Assignment 1

1496 words - 6 pages ✓ Expert Reviewed

1. Issues
The main issue in the scenario is the conflict between the two Acts of Parliament: Education Act 2013 (EA 2013) and the Education Reform Act 2016 (ERA 2013). ERA 2016 is passed reducing the school leaving age to 16 from 18 under EA 2013 and without consulting the Ofsted as required by EA 2013. Madonna aged sixteen wishes to leave school now relying on the ERA 2016. The question therefore is whether EA 2013 or ERA 2016 would apply and why.

2. Introduction
The question raises number of issues regarding Parliamentary sovereignty and related issues of entrenchment and express and implied repeal. The principle of parliamentary sovereignty in the UK, originates historically from the troublesome relationship between the English Parliament and the Crown. The Bill of Rights 1689 created the foundation for the Parliamentary sovereignty where Crown agreed with the Parliament to limit its power. One of the key definitions of Parliamentary sovereignty was given by AV Dicey who defines it as “the Parliament has the right to make or unmake any law whatever; and that no person or body is recognised by the law of England as having a right to override or set aside the legislation of Parliament. Dicey’s theory has both positive element and negative element. Positive in that it states that Parliament can pass any laws on any subject as it sees fit and it can make and unmake laws and it is not bound by the previous Parliament nor can it bind the future Parliament. The negative element of Dicey’s theory is that no one can question the validity of Act of Parliament even the courts.

3. Jurisdiction
The Parliament is supreme and it can pass any laws it likes. However, in the given scenario Parliament has passed ERA 2016 without consulting the Ofsted as required by the EA 2013. The question then arises whether Parliament had acted properly in passing the laws. Therefore as long as Act has been passed by following the correct Parliamentary procedure which involves the House of Common, House of Lords and the Crown, the courts will not have the power to disregard it, question it or inquire into the way it was passed in the Parliament . According to Ivor Jennings, it’s the obligation of the courts to recognise rules passed by the Parliament by of legislation. Therefore the duty of court is to interpret legislation and declare the law and not to review or examine the Act. In Stockdale and Hansard , Lord Denman CJ said Parliament includes all three Houses and the House of Commons cannot act alone. In Edinburgh & Dalkieth Railway v Wauchope correct procedure was not followed as required by the Standing Order. Lord Campbell stated that the task of the court is to see if Act has passed through both Houses and attained Royal assent and if so they cannot inquire into the “manner in which it was introduced into the Parliament”. In Lee v Bude & Torrington Junction Railway the court stated that if the court finds that an Act has been passed improperly,...

Find Another Essay On Assignment 1

Assignment 1

1264 words - 5 pages 1. The events of 9/11 opened the doors for security in Canada. We as a nation had to find a way to make sure something as tragic as the events that took place on September 11, 2001 never happens again and more importantly how to prevent it in our country. Even if that meant that Canada would have to spend a ton of money to up our security. Since the attacks of September 11th Canada has spent over 92 billion in their “new national security...

Assignment 1

1294 words - 5 pages best differentiated. The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) defines terrorism on the basis of three characteristics. In order for an act to be considered terrorism, it needs to be (1) a violent act, or acts dangerous to human life that violates laws; (2) appear to be intended (i) to intimidate or coerces civilian population; (ii) to influence policies of a government by coercion or intimidation; or (iii) to affect the conduct of a government by...

Assignment 1

1459 words - 6 pages In physical therapy, patients come to the clinic with a long list of symptoms and a specific mechanism of injury. It is the physical therapists job to take this information and form hypotheses of what pathology may be affecting the patient. With the patient that has been presented in this case, a full history shows a very good description of symptoms and what the patient remembers happening when the injury occurred. With this history, an...

assignment 1

988 words - 4 pages America has evolved over the centuries, from a British colony to an international powerhouse. At one point, the U.S was considered the greatest country in the world. America always found solutions to problems, and tried to help make peace throughout the world, but now that is up to debate. Why? The answer is simple, the government. The dishonesty and bad decisions have resulted in America’s title as a superpower to waver. The government is a...

assignment 1

1611 words - 6 pages very helpful information for people who would like alternatives to spanking. (Project No Spank, 2014) (The Center of Effective Disipline, 2014) Works Cited About Psychology. (2014, February 17). Retrieved from About.com: http://psychology.about.com/ Kidjacked Spanking Laws. (2014, February 17). Retrieved from Kidjacked: http://kidjacked.com/legal/spanking_law.asp Merriam-Webster. (2014, March 1). Retrieved from merriam-webster.com: http...

