This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Assignment 1: Sketch Briefly Descartes’ Proof For The Existence Of God. What Possible Objections Can You Raise Against This Proof?

880 words - 4 pages

1. Introduction
Descartes’ argument for the existence of God relies on the untenable notion of a substance of perfection and that it can be predicated of God. In this essay Descartes’ arguments for the existence of God will be briefly expounded, and then objections against his methodology employed in order to establish the proof of God, will be discussed.
2. Proof of God
God takes on a crucial place in Descartes’ philosophy. He was certain of his own finitude, but at the same time also aware of something infinite. There was for Descartes this confrontation between the finite imperfect mind and the sense of something beyond. Something infinite.
Descartes views himself as not having the capacity of perfection. Perfection is according to him an attribute, a feature of a being of true substance. A substance capable of not only having the power to create lesser substances, but also with the capacity of non-dependence on any other thing for its own existence (Cottingham, 2008:81).
Descartes deliberated that such a being would be of such constitution that it would possess attributes such as omnipotence, omniscient and benevolence. For Descartes there can exist only one such being and that is God, and this is what he stands to prove.
Descartes points out that in order for any effect to occur, its cause must own the effect itself, and this he calls “causality” (Tutorial for PLS3702, 2014:17)
In order to prove the existence of God, Descartes employs two arguments, the cosmological and ontological.
The cosmological argument makes inference from certain alleged facts about the world, (cosmos) about the existence of a unique and perfect being, God (Reichenbach, 2014:1). Descartes is aware of such a unique and perfect being, and this awareness he states, could only have been planted by such a unique being, thus by God himself.
His ontological argument follows the reasoning that God is by definition a supremely perfect being, the greatest of all beings. Such a being would by the mere fact of its supremacy, have existence as a property. God must therefore exist (Tutorial for PLS3702, 2014:17).
3. Objections
The method Descartes employs in order to prove the existence of God is very similar to the proof of St Anselm, in that he deduces the existence of God from internal logic. “God is that than which nothing greater can be thought” (Atkinson, 2011:80).
The validity of employing such methodology to determine existence of something is suspect, as it may fall prey to faulty logic.
His other assertion on “causality” where he states that the effect should have all its characteristics within its cause does not seem plausible. If this was...

Find Another Essay On Assignment 1: Sketch briefly Descartes’ proof for the existence of God. What possible objections can you raise against this proof?

Analysis on Descartes' God existence proof

893 words - 4 pages The objective of this paper is to examine Descartes' argument for the existence of God. To do this we firstly have to review Descartes' proof of God existence. And after this we will see what objections can his theories hold.Descartes set out to build a set of arguments designed to prove God's existence. His goal in proving God's existence had to be incontestable, there could not be any doubt. Descartes started by renouncing all his beliefs, so

Descartes Third Meditation: Proof of Gods Existence

1350 words - 5 pages conceivable or tangible limits in any of their aspects or qualities. The only example of this for Descartes would be an entity of omnipotence, who would be all knowing, all powerful, and that of which no greater can be conceived, in other words God. The next concept that must be explained is in fact the very first premise for Descartes' Third Meditation Proof for the Existence of God, that of the Causal Adequacy Principle. Descartes reasons that

Proof for God's Existence

2205 words - 9 pages simply ignore this profound truth is itself a testament that the individual is divorced from reality. The Bible declares such person to be a fool (Ps 53:1): The fool hath said in his heart, there is no God. Corrupt are they, and have done abominable iniquity: There is none that doeth good. (KJV Ps. 53:1) Indeed, we can know this all powerful and supreme God (the author of all creation) on a personal basis through what He has imparted to us

Proof of God's Existence

1193 words - 5 pages began to exist. Therefore, the universe has a cause for its coming into being. This argument can be countered with a series of questions about whether or not the universe ever began to exist or has it always existed. When it's all said and done, it is accepted that the universe did begin, and, therefore, has a cause for its existence and a Creator. (Kreeft)God's existence is also very easily seen in the earth and universe as a whole. The earth is a

Proof of the Existence of Evolution

602 words - 2 pages has been found, and finally the distribution of related species of animals over a broad geographical range. What is a Fossil? “Fossils are the mineralized remnants or impressions of once-living organisms” (www.actionbioscience.org) Which means “the remains of plants and animals from the past that have been encased in rocks”. Now, let’s take Dinosaurs for example. They don’t exist today, however evidence found fossil records of them. This is

