower As Supreme Allied Commander

1919 words - 8 pages

Question #1
The purpose of this essay is to present a brief statement of Eisenhower’s critical thinking as the commander of the Mediterranean Theater in 1942-43 using the Critical Thinking Model proposed by Dr. Steve Gerras. Two of Eisenhower’s decisions or actions will be assessed using components of the Critical Thinking Model to determine if he did or did not demonstrate critical thinking.
The model used in this discussion is a derivative of the Paul and Elder model. The elements of the model discussed throughout this analysis are clarify concern, assumptions and, inferences . First, it will be assessed the Darlan Deal and Torch Landing. This analysis should reflect indeed if Eisenhower’s decisions were in concert with the Critical Thinking Model already established.
Whereas an assumption is something we take for granted, an inference is an intellectual act in which we conclude something based on a perception as to how the facts and evidence of a situation fit together . The military dimension and the outcome of Eisenhower action is interrelated to the political arena and its consequences. At first, political leader expressed to the Supreme Commander that he could use any mean to secure the West and North Africa including Admiral Darlan and his forces to be part of the Allied forces. This strategic goal set the tone for Eisenhower to put an action plan in place and to strike a deal with Darlan.
Nevertheless, the Darlan deal seemed to be a failure because soon after a deal was struck, Washington and London condemned him on the public opinion. GEN Eisenhower’s decision became a political liability for both Allied countries. The desired effect to make a neutral actor into an allied was his aim. His inference to make a relevant force and to secure a strategic geographical area to avoid losses of lives was not adequate to the political leadership.
From the military standpoint, his assumptions and inferences were corrected to the point the “Operation Torch” was strategically a success. Critical thinkers strive to become adept at making sound inferences . If one looks at his inferences were justified and logical, one should think they were. The Darlan Forces' analysis demonstrated that could have swung either way. His assumptions and inferences led to a deal with Darlan that saved lives.
After evaluating Critical Thinking Model within the context of a two-folded decision, and considering Eisenhower’s lack of high command experience, many of his instincts and inferences would prove correct . Although, one also should conclude that clarify concern, which is the step to ensure that the correct issue is being addressed, was weakly reviewed.
Question #2:
The purpose of this paper is to assess and analyze Eisenhower’s decision-making in the Frandendall relief situation using the Rational and Incremental Decision Making Models described by Professor Allen and Dr. Coates. Then, it explains which model best describes Eisenhower’s actions. These...

Find Another Essay On Assessment of Eisenhower as Supreme Allied Commander

Allied Unity as the Main Factor in the Eventual Defeat of Napoleon

1682 words - 7 pages Allied Unity as the Main Factor in the Eventual Defeat of Napoleon During the years of 1812-1815 there was a lot of change and a lot of conflict in Europe. Napoleon was at the centre of all the change and conflict and in the end he was sorely beaten. The question asks to what extent was allied unity responsible for the defeat of Napoleon, this essay will answer by looking at developments in Europe between 1812 and

Part of the Whole: The Supreme Court as an Enabler of Policy Change

904 words - 4 pages In his influential 1957 Journal of Public Law article, “Decision-Making in a Democracy: The Supreme Court as a National Policy-Maker,” Robert Dahl argues for the Supreme Court's role as a policy arbiter, describing it as being pseudo-political, acting to contravene the political sphere and legislative maneuvering while itself remaining outside of political life. Even per the skeptical Dahl, the Court can be effective in shaping policy

From 1790 to 1857, the Supreme Court emerged as the most powerful branch of our government

1139 words - 5 pages From 1790 to 1857, the Supreme Court emerged as the most powerful branch of our government.I agree with the above statement. The US Supreme Court started slowly as a branch of our government, but by 1857 it emerged as the most powerful branch. The Presidency and the Executive branch certainly can create things, implement new ideas and have a large impact on all the citizens' lives. The Congress as the legislative branch can establish or change

Nixon vs. The United States of America. Explains all aspects of the case and the reasons why the Supreme court decided as they did

714 words - 3 pages had much to hide.On Nov. 1 Leon Jaworski replaced Cox but continued to press for the tapes and on Mar. 1 1974, a federal jury indicted 7 men for conspiracy to obstruct justice. On April 30 the president released edited transcripts--containing suspicious gaps of Watergate related Oval Office conversations. Not satisfied Judge Sirica subpoenaed additional tapes, but Nixon refused and the case moved to the Supreme Court.DecisionOn July 24, the

Wechsler Nonverbal Scale of Ability as an Instrument in Nondiscriminatory Assessment

1496 words - 6 pages ability and intellect, one would think there is a unanimous definition for intelligence, but that is not the case. The book of Psychological Testing and Assessment defines intelligence as “A multifaceted capacity that manifests itself in different ways across the life span but in general includes the abilities and capacities to acquire and apply knowledge, to reason effectively and logically, to exhibit sound judgment, to be perceptive, intuitive

What would you identify as “fundamentally problematic and distasteful” (in Merchant of Venice, Shakespeare)? Do you agree with his assessment?