Assignment 1

1219 words - 5 pages that the students in experiment 1 who were focused on just taking notes would score higher than the students who were told to multitask during the lecture. However, for experiment 2, I would surmise that the students sitting next to a confederate would score lower than those who were not sitting next to a confederate, but the difference would not be large enough to claim statistical significance. The researchers found that in both experiments...

Assignment #1

1571 words - 6 pages Section A: Applied Ethics 1. Q: Should Baby Theresa have been killed so that her organs could be used to save other children? Why or why not? State a position on this controversial case, and offer at least 2 reasons in support of your view. A: Despite great internal controversy, I believe that Baby Theresa’s organs should have been harvested even though it cost her her life. This is because of the fact that she had been deemed mentally...

Experiment 1: IR Unknown/Spectroscopy Assignment FOURIER-TRANSFORM INFRARED SPECTROSCOPY

2725 words - 11 pages Sharp peaksAromatic Csp2-H 3023-3088cm-1 Medium Sharp peaksUnsaturated Csp3-H 2867-2965cm-1 Strong Sharp peaksH-NMR + Assignment: AssignmentAB Shift (ppm)1.3107.01 to 7.46For HA, a large singlet was observed instead of 7 peaks due to their identical electronic environments. This is because methyl...

Writing Assignment #1: Civility or Savagery?, Lord Of The Flies

642 words - 3 pages Manal Ammagui10/06/14P-3Writing Assignment #1: Civility or Savagery?In William Golding's book ...

Breed Developement and Welfare Assignment 1 - Welfare and Legislaion.

1761 words - 7 pages poultry (other than laying hens kept in battery cages) must ensure that, in addition to the requirements in Schedule 1, the conditions under which the birds are kept comply with the requirements in Schedule 3.3-5 FREEDOMS1.Freedom from hunger and thirst by ready access to fresh water and a diet to maintain full health and vigour.2.Freedom from discomfort by providing an appropriate environment including shelter and a comfortable resting...

Internet Assignment Four Part A 1. What are the questions

773 words - 3 pages Internet Assignment Four Part A 1. What are the questions about war and ethics? 2. The article is about the presidents wanting to give a preemptive attack on Iraq. If Iraq hasn't fired upon us how come we are going to attack them, and also without the consent of other nations in the UN. Many questions are raised in this piece, about our judgment towards Saddam Hussein. It also focuses on the consequences of an attack to Iraq. Such as India...

Similar Essays

Assignment 1 - 1183 words

1183 words - 5 pages ASSIGNMENT 1 LANGUAGE RELATED TASKSNAME: SAPNA DILEESHDATE : 5TH APRIL 2014Part 1: GrammarHe's just gone out (Pre-intermediate)a). Analysis of Meaning:He was here, but left a short time ago.Just - short time ago (Murphy Raymond, English Grammar in Use, Intermediate, Cambridge University Press, 2003)b). Conveying...

Generational Assignment: Module 1

1038 words - 4 pages (Toussaint, 2013). Generational Assignment 2: Mind Gap Do you believe that the survey results were accurate? Why or why not? According to the survey results, 40% Human Resource Professional (HR professionals) reported that there was conflict between employees due to the generational differences. In addition, 58% of HR Professional conveyed the conflict that occurred was between the younger and older workers. I agree with the findings, based...

Essay Assignment 1

801 words - 3 pages trauma has on those infected and affected by HIV.” (Whetten R. and Shirey K., 2011. pp 1) CONCLUSION Though, in the first part of this assignment, I dwelt rather heavily on the effect AIDS has on the family structure and in particular children in those families, I am aware that the effects of HIV and AIDS are tremendous. Works Cited Bollinger, L, Stover J. , Palamuleni M.E.. 2000, The Economic Impact of AIDS in Malawi Malawi...

The Color Purple Literary Assignment 1

1022 words - 4 pages The Color Purple Literature Assignment 1 Alice Walker published The Color Purple in 1982, although the book was set in the early 1900’s. The time is set in the early 1900’s because racism and sexism was a significantly greater widespread problem. Alice Walker vividly portrayed the theme of racism by using setting, harsh language, and the letter format. The setting and time period of the novel creates instances in the atmosphere where racism...