Descartes Argument for the Existence of God

1209 words - 5 pages attribute as a perfect being. Secondly, God’s existence. These two essential properties must always be found together to ensure his necessary existence. Descartes argues that we can no more imagine God not existing then we can imagine a mountain without a valley. In this analogy Descartes is trying to draw out the distinction between ordinary existence and necessary existence. The idea of a mountain implies a valley. It may be possible to

Descartes' Fifth Meditation This essay provides insight into Descartes' Fifth Meditation and the existence of God

629 words - 3 pages In his Fifth Meditation, Descartes' attempts to once again prove the existence of God. He comes up with a number of examples that relate aspects from the material world in order to further his belief that God really does in fact exist. He states his theories favoring God's existence, most notably in his second ontological argument. At the same time he also presents several possible objections that could come into play, and refutes them

Descartes and the Existence of God

1181 words - 5 pages Descartes and the Existence of God Once Descartes has realized that he can know with certainty that “I exist” is true, he continues to build on his foundation of truths. The truth about the nature of God, proof of God’s existence, and the nature of corporeal objects are considered, among others, after Descartes proves his existence. Descartes’ principal task in the Meditations was to devise a system that would bring him to the truth. He

"Creative expression allows people to attempt to escape from what they view as painful realities of human existence" This essay explains this statement with proof from 3 novels

1681 words - 7 pages It has been said that, "creative expression allows people to attempt to escape from what they view as painful realities of human existence." The validity of this statement can be proven upon examining James Thurber's short story "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty, secondly, Jeremiah S. Chechik's film Benny & Joon, and finally, Tennessee Williams' play, The Glass Menagerie.James Thurber's short story, tells of a man named Walter Mitty. In the

Is A Religious Experience Proof To The Existence O

546 words - 3 pages God at the same time? What about the idea that now Jane, from being doubtful and unconvinced about God, she What are common in religious experiences, is that they are of the same nature. This could be seen as for and against them. You could look at it from the point of view, that because many people are seeing the same things, this could be proof towards the existence of God.Though one thing against religious experiences is that as they are of the same nature this could be seen Straightens faith!

The Existence of God: the Arguments of Locke and Descartes

1366 words - 5 pages Descartes believes that God's existence is clear and distinct. God exists because the thought of God is derived from a "completely clear and distinct" idea from within his being (which he concedes is a thinking being). Having come from distinct thoughts, the idea of God can therefore never be considered a falsity. From this very distinct idea of God comes everything else that one grasps distinctly and clearly. He states, "From the fact

Similar Essays

Descartes' Proof For The Existence Of God

4707 words - 19 pages explanation. Third, we live in an age which is largely skeptical of the whole enterprise of giving proofs for the existence of God. A puzzled student once remaked, "If it were possible to prove that God exists, what would one need faith for?" So, even those inclined to grant the truth of the conclusion of Descartes' proof are often skeptical about the process of reaching it. Philosophers are inclined to evaluate arguments carefully. This page is

Descartes Proof For The Existence Of God

1542 words - 6 pages scriptures because we think that they come from God. Generally saying, this is a circular argument that cannot be used as a proof. We would all like to believe that we believe in God and our given religion because of faith. But what is faith? And how can a Jew, a Christian or a Muslim all have the same certainty about their given religions without being in any doubt of their minds as to the certainty of their religions and faith. Descartes set out

Descartes Proof Of God. This Examines Descartes' Argument For The Existence Of God

1282 words - 5 pages we perceive the idea of God, for if it was not clear and distinct then it would not necessarily be true. But the clarity and distinctness of our thoughts depends on the existence of God. This seems to me a very circular argument and can hardly survive as a proof. Descartes said right from the beginning of the meditation that he has the idea of a perfect being and that he is imperfect. This leads into the second problem I have with Descartes

Proof For The Existence Of God

1531 words - 6 pages Proof For the Existence of God From the diversity of men and creatures on this earth, there has always been one unifying link. At the root of humanity’s existence, lies the root of all things natural and infinite, a hint of something supreme and purposeful, something incomprehensible; a glimpse of what is real and what is possible. Inspired by wonder one can easily be surprised by the doubts presented as to the existence and identity of this