521 words - 2 pages What would you identify as "fundamentally problematic and distasteful" (in Merchant of Venice)? Do you agree with his assessment?There has been a lot of controversy about William Shakespeare's play, Merchant of Venice. Contrasting views are held on the anti-Semitic values in the play, which are identified as "fundamentally problematic and distasteful". However, I do not agree that the play has any "fundamentally problematic and distasteful

How issues such as immigration, abortion, specifically the Supreme Court decision of Roe v. Wade, and flag burning have divided American society and how decisions or comprimises have been reached

682 words - 3 pages burning the American flag should be one of them. Throughout the world the burning of a flag is regarded as one of the most ugly, most offensive forms of antigovernment feeling. The heat of public passion over this issue ignited the action of the Congress. Following a second US Supreme Court decision supporting flag burning as a legitimate form of freedom of expression, demands were heard for a Constitutional amendment. However, in June of 1990, a

Understanding Human Behavior is critical to organizations - discuss the benefits of self evaluation/self assessment as it relates to leaders today

897 words - 4 pages informal learning, it appears that the field has significant potential. Leaders who are actively trying to further their careers would be interested in how they could use their self-assessment of their skills as a basis in which they can further develop their skill sets in the future without any formal training. Leader self-development enables leaders to adapt to the continually changing environment both within and outside of the organization


988 words - 4 pages Dwight D. Eisenhower was the 34th president of The United States, with his vice president Richard Nixon. Dwight D. Eisenhower was elected into office on January 20, 1953 until January 20, 1961. Dwight D. Eisenhower was a republican president; He was also a five-star general in the United States Army during World War II and served as Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces in Europe. Dwight D. Eisenhower was born in Texas on October 14, 1890; he

Dwight D Eisenhower

1260 words - 5 pages Establishment. Westport, CT, Praeger, 1999. 3. Divine, Robert A. Eisenhower and the Cold War. New York, Oxford University Press, 1981. 4. Broadwater, Jeff. Eisenhower and the Anti-Communist Crusade. Chapel Hill, University of North Carolina Press, 1992. 5. (Document) Beasley, Charles A. Grant and Eisenhower: A Comparative Study of the Soldier Turned Political Leader. Carlisle Barracks, PA, Army War College, March 1991. 6. (Periodical) Barclay, C. N. Dwight David Eisenhower 1890-1969: A Tribute to the Supreme Allied Commander, 1942-45. Army Quarterly 98

Eisenhower and his political career

2416 words - 10 pages for president under the Republican ticket.'My first day at the president's desk,' Dwight D. Eisenhower wrote in his diary on January, 21 1953. 'Plenty of worries and difficult problems. [just seems] like a continuation of all I've been doing since July of 1941-even before that. To Eisenhower the political game was a new experience, but all the demands of the presidency were very familiar. As Supreme Allied commander and Army Chief of

Similar Essays

Supreme Commander, Dwight David Ike Eisenhower Essay

2005 words - 9 pages Nacco 1 “The eyes of the world are upon you. The hopes and prayers of liberty-loving people everywhere march with you… I have full confidence in your courage, devotion to duty and skill in battle. We will accept nothing less than full Victory” (General Dwight D. Eisenhower, Supreme Commander, Order of the Day, June 6, 1944, 2)! The quote above was a speech given to the soldiers from the Allied Supreme

Biograpy Of Dwight David Eisenhower, Before President, Commander Of Ww2, Problems He Faces, And During Presidency

845 words - 3 pages States of America. Serving two terms, it was incredibly easy for him to gain President of the United States for his second term. As of any president, Eisenhower also ran across many problems. Does the average man know why Eisenhower wanted to became president, or his presidential terms? Confident to say, the average man or woman does not know these things.The highest office of the land would also be known as the White House, or down to the power of

George Washington As Commander Of Continental Forces

836 words - 4 pages On June 15, 1775, the Continental Congress unanimously elected George Washington as general and commander in chief of its continental army. Two weeks later, on July 3, Washington halted his horse under an elm on the common in Cambridge, drew his sword, and took command of the ragged band of men, which made up the continental army. In his general order of the following day, Washington made it clear what it was going to take to win the war: “

Assess The Achievements Of Alexander The Great As King, Commander And Statesman

2894 words - 12 pages , but as time went on he also showed his paranoia towards them, in which Badian argues by the end of his life Alexander showed the ultimate "loneliness of supreme power". As statesman, Alexander methods of liberating Greece and Persia under his rule clearly worked, but did create problems. His decisions and achievements as commander, statesman and king will be assessed below on specific events which occurred in Alexander's life.After taking the